| Literature DB >> 35883434 |
Said Moshawih1, Ai Fern Lim1, Chrismawan Ardianto2, Khang Wen Goh3, Nurolaini Kifli1, Hui Poh Goh1, Qais Jarrar4, Long Chiau Ming1,2.
Abstract
Colorectal cancer is one of the most prevalent cancer types. Although there have been breakthroughs in its treatments, a better understanding of the molecular mechanisms and genetic involvement in colorectal cancer will have a substantial role in producing novel and targeted treatments with better safety profiles. In this review, the main molecular pathways and driver genes that are responsible for initiating and propagating the cascade of signaling molecules reaching carcinoma and the aggressive metastatic stages of colorectal cancer were presented. Protein kinases involved in colorectal cancer, as much as other cancers, have seen much focus and committed efforts due to their crucial role in subsidizing, inhibiting, or changing the disease course. Moreover, notable improvements in colorectal cancer treatments with in silico studies and the enhanced selectivity on specific macromolecular targets were discussed. Besides, the selective multi-target agents have been made easier by employing in silico methods in molecular de novo synthesis or target identification and drug repurposing.Entities:
Keywords: cheminformatics; chemotherapy; drug discovery; kinases; protein targets
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35883434 PMCID: PMC9312989 DOI: 10.3390/biom12070878
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Biomolecules ISSN: 2218-273X
Figure 1(a) The top 20 mutated genes with high functional impact involved in colorectal cancer extracted from the ICGC Data Portal in three projects: Colon Adenocarcinoma—TCGA, US, Adenocarcinoma, non-Western (China), Rectum Adenocarcinoma—TCGA, US. https://dcc.icgc.org/ (accessed on 15 December 2021) (b) Significantly mutated genes in hypermutated and non-hypermutated tumors adopted from The Cancer Genome Atlas Network [7].
Figure 2The driver genes and signaling pathways involved across the CRC adenoma–carcinoma sequence from the transition of normal epithelium through to the metastasis stage in colorectal cancer (adopted from [6]). IRS2; insulin receptor substrate 2, MDM2; Mouse double minute 2 homolog, mTOR; Mammalian target of rapamycin. PAK4; p21 (RAC1) activated kinase 4, EMT; epithelial–mesenchymal transition.
Figure 3The genetic pathways and frequencies of mutations collected from 13 studies and 4535 samples in the cBioportal platform that results in deregulation in Wnt signaling pathway, leading to the cell phenotypic modification. The dotted arrow illustrates induction. CTNNB1: Catenin Beta 1, TCF7: Transcription Factor 7, DKK: Dickkopf WNT Signaling Pathway Inhibitor, LRP: LDL Receptor Related Protein, SFRP: Secreted Frizzled Related Protein. The percentage under each gene represents the percent of mutated/altered samples related to the profiled ones in those studies [30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38].
In silico screening studies that tackle tumor suppressor genes with a library of compounds used and the summaries of those findings.
| Screening Type | Ligands | Receptor/PDB ID | Summaries | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A set of docking methods followed by molecular dynamic simulations | ZINC13, NCI, and | APC-Asef/3NMZ | The main target was to prevent APC-Asef interaction that spreads CRC to the entire colon. The induced fit was performed on compounds with a variety of chemical scaffolds and direct interaction with Arg549 and other active site residues. Because of the strong interactions with Arg549, visible conformational changes occur, allowing for proper positioning inside the peptide binding region. The top hit inside the APC-Asef binding region was subjected to specific MD simulations, which revealed substantial interactions necessary for biochemical recognition in a dynamic microenvironment. | [ |
| Structure-based virtual screening by rigid and flexible docking followed by in vitro assays | 13.3 million drug-like and 89.4 natural product compounds | TNKS-1/2RF5 | This study targets the WNT/β-catenin pathway by developing inhibitors against tankyrase 1/2. Out of 11 structurally representative top hits, one compound was selected for experimental analysis | [ |
| Structure-based virtual screening followed by biological assays | 500,000 structurally diverse compounds | Homology modeling of the closely related Smoothened receptor (PDB ID: 4JVK) | The study’s aim was to screen ligands targeting the transmembrane domain of frizzled protein-7 Fzd7. Fzd7 inhibitors have been identified in six small molecule drugs. With IC50 values in the sub-micromolar range, the strongest hit, SRI37892, effectively suppressed Wnt/Fzd7 signaling. | [ |
| High-throughput, and ligand docking-based virtual | 20,000 natural products | Human Telomeric DNA/1KF1 | Using the X-ray crystal structure of the intramolecular human telomeric G-quadruplex DNA, a model of the intramolecular G-quadruplex loop isomer of NHE III1 was created. The aim of this study is to stabilize the c-myc G-quadruplex. The naphthopyrone fonsecin B was found the top candidate. | [ |
| Binding site identification, drug design, and large-scale virtual screening | 4.7 million compounds from ZINC12 drug-like subset | Myc-Max recognizing DNA/1NKP | A binding site on the structurally organized Myc-Max complex’s DNA-binding domain was discovered. Computer-aided drug design was employed to identify a small molecule that can inhibit Myc-Max functionality. In vitro analysis found a chemically different scaffold inhibitor than the previously identified Myc inhibitor. | [ |
| A comprehensive molecular docking and bioinformatics analysis followed by in vitro assays | NSC765600 and NSC765691, derived from diflunisal and fostamatinib respectively | CCND1/6P8G CDK4/4O9W PLK1/2W9F and CD44/1UUH | CCND1/CDK4/PLK1/CD44 were identified as target genes for NSC765600 and NSC765691 compounds by target prediction tools. In numerous cancer types, the mRNA levels of CCND1/CDK4/PLK1/CD44 were greater in tumor tissues than in normal tissues. Protein-protein interaction networks among those genes have been shown after taking into account the gene neighborhood, gene fusion, gene co-occurrence, and the coexpression of CDK4 with CCND1, CD44, and PLK1, and CCND1 with PLK1 have been illustrated. The antiproliferative and cytotoxic effects of the 2 compounds against a panel of NCI-60 cancer cell lines have been illustrated. | [ |
| A comprehensive molecular docking and bioinformatics analysis followed by in vitro assays | Sulfasalazine | KRAS/6BP1, MMP7/2Y6C and CD44/1UUH | The molecular docking revealed a unique interaction between sulfasalazine and KRAS, MMP&, and CD44. Bioinformatic analysis identified overexpression of those oncogenes in CRC cells. The synergistic effects of the sulfasalazine and cisplatin were successful in reducing cell viability, colony, and sphere formation in CRC cell lines. Sulfasalazine therapy reduced KRAS/MMP7/CD44 expression in CRC cell lines in a dose-dependent fashion. | [ |
| Molecular docking and virtual screening followed by in vitro and in vivo assays | 13,000 diverse small molecules from the ZINC database | ND | 68 compounds were identified from the screening to interact with the binding site of α5β1-integrin. By inhibiting the urokinase receptor/integrins interaction, 2-(Pyridin-2-ylamino)-quinolin-8-ol and 2,2′-(methylimino)di (8-quinolinol) suppressed ERK activation. In vivo, these two drugs suppressed ERK activation, tumor development, and metastasis in a model head and neck cancer. | [ |
| Protein binding pocket prediction and structure-based virtual screening | 5000 chemical compounds collected from ZINC were chosen based on structural similarity indices to the four ligand probes | GSK3β/3DU8 | A protein binding pocket screening was done on an X-ray model of human GSK3 beta using the geometric analysis via the Voronoi tessellation algorithm. Pocket geometry is the most important factor in ligand binding. Using molecular docking to find probable binding sites yielded comparable results to protein pocket prediction. | [ |
| Computational drug-repositioning approach for identifying novel anti-cancer agents | 973,296 chemical–gene interactions from Comparative Toxicogenomics Database including 7570 chemicals/drugs and 20,116 genes | ND | DrugPredict platform was employed to repurpose chemicals and drugs for endothelial ovarian cancer. Indomethacin decreases cell viability and promotes apoptosis in patients with primary high grade severe cancer-derived cell lines. Because it inhibits β-catenin and represses multiple Wnt signaling targets, such as Lgr5, TCF7, and Axin2, it proved effective against platinum-resistant ovarian cancer cells. | [ |
| Virtual screening by molecular docking followed by in vitro assays. | 1990 small molecules from the National Cancer Institute database | β-catenin/Tcf4 complex | Site A hotspot on beta-catenin was chosen as a virtual screening pharmacophore. The top-ranked molecule has effectively reduced the β-catenin/Tcf4 driven activity in the CRC cell line. It prevents β-catenin from directly binding to Tcf4 and suppresses the expression and activity of Wnt/β-catenin target genes and gene products. | [ |
| New binding pockets detection, structure- and ligand-based virtual screening, molecular dynamics simulations, and binding free energy calculations | 1880 structures from diversity Set II were | Domain 1 and 2 of LRP6/4DG6, | After applying Lipinski’s rule | [ |
| Ensemble docking-based virtual screening | 3520 natural products | Tp53/1TSR | Natural products were screened to identify a ligand that stabilizes the function of the wild type p53 by targeting its Loop1/Sheet3 pocket. Due to the flexibility of Loop1, ensemble docking for 7 conformations was performed. Compound torilin not only enhanced p53 activity but also p21 protein production, which is downstream of p53. | [ |
| The Nanoluc/YFP-based bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET) test was combined with structure-based virtual screening and followed by | Commercially available protein-protein interaction small molecules from ChemDiv | Bcl-xL/2YXJ | The purpose of this study is to find inhibitors of Bax/Bcl-xL and Bak/Bcl-xL interactions. Based on BRET techniques, a screening platform for Bak/Bcl-xL and Bax/Bcl-xL interactions were developed and identified inhibitors of both interactions. ABT-737, an inhibitor for Bcl-xL, was employed as a positive control drug to identify more inhibitors. 50 Compounds were selected via virtual screening that targeted the ABT-737 binding site and only BIP-A1001 and BIP-A2001 showed dose-response inhibition for the Bax and Bcl-xL interactions within low micromolar concentration | [ |
| Pharmacophore- and structure-based virtual screening | 582,474 compounds from TimTec Compound Libraries | MDM2/3JZK | Based on a conventional Mdm2 inhibitor, a set of pharmacophoric characteristics was developed and utilized to screen a ligand library, and the potential inhibitors were docked into the receptor to check their potential to stop MDM2-p53 interaction. Triazolopyrimidine was among top 5 compounds that bind to the MDM2 active site. | [ |
| Pharmacophore virtual screening and molecular dynamic simulations. | National Cancer Institute and ZINC | Caspase-9/1JXQ | Due to a substantial missing section of the crystallographic structure, the caspase-9 structure was refined. Four structures were employed with | [ |
| Structure- and ligand-based 3D pharmacophore models followed by in vitro assays | 50,000 compounds from Maybridge database | Caspase-3/1pau | Using 25 various compounds, a ligand-based pharmacophore model was generated. Further docking experiments on known inhibitors revealed that the amino acids Arg207, Ser209, and Trp214 found in the active region of caspase-3 are critical for ligand binding. From this study, methyl piperazine was identified as a non-peptide inhibitor against Caspase-3. | [ |
| Homology modeling for predicting target protein sequence and virtual screening for finding inhibitors | Mcule database was used for small molecule virtual screening | TNFRSF10B/2ZB9, 3NKE, 3NKD | TNFRSF10B best model was built by using 2ZB9 template and assessed by 3 different software with high scores. An evolutionary tool was employed to construct a neighbor-joining tree of the target gene based on TNFRSF10A, TNFRSF10D and TNFRSF10B genes. Virtual screening revealed 4 lead compounds with inhibitory activities against the mutated TNFRSF10B activity. To investigate the highly interacting proteins of the target protein, a functional partner network of the TNFRSF10B protein was created. TNFSF10 was utilized as a ligand-protein in protein-protein docking because it had the greatest interaction. | [ |
| Virtual screening (pharmacophoric molecular identification), molecular docking, followed by molecular dynamics and experimental assays | 8 million compounds from a clean and drug-like subset of the ZINC database, and 260,071 compounds from the NCI-2003 library | The crystal structure of TGF-b3 in complex with the extracellular domain of TßRII/1KTZ | The main purpose of this study was to discover drugs that antagonize TGF-b signaling by protein-protein competitively inhibiting TGF-b binding to TßRII. Two compounds were found with a quite good binding affinity (26 and 18 µM). Three compounds were found to bind to SS1 on TßRII over the duration of the simulations, according to molecular dynamics trajectories. The 3 compounds share the chemical property of being aromatic and fairly flat | [ |
| Shape-based virtual screening followed by experimental work and X-ray crystallization study for TGFb-1 inhibitor | 200,000 Compounds in the multi-conformational Catalyst database | The pharmacophoric query was constructed using SB203580′s conformation as shown in the X-ray combination with p38 (PDB: 1a9u). | The pharmacophore features were chosen based on a derived alignment of p38-SB203580 (a triarylimidazole) with TβRI’s ATP site. 87 compounds were identified satisfying both the shape constraint and pharmacophore features. With IC50 of 60 nM, HTS466284 was found to be a strong, non-toxic inhibitor of TßRI in vitro and in cell culture. The aromatic contacts of the HTS466284 indicated by the shape question are satisfied by the quinoline, pyrazole, and pyridyl rings. | [ |
| 2.4 million molecules were retrieved from PubMed to train the RNN model | caspase-6/3OD5 | For | [ |
Figure 4The composition of VEGFR consists of seven immunoglobin-like motifs. VEGF binds to the extracellular domain, and VEGFRs dimerize, leading to a conformational change that is transmitted across the membrane, which leads to activation. Adapted from Schrodinger tutorials [86].
Figure 5(A) The crystal structure of the VEGFR2 kinase domain in complex with a benzimidazole inhibitor (2QU5) has the phenylalanine (highlighted in yellow) of the DFG motif facing much closer to the surface of the active site; therefore, it is in the inactive DFG-out state, and (B) The crystal structure of the VEGFR2 kinase domain in complex with a naphthamide inhibitor (3B8R), showing that the DFG motif has the phenylalanine (highlighted in yellow) facing in towards the center of the pocket between the N-lobe and C-lobe; therefore, it is in the active DFG-in state. The two PDB-derived structures were visualized by Discovery Studio v21.1.
An overview for some Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor Receptor-2 inhibitors, their PDB-ID, resolution, and their effects on other receptor kinase targets.
| VEGFR2 Inhibitor | PDB ID | Resolution | Comments | Inhibitor Type/other RTKs Inhibition |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sorafenib | 4ASD | 2.03 Å | Mutated | Type IIA, also inhibits VEGFR2/3, BRaf, CRaf, mutated BRaf, Kit, Flt3, RET and PDGFRB |
| Axitinib | 4AG8 | 1.95 Å | Mutated | Type IIA, also inhibits VEGFR2/3, PDGFRB |
| Sunitinib | 4AGD | 2.81 Å | Mutated | Type I, also inhibits PDGFRB/alpha, VEGFR2/3, Kit, Flt3, CSF-1R, and RET |
| Pazopanib | 3CJG | 2.25 Å | Not mutated | Type I, also inhibits PDGFRB/alpha, VEGFR2/3, FGFR1/3, Kit, Lck, Fms, Itk. |
| Lenvatinib | 3WZD | 1.57 Å | Mutated | Type I1/2A, also inhibits PDGFR, VEGFR2/3, FGFR, Kit, RET |
| PF-00337210 | 2XIR | 1.50 Å | Mutated | Type II inhibitor |
| CHEMBL272198 | 3B8R | 2.70 Å | Mutated | Type I, also inhibits Aurora B, ABL1, c-MET, Tie2, Lck, Lyn |
| CHEMBL194911 | 1YWN | 1.71 Å | Mutated | Tie-2 and VEGFR2 dual inhibitors |
| 2-Anilino-5-aryloxazole | 1Y6A | 2.10 Å | Not mutated | |
| LENVATINIB | 3WZD | 1.57 Å | Mutated | Also inhibits VEGFR2/3, PDGFR, FGFR, Kit, RET |
| TIVOZANIB | 4ASE | 1.83 Å | Mutated | Pan-inhibitor of VEGF receptors |
| MOTESANIB | 3EFL | 2.20 Å | Mutated | Inhibitor of VEGF, PDGF, and Kit receptors |
Summaries of high throughput virtual screening that aim at finding hits against vascular endothelial growth factor receptor-2.
| Screening Method | Database Size | Summaries | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|
| High throughput virtual screening for EGFR inhibitors | 400,000 compound library of tyrosine kinase inhibitors from ChemBioBase | Indenopyrazole framework was reported as cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor. The framework was discovered to be one of the most prevalent structures among the top 100 scoring compounds, prompting the development of a series of indenopyrazoles. Interestingly, some of the synthesized compounds suppressed VEGFR-2 tyrosine kinase at 1 micromolar. | [ |
| Molecular docking, multicomplex pharmacophore and fingerprint-based 2D similarity in an individual and a combined manner. | 409 actives and 24,680 decoys | In a retrospective comparison, the three combined approaches outperformed 43 of 45 previously published articles. The results showed that the 2D fingerprint ECFP 4 outperformed the multicomplex pharmacophore Glide SP. In self- and cross-docking studies, Glide SP docking with PDB ID: 3EWH was shown to be the best choice for molecular docking-based screening. | [ |
| Molecular flexible docking followed by virtual screening, pharmacophore and ligand energy inspection | 284 compounds from the PubChem database were found with the highest similarity with the best active compound. | Among 23 inhibitors, compound CHEMBL346631 (Pubchem CID: 9936664) was identified as the highest efficient ligand interaction with VEGFR2. The greatest affinity against Renal Cell Carcinoma was found in the dicarboxamide (SCHEMBL469307) from the PubChem database. The original inhibitor chemical is more stable in the receptor protein than the virtually screened one. | [ |
| Virtual screening followed by molecular dynamics and binding free energy decomposition calculations | 30,792 natural derivatives from the ZINC 15 database | Three 1-azabicyclo [2.2.2] octane-3-carboxamide derivatives with excellent affinity were discovered using the VEGFR2 inhibitor as a reference to uncover more inhibitors from natural resources. These potential molecules might be VEGFR-2 inhibitors, according to the RMSD study of each VEGFR-2–inhibitor combination, in addition, they showed low binding free energy and decomposition energy for each VEGFR-2–inhibitor interaction. | [ |
| Virtual screening by using homology models, pharmacophore modeling and in vitro studies | 46 derivatives of 2-anilino-5-phenyloxazoles | As VEGFR2 inhibitors, two 2-anilino-5-phenyloxazole derivatives were shown to be effective. Because the crystal structure of VEGFR2 was not available at the time of this work, homology models were employed instead. At the ATP-binding region, the compounds shared a pharmacophore and established hydrogen bonds with the backbone’s Cys919. The activation loop was disordered between residues 1046 and 1065 in both crystal structures, indicating that residues beyond this region were not directly contributing to the binding affinity. | [ |
| Structure-based pharmacophore models followed by virtual screening of several commercial databases. | Key Organics (48,768), Maybridge (94,448), Otava (69,700), Life Chemicals (248,445), | Following pharmacophore modeling, 16,000 and 19,000 compounds were identified as type I and type II inhibitors respectively. A total of 100 compounds were taken to biological testing after the flexible docking. Three compounds with excellent binding and drug-like characteristics were discovered. The 3-membered ring of the triazinoindole derivative (IC50 = 1.6 micromolar) establishes two standard hydrogen bonds with the backbone NH and the carbonyl oxygen of Cys917 in the kinase motif (type II). | [ |
| De novo structure-based identification methods followed by in vitro assays | A range of pyrazole-based compounds was designed to be employed. | Using a structure-based de novo design, the researchers discovered a new VEGFR2 inhibitor scaffold. As a multi-tyrosine kinase inhibitor, this resulted in the development of a pyrazole-based molecule (JK-P3) that targets VEGFR2 kinase activity and angiogenesis while also inhibiting FGFR kinases in vitro. | [ |
Figure 6RTK, RAS, and PI3K signaling in colorectal cancer showing the genetic pathways and frequencies of mutations in 13 studies and 4535 samples in cBioportal platform that led to deregulation in this pathway reaching the cell phenotypic modification. The percentage under each gene represents the percent of mutated/altered samples relative to profiled ones in those studies [30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38].
The characteristics of virtual screening, protein kinases, and the resulting compounds of the screening.
| Screening Type | Ligands | Receptor/PDB ID | Findings | Ref. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Structure-based screening | Curcumin, litreol, triterpene | EGFR/3POZ | The predicted pharmacological features of curcumin were found to be better than litreol and triterpene. | [ |
| Pharmacophore and docking screening for Korean | 128 ginsenosides | EGFR/1M17 | Molecular docking studies identified 14 hit molecules based on scoring function and suitable binding orientation with critical active site amino acids. | [ |
| The combination of docking and molecular | Erlotinib, Afatinib, and WZ4002 were optimized into A1, B1, and C1 lead compounds. | EGFR/1M17 | Molecular docking was successful in designing new potential compounds using the pharmacophore model of lead compounds. The interaction between lead compounds and the receptor was evaluated by MMGBSA. A1 is a potential compound as an EGFR inhibitor. | [ |
| Structure-based virtual screening | 615,462 compounds were obtained from the ZINC database | EGFR/1M17 | Six compounds displayed good effects when compared with erlotinib at 30 μM. At 2 μM, one compound showed inhibiting effects close to those from erlotinib. | [ |
| Structure-based virtual screening for non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) | 93 million compounds obtained from the PubChem database | AKT/3AOX | The virtual screening showed that (PubChem CID123449015) is more efficient to be a better prospective candidate for NSCLC treatment having better pharmacological profile than the pre-established compound PubChem CID71721648 with low toxicity and cytotoxicity | [ |
| Structure-based screening for repurposing of an antifungal drug against gastrointestinal stromal tumors | A docking with 36 antifungal drugs and 5 antineoplastic drugs. | PDGFRA/5K5X | Itraconazole was predicted as a better PDGFRA inhibitor among all the computationally tested drugs. The binding affinity of Imatinib was close to that of Itraconazole. | [ |
| Structure-based virtual screening toward the experimental DNA G-quadruplex (G4s) structures of | 693,000 commercial compounds obtained from Asinex | Ensemble docking simulations resulted in 442 for | [ | |
| Machine learning-based virtual screening with multiple PI3Kγ protein structures. | 87 crystallographic structures of PI3Kγ-inhibitor complexes | PI3Kγ/4wwo, 5g2n, 3r7q, 3ml8, 2a5u, 4flh, 4fjy, 4ps7, 2v4l, 3dbs | The developed NBC model integrating ten PI3Kγ proteins showed a satisfactory prediction power against PI3Kγ inhibitors. | [ |
| A support vector machine as a virtual screening tool for searching Abl inhibitors from large compound libraries | 13 and a half Million PubChem, | Similarity screening with known Abl inhibitors | The model shows substantial capability in identifying Abl inhibitors at substantially | [ |
| A structure- and ligand-based virtual screening were involved to investigate ligands targeting the allosteric site of Abl kinase | 1424 compounds from DrugBank database v3.0 | Abl/3K5V | A series of in silico techniques like virtual screening, molecular dynamics, and steered molecular dynamic simulations were employed. Gefitinib was identified as an inhibitor for over-expressing Bcr-Abl protein in the K562 CML cell line. It was found that the combination of imatinib and gefitinib produced a synergistic antiproliferative effect in such a cell line. | [ |
| High Throughput Virtual Screening, Standard Precision, and Extra | Natural product libraries of ZINC database and Drug bank database | Abl1/3QRJ | Comparative docking analysis was also carried out on the active site of the ABL tyrosine kinase receptor with a reported reference inhibitor. The purpose was to identify inhibitors for mutated BCR-ABL protein. Six inhibitors were further validated and analyzed through pharmacokinetics properties and a series of ADMET parameters by in-silico methods | [ |
| Structure-based pharmacophore modeling, virtual screening, and molecular docking simulations | 200,000 commercially compounds | 14-3-3σ isoform/1YWT | The purpose was to design a small molecule able to inhibit protein–protein interactions between 14-3-3 and c-Abl. BV02 which was designed by in silico process is a terephthalic acid derivative and was found as an anti-proliferative on human leukemia cells either sensitive or resistant to Imatinib due to the T315I mutation. It also mediates c-Abl release from 14-3-3 protein. | [ |
| High throughout virtual screening for calculating the binding score, hydrogen bonds, and hydrophobic complementarity, and free energy of binding. | 300,000 molecules from the SPECS subset from the Zinc. The database was filtered down to 90,000 for compounds with a logS value of greater than—4 for better solubility | BRaf/2FB8 | Identification of a series of purine-2,6-dione analogs that are selective for BRaf. | [ |
| A virtual docking screening along with pharmacokinetics and drug-likeness predictions to find V600E-BRAF inhibitors. | Eleven derivatives of 4-(quinolin-2-yl) pyrimidin-2-amine. | V600E-BRAF/3OG7 | Two derivatives of 4-(quinolin-2-yl) pyrimidin-2-amine were found to have binding patterns similar to that of the vemurafenib the drug used against V600E-BRAF malignancies. | [ |
| Computer-aided drug discovery including pharmacophore modeling, molecular docking, and molecular dynamic simulations for finding KRAS G12D potential inhibitors | More than 214,000 compounds from InterBioScreen and ZINC databases | KRAS G12D/6GJ8 | Firstly, a common pharmacophoric feature model was generated to extract the important criteria for KRAS inhibition. Ligands from databases were mapped on the model and mapped compounds were finally subjected to molecular docking and dynamic simulations. Four potential inhibitors displaying favorable stability with KRAS G12D were obtained, and only 2 of them showed better binding free energies. | [ |
| Fragment-based drug design was conducted to inhibit KRAS-PDEδ protein–protein interactions | Quinazolinone and f benzimidazole fragments that are attached with PDE gamma | PDEδ/5×73 | A combination of the two fragments produced novel quinazolinone-imidazole KRAS-PDEδ inhibitors. The experimental results approved the high binding affinity and antitumor activity of this compound. | [ |
| Structure-based screening for molecular binding interactions binding affinities | 49 Artemisinin derivatives | HDAC2/3C0Z | It has been found that artemisinin dimer and artemisinin dimer hemisuccinate are promising anticancer drug agents, with better therapeutic efficacy than the standard inhibitors; ulixertinib and apicidin for the treatment of cancer via inhibition of ERK1, ERK2 and HDAC7. | [ |
| Scaffold hopping, followed by fragment-based drug discovery and molecular dynamics simulations | The ERK2 inhibitor Ulixertinib was used for scaffold hopping. | ERK2/6GDQ | Initial hits retained from scaffold hopping usually are not enough for finding potential hits. FBDD can be employed for improving the binding potential of the hopped hits. The identified ligands showed good binding affinity similar to Ulixertinib | [ |
| Structure-based pharmacophore study, followed by virtual screening | 200,158 compounds from the SPECS library | (MAP2K2) MEK2/3DV3 | The pharmacophore model of MEK1 inhibitors was constructed and used for a large-scale virtual screening. 13 virtual hits against MEK1 were obtained from the SPECS library. Then, a small library of carbazoles was synthesized based on one hit by bioisosteric replacement with IC50 at the micromolar level of allosteric inhibition of MEK2. | [ |
| Docking analysis, and pharmacophore modeling study | 350 anticancer natural products. | HER2/3RCD | The hits were selected for the comparative study with the established HER2 inhibitors lapatinib and neratinib and interactions were studied. Finally, the pharmacophoric model was built. Eight natural products were obtained as hits by virtual screening and the comparative study. Results revealed that mostly anthocyanidins have the potential to target the kinase domain of HER2. | [ |
| 2D, 3D quantitative structure–activity relationship (QSAR) and pharmacophore studies. | 725 hits World Drug Index (WDI) and 19,773 from ChemBridge. | IGF-1R/5HZN | Virtual screening of structurally diverse ligands of dual inhibitors of IGF-1R and insulin receptor. Alignment independent molecular descriptors were established for 3Dconformations. Dual potential inhibition of IGF-1R and IR was found for Tirofiban, Practolol, Edoxaban, Novobiocin | [ |
| Structure-based virtual screening, molecular docking, molecular dynamics simulation and ADME prediction | A set of compounds from the NCI database in addition to naringin | PTEN/1D5R | Naringin was found to have better binding with PTEN among the 5 top-ranked compounds, docking scores and energy. The pharmacokinetic properties, Lipinski’s rule violations and binding stabilities of naringin have achieved the best results. | [ |
| Structure-based virtual screening followed by biological evaluation | 35,367 compounds from SPECS | AKT-1/3MVH | Two compounds were identified as AKT inhibitors with micromolar activity and high selectivity index against cancer cell lines. | [ |
| bi- and three-dimensional physical-chemical filtrations followed by phenotypic assays. | 5.9 million compounds from eMolecules database | mTOR/4JT5 PI3Kα/4JPS | The aminopyridine scaffold was found to target the PI3K-AKT-mTOR pathway especially the mTOR and PI3Kα proteins. This kind of drug discovery produced soluble, stable, membrane-permeable and highly selective compounds. | [ |
| Pharmacophore-based virtual screening, molecular docking, and binding free energy calculations study. The structural design of cyclic peptides also included | Three databases; TOS Lab 39,988 | PI3Kα/4KYN | compounds having indole and benzothiazole moieties can act as potent inhibitors against PI3Kα. Linear and cyclic compounds were found to be effective for PI3Kα. 1, 3, 4-oxadiazole-based cyclic peptides with tryptophan showed that cyclic peptides can act as good inhibitors against PI3Kα | [ |
| Virtual inverse screening followed by biological assays | Indirubin-3′-oxime (IOX) and three derivatives of bromo-indirubin-3′oxime; 5BIO, 6BIO, and 7BIO were screened against 6000 protein binding sites | 5 BIO: CDK2/1pxo 6 BIO: GSK3B/1q41 PDK1/1oky 7 BIO: RIFK/1nb9 IOX: CDK2/1pxp | The purpose is to identify kinase targets for three derivatives of indirubin; 5BIO, 6BIO, and 7BIO. 5BIO, 6BIO (EF = 16) and IOX (EF = 20) show significant enrichment of their well-known targets (CDK2, CDK5, GSK-3β) in the top 1%. This process has led to the identification of the kinase PDK1 as an unknown target of the indirubin derivative 6BIO. | [ |
| Ligand-based screening, rigid and flexible receptor-based docking, molecular adynamic simulations and binding free energy calculations | 688,086 compounds from ZINC 15 were reduced to 157,623 compounds after the pre-screening process. | PDK1/2BIY | The compounds were first screened by using the ligand-based method, then rigid docking, followed by flexible molecular docking using, molecular dynamics simulation and molecular mechanics/Poisson–Boltzmann surface area (MM-PBSA) binding free energy calculations. | [ |
| Ensemble docking to disrupt protein–protein interactions followed by rescoring with the molecular mechanics Poisson–Boltzmann surface area (MM/PBSA) | 84,589 compounds were studied by Xiao et al. [ | FGF23/2P39 | The target selected has only a partial crystal structure and no a priori knowledge of small-molecule binding sites. Two putative binding sites for drug-like antagonist molecules binding to the hormone FGF23 were identified using a multicenter ensemble docking technique. The use of MM/PBSA rescoring to further enhance the MED results demonstrates the value of going from lower-resolution approaches to higher-resolution methods for refining a predicted binding mode. This study also reveals how the steric crowding of pockets by side-chain conformers might affect docking outcomes. Authors hypothesized that the protein–protein interface is being drugged and not a distal pocket that would indicate allosteric signaling | [ |