| Literature DB >> 35740591 |
Paolo Palmisciano1, Gina Watanabe2, Andie Conching2, Christian Ogasawara2, Gianluca Ferini3, Othman Bin-Alamer4, Ali S Haider5, Maria Gabriella Sabini6,7, Giacomo Cuttone7, Sebastiano Cosentino8, Massimo Ippolito8, Giuseppe E Umana9.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The development of [68Ga]Ga-DOTA-SSTR PET tracers has garnered interest in neuro-oncology, to increase accuracy in diagnostic, radiation planning, and neurotheranostics protocols. We systematically reviewed the literature on the current uses of [68Ga]Ga-DOTA-SSTR PET in brain tumors.Entities:
Keywords: Gallium PET; PET; meningioma; neuro-oncology; nuclear medicine; theranostics
Year: 2022 PMID: 35740591 PMCID: PMC9221214 DOI: 10.3390/cancers14122925
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cancers (Basel) ISSN: 2072-6694 Impact factor: 6.575
Figure 1PRISMA 2020 flow diagram.
Summary of all included studies and pooled patients.
| Characteristics | Total | Diagnostic Purposes | Treatment Planning | Neuro-Theranostics |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cohort size, No. (%) | ||||
| Patients | 1030 | 644 (62.5%) | 337 (32.7%) | 49 (4.8%) |
| Lesions | 1277 | 867 (67.9%) | 356 (27.9%) | 54 (4.2%) |
| Pathology, No. lesions (%) | ||||
| Meningioma | 1196 (93.6%) | 806 (93%) | 355 (99.7%) | 40 (74.1%) |
| Pituitary adenoma | 36 (2.8%) | 36 (4.2%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) |
| Brain metastases | 15 (1.2%) | 15 (1.7%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) |
| High-grade glioma | 12 (0.9%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) | 12 (22.2%) |
| Pituitary carcinoma | 6 (0.5%) | 3 (0.3%) | 1 (0.3%) | 2 (3.7%) |
| Granulomatous inflammation | 2 (0.2%) | 2 (0.2%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) |
| Lymphoma | 2 (0.2%) | 2 (0.2%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) |
| Glomus jugulare | 1 (0.1%) | 1 (0.1%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) |
| Hemangioma | 1 (0.1%) | 1 (0.1%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) |
| Schwannoma | 1 (0.1%) | 1 (0.1%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) |
| Tracer, No. patients (%) | ||||
| DOTATOC | 548 (53.2%) | 275 (42.7%) | 250 (74.2%) | 23 (46.9%) |
| DOTATATE | 403 (39.1%) | 329 (51.1%) | 68 (20.2%) | 6 (12.2%) |
| DOTANOC | 59 (5.7%) | 40 (6.2%) | 19 (5.6%) | 0 (0%) |
| DOTATOC/DOTATATE | 20 (1.9%) | 0 (0%) | 0 (0%) | 20 (40.8%) |
Overview of all included studies using [68Ga]Ga-DOTA-SSTR PET for diagnostic purposes.
| Authors—Year | Reason for | Patients/ | Pathology/Tracer | MBq Dose/ | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Henze, 2001 [ | Diagnostic | 3/ | Meningioma/ | 175/ | Higher accuracy in evaluating intraosseous extent at skull base |
| Afshar-Oromieh, | Compare the accuracy to MRI | 134/ | Meningioma/ | 139.6 (55–307)/ | Higher sensitivity for tumors at falx cerebri and skull base |
| Graf, 2012 [ | Detect infracranial invasion | 16/ | Meningioma/ | 70–120/ | Higher accuracy in evaluating infracranial invasion |
| Law, 2013 [ | Systemic tumor staging | 1/ | Meningioma/ | 250/ | Incidental meningioma detection |
| Yilmaz, 2013 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | High DOTATOC uptake with low FDG uptake |
| Boss, 2014 [ | Assess the accuracy of hybrid PET/MRI | 3/ | Meningioma/ | 135 (126–153)/ | Similar accuracy to PET/CT |
| Slotty, 2014 [ | Differentiate recurrence from scarring | 1/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Higher accuracy in differentiating tumor (uptake) versus scar (no uptake) |
| Zhao, 2014 [ | Assess pituitary reserve and residual adenoma | 35/ | Pituitary adenoma/ | 100–200/ | Higher DOTATOC uptake pituitary reserve and higher FDG uptake residual tumor |
| Afshar-Oromieh, 2015 [ | Assess the accuracy of hybrid PET/MRI | 15/ | Meningioma/ | 190 (100–265)/ | High sensitivity/specificity (PET) and morphological evaluation (MRI) |
| Klingenstein, | Differential | 13/ | Meningioma (10), other (3)/DOTATATE | N/A/ | Confirm meningioma (high uptake) vs. other diseases (no/low uptake) |
| Rachinger, 2015 [ | Differentiate tumor from tumor-free tissue | 21/ | Meningioma/ | 150/ | SUVmax 2.3 threshold to differentiate tumor tissue versus non-tumor tissue |
| Taneja, 2015 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Granulomatous inflammation/ | N/A/ | High uptake in granulomatous inflammation |
| Xiao, 2015 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Pituitary carcinoma/ | N/A/ | High expression SSTR2 in pituitary carcinoma plus FDG-undetected lesions (4) |
| Basu, 2016 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Pituitary adenoma and meningioma/ | N/A/ | Synchronous detection meningioma plus pituitary adenoma |
| Sommerauer, | Predict tumor growth rate | 23/ | Meningioma/ | 150/ | DOTATATE-PET predicts tumor growth in grade-1 and grade-2 meningiomas |
| Garmes, 2016 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Pituitary carcinoma/ | N/A/ | Confirmation of pituitary carcinoma with metastases |
| Kunz, 2017 [ | Detect intraosseous invasion | 82/ | Meningioma/ | 150/ | Higher detection transosseous extent of meningiomas than contrast-enhanced MRI |
| Unterrainer, | Diagnostic | 1/ | Brain metastasis/ | N/A/ | High tracer uptake in metastases from thyroid carcinoma |
| Villanueva-Meyer, 2018 [ | Tumor staging | 1/ | Meningioma/ | 136.9/ | Detection of multiple dural-based plus liver metastases |
| Dressen, 2019 [ | Assess SSTR2 expression | 67/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | High DOTATATE uptake (SSTR2 expression) may coincide with low FDG uptake (low metabolic rate) |
| Ivanidze, 2019 [ | Diagnostic | 20/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Differentiate residual meningioma versus post-therapy change (target lesion/superior sagittal sinus) |
| Purandare, 2019 [ | Differential | 40/ | Meningioma (31), dural metastases (4)/DOTATOC | N/A/ | Higher accuracy in differentiating meningiomas (high uptake) from dural-based metastasis (low uptake) |
| Unterrainer, | Diagnostic | 1/ | Meningioma and dural metastasis/ | N/A/ | Differentiation of concurrent meningioma and dural-based metastasis |
| Unterrainer, | Diagnostic | 1/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Detection of multiple meningiomas and liver, lung, and bone metastases |
| Bashir, 2020 [ | Differential | 2/ | Meningioma (1), lymphoma (1)/ | N/A/ | Different lesions showed similar SUVmax |
| Bashir, 2020 [ | Relation tracer uptake and SSRT2 expression | 15/ | Meningioma/ | 105/ | Tumor-to-background ratio best PET metric for the evaluation of SSTR2 expression |
| Ueberschaer, | Assess the extent of resection | 49/ | Meningioma/ | 150/ | Postoperative PET has higher accuracy than Simpson grade |
| Assadi, 2021 [ | Assess radionuclide response | 1/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Reduced SUVmax after radionuclide |
| Barone, 2021 [ | Assess SUV changes after radiosurgery | 20/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Post-radiosurgery reduction of SUVmax in 7/12 patients |
| Einhelling, 2021 [ | Compare the accuracy to MRI | 57/ | Meningioma/ | 163.2/ | High sensitivity in detecting small sphenoidal or orbital meningiomas |
| Fabritius, 2021 [ | Differential | 1/ | Brain metastasis/ | N/A/ | High expression SSTR2 in breast cancer metastasis |
| Hanslund-Vinding, 2021 [ | Assess residual tumor post-surgery | 6/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | DOTATATE plus biopsy “area of doubt” to confirm complete tumor resection |
| Kaya, 2021 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Pituitary carcinoma/ | N/A/ | Confirmation of spinal cord metastases |
| Ragni, 2021 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Brain metastasis/ | N/A/ | Incidental finding pituitary mass in NEN follow-up |
| Vay, 2021 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Confirm optic nerve sheath meningioma |
| Yarmohammadi, 2021 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Confirm optic nerve sheath meningioma |
| Balabanc Genc, 2022 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Glomus jugulare/ | N/A/ | Confirm recurrent glomus jugulare invading the cerebellum |
| Farce, 2022 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Schwannoma/DOTATOC | N/A/ | Low DOTATOC uptake, low FDG uptake, high choline uptake |
| Filizoglu, 2022 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Pituitary carcinoma/ | N/A/ | Confirm pituitary carcinoma plus systemic metastases |
| Fine, 2022 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Brain metastasis/ | N/A/ | Confirm pineal metastasis in neuroendocrine neoplasm follow-up |
| Mairal, 2022 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Mismatch low DOTATOC and high FDG |
| Saidi, 2022 [ | Diagnostic | 1/ | Hemangioma/DOTATATE | N/A/ | High DOTATATE uptake post-traumatic hemangioma |
Overview of all included studies using 68Ga-DOTA-SSTR PET for planning radiotherapy and/or surgical resection.
| Authors—Year | Reason for | Patients/ | Pathology/Tracer | MBq Dose/ | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Milker-Zabel, | Volume contouring for fractionated SRT | 26/ | Meningioma/ | 156/ | Change target definition in 19 patients (73%) |
| Gehler, 2009 [ | Volume contouring for intensity-modulated RT | 26/ | Meningioma/ | 150/ | Improved target definition for skull base and recurrent tumors |
| Nyuyki, 2010 [ | Volume contouring for SRT | 42/ | Meningioma/ | 70–120/ | Improved target definition for osseous infiltrated tumors |
| Thorwart, 2011 [ | Volume contouring for intensity-modulated RT | 1/ | Meningioma/ | N/A | Lower target definition with PET/MRI than PET/CT + MRI |
| Combs, 2013 [ | Volume contouring for proton/carbon therapy | 70/ | Meningioma/ | N/A | Improved target definition for post-resection lesions |
| Graf, 2013 [ | Volume contouring for fractionated SRT | 54/ | Meningioma/ | 70–120/ | Improved target definition for skull base tumors (lower GTV) |
| d’Amico, 2014 [ | Volume contouring for cyber knife | 1/ | Pituitary carcinoma/ | N/A | Improved target definition for pituitary carcinoma invading the cavernous sinus |
| Maclean, 2017 [ | Volume contouring for RT | 10/ | Meningioma/ | 100/ | Improved inter-observer variability in contouring |
| Stade, 2018 [ | Volume contouring for RT | 10/ | Meningioma/ | N/A | Reduction in treatment volumes and doses to organs at risk |
| Zollner, 2018 [ | Volume contouring for RT | 20/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Extended safety margins (>1 cm) favor higher local control |
| Acker, 2019 [ | Volume contouring for cyber knife | 10/ | Meningioma/ | 165/ | PET/MRI improves target definition in training doctors |
| Graef, 2021 [ | Volume contouring for cyber knife | 8/ | Meningioma/ | 168/ | Improved target definition for optic nerve sheath meningiomas |
| Guinto-Nishimura, 2021 [ | Intraoperative resection guidance | 1/ | Meningioma/ | N/A | Improved target definition for intraosseous meningioma |
| Kowalski, 2021 [ | Volume contouring for RT | 19/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Improved target definition for intraosseous and falx meningiomas |
| Mahase, 2021 [ | Volume contouring for hypofractionated RT | 8/ | Meningioma/ | N/A | Reduction in treatment volumes and doses to organs at risk |
| Pelak, 2021 [ | Volume contouring for proton therapy | 30/ | Meningioma/ | 75-273/ | Identification of MRI-undetected lesions and improved definition of intraosseous extension |
Overview of all included studies using [68Ga]Ga-DOTA PET for planning neurotheranostics therapy.
| Authors—Year | Reason for [68Ga]Ga-PET | Patients/ | Pathology/Tracer | MBq Dose/ | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Collamati, 2015 [ | Estimate uptake of [90Y]Y-DOTATOC tracer | 23/ | High-grade glioma (12), meningioma (11)/ | N/A/ | Pilot study using 68Ga-DOTATOC to estimate uptake of 90Y-DOTATOC radiotracer to guide tumor resection |
| Novruzov, 2015 [ | Assess SSTR2 expression for [177Lu]Lu-DOTATE therapy | 1/ | Pituitary carcinoma/ | N/A/ | High [68Ga]Ga -DOTATATE uptake (SSTR2 expression) in pituitary carcinoma with use for [177Lu]Lu-DOTATE therapy |
| Seystahl, 2016 [ | Assess SSTR2 expression for [177Lu]Lu-DOTATE therapy | 20/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Higher SSTR2 expression in a tumor correlated with higher rates of stable disease at 6 months post-therapy |
| Verburg, 2019 [ | Intraarterial injection versus venous infusion to evaluate tracer uptake for [177Lu]Lu-DOTATE therapy | 4/ | Meningioma/ | N/A/ | Selective intraarterial DOTATATE injection increases tracer uptake in meningiomas with insufficient venous uptake confirming eligibility for [177Lu]Lu-DOTATE therapy |
| Lybik, 2021 [ | Assess SSTR2 expression for [177Lu]Lu-DOTATE therapy | 1/ | Pituitary carcinoma/ | N/A/ | High [68Ga]Ga-DOTATATE uptake (SSTR2 expression) in pituitary carcinoma with use for [177Lu]Lu-DOTATE therapy |
Overview of all ongoing clinical trials on [68Ga]Ga-DOTA-SSTR PET in neuro-oncology.
| Investigator—Trial Number | Enrollment/ | Inclusion Criteria | Exclusion Criteria | Primary | Secondary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Filipsson Nyström | 22/ | (1) Naïve, unoperated pituitary tumor with GH or ACTH or TSH production or non-functioning without treatment with somatostatin analogues or dopamine agonists. | (1) Pregnancy or lactating; | SUVmax in pituitary tumors compared to normal pituitary | (1) Correlate [68Ga]Ga-DOTATOC uptake with expression of SSTR2; |
| Ivanidze | 90/ | (1) Age ≥ 18 years; | (1) Contraindications to gadolinium-based contrast agent; | Diagnostic accuracy of [68Ga]Ga-DOTATATE PET/MRI will be compared to MRI alone. | Correlate [68Ga]Ga-DOTATATE PET/MRI with expression of: |
| Johnson | 12/ | (1) Any meningioma with ≥10 mm measurable residual disease; | (1) Neurofibromatosis type 1 or 2; | (1) Diagnostic accuracy of [68Ga]Ga-DOTATATE PET/CT; | N/A |
| Merrell | 41/ | (1) Prior treatment (surgery and/or radiation); | (1) Eligibility for surgery or radiation with curative intent; | Progression-free survival at 6 months after [68Ga]Ga-DOTATATE PET/MRI + [177Lu]Lu-DOTATATE therapy. | (1) Overall survival; |
Figure 2(A) MRI scan showing a left sphenopetrosal lesion suspected to be meningioma; (B) [68Ga]Ga-DOTATOC PET/CT scan showing high tracer uptake of the left sphenopetrosal lesion, suggesting the diagnosis of meningioma, normal tracer uptake of the pituitary gland.
Figure 3[68Ga]Ga-DOTATOC PET/CT scan showing a left intraventricular lesion with high tracer uptake in a patient with a history of carcinoid. GK treatment was planned by contouring the margins of the lesion with tracer uptake.