| Literature DB >> 31546966 |
Nicholas T Bott1,2, Aidan Hall3, Erica N Madero4, Jordan M Glenn5,6, Nami Fuseya7, Joshua L Gills8, Michelle Gray9.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Currently, there is no pharmaceutical intervention to treat or delay pathological cognitive decline or Alzheimer's disease and related dementias (ADRD). Multidomain lifestyle interventions are increasingly being studied as a non-pharmacological solution to enhance cognitive reserve, maintain cognition, and reduce the risk of or delay ADRD. Review of completed and prospective face-to-face (FTF) and digital multidomain interventions provides an opportunity to compare studies and informs future interventions and study design.Entities:
Keywords: Alzheimer’s disease; cognition; cognitive reserve; dementia; digital; health promotion; healthy aging; internet; lifestyle; primary prevention; risk reduction; telemedicine
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31546966 PMCID: PMC6770494 DOI: 10.3390/nu11092258
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nutrients ISSN: 2072-6643 Impact factor: 5.717
Figure 1Lifespan protective and risk factors for ADRD. ADRD = Alzheimer’s disease & related dementias; Figure adapted from Kivipelto et al., 2018 [19].
Completed Face-to-Face multidomain interventions to enhance cognitive reserve and reduce risk of Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias (ADRD).
| Study Title | Study Sample | Intervention Components | Study Length & Intervention Frequency | Primary Outcomes | Other Outcomes | Adherence/Attrition | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FINGER |
Finnish adults age 60–77 CAIDE score > 6 Average or slightly declined cognition |
Diet Exercise Cognitive training Social activities Metabolic/vascular risk management |
Daily diet plan Strength training 1–3x/week, aerobic 2–5x/week Cognitive training 3x/week (10 group sessions) Risk management checkup at 3 time points 2 year study, follow up at 7 years |
Mean NTB score difference was shown to be 0.022 points (standardized) higher between groups (intervention vs. controls) |
Significant intervention effect on executive function and processing speed Risk of cognitive decline increased for controls vs. intervention Significant intervention effects on BMI, exercise, and diet. |
1190 (94%) participants used for final analysis 416 (72%) of intervention subjects completed all domain interventions regularly 86 (14%) intervention and 66 (11%) control participants dropped out; mostly health-related. |
Participants may have had existing dementia-related changes to the brain. Providing necessary health knowledge to controls may masked the true intervention effect. |
| MAPT |
French adults age ≥ 70 Spontaneous memory complaint Limitation in IADL Slow Gait |
Diet Exercise Cognitive Training Management of cardiovascular risk factors Omega 3 dietary supplement (in 2 arms) |
3 year study 12 two-hour sessions on cognitive training, physical activity, and nutrition 2 sessions per week in first month and 1 session per week in second month Preventive consultation at baseline, 12 months, and 24 months |
Participants in multi domain + supplement intervention showed increase in cognitive score compared to placebo, but not significant. |
Less decline in MMSE items used in composite for multi domain + supplement versus placebo. |
1268 (77%) participants completed study |
Did not look at individual contributions of components Low intensity of intervention |
| preDIVA |
Dutch adults aged 70–78 years |
Exercise Management of cardiovascular risk factors Smoking Cessation Health Coaching Chronic Disease Management |
6 years 18 visits total (1x every 4 months) Individually tailored lifestyle advice and medication adjustment |
No difference in incidence of dementia between groups at 6 years |
No difference in disability, cognitive, or depressive symptoms. Non-significant differences between groups in systolic blood pressure, BMI, total/LDL cholesterol, and mortality. |
3519 (99.8%) participants completed study |
Small difference in risk between groups may be due to high standards of usual care. |
| SPRINT-MIND |
American and Puerto Rican adults aged 50 + years Baseline systolic blood pressure between 130 and 180 mm Hg |
Antihypertensive Medication Diet Exercise Weight loss |
4 years (8 years for final follow-up) Biometrics collected every 3 months Cognitive batteries administered at baseline, 2, and 4 years “Milepost” assessment for intervention every 6 months |
No difference in probable dementia occurrence between groups. |
Difference in SBP measure for intensive vs. standard group Occurrence of MCI was lower in Intensive group, but not significant. Significant between-group difference in probable dementia/MCI composite (favoring Intensive). |
3972 (92.6%) of intensive treatment and 3949 (92.3%) standard completed cognitive assessment at follow up Completion rates above 90% for both groups at 2 & 4 years |
Intervention terminated early for cardiovascular benefits Loss of participants to follow-up may have lead to underestimated conversion to PD/MCI |
The gray background is just to the table to be clearer. ADRD = Alzheimer’s disease and Related Dementias; BMI = body mass index; FINGER = Finnish Geriatric Intervention Study to Prevent Cognitive Impairment and Disability; IADL = Instrumental Activities of Daily Living; MAPT = Multidomain Alzheimer Preventive Trial; MCI = Mild Cognitive Impairment; MMSE = Mini Mental State Exam; NTB = Neuropsychological Test Battery; preDIVA = Prevention of Dementia by Intensive Vascular care; SPRINT-MIND = Sub-study of Systolic Blood Pressure Intervention Trial.
On-going or prospective Face-to-Face multidomain interventions to enhance cognitive reserve and reduce risk of ADRD.
| Study Title | Sample/Sampling Method | Interventions | Study Length & Intervention Frequency | Main Outcomes | Issues Addressed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age well.de |
German adults aged 60–77 |
Diet Exercise Vascular risk factor management Cognitive training Medication management Social lifestyle Depressive/Grief symptom management |
2 years Structured interview at 12 and 24 months. Motivational meeting at 12 months for intervention group. |
Improvement in composite Cognitive Score for intervention Decreasing mortality and depressive symptoms Keeping track of IADL and readiness for change through intervention |
Lack of studies done with German populations Health complications over mismanaged medication Social support |
| SMARRT |
Kaiser Permanente patients aged 70–89 Decreased cognition Minimum of 2 risk factors HER screening |
Diet Exercise Mental exercises Social experiences Vascular risk factor management Medication management |
2 years Cognitive assessments every 6 months Risk Assessment and Counseling following cognitive assessments |
Change in NTB scores over time Improvement in all areas of intervention components Improve sleep quality and positive behavior |
Looks at efficacy multi domain interventions in U.S. Possible negative medication interactions Developing goal-setting behavior post-study |
| EMuNI |
Italian adults aged 60–80 Existing memory complaints |
Cognitive health literacy Diet Nutritional supplement (Tramiprosate) Exercise Cognitive training |
1 year Biweekly nutrition lessons Daily supplement Weekly exercise Biweekly cognitive training |
Improvement in cognitive batteries Increase of positive MRI markers Increasing positive outcomes in more intense intervention groups |
Explores how different intensity level interventions affect positive outcomes Includes participants with subjective cognitive decline |
| MIND-ADmini |
Adults aged 60–85 Prodromal AD Score of ≥3 on Lifestyle Index MMSE ≥ 24 |
Diet Exercise Cognitive training Vascular risk factor management Nutritional Supplement (Fortasyn Connect) |
6 months (with a possible 6-month extension) |
Feasibility of/adherence to intervention Encourage lasting lifestyle change Positive cognitive and health related outcomes |
Participants experiencing cognitive impairment Exploring use of dietary supplement paired with multi-domain intervention |
| Taiwan Multidomain Intervention Efficacy Study |
Participants with MCI ( |
Diet Exercise Cognitive training Smoking cessation Neuropsychiatric symptoms |
1 year 16-week control data gathering Weekly intervention meetings for 4 months 2 individual sessions |
Increasing cognitive battery scores Supporting ADL and targeting neuropsychiatric symptoms |
Taiwanese Sample Participants experiencing cognitive decline |
| Brain, Body, Life: General Practice, Lifestyle Modification Program (BBL-GPLMP) |
GP referred CHC or overweight |
Exercise Diet Online psychoeducation modules |
GP: 12 FTF sessions over 6 weeks LMP: 8 online sessions; 1 session each with dietician & EP |
Validated AD risk factor survey Cognition, PA, depressive symptoms, diet, sleep quality |
Intervention delivered within clinical workflow Australian sample |
The gray background is just to the table to be clearer ADRD = Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias; EHR = Electronic Health Record; EP = Exercise physiologist; EMuNI = Efficacy of Multiple Nonpharmacological Interventions; IADL = Instrumental Activities of Daily Living; MCI = Mild Cognitive Impairment; MIND-ADmini = Multimodal Preventive Trial for Alzheimer’s Disease (Mini); MMSE = Mini Mental State Exam; NTB = Neuropsychological Test Battery; PA = Physical activity; SCD = Subjective Cognitive Decline; SMARRT = Systematic Multi-Domain Alzheimer’s Risk Reduction Trial.
On-going and prospective World-Wide Fingers multidomain interventions to enhance cognitive reserve and reduce risk of ADRD
| Authors/Date | Sample/Sampling Method | Interventions | Study Length & Intervention Frequency | Main | Differentiating Factors from FINGER |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| POINTER |
U.S. adults age 60–79 years High risk from lifestyle factors (e.g., poor diet) First-degree family history of memory impairment |
Diet Exercise Vascular risk factor management Social stimulation Cognitive training |
2 years |
Efficacy of multi domain intervention, culturally suited to Americans Protection from cognitive decline for high-risk individuals |
U.S. sample High-risk individuals used to potentially show greater benefits of intervention |
| SINGER |
|
Diet Exercise Vascular risk factor management Social stimulation Cognitive training |
6 months |
Increased protection against cognitive decline Usefulness/ease of implementation for Singaporean adults |
Singaporean Sample |
| MIND-CHINA |
Rural Chinese adults aged 60–79 years |
Diet Exercise Intellectual training Social activities Vascular risk management Lifestyle guidelines |
Compare vascular risk factor treatment plans |
Chinese sample |
The gray background is just to the table to be clearer. POINTER = Study to Protect Brain Health Through Lifestyle Intervention to Reduce Risk; MIND-CHINA = Multimodal Intervention to delay Dementia and disability in rural China; MYB = Maintain Your Brain; SINGER = Singapore Intervention Study to Prevent Cognitive Impairment and Disability.
On-going or prospective digital multidomain interventions to enhance cognitive reserve and reduce risk of ADRD.
| Title | Sample/Sampling Method | Interventions | Availability | Study Length | Primary Outcomes | Issues Addressed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MYB |
Australian adults aged 53 + Recruitment from longitudinal health study (45 and Up) |
Exercise Diet Cognition Depressive/Anxiety symptoms Lifestyle risk factors (e.g., smoking/heavy drinking) |
3 years 2–4 modules assigned in 1 year (risk factor dependent) Motivational session every 3 months Annual follow-up |
Improvement/lack of decline in composite cognitive score Decreased incidence of dementia Impact on module-focused risk factors Assessing efficacy of an online approach |
Fully remote intervention Personally tailored interventions |
Web-based intervention Fully digital intervention Personalized risk-factor intervention |
| DC-MARVEL |
Aged 45–64 years At risk for dementia |
Diet Exercise Cognitive training Sleep Stress Social engagement Health coaching |
Online Not publicly available |
2 years |
Lifestyle risk and protective factor score Cognitive assessment score Clinical biomarkers |
Cross-platform, app-based intervention Fully digital intervention Personalized intervention plans |
| BBL-CD |
Australian adults aged 65 + years SCD or previously diagnosed MCI |
Diet Exercise Cognitive activity |
Online Not publicly available |
6 Months 1 module/ 2 week (one week in between) Assessed at 9 weeks, 3 and 6 months |
Cognition, Executive Function and IADLs (ADAS-Cog-Plus) AD risk/protective lifestyle factors Motivation, health-related quality of life, adherence |
Personalized intervention plans Participants experiencing cognitive impairment |
| HATICE |
Finnish, Dutch, French adults age 65 + Two or more cardiovascular risk factors History of diabetes or cardiovascular disease |
Diet Exercise Cardiovascular risk factor management |
Online, not publicly available |
18 months FTF interview and biometrics at baseline and 18 months. Online questionnaires at baseline, 3, 12 and 18 months. Phone call for medication use at 12 months |
Increase in composite z-scores of biometrics from baseline Intervention unaffected by cultural differences (when adjusted to that culture) |
Culture-specific guidelines on CVRF/weight can affect implementation Coaches serve mostly as motivational support for change |
The gray background is just to the table to be clearer. ADRD = Alzheimer’s disease and related dementias; BBL-CD = Body, Brain, Life for Cognitive Decline; DC-MARVEL = Digital Cognitive Multi-domain Alzheimer’s Risk Velocity study; FTF = Face-to-face; HATICE = Healthy Aging Through Internet Counselling in the Elderly; IADL = Instrumental Activity of Daily Living; MCI = Mild Cognitive Impairment; SCD = Subjective Cognitive Decline.