| Literature DB >> 32313062 |
Felix Aberer1, Verena Theiler-Schwetz1, Haris Ziko1, Bettina Hausegger2, Iris Wiederstein-Grasser2, Daniel A Hochfellner2, Philipp Eller3, Georg Tomberger4, Martin Ellmerer4, Julia K Mader5, Vladimir Bubalo2.
Abstract
Intravascular glucose sensors have the potential to improve and facilitate glycemic control in critically ill patients and might overcome measurement delay and accuracy issues. This study investigated the accuracy and stability of a biosensor for arterial glucose monitoring tested in a hypo- and hyperglycemic clamp experiment in pigs. 12 sensors were tested over 5 consecutive days in 6 different pigs. Samples of sensor and reference measurement pairs were obtained every 15 minutes. 1337 pairs of glucose values (range 37-458 mg/dl) were available for analysis. The systems met ISO 15197:2013 criteria in 99.2% in total, 100% for glucose <100 mg/dl (n = 414) and 98.8% for glucose ≥100 mg/dl (n = 923). The mean absolute relative difference (MARD) during the entire glycemic range of all sensors was 4.3%. The MARDs within the hypoglycemic (<70 mg/dl), euglycemic (≥70-180 mg/dl) and hyperglycemic glucose ranges (≥180 mg/dl) were 6.1%, 3.6% and 4.7%, respectively. Sensors indicated comparable performance on all days investigated (day 1, 3 and 5). None of the systems showed premature failures. In a porcine model, the performance of the biosensor revealed a promising performance. The transfer of these results into a human setting is the logical next step.Entities:
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32313062 PMCID: PMC7170864 DOI: 10.1038/s41598-020-63659-4
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Sci Rep ISSN: 2045-2322 Impact factor: 4.379
Figure 1B. Braun SGCPLUS blood glucose measurement system. The left picture indicates the reusable part of the sensor as attached to the patient arm (symbolic picture), responsible for optical activation and read-out of the sensor chemistry, and the disposable part (black/green) hosting the sensor chemistry and being connected to the arterial line. The right column of pictures indicates the principle functionality of the optical measurement technology as described in more detail in the document.
Figure 2A Glucose clamp scheme for each study day. The Bins are illustrating different glucose areas B Percentual distribution of samples according to ISO 15197:2013.
%deviation from sensor to reference glucose (overall and split for values <100 mg/dl and ≥100 mg/dl).
| % deviation from reference | <100 mg/dl (n = 414) | ≥100 mg/dl (n = 923) | All (n = 1337) |
|---|---|---|---|
| <15% | 100% (414) | 98.8% (912) | 99.2% (1326) |
| <10% | 99.0% (410) | 91.5% (845) | 93.8% (1255) |
| <5% | 79.2% (328) | 58.5% (540) | 64.9% (868) |
A Mean Absolute Relative Differences (MARDs, n = number of available value pairs) for different glycemic ranges. B MARDs on days 1, 3 and 5 of sensor use.
| A | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sensor | Overall (n) | Hypoglycemia < 70 mg/dl (n) | Euglycemia ≥ 70–180 mg/dl (n) | Hyperglycemia ≥ 180 mg/dl (n) |
| Sensor 1 | 4.3 (111) | 6.1 (21) | 3.2 (49) | 5.2 (41) |
| Sensor 2 | 5.2 (110) | 6.4 (21) | 4.5 (49) | 5.1 (40) |
| Sensor 3 | 2.5 (113) | 4.5 (21) | 2.2 (49) | 2.5 (43) |
| Sensor 4 | 5.1 (112) | 4.3 (21) | 5.0 (49) | 5.7 (42) |
| Sensor 5 | 6.4 (112) | 5.3 (21) | 6.8 (49) | 7.0 (42) |
| Sensor 6 | 3.6 (112) | 3.9 (21) | 3.4 (47) | 3.6 (44) |
| Sensor 7 | 5.0 (108) | 5.3 (19) | 5.1 (50) | 4.8 (39) |
| Sensor 8 | 5.1 (111) | 8.6 (19) | 3.1 (51) | 5.5 (41) |
| Sensor 9 | 3.4 (112) | 4.7 (19) | 3.2 (52) | 3.5 (41) |
| Sensor 10 | 3.5 (113) | 9.6 (19) | 2.8 (52) | 3.7 (42) |
| Sensor 11 | 5.5 (110) | 8.9 (19) | 5.6 (52) | 4.5 (39) |
| Sensor 12 | 3.4 (113) | 6.0 (19) | 3.1 (52) | 3.3 (42) |
| All Sensors | 4.3 (1337) | 6.1 (240) | 3.6 (601) | 4.7 (496) |
| Day 1 | 3.5 (424) | 10.5 (78) | 2.8 (191) | 3.1 (155) |
| Day 3 | 4.7 (456) | 4.3 (84) | 4.6 (209) | 5.2 (163) |
| Day 5 | 4.6 (457) | 5.0 (78) | 3.3 (201) | 6.1 (178) |
Figure 31337 sensor-reference pairs displayed in the adjusted Bland-Altman plot including indication of fulfilment of ISO 15197:2013 criteria (15 mg/dl for glucose values <100 mg/dl and 15% for glucose values ≥100 mg/dl, bold black line). On the x-axis the reference glucose values are indicated. On the y-axis the deviation in mg/dl from sensor of 1337 sensor-reference pairs.
Figure 4Parkes Error Grid for 1337 sensor-reference value pairs: On the y-axis sensor glucose is displayed, on the x-axis reference glucose is indicated. The grid is divided into zones displaying the degree of potential risk caused by erroneous measurements: values in zone A do not alter clinical action; zone B indicates altered clinical action with small or no significant effect on clinical outcome; zone C shows altered clinical action with probable effect on clinical outcome; zone D results in altered clinical action which could be associated with significant medical risk; and zone E causes altered clinical action which could have dangerous consequences.