| Literature DB >> 23724008 |
Darina Czamara1, Carla M T Tiesler, Gabriele Kohlböck, Dietrich Berdel, Barbara Hoffmann, Carl-Peter Bauer, Sibylle Koletzko, Beate Schaaf, Irina Lehmann, Olf Herbarth, Andrea von Berg, Bertram Müller-Myhsok, Gerd Schulte-Körne, Joachim Heinrich.
Abstract
Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and dyslexia belong to the most common neuro-behavioral childhood disorders with prevalences of around 5% in school-aged children. It is estimated that 20-60% of individuals affected with ADHD also present with learning disorders. We investigated the comorbidity between ADHD symptoms and reading/spelling and math difficulties in two on-going population-based birth cohort studies. Children with ADHD symptoms were at significantly higher risk of also showing reading/spelling difficulties or disorder (Odds Ratio (OR) = 2.80, p = 6.59×10⁻¹³) as compared to children without ADHD symptoms. For math difficulties the association was similar (OR = 2.55, p = 3.63×10⁻⁰⁴). Our results strengthen the hypothesis that ADHD and learning disorders are comorbid and share, at least partially, the same underlying process. Up to date, it is not clear, on which exact functional processes this comorbidity is based.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2013 PMID: 23724008 PMCID: PMC3664565 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0063859
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Study characteristics of children aged 10 years from GINIplus and LISAplus.
| SDQ hyperactivity/inattention category | ||||
| Normal | Borderline | High | Total | |
| Gender | ||||
| Male | 2027 (81.9%) | 163 (6.6%) | 285 (11.5%) | 2475 |
| Female | 2180 (91.4%) | 95 (4.0%) | 111 (4.6%) | 2386 |
| Study | ||||
| GINIplus | 2782 (86.7%) | 163 (5.1%) | 262 (8.2%) | 3207 |
| LISAplus | 1425 (86.2%) | 95 (5.7%) | 134 (8.1%) | 1654 |
| Study center | ||||
| Munich | 2219 (87.0%) | 128 (5.0%) | 204 (8.0%) | 2551 |
| Leipzig | 334 (84.8%) | 23 (5.8%) | 37 (9.4%) | 394 |
| Bad Honnef | 175 (87.9%) | 13 (6.5%) | 11 (5.6%) | 199 |
| Wesel | 1479 (86.1%) | 94 (5.5%) | 144 (8.4%) | 1717 |
| Parental education | ||||
| Both parents <10 yrs | 256 (78.1%) | 27 (8.2%) | 45 (13.7%) | 328 |
| At least one parent 10 yrs | 1046 (82.9%) | 85 (6.7%) | 132 (10.4%) | 1263 |
| At least one parent >10 yrs | 2747 (88.9%) | 138 (4.4%) | 206 (6.7%) | 3091 |
| Age of mother | ||||
| At birth <30 yrs | 1251 (83.9%) | 94 (6.3%) | 146 (9.8%) | 1491 |
| At birth at least 30 yrs | 2924 (87.8%) | 159 (4.8%) | 246 (7.4%) | 3329 |
| Daily TV/PC use | ||||
| <1 h in summer & <2 h in winter | 2790 (87.7%) | 162 (5.1%) | 230 (7.2%) | 3182 |
| > = 1 h in summer or > = 2 h in winter | 1361 (84.3%) | 93 (5.7%) | 161 (10.0%) | 1615 |
| Single parent | ||||
| No | 3714 (87.9%) | 199 (4.7%) | 312 (7.4%) | 4225 |
| Yes | 422 (76.6%) | 52 (9.4%) | 77 (14.0%) | 551 |
| Exposure to tobacco smoke at home | ||||
| Never | 2220 (89.4%) | 108 (4.3%) | 156 (6.3%) | 2484 |
| Only postnatal | 1197 (84.7%) | 83 (5.9%) | 133 (9.4%) | 1413 |
| Only prenatal | 101 (85.6%) | 7 (5.9%) | 10 (8.5%) | 118 |
| Pre- and postnatal | 391 (77.1%) | 43 (8.5%) | 73 (14.4%) | 507 |
| Special training in reading/spelling | ||||
| No | 3553 (89.5%) | 167 (4.2%) | 249 (6.3%) | 3969 |
| Yes | 521 (70.8%) | 81 (11.0%) | 134 (18.2%) | 736 |
| Reading/spelling difficulties | ||||
| No | 3699 (89.1%) | 173 (4.2%) | 280 (6.7%) | 4152 |
| Yes | 365 (67.8%) | 75 (14.0%) | 98 (18.2%) | 538 |
| Severity of dyslexia | ||||
| Reading/spelling problems | 191 (72.0%) | 37 (14.0%) | 37 (14.0%) | 265 |
| Reading/spelling disorder | 79 (65.8%) | 10 (8.3%) | 31 (25.9%) | 120 |
| Math difficulties | ||||
| No | 4000 (87.1%) | 235 (5.1%) | 355 (7.8%) | 4590 |
| Yes | 102 (70.8%) | 16 (11.1%) | 26 (18.1%) | 144 |
given numbers indicate the number of individuals with available corresponding phenotypes.
SDQ hyperactivity/inattention is categorized as normal (SDQ score lower than 6), borderline (SDQ score between 6 and 7) and high (SDQ score higher than 7).
refers to children with reading/spelling disorder as well as to children with reading/spelling problems.
distinction between reading/spelling problems and reading/spelling disorder was only made in GINIplus.
Association results from logistic regression analysis between reading/spelling difficulties and ADHD symptoms measured by the SDQ-hyperactivity/inattention score.
| SDQ hyperactivity/inattention score | |||||||||||
| Model | Normal | Borderline | High | ||||||||
| dyslexic | nondyslexic | OR | dyslexic | nondyslexic | OR[95% CI] | p-value | dyslexic | nondyslexic | OR[95% CI] | p-value | |
| Dyslexiacrude | n = 365 | n = 3699 | 1.00(reference) | n = 75 | n = 173 | 4.39[3.28–5.88] |
| n = 98 | n = 280 | 3.57[2.75–4.57] |
|
| Dyslexiaadjusted I | n = 365 | n = 3699 | 1.00(reference) | n = 75 | n = 173 | 4.30[3.20–5.78] |
| n = 98 | n = 280 | 3.25[2.51–4.21] |
|
| Dyslexiaadjusted II | n = 333 | n = 3298 | 1.00(reference) | n = 65 | n = 154 | 3.95[2.86–5.45] |
| n = 87 | n = 253 | 2.80[2.11–3.70] |
|
refers to the number of individuals with reading/spelling difficulties for whom full phenotypic information was available and who were included in regression analysis.
refers to the number of individuals without reading/spelling difficulties for whom full phenotypic information was available and who were included in regression analysis.
adjusted for gender, age, study and study center.
additional adjustment for parental education, age of mother at birth, daily TV/PC use, single parent and ETS exposure.
p-values <0.05 are depicted in bold.
Figure 1Sensitivity analysis for reading/spelling problems and reading/spelling disorder in GINIplus.
ORs and 95% confidence intervals are depicted for reading/spelling problems and reading/spelling disorder in three investigated models (crude, adjusted for gender, age, study and study center and additional adjustment for parental education, age of mother at birth, daily TV/PC use, single parent and ETS exposure). Normal SDQ score was chosen as reference category.
Figure 2Sensitivity analysis for reading/spelling problems and reading/spelling disorder in males from GINIplus.
ORs and 95% confidence intervals are depicted for reading/spelling problems and reading/spelling disorder in three investigated models (crude, adjusted for gender, age, study and study center and additional adjustment for parental education, age of mother at birth, daily TV/PC use, single parent and ETS exposure). Normal SDQ score was chosen as reference category.
Figure 3Sensitivity analysis for reading/spelling problems and reading/spelling disorder in females from GINIplus.
ORs and 95% confidence intervals are depicted for reading/spelling problems and reading/spelling disorder in three investigated models (crude, adjusted for gender, age, study and study center and additional adjustment for parental education, age of mother at birth, daily TV/PC use, single parent and ETS exposure). Normal SDQ score was chosen as reference category.
Association results from logistic regression analysis between math difficulties and ADHD symptoms measured by the SDQ-hyperactivity/inattention score.
| SDQ hyperactivity score | |||||||||||
| Model | Normal | Borderline | High | ||||||||
| dyscalculic | non dyscalculic | OR | dyscalculic | non dyscalculic | OR [95% CI] | p-value | dyscalculic | non dyscalculic | OR [95% CI] | p-value | |
| Dyscalculia crude | n = 102 | n = 4000 | 1.00 (reference) | n = 16 | n = 235 | 2.67 [1.55–4.60] |
| n = 26 | n = 355 | 2.87 [1.84–4.48] |
|
| Dyscalculia adjusted I | n = 102 | n = 4000 | 1.00 (reference) | n = 16 | n = 235 | 3.03 [1.75–5.26] |
| n = 26 | n = 355 | 3.48 [2.20–5.50] |
|
| Dyscalculia adjusted II | n = 91 | n = 3576 | 1.00 (reference) | n = 15 | n = 207 | 2.82 [1.58–5.07] |
| n = 21 | n = 320 | 2.55 [1.52–4.26] |
|
refers to the number of individuals with math difficulties for whom full phenotypic information was available and who were included in regression analysis.
refers to the number of individuals without math difficulties for whom full phenotypic information was available and who were included in regression analysis.
adjusted for gender, age, study and study center.
additional adjustment for parental education, age of mother at birth, daily TV/PC use, single parent and ETS exposure.
p-values <0.05 are depicted in bold.