Batzella, Crambe and Monanchora: Highly Prolific Marine Sponge Genera Yielding Compounds with Potential Applications for Cancer and Other Therapeutic Areas.

Pyrroloquinoline and guanidine-derived alkaloids present distinct groups of marine secondary metabolites with structural diversity that displayed potentialities in biological research. A considerable number of these molecular architectures had been recorded from marine sponges belonging to different marine genera, including Batzella, Crambe, Monanchora, Clathria, Ptilocaulis and New Caledonian starfishes Fromia monilis and Celerina heffernani. In this review, we aim to comprehensively cover the chemodiversity and the bioactivities landmarks centered around the chemical constituents exclusively isolated from these three marine genera including Batzella, Crambe and Monanchora over the period 1981-2017, paying a special attention to the polycyclic guanidinic compounds and their proposed biomimetic landmarks. It is concluded that these marine sponge genera represent a rich source of novel compounds with potential applications for cancer and other therapeutic areas.

1. Introduction

As a result of the rise of many current medical challenges, including hepatitis, parasitic infection, lifestyle-induced diseases, such as diabetes, hypertension, many forms of cancer, multi-drug resistance pathogens and other diseases, searching for new bioactive compounds with novel modes of action is necessary. Marine natural products represent potent, promising and sustainable sources for biomedications [1]. Up to present time, eight marine-derived drugs were approved for market pipelines for the treatment of some of these current medical challenges [2,3]. Marine sponges (phylum Porifera), even though they are the most primitive class within the animal kingdom, are considered renewable powerful suppliers for bioactives. The marine genera belonging to the order Poecilosclerida, Batzella (family Chondropsidae), Crambe and Monanchora (family Crambeidae), are rich in the production of highly physiologically active pyrroloquinoline and guanidine-derived alkaloids [4,5,6], with a vast scope of biological potentialities including cytotoxic and antiviral [7,8,9,10,11,12], HIV-1 inhibitors [13,14], enzyme inhibitors [15], receptor antagonist [16], Ca2+ channel blocker [17], antifungal [18] and antimicrobial [19,20,21]. These interesting compounds are considered taxonomic markers in particular for some Poecilosclerida and Axinellida marine sponge genera [5]. Their complex molecular architectures and potent biological activities have made them for years ideal target molecules for synthetic applications [22,23,24,25,26,27,28]. Beside the production of guanidine-derived architectures, some deep-water species of Batzella produced pyrroloquinoline-derived alkaloids, which raises a chemotaxonomic question about the systematic relatedness of this genus (family Chondropsidae) to other genera like Crambe and Monanchora (family Crambeidae). A chemosystematic exploration has revealed that Batzella sponges containing cyclic guanidine alkaloids are chemically and taxonomically similar, and perhaps synonymous with, Monanchora and Crambe. However, the deep-water Batzella sponges produced pyrroloquinoline alkaloids is taxonomically unrelated to the Batzella previously mentioned. Chemically, it is almost similar to the Zyzzya and Latrunculia marine sponges but their phylogenetic relationship is still undetermined [29]. Systematically, the World Porifera Database accepts nine valid species of Batzella [30], nine valid species in the genus Crambe [31] and fourteen valid species currently in the genus Monanchora [32]. To the best of our knowledge, previous chemical investigations of Batzella was centered on only a single unidentified species from Madagascar [33], for the genus Crambe only one identified species, the type species Crambe crambe from the Mediterranean [34] and finally five identified Monanchora species including Monanchora ungiculata [35], Monanchora dianchora [36], Monanchora pulchra [37], Monanchora arbuscula [38] and Monanchora unguifera [35] in addition to one unidentified species of Monanchora n. sp. [39].

2. Chemistry and Biology of Natural Products Isolated from Batzella, Crambe and Monanchora

In this review, we provide comprehensive insights on the previous chemical and biological reports for the metabolites of the three marine genera. To facilitate the handling of this survey, the isolated natural compounds are classified by their polycyclic skeleton coupled with their recorded biological potentialities whenever applicable.

2.1. Piperidine Iminosugars Alkaloids

(+)-Batzellasides A-C (1–3), three alkylated piperidine iminosugars were isolated from a Madagascar sponge, Batzella sp. and represented the first naturally occurring marine iminosugars. These compounds demonstrated inhibition of the growth of Staphylococcus epidermidis with MICs (Minimum Inhibitory Concentration) that were under 6.3 μM [33] (Figure 1).

Figure 1

Isolated iminosugars 1–3 from Batzella sp.

2.2. Bicyclic Guanidine Alkaloids

Eleven bicyclic guanidine metabolites including five bearing crambescin type A (4–8), three bearing crambescin type B (9–11) and further three possessing crambescin type C (12–14) were recorded from the Mediterranean sponge Crambe crambe. Their structures were established using NMR and careful HRMS/MS data analyses for the complete assignment of the alkyl chain lengths. These compounds demonstrated cytotoxic activity against neuronal cell lines in micromolar range [34,40,41]. Additional homologue crambescin A (15), the only known bicyclic compound reported from the Caribbean sponge Batzella sp. Compound 15 displayed potent cytotoxicity against proliferating Vero cells and HIV gp120-human CD4 binding inhibition activity with IC50 > 100 μM [14]. Further bicyclic compounds including dehydrocrambine A (16) recorded from Monanchora sp. that inhibits HIV-1 fusion [42]. Monanchorin (17), a guanidine alkaloid with unusual bicyclic skeleton from Monanchora ungiculata showed very weak cytotoxic activity with IC50 = 11.3 μM against IC2 murine mast cell lines [35]. The simple pyrimidine monalidine A (18), an anti-parasitic bicyclic guanidine alkaloid, was recently recorded from Monanchora arbuscula [43]. Urupocidins A (19) and B (20), bisguanidine alkaloids possessing unusual N-alkyl-N-hydroxyguanidine motif, were isolated from Monanchora pulchra. Urupocidin A (19) increases nitric oxide production in murine macrophages via inducing iNOS expression [44]. Recently, seven cytotoxic guanidine alkaloids were described from a French Polynesian Monanchora n. sp. including three bicyclic architectures possessing a free carboxylic acid group monanchoradins A–C (21–23) and four bicyclic compounds bearing crambescin A2 type skeleton with a short butyl-guanidine side chain including dehydrocrambescin A2 418 (24), (−)-crambescin A2 392 (25), (−)-crambescin A2 406 (26) and (−)-crambescin A2 420 (27) along with monalidine A (18). Most of these compounds showed antiproliferative and cytotoxic activities against several cancer cell lines including KB, HCT-116, HL-60, MRC-5 and B16-F10, with IC50 values in the micromolar range. The bicyclic analogue monanchoradin A (21) that bearing a carboxylic acid functionality was found to be less potent, however, it is still in the nanomolar range. On the other hand, the bicyclic compounds 24–27 bearing the butyl-guanidine terminus were found more potent, in particular (−)-crambescin A2 420 (27) that was found to be the most active with IC50 = 0.03 μM against KB cancer cell lines [39]. Moreover, the simple compound 18 showed potent antiproliferative and cytotoxic activities against KB, HCT-116, MDA-435, HL-60 and MRC-5 with an IC50 values 0.2/0.4, 0.84/0.74, 0.32/0.86, 1.3/1.3, 0.55/0.60 μM respectively. It is worth noting that the bicyclic (−)-crambescin compounds 25–27 are enantiomers for the antipodal bicyclic (+)-crambescins, recently isolated from the marine sponge Pseudaxinella reticulata (now known as Dragmacidon reticulatum, family Axinellidae) and their recording draws important insights about chirality and its dependence on the species of sponge [45] (Figure 2).

Figure 2

Isolated bicyclic guanidine alkaloids 4–27.

2.3. Tricyclic Guanidine Alkaloids Bearing Ptilocaulin

Four tricyclic compounds including 8a,8b-dehydroptilocaulin (28), 8a,8b-dehydro-8-hydroxyptilocaulin (29), 1,8a;8b,3a-didehydro-8-hydroxyptilocaulin (30) and mirabilin B (31) were recorded from the Bahamas marine sponge, Batzella sp. [46]. (+)-Ptilocaulin (32), an antimicrobial and cytotoxic tricyclic guanidine alkaloid, in addition to isoptilocaulin (33) and (+)-8-hydroxyptilocaulin (34), were obtained from Monanchora arbuscula [38,47]. Moreover, (+)-ptilocaulin (32), exhibited antimicrobial activity against an oxacillin-resistant strain of Staphylococcus aureus with IC50 = 1.3 μM [48]. Further three tricyclic guanidine alkaloids, including 1, 8a; 8b, 3a-didehydro-8β-hydroxyptilocaulin (35), 1, 8a; 8b, 3a-didehydro-8α hydroxyptilocaulin (36) and mirabilin B (31), were described from Monanchora unguifera [49]. The mixture of 35 and 36 was active against the malaria parasite Plasmodium falciparum with an IC50 = 3.8 μM. Furthermore, mirabilin B (31) exhibited antifungal activity against Cryptococcus neoformans with an IC50 = 7.0 μM and antiprotozoal activity against Leishmania donovani with an IC50 = 17 μM [49]. The tricyclic guanidines 31–36 were identified from a Brazilian specimen of Monanchora arbuscula and were tested for their cytotoxicity against four cancer cell lines including HL-60, MDA-MB-435, HCT-8 and SF-295. The two compounds (+)-ptilocaulin (32) and (+)-8-hydroxyptilocaulin (34) displayed cytotoxicity with IC50 values ranging from 5.8–40.0 and 7.9–61.5 μM respectively. However, the other compounds 31, 35 and 36 exhibited no activity. Additionally, compounds 32 and 34 were tested for their hemolytic activity against potential damage of mouse erythrocytes plasma membrane, where they displayed effective concentrations with EC50 values of 577.95 and 352.91 μM respectively [50]. Further anti-parasitic tricyclic guanidine alkaloid arbusculidine A (37) was reported recently from Monanchora arbuscula [43] (Figure 3).

Figure 3

Isolated tricyclic guanidine alkaloids 28–37.

2.4. Tricyclic Pyrroloquinoline Alkaloids

Seven highly functionalized pyrroloquinoline alkaloids including three compounds named batzellines A-C (38–40) and four compounds named isobatzellines A-D (41–44) were isolated from the deep-water Bahama’s sponge Batzella sp. The isobatzellines A-D (41–44) showed in vitro cytotoxicity against P388 leukemia cell with IC50 values 0.42, 2.6, 12.6 and 20 μM and moderate antifungal activity against Candida albicans with IC50 3.1, 25, 50 and 25 μM respectively [7,51,52]. Further brominated compounds incorporating the pyrroloiminoquinone moiety, trivially named discorhabdins P, S, T and U (45–48) were obtained from a deep-water marine sponge of the genus Batzella. Discorhabdin P (45) inhibited CaN and CPP32 with IC50 values of 0.55 and 0.37 μM respectively. It also showed in vitro cytotoxicity against the cultured murine P-388 tumor cell line and human lung carcinoma A-549 cell line, with IC50 values of 0.025 and 0.41 μM, respectively [53]. Compounds 46–48 displayed in vitro cytotoxicity against cultured murine P-388 tumor cells, with IC50 values of 3.08, >5 and 0.17 μM, respectively. Further cytotoxicity was also observed for A-549 human lung adeno-carcinoma cells, with IC50 values of >5, >5 and 0.17 μM and for PANC-1 human pancreatic cells with IC50 values of 2.6, 0.7 and 0.069 μM, respectively [54]. A comprehensive review on their therapeutic applications has been reported [55]. Additionally, secobatzellines A-B (49–50), two simple pyrroloiminoquinone enzyme inhibitors were recorded from a deep-water marine sponge of the genus Batzella. Secobatzelline B (50) is an artifact compound that was obtained during the purification process. Secobatzelline A (49) inhibited calcineurin (CaN) and CPP32 with IC50 values of 0.55 and 0.02 μM. Moreover, secobatzelline B (50) inhibited calcineurin (CaN) IC50 values of 2.21 μM. Furthermore, compounds 49 and 50 displayed cytotoxicity in vitro against the cultured murine P-388 tumor cell line, with IC50 values 0.06, 1.22 μM and against human lung carcinoma A-549 cell line, with IC50 values of 0.04, 2.86 μM [56]. A huge number of synthetic aminoiminoquinone and aminoquinones analogues were prepared and tested as capase inhibitors [57]. Furthermore, a comprehensive evaluation for the cytotoxic activity of compounds 38–39, 41–44 and 49–50 were determined against four different pancreatic cell lines Panc-1, AsPC-1, BxPC-3 and MIA-PaCa2 as well as in the Vero cell line, an epithelial cell line from the kidney tissue of an African green monkey [58] (Figure 4).

Figure 4

Isolated pyrroloquinoline alkaloids 38–50 from Batzella sp.

2.5. Polycyclic Alkaloids Bearing Batzelladine

Batzelladines represent a distinct class of particular guanidine-derived alkaloids that usually contain two main guanidinic moieties. Chemically, they are esters compounds that bear a principle tricyclic ring system named clathriadic acid that acting as an acidic portion bonded to another clathriadic acid molecule or crambescin A bicyclic system as an alcoholic part. Such a unique class of marine alkaloids is assumed to be synthesized biomimetically from different modes of cyclization between a polyketide-derived chain and a putative guanidine precursor affording these structurally complex metabolites [59]. These natural compounds are known for their potent bioactivities [13,14]. A considerable number of bioactive batzelladines were recorded from Batzella sponges. Batzelladines A-E (51–55), five potential inhibitors of HIV gpl20-human CD4 binding were recorded from the Caribbean sponge Batzella sp. [13,14]. Batzelladines F-I (56–59), four inducers of p56lck-CD4 dissociation, were isolated from Batzella sp. collected from Jamaica [60]. Batzelladine J (60) was isolated from the Caribbean Monanchora unguifera [61]. A further six guanidines—including batzelladines K-N (61–64), batzelladine C (53) and dehydrobatzelladine C (65)—were discovered from Jamaican Monanchora unguifera with activities against several cancer cell lines, protozoa, HIV-1 and AIDS [14,62,63]. Batzelladine C (53) displayed anti-HIV-1 activity at an EC50 of 7.7 μM [63]. Four batzelladines 66–69 containing crambescin A bicyclic system in addition to dihomodehydrobatzelladine (70) were reported from the Caribbean Monanchora arbuscula. These compounds displayed mild antitumor activity with GI50 (3–7 μM) against three cancer cell lines, lung carcinoma A549, colon carcinoma HT-29 and breast MDA-MB-231, in addition to antimalarial activity against protozoa [64]. Norbatzelladine L (71) was isolated from unidentified species, Monanchora sp. that displayed MNTC (maximum non-toxic concentration) at 2.5 μg mL−1 against HSV-1, with 97% of inhibition in the viral adsorption phase. Furthermore, it displayed cytotoxicity against several human cancer cell lines including leukemia, colorectal, breast, melanoma and glioblastoma [65,66]. Two anti-infective tricyclic members with unique stereochemical features—named merobatzelladines A–B (72–73)—were isolated from Monanchora sp. Merobatzelladines A-B exhibited moderate antimicrobial activity against Vibrio anguillarum with inhibitory zones of 9–10 mm on application of 50 μg of a sample to a paper disk of 6 mm diameter. Moreover, 72–73 also inhibited Tripanosoma bruceibrucei (GUT at 3.1) with IC50 = 0.24 μg mL−1 each. Furthermore, they display moderate inhibitory activity against the K1 strain of Plasmodium falciparum with an IC50 = 0.48 μM and 0.97 μM, respectively [67]. Four anti-parasitic batzelladines (74–77) against Trypanosoma cruzi and Leishmania infantum were recently recorded from Monanchora arbuscula [43,68]. Numerous synthetic batzelladines and their derivatives showed potent activities against HIV-1 and AIDS opportunistic infectious pathogens, inhibition of HIV-1 envelope-mediated fusion [69], inhibitors of HIV-1 Nef interactions with p53, actin and p56lck [70], antimalarial, antileishmanial, antimicrobial and antiviral (HIV-1) activities [71], inhibitors against HIV-1 reverse transcriptase (RT) [72] and antileishmanial [73] (Figure 5 and Figure 6).

Figure 5

Isolated batzelladine alkaloids 51–64.

Figure 6

Isolated batzelladine alkaloids 65–77.

2.6. Pentacyclic Alkaloids Bearing Crambescidin

Crambescidines are pentacyclic guanidine-derived alkaloids that represent recognizable complex marine metabolites. Chemically, they bear a common core of (5,6,8b)-triazaperhydroacenaphthalene in their molecules (trivially named as vessel) that coupled with a linear ω-hydroxy fatty acid (spermidine or hydroxyspermidine). These compounds vary from one to another in the length of the internal polymethylene chain and the oxidation degree of the two-spiro rings within the pentacyclic core. This group of compounds covers the major secondary metabolites recorded from these three genera. Since the discovery of the parent antiviral and cytotoxic marine metabolite ptilomycalin A (78) by Kashman and co-workers [74] from Ptilocaulis spiculifer (family Axinellidae) and Hemimycale sp. (family Hymedesmiidae) collected from the Red Sea coast in 1989, renewable efforts led to the discovery of further crambescidin analogues. Crambescidin 800 (79), crambescidin 816 (80), crambescidin 830 (81) and crambescidin 844 (82) were recorded from the Mediterranean marine sponge Crambe crambe [75]. These compounds demonstrated antiviral and cytotoxic activity against Herpes simplex virus, type1 (HSV-l) and cytotoxic activity against L1210 murine leukemia cells. Compounds 79, 80 and 82 showed complete inhibition for HSV-l and 98% of L1210 cell growth at concentration of IC50 = 0.1 μM. Furthermore, crambescidin 816 (80) displayed potent Ca2+ antagonist activity and inhibited the acetylcholine-induced contraction of guinea pig ileum within very low concentrations [17], however, recent novel evidence showed that compound 80 partially blocked CaV and NaV channels in neurons, proposes that this compound might be included in decreasing the neurotransmitter release and synaptic transmission within the central nervous system [76]. Further, recent study proved that crambescidin 816 (80) could be stored into specialized sponge cells where it can be dispersed into the water affording a chemical umbrella surrounding the Crambe crambe sponge [77]. Recently, Botana and co-workers [78] reported important insights about the mechanism of the neurons cytotoxic activity of crambescidin 816 (80) in primary cultures of cortical neurons. These results showed that compound 80 is responsible for the decreasing of neuronal viability and hence provided a dose-dependent increase in cytosolic Ca2+ level that was also linked to the presence of Ca2+ in the extracellular media. Crambescidins 78, 79 and 80 were recorded also from Batzella sp. [14]. 13,14,15-isocrambescidin 800 (83) with trans-ring junction within the pentacyclic core and crambidine (84) were discovered from Crambe crambe [17,79]. Surprisingly, compound 83 was found to be a less potent cytotoxic against L1210 cells compared to other crambescidines and there was no observed antiviral activity against HSV-1. This observation could be attributed to the enclosed ionic pocket feature found in 78 and related crambescidins and lacking in 83 [80]. Additional crambescidin analogues with a chlorinated spermidine motif including crambescidin 818 (85), crambescidin 834 (86), crambescidin 673 (87), crambescidin 687 (88) and 13,14,15-isocrambescidin 657 (89) without a spermidine unit were recorded from the FABMS guided isolation of Crambe crambe extracts. The ADMET predictor revealed that ptilomycalin and crambescidin 800 (78–79) possess three features of the Lipinski guidelines. Additionally, 78 showed low flexibility and a low tendency to permeate into cell membranes. However, compound 79 displayed low permeability, low flexibility and less tendency to permeate the cell membranes [81] Compounds 87, 88 and 89 exhibited in vitro cytotoxicity against L1210 murine leukemia five times compared to compound 80. Furthermore, they displayed antimicrobial activity against Rhodotorula glutinis [82,83]. Crambescidin 800 (79), crambescidin 359 (90) and crambescidin 431 (91) have been isolated from Monanchora unguiculata [62]. Crambescidin 826 (92) and fromiamycalin (93) were recorded from Monanchora sp. They inhibited HIV-1 envelope-mediated fusion in vitro with an IC50’s = 1–3 μM [14,42]. Indeed 78, 79 and 93 displayed high cytotoxic activity against CEM 4 infected by HIV-1 with CC-50 of 0.11 μg mL−1, without cytoprotective effects, at a dose of <0.1 μM [84]. The antifungal 78 inhibits melanogenesis of Cryptococcus neoformans in vitro through the inhibition of the biosynthesis of laccase in the melanin biosynthetic pathway with an IC50 value of 7.3 μM [85]. Additionally, 79 induced a morphological change with neurite outgrowth in neuro 2A cells at concentration of 0.03–0.1 μM and recorded to induce the differentiation of K562 chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML) cells into erythroblasts accompanied by cell cycle arrest at the S-phase as well [86]. Further pentacyclic members were described, including crambescidin acid (94) from Monanchora ungiculata [35] and crambescidic acid (95) from Monanchora unguifera [61]. Crambescidin 359 (90) and 16-β-hydroxycrambescidin 359 (96) were obtained from Monanchora unguifera [63]. Ptilomycalin D (97) showed cytotoxicity against cancer cell line P-388 with IC50 = 0.1 μM in addition to 78 and 95 were reported from Monanchora dianchora [36]. Monanchocidins A-E (98–102) are five unusual pentacyclic guanidine alkaloids with a morpholine modified spermidine motif from Monanchora pulchra. These compounds exhibited potent cytotoxic activities against HL-60 human leukemia cells with IC50 values of 540, 200, 110, 830 and 650 μM respectively [37]. Monanchocidin A (97) showed anti-migratory activity against several human cancer cell lines where it is able to prevent local expansion and metastatic spread of cancer cells [87]. Moreover, it could be a promising new compound for overcoming resistance to standard therapies in genitourinary malignancies by the induction of autophagy and lysosomal membrane permeabilization [88]. Monanchomycalins A-B (103–104), two pentacyclic with a modified spiro five-membered ring, showed potent cytotoxicity against HL-60 human leukemia cells with the IC50 values 120 and 140 nM, respectively, were isolated from Monanchora pulchra [89]. Recently, compound 104 was recorded to inhibit of the TRPV1, TRPV2 and TRPV3 channels with EC50 values 6.02, 2.84 and 3.25 μM, respectively, however it displayed no activity against the TRPA1 receptor [90]. Moreover, monanchomycalin C (105) exhibited cytotoxicity against human breast cancer cell lines MAD-MB-231 with an IC50 of 8.2 μM, isolated from Monanchora pulchra [91]. Normonanchocidins A-B and D (106–108) were isolated from Monanchora pulchra. Compound 106 and a mixture of 107 and 108 (1:1) displayed cytotoxic activities against human leukemia THP-1 cells with IC50 values of 2.1 μM and 3.7 μM and against cervix epithelial carcinoma HeLa cells with IC50 of 3.8 μM and 6.8 μM, respectively [92]. Recently, further three cytotoxic pentacyclic guanidine compounds including crambescidin 786 (109), crambescidin 814 (110) and 20-norcrambescidic acid (111) along with pentacyclic analogues 79, 90, 92 and 95 were isolated from a French Polynesian sponge Monanchora n. sp. The isolated compounds showed potent antiproliferative and cytotoxic activities against KB, HCT-116, HL-60, MRC-5 and B16-F10 cancer cells. Compounds 109, 110 and 111 exhibited cytotoxicity against KB cell lines with an IC50 values 0.3 μM, 5 nM and 0.5 μM, respectively. The two crambescidin 95 and 111 where the (anchor) motif is terminated with the carboxylic acid functionality displayed potent cytotoxic activity against KB cell lines with IC50 = 0.55 μM, however, they still less active compared with analogues possessing spermidine terminus. Furthermore, crambescidin 800 (79) exhibited the highest cytotoxic activity, while shorter pentacyclic homologue 109 along with the longer one 110 were found less active. These observations might highlight the impact of the polymethylene chain length within the (anchor) motif as a spacer for two site interactions. Crambescidin 359 (90), possessing only a pentacyclic core, showed no activity against KB cell lines and this correlates with the importance of the spermidine part for cytotoxicity. Regarding the B16-F10 murine melanoma cells, crambescidins 79, 92 and 110 exhibited moderate activity with IC50 values of 0.2, 0.8 and 0.2 μM respectively. The discovery of 20-norcrambescidic acid (111) with this new pentacyclic motif carries some biogenesis impacts and raises some important insights about the variation in the oxidation degree and the mode of cyclization within the pentacyclic core [39]. A further two new hybrid pentacyclic guanidines monanchoxymycalin A-B (112–113) were obtained from the Far-Eastern marine sponge Monanchora pulchra. They displayed cytotoxic activities against cervical epithelioid carcinoma HeLa cells and breast adenocarcinoma MDA-MB231 cells [93]. Additionally, ptilomycalins E-H (114–117)—with guanidinic modified spermidine—were recorded from the Madagascar marine sponge Monanchora unguiculata. They displayed promising antimalarial activity against Plasmodium falciparum with IC50 values 0.38, 0.30 and 0.27 μM respectively [94,95] (Figure 7 and Figure 8).

Figure 7

Isolated pentacyclic crambescidin alkaloids 78–89.

Figure 8

Isolated pentacyclic crambescidin alkaloids 90–117.

2.7. Acyclic Guanidine Alkaloids

Small number of open chain guanidine-derived alkaloids was recorded. Pulchranin A (118), was described as the first marine non-peptide inhibitor of TRPV-1 channels with an EC50 value 41.2 μM, in addition two other acyclic members pulchranins B–C (119–120) reported from the Far-Eastern marine sponge Monanchora pulchra. Compounds 119 and 120 exhibited moderate inhibition against TRPV1 with EC50 value 95 and 183 µM respectively and were even less potent against TRPV3 and TRPA1 receptors [96,97]. Moreover, two synthetic derivatives—dihydropulchranin A (121) and hexadecylguanidine (122)—were prepared and studied for their TRPV channel-regulating activities. Compound 121 showed activity as an inhibitor of rTRPV1 and hTRPV3 receptors with EC50 values of 24.3 and 59.1 μM, respectively, while compound 122 was found not active against those receptors [98]. Additionally, recent studies revealed that pulchranin A (118) exhibited cytotoxic properties and prevented EGF-induced neoplastic transformation in vitro [99]. Further, acyclic analogue unguiculin A (123) with a modified bis-guanidine spermidine motif was isolated from the Madagascar marine sponge Monanchora unguiculata. It displayed antimalarial activity against the parasite Plasmodium falciparum with IC50 value of 6.04 μM [94,95]. Recently, a further two acyclic bis-guanidine alkaloids—named unguiculins B-C (124–125), beside unguiculin A (123)—were discovered from the French Polynesian Monanchora n. sp. sponge. These compounds displayed potent cytotoxic activity against KB cell lines with IC50 values 0.19/0.22, 0.08/0.09 and 0.03/0.03 μM respectively. Such activity might be attributed to the two terminal guanidines ends. Moreover, unguiculin C (125), the shorter homologue was found the most active. This could be concluded of how the chain and its length can play an important role as a spacer between two sites of interaction. Moreover, unguiculin B (124) showed further cytotoxicity against HCT-116, HL-60 and MRC-5 cell lines with IC50 values 3.6/3.6, >10/>10 and 9.6/11.4 µM respectively [100,101] (Figure 9).

Figure 9

Isolated acyclic guanidine alkaloids 118–125.

2.8. Terpenoid Compounds

Marine sponges belong to Monanchora genus have also produced a small number of terpenoid metabolites and classical sterols [102]. Nine sesterterpenoids 126–134 were isolated from the Korean Monanchora sp. along with four phorbaketals 135–138. These compounds were investigated for their cytotoxic activity against four human cancer cell lines—A498, ACHN, MIA-paca and PANC-1—where some of them showed potent cytotoxicity [103]. Seven cytotoxic 5α,8α-epidioxy sterols 139–145 were also described from Monanchora sp. These sterols showed moderate cytotoxicity against several human carcinoma cell lines including renal (A-498), pancreatic (PANC-1 and MIAPaCa-2) and colorectal (HCY-116) cancer cell lines [104]. Monanchosterols A-B (146–147) were identified from a South Korean Monanchora sp. and described as the first examples of naturally occurring steroids bearing a rearranged bicyclo [4.3.1] A/B ring system. Moreover, Monanchosterols A-B (146–147) exhibited significant inhibition of mRNA expression of Il-60 without notable cytotoxicity to the cells in a dose-dependent manner [105] (Figure 10).

Figure 10

Isolated terpenoid and steroidal metabolites 126–147 isolated from Monanchora sp.

3. Biomimetic Landmarks of Polycyclic Guanidinium Motifs

The bio-mechanistic studies along with the structural analyses for the different polycyclic guanidine alkaloids revealed two important insights; the first is chemical; where they are sharing the same biogenesis routs. A second is ecological; where marine sponges that produced such metabolites could be systematically classified under the same order. Generally, the different polycyclic guanidinic moieties could be biomimetically synthesized by way of the double aza Michael strategy, by the addition of free guanidine to α, β unsaturated polyketide chains (Figure 11) [59].

Figure 11

Structural analysis of different polycyclic guanidine alkaloids.

3.1. Bicyclic Compounds Possessing Crambescins Type A, B and C

Snider and his team had several contributions towards the biomimetic synthesis of the polycyclic guanidinic motifs. The bicyclic crambescin alkaloids possess three different cyclic moieties—crambescin type A with tetrahydropyrrolo [1,2-c] pyrimidine nucleus, crambescin type B possesses an oxa-6,8-diazaspiro [4.5] motif, while crambescin type C displays a tetrahydropyrimidin fragment. Crambescins type B and C were isolated exclusively from the Mediterranean marine sponge Crambe crambe [34,40,41]. A postulated strategy showed that these three guanidinium cores could be constructed biomimetically through a conjugated Michael addition of guanidine to enone ester. This strategy seems pertinent since it gathers the formation of three different atom arrangements from one unified precursor (Figure 12) [106].

Figure 12

Proposed retrosynthetic analysis of the bicyclic alkaloids.

The less basic O-methylisourea was chosen as guanidine precursor instead of free guanidines. The condensation of O-methylisourea with previously prepared enone (148) followed by acid hydrolysis and desilylation afforded the corresponding dihydropyrimidine intermediate (149). In presence of methanolic ammonium acetate saturated with ammonia, 150 afforded the key compound 150, corresponding to crambescin type C. Subsequently, 150 was transformed to compound 151, corresponding to crambescin type A by mesylation, hydrogenolysis and cyclization. Compound 152 possesses crambescin type B was obtained by cyclization of 150 under basic condition (Figure 13) [106].

Figure 13

a: 2 equiv. O-methylisourea and 7 equiv. NaHCO3 in DMF for 12 h at 60 °C, 79%; b: hydrolysis, TBAF, THF, 12 h, rt, 90%; c: NH4OAc (1.5 equiv.), MeOH saturated with NH3 at 60 °C for 2 days, 61%; d: MsCl, Et3N in DCM for 30 min, 0 °C, 6 h, rt; e: Et3N in CHCl3, reflux, 12 h, 90%; f: Et3N in CHCl3, Δ, 12 h.

Based on the previous biomimetic approach, Berlinck and co-workers [43] accomplished the biomimetic synthesis of the cytotoxic and anti-parasitic monalidine A (18). 1,3-diketone 153 was introduced for condensation with guanidine free base to afford the corresponding pyrimidine 154 in 25% yield. Subsequently, the key intermediate 152 was cyclized using the Mitsunobu modified protocol to afford 18 as hydrochloride salt in a 67% yield (Figure 14).

Figure 14

a: Guanidine hydrochloride, t-BuOK, CF3CH2OH, 30 min, then 154, rt, 48 h, 25%; b: Ph3P, imidazole, I2, CH2Cl2, −18 °C, 6 h, 67%.

3.2. Tricyclic Possessing Ptilocaulin/Batzelladine

(±)-Ptilocaulin (32) was first synthesized biomimetically as a racemic mixture via Michael addition strategy by addition of free guanidine to enone 155 followed by intramolecular enamine formation. (−)-Ptilocaulin (156) was formed as a kinetic product where the guanidine was added to the less hindered top convex face of enone 155, whereas (+)-ptilocaulin (32) was obtained as a thermodynamic adduct as the guanidine was added to the more hindered bottom side of enone 155. This strategy highlights and proves a unique unified biosynthetic route for ptilocaulins and related tricyclic guanidinic analogues (Figure 15) [107,108,109].

Figure 15

a: Guanidine, PH, reflux 25 h, then HNO3 (1% aq), 35%.

The tricyclic guanidinium framework of batzelladine K (61) was biomimetically synthesized through the addition of free guanidine to a bis-enone 157 affording the pyrrolidine-dione 158, which was subsequently introduced to cyclization followed by iminium ion formation giving rise to the full fused tricyclic guanidinium core. A subsequent reduction afforded 61. A unified synthetic strategy was applied to ptilocaulin (32), isoptilocaulin (33) and batzelladine K (61), which indicated that these classes of tricyclic guanidines are subjected to the same biomimetic gate (Figure 16) [71,110,111].

Figure 16

a: Guanidine, DMF, 0 °C, then 25 °C, 5 h b: 0 °C, MeOH-H2O (2:1), NaBH4 (6 equiv.), 25 °C, 16 h, 25%.

3.3. Pentacyclic Possessing Ptilomycalins, Crambescidins and Monanchomycalins

Numerous total syntheses of the pentacyclic guanidinium core of ptilomycalin A (78), crambescidin 800 (79) and crambescidin 359 (95) were biomimetically achieved [23,112,113]. A biomimetic synthesis of the methyl ester of the pentacyclic nucleus of 78 was conducted through a conjugated condensation of O-methylisourea as protected guanidine strategy with double Michael acceptor bis-enone 159 as α-β unsaturated polyketide framework. Subsequently, desilylation under acidic conditions provided the first seven-membered spiroaminal ring within the intermediate 160. Later, the second six-membered spiroaminal ring was achieved under basic conditions followed by subsequently aminal formation affording the ptilomycalin A pentacyclic framework 161 (vessel) in one single biomimetic step (Figure 17).

Figure 17

a: O-methylisourea, i-Pr2EtN, DMSO, 80 °C, 1.5 h (52%, 4:l, H10, H13 trans: H10, H13 cis); b: NH3, NH4OAc, t-BuOH, 60 °C, 40 h (72%, 1:1, H10, H13 cis β: H10, H13 cis α); c: 3:7 HF-CH3CN, −30 °C, 3d; d: Et3N, MeOH, 60 °C, 20 h (78%).

Recently, a detailed biomimetic gate was proposed illustrating the biogenesis of different pentacyclic guanidinium cores. The pentacyclic core of monanchomycalin A (103), suggests polyketide-like biogenesis, followed by spermidine-spermidine condensations. Two different precursors were employed, including either nine acetate units as in monanchomycalin B (104) and other known pentacyclic members, or ten acetate and one propionate units as in monanchomycalin A (103). To finish the pentacyclic guanidinium polyketide framework (vessel), a cyclization key-step developed by adding guanidine to bis-α, β unsaturated chain followed by imine-enamine tautomerization (transformation (a)). Further conversions including the allylic oxidation (transformation (b)) to afford putative intermediates (III and/or IV) followed by cyclization-elimination (c) and (d) to generate monanchomycalins A-B (103–104) and related pentacyclic analogues. Moreover, the interconversion of the presumptive intermediates III and IV (transformation (e)) through allylic rearrangement like reactions also might be possible (Figure 18) [89].

Figure 18

Proposed conversions (a–e) and hypothetical biogenesis of different pentacyclic guanidine alkaloids.

Recently, Guzii and collaborators [96] proposed biogenetic correlations linking between the acyclic guanidine alkaloid pulchranin A (118) and the pentacyclic crambescidins and monanchomycalins A-B (103–104). This proposed biogenetic rout could unify the variation in the oxidation degree for the left-hand side spiroaminal rings (Figure 19).

Figure 19

Pulchranin A (118), as a biosynthetic precursor for pentacyclic compounds (103–104).

4. Conclusions

In conclusion, we have presented complete and comprehensive up-to date literature survey exclusively dedicated to the chemistry, biology and insights on the most leading biomimetic syntheses of guanidine derived natural products isolated from marine sponges of three genera Batzella, Crambe and Monanchora. One hundred forty-seven marine natural products were recorded with distinct structural diversities that afforded wide scope of bioactivities. For their chemodiversity, along with their displayed biological potentialities, they still present promising and attractive marine species that are worth attracting the worldwide interest of natural products chemists and pharmacologists.