| Literature DB >> 35459116 |
Jane A Sedgwick-Müller1, Ulrich Müller-Sedgwick2, Marios Adamou3, Marco Catani4, Rebecca Champ3, Gísli Gudjónsson5, Dietmar Hank6, Mark Pitts7, Susan Young8, Philip Asherson9.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is associated with poor educational outcomes that can have long-term negative effects on the mental health, wellbeing, and socio-economic outcomes of university students. Mental health provision for university students with ADHD is often inadequate due to long waiting times for access to diagnosis and treatment in specialist National Health Service (NHS) clinics. ADHD is a hidden and marginalised disability, and within higher education in the UK, the categorisation of ADHD as a specific learning difference (or difficulty) may be contributing to this. AIMS: This consensus aims to provide an informed understanding of the impact of ADHD on the educational (or academic) outcomes of university students and highlight an urgent need for timely access to treatment and management.Entities:
Keywords: ADHD; Academic achievement; Academic performance; Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder; College; Educational outcomes; Higher education; University; University students
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35459116 PMCID: PMC9027028 DOI: 10.1186/s12888-022-03898-z
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Psychiatry ISSN: 1471-244X Impact factor: 4.144
Typical characteristics of ADHD and associated behaviours in adults with ADHD Adapted from Asherson et al., [19], Nigg [20], Sedgwick [21]
| Typical characteristics | Associated behaviours |
|---|---|
| Inattention (“attention deficit”) | Quickly losing focus, shifting attention, absent-mindedness. |
| Easily distracted by low-priority activities or activities that other people tend to ignore. | |
| Spontaneous mind-wandering, “zoning out” or daydreaming which makes it hard to focus on reading, writing, or listening to others. | |
| Can overlook details, which leads to errors or incomplete work. | |
| Quietly getting bored, especially when the novelty has worn off. | |
| Hyper-attentiveness (or hyper-focus – a paradoxical symptom) | May be a coping mechanism for distraction – tuning out and becoming totally absorbed in self interesting, stimulating or rewarding tasks and activities. |
| Disorganisation & forgetfulness | Poor organizational skills (e.g., problems with planning, goal setting, decision making, keeping track of tasks/responsibilities, problem solving). |
| Procrastination, poor time management, forgetting commitments, appointments, or deadlines. | |
| A habit of losing or misplacing things (keys, wallet, phone, documents). | |
| Hyperactivity, restlessness, fidgety or having lots of energy | Feeling agitated, inner restlessness, always “on the go” as if driven by a motor, talking excessively, trouble sitting still, or tapping. |
| Getting quickly or easily bored, craving excitement or stimulation. | |
| Engaging in high intensity or extreme sports/activities that involve speed, height, a high level of physical exertion and highly specialised gear. | |
| Impulsivity | Interrupting others or talking over them; blurting out thoughts or saying things without thinking. |
| Engaging in reckless or risk behaviours without much concern for the consequences (e.g., spontaneous sexual “hook-ups”, gambling, Internet overuse, binge drinking or drug taking, driving too fast). | |
| Emotional lability (or emotional dysregulation) | Regular feelings of irritability, inability to cope, short or explosive temper, being easily flustered and/or stressed, hypersensitive to criticism. |
| Low self-esteem, sense of underachievement, constantly worrying about making the same mistakes, not meeting obligations, fatigue or burn-out, finding it hard to stay motivated. |
University students with ADHD – Summary of key findings (From Sedgwick [21]
| Theme | Findings |
|---|---|
● Poor performance in time-limited exams and poor overall academic achievement. ● Lower levels of social adjustment, social skills, and self-esteem in relationships. ● A range of factors predicted academic success including better coping strategies, a positive mental attitude/resilience and physical exercise. | |
● High intelligence quotient (IQ) does not preclude the possibility of having ADHD. ● Students who get good grades but still report ADHD related symptoms are most at risk of not getting diagnosed and treated. | |
● NMTech could precipitate or perpetuate ADHD-related behaviours. ● Internet overuse (or addiction). ● Important to ask about NMTech use during assessments for ADHD. | |
● Paucity of research in university students with ADHD. ● Academic performance and achievement improve with medical treatment. ● Coaching is not defined as a psychological treatment, but it may be useful. | |
● Likely to misuse tobacco, alcohol and other licit or illicit substances. ● Prevalence rates for use of psychostimulants as “study drugs” is between 5 and 35% in North American and 0.8–16% in Europe, but even lower in Ireland and the UK. | |
| ● Concerns about students feigning ADHD to get a prescription for stimulant medication, but detection depends on the knowledge, skills and expertise of the practitioner undertaking a diagnostic assessment. |
Differentiating Giftedness and ADHD Compiled from Mullet and Rinn [65]
| Indicators of Intellectual giftedness | Indicators of ADHD |
|---|---|
| Boredom, daydreaming and attentional difficulties in unchallenging learning environments. | Boredom, daydreaming and attentional difficulties in multiple domains. |
| Low tolerance for tasks or activities that seem irrelevant. | Low tolerance for tasks or activities that seem irrelevant. |
| Extended periods of time spent on topics of self-interest. | Extended periods of time spent on topics of self-interest. |
| Discrepancies between intellectual, physical, emotional, and social development. | Discrepancies between intellectual, physical, emotional. and social development. |
| Emotional intensity may lead to power struggles with authorities. | Emotional intensity may lead to power struggles with authorities. |
| Questions or challenges rules, regulations, customs, and traditions. | Poor impulsive control may cause difficulties adhering to rules, regulations, customs, and traditions. |
| High activity levels that is focused and directed, restlessness, may need less sleep. | High activity levels that is random rather than goal directed, restlessness, problems with sleep. |
| Tendency to answer correctly when responds impulsively to questions. | Tendency to guess incorrect answers when responds impulsively to questions. |
| Prone to social problems and struggles in social relationships. | Difficulties regulating or inhibiting behaviour in social contexts, prone to social problems and struggles in social relationships. |
Summary of the main consensus points
| i. ADHD is a hidden disability and should no longer be categorised as a specific learning difference/ difficulty (SpLD) in higher education. | |
| ii. There is a need to overcome the stigma associated with having ADHD. | |
| iii. There is a lack of access to assessment and treatment for university students with ADHD. Many of these students are assessed by a specialist teacher assessor or educational psychologist and get a recommendation for reasonable adjustments and a referral to their GP to access specialist medical treatment. | |
| iv. There are long waiting lists to be seen by NHS specialist adult ADHD clinics. | |
| v. There is a need to develop rapid access care pathways for the medical treatment of ADHD in university students. | |
| vi. Some students with ADHD do not perform well at university, whereas other students performed very well, and what seemed to make the difference was the level of personalised support that they received. | |
| vii. There is a need to develop training that includes psychoeducation, how to screen for (and diagnostically assess) ADHD and use recommended strategies for supporting students with ADHD in higher education. | |
| viii. Best practice for supporting university students with ADHD would entail joint/ collaborative working between university disability services and NHS or private service providers. |
Summary of the main recommendations from the expert group
Current UCAS codes/categories and definitions of disability
| No Disability | |
| Social/communication impairment such as Asperger’s Syndrome/other Autistic Spectrum Disorder | |
| Blind/serious visual impairment uncorrected by glasses | |
| Deaf/serious hearing impairment | |
| Long standing illness or health condition such as cancer, HIV, diabetes, chronic heart disease, or epilepsy | |
| Mental Health Condition, such as depression, schizophrenia, or anxiety disorder | |
| Specific Learning Difference e.g., dyslexia, dyspraxia, or ADHD | |
| Physical Impairment or mobility issues | |
| Disability, impairment, or medical condition not listed above | |
| You have two or more impairments and/or disabling medical conditions |
Fig. 1Disabled university students in the UK. Source: Table 15: UK-domiciled student enrolments by disability and sex, for the academic year 2018-19, (total number of disabled students 316,380) [22]. NB: There are high rates of overlap between ADHD and both SpLDs and mental health conditions, but the prevalence of ADHD is unknown, because there is no separate category for it
Fig. 2Disabled university students in Ireland. Source: Fig. 3 Breakdown of students by Category of Disability 2016/17 (total number of disabled students 12,630) [88]
Fig. 3Model of Working Memory (Adapted from Baddeley [111]
Specifiers and Characteristics of SLD [6], and typical SpLD terms [104–106]
| SLD with impairment in | Characteristics | Typical SpLDs |
|---|---|---|
| Reading (reading disorder, RD) | Deficits in | Dyslexia |
| Mathematics (maths disorder, MD) | Deficits in number sense, memorisation of arithmetic facts, accurate or fluent calculation or math reasoning | Dyscalculia |
| Written expression (writing disorder, WD) | Deficits in | Dysgraphia |
Examples of organisation and regulatory roles of executive functions [95]
| ORGANISATION (gathering information & structuring it for evaluation) | REGULATION (Evaluating available information & modulating environmental responses) |
|---|---|
| Language/ rule acquisition | Initiating & inhibiting context specific action/ behaviour |
| Attention, staying focused | Motivation |
| Planning | Self-control, self-monitoring |
| Sequencing, prioritising | Moral reasoning |
| Problem-solving (fluid intelligence) | Emotional regulation |
| Thinking about 2 or more concepts simultaneously | Decision-making |
| Abstract thinking | |
| Selecting/ filtering relevant sensory information |
Examples of screening questionnaire & diagnostic tools
| Adult ADHD Self-Report Scale (ASRS) (Kessler et al., [ | ADHD |
| Autism-Spectrum Quotient (AQ-10) (Allison et al., [ | ASD |
| The Adult Dyslexia Checklist, British Dyslexia Association [ | Dyslexia |
| Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K10) (Kessler et al., [ | Anxiety & depression |
| Penn State Worry Questionnaire (PSWQ) (Meyer et al., [ | Pathologic worry |
| The Simple Screening Instrument for Substance Abuse (SSI-SA) (Center for Substance Abuse Treatment [ | Substance misuse |
The Improving Access to Psychological Therapies Manual [ • Page 33: Generalised Anxiety Disorder Scale (GAD-2) • Page 36: Generalised Anxiety Disorder Scale (GAD-7) • Page 35: Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ-9) • Page 42: Panic Disorder Severity Scale | Anxiety, depression & panic disorder |
| These and other online tools are also available at: | Various |
| DIVA Foundation [ | ADHD |
| ACE+ [ | ADHD |
| Weiss Functional Impairment Rating Scale–Self Report (WFRIS-S) [ | Functional impairment |
Fig. 4Potential Support pathway for university students with ADHD
Potential education related problems and reasonable adjustments
| Potential education related problems due to | Potential reasonable adjustment |
|---|---|
| Mind wandering ( | 25–50% extra writing time in examinations |
| Poor working memory ( | 25–50% extra writing time in examinations, separate room for writing examinations |
| Disorganisation and inefficiency | Academic coaching, being invigilated in an examination by a support worker familiar with ADHD |
| Difficulties with planning ahead, misjudging how long tasks take to perform ( | 25–50% extra writing time in examinations, flexible start times for an examination |
| Procrastination/ waiting until the “last minute” to submit work, “pulling all-nighters” ( | Academic coaching/ specialist mentoring, 10 to 20 min of a rest break during examinations |
| Forgetfulness ( | Having the ability to negotiate extensions to deadlines for assignments/ course work |
| Difficulty sustaining attention ( | Academic coaching/ specialist mentoring, the ability to study part-time or to defer examinations |
| Difficulties following long explanations, note taking, or reading a lot | Academic coaching/ specialist one-to-one study skills support or subject specific support |
| Hyper-focus on topics of self-interest to the detriment of other topics and tasks | Academic coaching/ specialist one-to-one study skills support, subject specific support |