| Literature DB >> 35955010 |
Ngina McAlpin1, Cordelia R Elaiho2, Farrah Khan3, Cristina Cruceta4, Crispin Goytia4,5,6, Nita Vangeepuram2,5,6.
Abstract
There have been few youth-led diabetes prevention programs. Our objective was to conduct focus groups to explore peer influences on adolescent lifestyle behaviors and strategies for implementing a youth peer education model for diabetes prevention. We conducted six focus groups with 52 youth (ages 13-22; 62% male, 38% female; 64% Hispanic, 36% non-Hispanic Black) from East Harlem, NYC. We used a Thematic Analysis approach to identify major themes, compared findings, and resolved differences through discussion and consensus. Three dominant themes arose: (1) Adolescents generally encounter more unhealthy peer influences on diet and more healthy peer influences on physical activity; (2) Adolescents endorse youth-led diabetes prevention strategies and describe ideal qualities for peer leaders and methods to support and evaluate leaders; (3) Adolescents prefer text messaging to monitor behaviors, track goals, and receive personalized guidance. Using study findings, our Community Action Board developed a peer-led diabetes prevention program for prediabetic adolescents.Entities:
Keywords: community-based; diabetes prevention; focus groups; mobile health technology; peer education; youth
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35955010 PMCID: PMC9368486 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph19159655
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 4.614
Representative Subthemes and Supporting Quotes for Theme 1: Adolescents generally encounter unhealthy peer influences related to dietary choices and healthy peer influences related to physical activity.
| Quote Number | Quote |
|---|---|
|
| |
| 1 | “Since me and my friends, we play sports, they notice how slow I get and they try to encourage me and tell me you’re running slow, you have to eat healthier.” |
| 2 | “How my friends influence what I eat is like-at lunch me and my friends start getting the same exact thing that we order. We all get the same thing together…o we usually eat like pizza, fries or like…and get two of those and a soda.” |
| 3 | “No, after school with your friends if that’s like the scenario, if you’re with your friends and they’re eating at McDonalds you’re going to be like no I’m going to pass, I’m going to get a salad. Are you going to do that around your friends?” |
| 4 | “Like if you’re with a group of people and they all decide to go get one specific thing and you want something else it might cause you like to change your mind and just get what they’re getting.” |
| 5 | “My friends make fun of me…like if I get something…they’re like what are you getting, you can’t get that, get something else. So I get it.” |
| 6 | “…if I say I’m craving something then she wants it too. If she says it then I say it too.” |
| 7 | “Oh, my friends, they’ll be like oh you have to try this, this is really good, and then they get me hooked and I can’t live without it. It’s horrible.” |
| 8 | “So when I’m with my friends and stuff I eat a lot of junk food like chips and bread but when I’m with my family I eat a lot of white rice and they help me cut down.” |
|
| |
| 9 | “All my friends are lazy so we don’t really do much. When I’m with them we don’t do much activity at all, yeah.” |
| 10 | “Yes because they’re lazy and like I [would like to] go do something…and they’re like well we’re going to go inside.” |
| 11 | MODERATOR: So for some of you sometimes depending on who the friends are? |
| 12 | “Like when I go to school I’ll go to the weight room with my friends and my friends are like very competitive, athletic kids so like they make me want to be better than them and…competition.” |
| 13 | “After school if I’m bored or something I’ll go with my friends to the park and we’ll play basketball or we’ll just run.” |
| 14 | “My friends are too active. They’re like junkies. They’re like junkies…buff muscles. That’s my friends. They’re junkies.” |
| 15 | “My friends keep me from being lazy. Every day we walk to school instead of taking the bus and whatnot.” |
| 16 | “I think my friends definitely…influence me but they wouldn’t want me to go-for example last year, actually this year I joined track because I had a friend on the team and they were like yeah, just come and…and you’ll like it so I did.” |
| 17 | “Alright so today I wanted to be lazy at lunch and I was just going to sit on the bench and they’re like come on BOY 1, we need another person…play a game. So I got up and I played basketball.” |
| 18 | “And if they choose to play then you got to play.” |
| 19 | “My parents are lazy. They don’t do anything. So I usually just work out or like on the weekends just play football. That’s when I’m with my friends.” |
Representative Subthemes and Supporting Quotes for Theme 2: Adolescents endorse a youth peer educator model for diabetes prevention, and describe ideal qualities for peer leaders, strategies for building relationships between program leaders and participants, and methods to motivate, support and evaluate leaders.
| Quote Number | Quote |
|---|---|
|
| |
| 1 | “It’s more like when people our age talk to us we listen more and with adults it’s basically like okay we listen to you but we don’t really want to understand or don’t really want to do what you’re saying. So like when it’s somebody your age you kind of listen and you kind of do what they’re saying and take it into consideration.” |
| 2 | “I think it’s a good idea because people of our age have more of an influence than older people so we’d be able to influence people our age to do more stuff.” |
| 3 | “I like teams working together because if you do lose or you don’t get whatever you wanted at least you will have an experience working with somebody because if you just compete at the end of the day it looks like you’re just there for one thing and one thing only but if you work together at least you made new friends.” |
| 4 | “Maybe in both kind of because if you’re competitive that makes you work harder but at the same time if you don’t win then maybe you’ll get angry. If you work together then you’re not really working on the negatives of how somebody reacts to losing, you’re just working on doing points and everything.” |
|
| |
| 5 | “Kind of like a role model or an experienced person with diabetes or a person that already has learned about it or has seen somebody go through it.” |
| 6 | “Someone just like naturally a great leader and could kind of influence you, so like a good speaker.” |
| 7 | “I think we should just find someone who is very informational about it and could also give a very good presentation and also make it very interactive and also fun.” |
| 8 | “Being able to help somebody…I know people who had really difficult challenges and I’ve experienced a little…I wouldn’t want anybody else to live like that so being able to just spread that information of how to prevent that.” |
|
| |
| 9 | “If I see kids-the information that I’m giving them…apply it to their lives, like if I see them drinking water more or exercising more or eating more healthy then I’ll continue doing it.” |
| 10 | “I would stick with it if like everyone was enjoying it or I felt important like I was actually doing something.” |
| 11 | “If I’m a peer leader and everyone seems to not care about the topic, like I understand when you first get here you’re not going to care about it if you don’t know about it, but after I have taught my lesson and whatever you still don’t care about it you won’t see me again.” |
| 12 | “If I didn’t feel like anyone was enjoying it and I wasn’t engaging anyone I wouldn’t really try anymore.” |
|
| |
| 13 | “It’s not that hard to build relationships with teens. I guess people think too much about it. They’re nice and cool and you do fun things, that makes me want to like you and you don’t have an attitude or anything like that. It’s pretty easy.” |
| 14 | “Showing that they care about what the person is going through or about what they’re talking about, showing that they actually care about what they’re teaching.” |
| 15 | “I would try to speak to them how I would want to be spoken to and in a way they understand because I’m not going to sit there like I’m smarter than them or anything trying to teach them things that they probably don’t already know. Like I’ll sit there with them, be like-like I’ll say it to them in a way they understand, like I will say like-like throw a little slang in there or like something so they understand like what I’m trying to say to them.” |
| 16 | “Actually show an interest in what the kid has to say…because you can always tell when the kid has a real strong connection with an older classmate or something.” |
|
| |
| 17 | “Maybe another adult that’s not really-that doesn’t really go in and disrupt what they’re doing but watches what he’s teaching, he or she is teaching and how he does it or she does it.” |
| 18 | “You should just have-you see how she’s sitting in on our conversation, have someone sit in on the conversation to make sure they’re doing their job and if they ever go off-topic you either wait until the end of class or pull them aside.” |
| 19 | “…the person who is like adult. Just always be there just in case.” |
| 20 | “Yeah, I think that you should guide them throughout the whole program so they can know which-where they’re doing a good job or not so that they can change something if something is going wrong. |
| 21 | “You could take a survey of students, like ask them-like take a survey on a handful of students and ask them how class went.” |
| 22 | “To make sure, check and see if the people are actually learning something in the class.” |
| 23 | “Well they could have like one supervisor that will probably come in and take notes but the leader should be trustworthy where they don’t actually need someone to…someone high up to supervise.” |
Representative Subthemes and Supporting Quotes for Theme 3: Adolescents prefer text messaging for motivation and support, and to monitor key diet and physical activity behaviors, track weekly goals, and receive personalized advice and feedback.
| Quote Number | Quote |
|---|---|
|
| |
| 1 | “Yeah, I feel like there are some people that are probably on their phones at this hour and they’re going through that I can’t see phase so they’re like let me reflect on what I did today because I have nothing else to do because I’m bored and I can’t sleep. So they’re going to think about all the things that you just sent them because that’s the most relevant thing that’s come to them at a certain time, especially before bed. Because I don’t know if you’re like me but most times before I go to sleep I think about everything I’ve done for that day and it’s like if somebody sends you something like this I’m going to be like okay, maybe I should think about what I’ve eaten…ecause I didn’t eat at all today.” |
| 2 | “I don’t think every day because I feel like every day, then you will get tired…you start ignoring them after a while.” |
| 3 | “I think what type of physical activity you did, that’s a good question. So like did you go to the gym or I don’t know, play basketball or do some type of physical activity.” |
| 4 | “And how many drinks, sugary drinks you did, that’s a really good one because you had like a can of soda or I don’t know, a juice, something like that.” |
| 5 | “It’s actually pretty good because it’s actually telling you what you could do and what you-what some examples of what you can do. Like some people just don’t eat fruit but the text is actually letting you know that you can do it in different ways.” |
| 6 | “They should also have steps on how to make a smoothie or like yogurt because if-me personally if a friend went to make a smoothie or a yogurt and I don’t know how to do it I would like… |
| 7 | “I like the trying something new because it’s kind of telling you you should just not stick to like everyday stuff, not just do this one thing over and over again, try something new.” |
|
| |
| 8 | “I like those week goals or those monthly goals instead of like day-to-day goals.” |
| 9 | “…you gave me a goal reminder and it was like…walk 10 blocks three times a week I would be like oh yeah I have to remember that and I can do it and I get like a visual on my progress.” |
| 10 | “I think that’s a good idea. Like the part where it says what is getting in your way of completing your goal so you can figure out what you need to change so that you can complete your goal.” |
| 11 | “You got to trick me into it. If you trick me into it I’m going to laugh at it. You got to say something funny to set it up, you got to be like did you do it and then…be like did I do what? Did you do your goal and I’m like oh they got me and I’m going to start laughing…and I’m going to do extra.” |
|
| |
| 12 | “Maybe a picture of your favorite food or something that’s healthy like an apple or a pineapple.” |
| 13 | “Like for me you would send me is football really life and you would send a picture of my favorite team the Ravens and it would motivate me because I feel like I would look at them and be like oh snap that’s my team and then I’m going to have to play football at that moment.” |
| 14 | “Because when you’re thinking of something you heard that’s making you think maybe I should have tried it; maybe I should have done it.” |
|
| |
| 15 | “…they remind you about stuff because you probably just don’t even think about not eating or the way you eat until you get a text message about it and then you’ll think about it.” |
| 16 | “I like this way. It’s more personal. It’s giving you specific things that you could do.” |
| 17 | “Because like say if you said to get more active but I didn’t know what to do to get active, you gave me suggestions maybe I could ask my cousin to work with me. It gives ideas so I know what to do.” |
| Text Messaging—Timed Prompts/Photo Diary Messages | |
| 18 | “I think after school is like the perfect time because like what she said, people go to the store and make unhealthy decisions. That happens to me every day. So like that’s the perfect time to text a kid make healthy decisions.” |
| 19 | “…be engaged in conversation by sending you guys a picture of what we ate. That would be cool.” |
|
| |
| 20 | “Yeah, I think it’s a good idea because you get to compare what you’re doing with other people and maybe find other strategies to keep a healthy diet or stuff like that, just share…so that more ideas can come up…more solutions to a certain problem can be come up with.” |
| 21 | “Facebook is just too much…People they argue, post they’ve got problems, everything. Like I’m going to the hospital today to get my flu shot. Nobody needs to know all that. Keep that to yourself.” |
| 22 | “Yeah, and post it on a private page…private page. It stays relevant to the people inside of the group rather than posting it on your personal Facebook page.” |
| 23 | “As long as there’s someone keeping an eye on it and regulating it and it’s a safe environment for people to post things on the page and stuff like that.” |
|
| |
| 24 | “No, I’ll probably do it once in a while. Like I would do it one day or one week and then I’ll like skip a whole week and then I’ll do it the next week.” |
| 25 | “Because it’s too much work? FEMALE VOICE: Yeah…Like I could be wanting to do something and then I’ll get distracted, oh let me see what’s on Instagram, let me see…and I just forget all about it.” |
| 26 | “You don’t think people would get sick of entering their information day after day after day? Yes they would…after a week.” |
| 27 | “I don’t like apps that control how you eat. I don’t think that they’re good for you because if you look at the food through calories I think it’s not a smart way to do that. I think it’s better to know what you’re eating and just know that…cut certain things, like cut soda, cut junk food…instead of counting calories because counting calories restricts you from other things that may not necessarily be unhealthy because…because of the…calories…from the point of view of whether it’s-yeah, I think just counting calories is bad.” |
|
| |
| 28 | “For some reason, I don’t know, for communication purposes I think text messages impact me the most. If I get a text I think I’m more likely to respond to it than a message on Facebook.” |
| 29 | “Because texting is easier than social media and because I like texting a lot and I do it. Sometimes I’m on social media, sometimes I’m not so I’m not always going to respond to that.” |
| 30 | “-it’s sending you direct texts on like what you should do and what things you should think about and stuff like that.” |
| 31 | “It might be ineffective because if you keep sending texts like every day people might get annoyed.” |
| 32 | “Some people might actually care about cyber-bullying because some people might take what people say into consideration…Like it might get to them and hurt them and make them feel bad.” |
Translation of Focus Group Findings into Components of Youth Diabetes Prevention Program.
| Focus Group Finding | Strategy for Incorporation into Program |
|---|---|
|
| |
| Teens generally encounter unhealthy peer influences related to dietary choices (and are sometimes “forced” into unhealthy dietary behaviors) | Role play—communication skills with friends and family including the “broken record” method, “I” messages, expression of feelings, listening, and repetition |
| Teens generally encounter healthy peer influences related to physical activity | Group based physical activity with music and modeling by peer leaders; friendly competition for step counts |
|
| |
| Workshop Structure | 12-week group peer led program (1.5 h per session, held once a week) |
| Interactive Workshop Activities |
Group exercise demos with music Games (focus on topics related to healthy eating and being physically active; modeled after popular games; new teams formed each week; collaborate to earn points; top 3 receive a prize at the end of the workshop) Weekly goals Group discussions (focus on topics related to healthy eating and being physically active *; brainstorming, problem solving, role plays) |
| Identification of Peer Leaders |
Distribution of applications through community partners Individual and group interviews Selected individuals with desired qualities described in focus groups |
| Peer Leader Training |
Review of 12 weeks of workshop content, team building activities, and leadership/group facilitation skills (how to handle challenging situations, being flexible, dealing with conflicts, providing feedback, modeling, how to deal with downtime, and preparing/planning) |
| Peer Leader Supervision |
Observation of sessions by adults Observation checklist and feedback forms completed for each session |
| Peer Leader Support |
Weekly planning and debriefing meetings before and after each session Individual and group feedback |
|
| |
| Youth Engagement in Platform Development | Use of a participatory process with youth to codesign platform structure and message content. |
| Text Messaging—Behavior Tracking |
Messages about key diet and physical activity behaviors (fruit and vegetable intake, sugary beverage intake, physical activity time, and screen time) with automated messages sent back to participants based on their response Workshop specific behavior tracking message based on topic covered during workshop that week with automated messages sent back to participants based on their response |
| Text Messaging—Goal Setting |
Goal-setting message sent at the beginning of the week Mid-week goal check in message with automated responses sent to participants based on whether they report their goal is going well or not. Flag participants struggling with their goal for individual outreach from peer leader Goal completion message at the end of the week with automated responses sent to participants based on whether they report that they completed their goal. Flag participants who do not complete goal for individual outreach from peer leader |
| Text Messaging—Motivational |
Link with motivational graphic and text OR inspirational quote |
| Text Messaging—Tailored Messages |
Messages sent to participants asking about specific behaviors Automated messages sent back to participants based on their response, including specific suggestions with links |
| Text Messaging—Photo Diary |
Teens instructed to take and upload photos related to healthy eating or active living |
| Message Frequency | 1–2 messages per day |
| Monitoring of Platform | Centralized message tracker which documents messages sent and received and allows research staff/peer leaders to monitor messages, manually initiate messages, and respond to flagged messages |
* also include topics such as stress and dealing with difficult emotions, body image, healthy and unhealthy weight control behaviors, mindfulness, positive thinking, youth empowerment/advocacy, local resources, and healthy lifestyle on a budget.