| Literature DB >> 34959976 |
Brooke E Wickman1, Byambaa Enkhmaa2,3, Ronit Ridberg2, Erick Romero4, Martin Cadeiras4, Frederick Meyers2, Francene Steinberg1,2.
Abstract
Heart failure (HF) is a major health care burden increasing in prevalence over time. Effective, evidence-based interventions for HF prevention and management are needed to improve patient longevity, symptom control, and quality of life. Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) diet interventions can have a positive impact for HF patients. However, the absence of a consensus for comprehensive dietary guidelines and for pragmatic evidence limits the ability of health care providers to implement clinical recommendations. The refinement of medical nutrition therapy through precision nutrition approaches has the potential to reduce the burden of HF, improve clinical care, and meet the needs of diverse patients. The aim of this review is to summarize current evidence related to HF dietary recommendations including DASH diet nutritional interventions and to develop initial recommendations for DASH diet implementation in outpatient HF management. Articles involving human studies were obtained using the following search terms: Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH diet), diet pattern, diet, metabolism, and heart failure. Only full-text articles written in English were included in this review. As DASH nutritional interventions have been proposed, limitations of these studies are the small sample size and non-randomization of interventions, leading to less reliable evidence. Randomized controlled interventions are needed to offer definitive evidence related to the use of the DASH diet in HF management.Entities:
Keywords: DASH diet; diet pattern; dietary approaches to stop hypertension; heart failure; metabolism; metabolomics; personalized nutrition; precision nutrition
Mesh:
Year: 2021 PMID: 34959976 PMCID: PMC8708696 DOI: 10.3390/nu13124424
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nutrients ISSN: 2072-6643 Impact factor: 5.717
Figure 1The potential role of the DASH diet in heart failure management. Assessment of patients with heart failure (HF) stages (A–D) is followed by comprehensive clinical care management, which includes an individual-level DASH diet recommendation. Once successfully adopted and adhered to, the DASH diet can improve patients’ physical and functional capacities through reductions in blood pressure, body weight, and LDL cholesterol concentration and improvements in cardiac function, arterial compliance, exercise capacity, and quality of life. The positive effects of the DASH diet implemented as part of a comprehensive care plan for risk reduction and disease management and monitoring can contribute to improved health outcomes.
Comparison of nutrient composition of DASH diets used in feeding intervention studies.
| Study | Appel et al., | Sacks et al., | Lin et al., | Hummel et al., |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DASH diet name used in study | Combination diet | DASH diet at low, | Established recommendations + DASH diet (EST+DASH) | Sodium-restricted DASH diet (DASH/SRD) |
| Diet comparators | Control; Fruits-and-vegetables | Control at low, intermediate, and high sodium levels | Control; Established recommendations | None (DASH/SRD compared to baseline diet) |
| Energy level associated with | 2100 | 2100 | 1705 | 2040 |
| Macronutrients | ||||
| Fat (% of total kcal) | 26 | 26 | 26 | 29 |
| Saturated fat (% of total kcal) | 7 | 5 | 8 | Not available |
| Monounsaturated fat (% of total kcal) | 10 | 13 | 10 | Not available |
| Polyunsaturated fat (% of total kcal) | 7 | 8 | 6 | Not available |
| Carbohydrates (% of total kcal) | 57 | 56 | 57 | 58 |
| Protein (% of total kcal) | 18 | 18 | 18 | 19 |
| Cholesterol (mg/d) | 151 | 150 | 205 | 211 |
| Fiber (g/d) | Not available | 32 | 22 | 34 |
| Micronutrients | ||||
| Sodium (mg/d) | 2859 | 1150 or 2300 or 3450 | 2412 | 1450 |
| Potassium (mg/d) | 4415 | 4700 | 3256 | 4274 |
| Magnesium (mg/d) | 480 | 500 | 311 | Not available |
| Calcium (mg/d) | 1265 | 1250 | 907 | 1350 |
| Nutrient values based on: | Menu nutrient analyses | Menu nutrient targets described in study design publication | Mean intakes calculated from 24-h recall data at 18-month timepoint in intervention. Energy based on absolute intake (unadjusted) | Mean menu nutrient analyses from days 16-21 of the study |
| Intervention duration | 8 weeks | 30 days | 18 months | 3 weeks |
| Participants | ||||
| Mean BP changes in DASH diet group compared to control (mmHg) | Ambulatory 24-h BP compared to baseline | |||
| Systolic (mmHg) | −5.5 | −5.9 high; −5.0 intermediate; −2.2 low | −4.6 at 6 months; −2.1 at 18 months | −7 |
| Diastolic (mmHg) | −3.0 | −2.9 high; −2.5 intermediate; −1.0 low | −2.1 at 6 months; −1.0 at 18 months | −5 |
Figure 2Potential predictors of DASH diet success and mechanisms underlying its positive effects in heart failure. The DASH diet effectiveness in HF risk reduction and management can be influenced by many different factors. Examples of individual patient-level factors (I) and factors associated with the environment, society, and culture (II), which are also intertwined with the individual patient-level factors, are shown. In addition, there are factors specifically associated with the clinical management of heart failure that may influence DASH diet success (III) Once successfully implemented and adhered to, the DASH diet may reduce HF risk through several different mechanisms associated with improved systemic and local responses (IV).
Metabolite markers associated with DASH feeding studies.
| Study | Aim | Design & Diet | Subject Group | Omic Method | Bio-Sample | Main Finding |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mathew A, et al., 2015 J Card Fail [ | Characterize metabolomic changes following DASH Sodium-restricted diet intervention | Single arm, Controlled feeding study, 3 weeks DASH sodium reduced diet Ş | Adults with HTN and HFpEF ( | GC-MS and LC-MS, targeted | Serum | Short-chain acyl carnitine metabolites increased significantly, correlated with improved cardiac function |
| Derkach A, et al., 2017 AJCN [ | Evaluate the effect of sodium intake on metabolomic profiles following control and DASH diet intervention | RCT, Crossover Controlled feeing study, 2-week run-in, 12 weeks DASH vs. Control arms each with 3 sodium levels for 4 weeks each intervention ¥ | Adults with HTN, M + F, mixed race, | LC-MS, untargeted | Plasma | Sodium intake significantly associated with changes in 6 metabolite pathways. Adjustment for change in diet pattern or blood pressure did not alter associations |
| Rebholz CM, et al., 2018 AJCN [ | Identify metabolites associated with DASH diet pattern | RCT, Parallel, Controlled feeding study, 3-week Control run-in, 8 weeks feeding DASH diet or Control or Fruit & Vegetable-rich diet ≠ | Adults with pre-and stage 1 HTN, M + F, mixed race, | GC-MS and LC-MS, untargeted | Serum | Multiple metabolites differed significantly DASH vs. Control (97) and DASH vs. fruit/veg (67); Identified 10 most influential metabolites as candidate biomarkers for assessing adherence to DASH diet; metabolites represented classes of lipids, amino acids, xenobiotics and food components, cofactors and vitamins, carbohydrates |
| Reisdorph N, et al., 2020 Sci Report [ | Characterize changes in metabolome following DASH diet intervention, and characterize food specific compounds (FSC) | RCT, Crossover, Controlled feeding study, 2-week habitual diet run-in, 6-week feeding each of two DASH style diets Ş | Adults, M + F, | LC-MS, untargeted | Urine and foods | FSC from DASH diet were detected in urine along with other metabolites; 16 metabolites were significantly associated with BP and 6 with change in BP |
| Chaudhary P, et al., 2021 Hypertension [ | Evaluate the effect of sodium intake on metabolomic and lipidomic profiles between salt-sensitive and salt-resistant individuals | RCT, Crossover Controlled feeing study, 2-week run-in, 12 weeks DASH vs. Control arms each with 3 sodium levels for 4 weeks each intervention ¥ | Adults with HTN, M + F, mixed race, | LC-MS, untargeted | Plasma | Baseline comparisons exhibited no differences, but 3 metabolites differed significantly in salt sensitive subjects with change in sodium intake |
| Kim H, et al., 2021 MNFR [ | Determine if candidate serum biomarkers from original DASH trial replicate in urine in DASH-Sodium trial | RCT, Crossover Controlled feeing study, 2-week run-in, 12 weeks DASH vs. Control arms each with 3 sodium levels for 4 weeks each intervention ¥ | Adults with HTN, M + F, mixed race, | LC-MS, untargeted | Urine | Identified several novel metabolite markers of the DASH diet; Replicated 8 significant urine metabolites identified in serum of original DASH trial that distinguish DASH vs. Control; Identified 9 significant urine metabolites identical in DASH-high sodium and DASH-low sodium diets |
| Pourafshar S, et al., 2021 Nutrients [ | Characterize changes in metabolome following DASH diet intervention | RCT, Parallel, Controlled feeding study, 1 week Control run-in, 2 week feeding DASH diet or Control Ş | Adults with HTN, M + F, mixed race, | GC-MS, untargeted | Plasma and urine | Urine—19 metabolites differed significantly DASH vs. Control; Plasma—8 metabolites differed significantly DASH vs. Control; Major classes included phenolics, amino acid, organooxygen compounds, and cofactors |
DASH diet and metabolomic analyses in the literature. Seven DASH feeding trials have assessed diet-responsive metabolites in various biosamples. Table 1 shows a summary of the subject population, biosamples, omic technological approach, study aim, study design and diet, the main study findings, and the study reference. Ş: Separate DASH-style diet trial specimens. ¥: Measurements from DASH–Sodium trial specimens. ≠: Measurements from original DASH trial specimens. Abbreviations: J Card Fail—Journal of Cardiac Failure; AJCN—American Journal of Clinical Nutrition; Sci Report—Scientific Reports; Hypertension—Journal of Human Hypertension; MNFR—Molecular Nutrition & Food Research; RCT—randomized controlled trial; M—male; F—female; GC-MS—gas chromatography-mass spectrometry; LC-MS—liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry.
Metabolite markers and relationship to DASH diet components.
| Study | Omic Platform | Bio-Sample | Metabolites | Associated Foods/Food |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| [ | Targeted | Serum | Short-chain acyl carnitine metabolites increased significantly, L-carnitine and propionyl carnitine correlated with improved left ventricular cardiac function | Results associated with dietary changes and energy utilization; no specific foods were discussed other than increased fiber intake |
| [ | Untargeted | Plasma | Sodium intake significantly associated with changes in 6 metabolite pathways. Adjustment for change in diet pattern or blood pressure did not alter associations. Significant pathways (most increased with sodium restriction, while γ-glutamyl decreased with sodium restriction): | Greatest responder to reduced sodium intake was increase in 4-ethylephenylsulfate (Benzoate pathway) gut metabolite associated with soy intake; 4-allylpheol sulfate & homostachydrine (food component or plant group metabolites) may be related to herbs and seasonings added to low sodium diet to increase palatability; decrease in isovalerate (fatty acid pathway) may be gut microbiota changes related to salt intake |
| [ | Untargeted | Serum | Multiple metabolites differed significantly DASH vs. Control (97) and DASH vs. fruit/veg (67); metabolites represented classes of lipids, amino acids, xenobiotics and food components, cofactors and vitamins, carbohydrates | Citrus fruits (N-methylproline and stachydrine) |
| [ | Untargeted | Urine & food | Food specific compounds from DASH diet containing 12 specified foods were detected in urine along with other metabolites (13-190 metabolites per food); 16 urinary metabolites were significantly associated with BP and 6 with change in BP: | 12 specific foods from a DASH diet and their metabolites were characterized in this study: |
| [ | Untargeted | Plasma | Baseline comparisons exhibited no differences, but 3 metabolites (2 lipids and one organic acid derivative) differed significantly in salt sensitive subjects with change in sodium intake: | Salt sensitive individuals exhibit an altered metabolome on high salt intake, no specific foods or food components were investigated |
| [ | Untargeted | Urine | Identified additional novel urinary metabolites associated with DASH diet: | Plant foods (N-methylglutamate) |
| [ | Untargeted | Plasma & urine | Urine—19 metabolites (phenolic acids and microbial metabolites) differed significantly DASH vs. Control; Plasma—8 metabolites differed significantly DASH vs. Control; Major classes included phenolics, amino acid, organooxygen compounds, and cofactors | Whole grains, fruits, vegetables, herbs (polyphenol and phenolic acid rich foods) |