Margherita Marchetti1,2, Douwe Kamsma1, Ernesto Cazares Vargas3, Armando Hernandez García3, Paul van der Schoot4,5, Renko de Vries6, Gijs J L Wuite1, Wouter H Roos2. 1. Department of Physics and Astronomy and LaserLaB Amsterdam , Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam , 1081 HV Amsterdam , The Netherlands. 2. Moleculaire Biofysica, Zernike Instituut , Rijksuniversiteit Groningen , 9712 CP Groningen , The Netherlands. 3. Institute of Chemistry, Department of Chemistry of Biomacromolecules , National Autonomous University of Mexico , 04510 Mexico City , Mexico. 4. Institute for Theoretical Physics , Utrecht University , 3512 JE Utrecht , The Netherlands. 5. Department of Applied Physics , Eindhoven University of Technology , 5612 AZ Eindhoven , The Netherlands. 6. Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Science , Wageningen University , 6708 PB Wageningen , The Netherlands.
Abstract
While the structure of a multitude of viral particles has been resolved to atomistic detail, their assembly pathways remain largely elusive. Key unresolved issues are particle nucleation, particle growth, and the mode of genome compaction. These issues are difficult to address in bulk approaches and are effectively only accessible by the real-time tracking of assembly dynamics of individual particles. This we do here by studying the assembly into rod-shaped viruslike particles (VLPs) of artificial capsid polypeptides. Using fluorescence optical tweezers, we establish that small oligomers perform one-dimensional diffusion along the DNA. Larger oligomers are immobile and nucleate VLP growth. A multiplexed acoustic force spectroscopy approach reveals that DNA is compacted in regular steps, suggesting packaging via helical wrapping into a nucleocapsid. By reporting how real-time assembly tracking elucidates viral nucleation and growth principles, our work opens the door to a fundamental understanding of the complex assembly pathways of both VLPs and naturally evolved viruses.
While the structure of a multitude of viral particles has been resolved to atomistic detail, their assembly pathways remain largely elusive. Key unresolved issues are particle nucleation, particle growth, and the mode of genome compaction. These issues are difficult to address in bulk approaches and are effectively only accessible by the real-time tracking of assembly dynamics of individual particles. This we do here by studying the assembly into rod-shaped viruslike particles (VLPs) of artificial capsid polypeptides. Using fluorescence optical tweezers, we establish that small oligomers perform one-dimensional diffusion along the DNA. Larger oligomers are immobile and nucleate VLP growth. A multiplexed acoustic force spectroscopy approach reveals that DNA is compacted in regular steps, suggesting packaging via helical wrapping into a nucleocapsid. By reporting how real-time assembly tracking elucidates viral nucleation and growth principles, our work opens the door to a fundamental understanding of the complex assembly pathways of both VLPs and naturally evolved viruses.
The structure
of viral particles
is typically highly regular and remarkably stable.[1] A number of viruses have been reconstituted in
vitro, suggesting that quite generic physical driving forces
determine their assembly pathways. This motivated trials to replace
viral genomes with other cargo, allowing viruses to be employed, e.g., as drug delivery platforms.[2−4] Many bulk experimental
studies[5−8] as well as modeling and computer simulation approaches[9−11] have been performed to elucidate the in vitro assembly
pathways of viral particles. An important conclusion is that the multiplicity
of assembly pathways in the experiments obscures interpretation of
the findings.[12] Central questions yet to
be answered include the nature of the critical nuclei required for
productive viral particle formation as well as the nature and dynamics
of nucleic acid condensation during particle formation.[13−15] In order to discriminate between different pathways and to identify
assembly intermediates, real-time assembly of viral particles should
be probed at the single-particle level.Single molecule techniques
such as electron microscopy and atomic
force microscopy (AFM) provide for high-resolution images of viruses
but typically yield images with only limited information on dynamic
assembly pathways.[16,17] High-resolution AFM imaging and
electron microscopy have recently provided access to information on
transient capsid intermediates from which kinetic assembly parameters
can be estimated.[18] In addition, new approaches,
such as resistive-pulse sensing in nanofluidic devices, probe late-state
intermediates during viral assembly.[19] Here
we go beyond these recent studies by using combined confocal fluorescence
and optical tweezing to identify the nature of critical nuclei in
capsid formation. In addition, we use acoustic force spectroscopy
to probe in real-time not only the dynamics and nature of particle
growth but also nucleic acid condensation during the formation of
single, rod-shaped nucleocapsid particles.We do this for a
previously de novo designed artificial
capsid polypeptide bearing a stretch of lysines,[20] which interacts through electrostatic interactions with
the phosphates of single or double-stranded DNA templates to coassemble
into rod-shaped viruslike particles (VLPs). This polypeptide was designed
to mimic the essential features of the in vitro assembly
of Tobacco Mosaic Virus particles, viz. obligate coassembly with a
linear nucleic acid template, with growth proceeding from a single
nucleus. Indeed, the time evolution of the particle size distributions
of both TMV and the VLPs can be accurately fitted to the same kinetic
model, yielding similar energies for particle nucleation and particle
growth.[9,20,21] The rod-shaped
VLPs consist of a single DNA molecule coated with multiple copies
of the artificial capsid polypeptide. The latter we refer to as C–S10–B, with each of its three blocks encoding a specific
physicochemical functionality, mimicking corresponding functionalities
of viral capsid proteins (Figure A).
Figure 1
Artificial capsid polypeptide under investigation and
the resulting
formation of rod-shaped particles. (A) Schematic of the triblocks
polypeptide C–S10–B. Each block is highlighted
by a different color and its specific function, related to its physiochemical
properties, as described in the methods. (B) Particle formation on
DNA molecules of different lengths was probed with AFM imaging in
the air. On DNA of ∼1 μm contour length, mainly single
particles form in which the DNA is compacted 1/3 of its original length
(panel i). When a 3-fold longer DNA is employed (∼3 μm
contour length), 2–4 nucleation points are observed in the
early stages of particles assembly (panel ii). The white arrows point
at two different nucleation sites that are formed on the same DNA
molecule. (C) Quantification from AFM images of the “slow”
kinetics of particle formation on a 2.5 kbp DNA, being packed to 1/3
of its original length, as also previously shown.[20] Error bars are standard deviations and for each time point
∼100 particles were analyzed.
Artificial capsid polypeptide under investigation and
the resulting
formation of rod-shaped particles. (A) Schematic of the triblocks
polypeptide C–S10–B. Each block is highlighted
by a different color and its specific function, related to its physiochemical
properties, as described in the methods. (B) Particle formation on
DNA molecules of different lengths was probed with AFM imaging in
the air. On DNA of ∼1 μm contour length, mainly single
particles form in which the DNA is compacted 1/3 of its original length
(panel i). When a 3-fold longer DNA is employed (∼3 μm
contour length), 2–4 nucleation points are observed in the
early stages of particles assembly (panel ii). The white arrows point
at two different nucleation sites that are formed on the same DNA
molecule. (C) Quantification from AFM images of the “slow”
kinetics of particle formation on a 2.5 kbp DNA, being packed to 1/3
of its original length, as also previously shown.[20] Error bars are standard deviations and for each time point
∼100 particles were analyzed.We here use these simple model capsid polypeptides to address key
issues regarding capsid assembly pathways not only in real-time but
also at the single-particle level. We study the nature of the critical
nuclei for productive capsid formation, the dynamics of particle growth,
and the dynamics and nature of nucleic acid condensation during capsid
formation. Our study on this simple model system paves the way for
detailed real-time in vitro studies of the assembly
of naturally evolved viruses at the single-particle level.
Results
Real-Time Observation
of Nucleation on Long DNA
First
we use atomic force microscopy (AFM) imaging to recapitulate basic
properties of encapsulation of linear DNA by the artificial capsid
polypeptides.[17] Upon mixing the capsid
polypeptides with double-stranded DNA, rod-shaped particles are formed,
confirming earlier findings[20] (Figure B). The kinetics
of particle formation can be quantified by analyzing the length of
packaged DNA as a function of time (Figure C). DNA with a contour length <1 μm
typically displays one or two nucleation sites, while longer DNA with
a contour length >1 μm often shows more than two nucleation
sites (Figure B).
The relative frequency of the number of nucleation points and the
resulting branches in the self-assembled particle were quantified
for a 2.5 kbp-long DNA (contour length of ≈850 nm) (Fig. S1). Next to imaging in air, we additionally
performed AFM imaging in aqueous solution. This yielded an average
diameter of the VLPs of 9 nm, a value that matches the expected lateral
dimensions of the VLP (Fig. S1).Next we turn to investigating the assembly of single viruslike particles
in real-time, first considering the nucleation of artificial capsids
on their DNA templates. Specifically, we wish to elucidate the nature
of the critical nuclei required for productive capsid growth. For
this, we combine confocal fluorescence microscopy and optical tweezing.[22] A long DNA molecule (λ-phage DNA, contour
length ≈16.5 μm) is attached at both ends to a microsphere
(“bead”), and both beads are trapped using a double
optical tweezers setup. Simultaneous confocal scanning laser microscopy
allows for real-time probing of the local binding of fluorescently
labeled artificial capsid polypeptides on the DNA[23] (Figure A). Because the DNA in this assay is long, multiple nuclei are expected
to form (Fig. S1), making this technique
particularly well suited to zoom in on VLP nucleation events. First,
nucleation is allowed to proceed unimpeded by repeatedly keeping the
DNA in a relaxed state (<1 pN) for a fixed amount of time (5 min),
followed by a short period of imaging at a constant force of 5 pN
(Figure B). We observe
a shortening of the end-to-end distance as a function of time, indicating
condensation of the DNA during the relaxed state phases (Figure B,i). We also observe
an increasing number of nuclei as a function of time and a corresponding
increase of the total fluorescence intensity (Figure B,ii). With these findings, which are supported
by our AFM data, we confirm that in our dynamic assay multiple nucleation
sites are indeed formed, capable of compacting the DNA in a progressive
way.
Figure 2
Optical tweezers combined with confocal fluorescence microscopy
reveals protein binding and compaction. (A) Illustration of a dual
trap optical tweezers combined with confocal fluoresce microscopy.
Two focused lasers beams (red) trap two microspheres that are chemically
attached to a DNA molecule. Proteins in solution (green dots) bind
to the DNA, and their fluorescence tag lights up when the scanning
laser (light green beam) illuminates them. (B) Progressive packaging
of the DNA by the polypeptides. (i) Confocal fluorescence images show
how DNA shortening (from top to bottom, time = 0, 5, 15, 25 min. Yellow
scale bar, 2.5 μm) is accompanied by an increase in the fluorescence
intensity. (ii) Plots of fluorescence intensity, which is directly
related to the number of bound peptides (fluorescence images y-position vs integrated fluorescence intensity (a.u.) along
the DNA).
Optical tweezers combined with confocal fluorescence microscopy
reveals protein binding and compaction. (A) Illustration of a dual
trap optical tweezers combined with confocal fluoresce microscopy.
Two focused lasers beams (red) trap two microspheres that are chemically
attached to a DNA molecule. Proteins in solution (green dots) bind
to the DNA, and their fluorescence tag lights up when the scanning
laser (light green beam) illuminates them. (B) Progressive packaging
of the DNA by the polypeptides. (i) Confocal fluorescence images show
how DNA shortening (from top to bottom, time = 0, 5, 15, 25 min. Yellow
scale bar, 2.5 μm) is accompanied by an increase in the fluorescence
intensity. (ii) Plots of fluorescence intensity, which is directly
related to the number of bound peptides (fluorescence images y-position vs integrated fluorescence intensity (a.u.) along
the DNA).In order to study the mechanical
effect of polypeptide binding
to the DNA, relaxed DNA was first incubated with the proteins in solution,
then stretched to an end-to-end distance nearly equal to its contour
length, and subsequently relaxed back to zero force while recording
the retraction force (Figs. S2 and S3).
We find that the apparent persistence length Lp obtained by fitting a wormlike chain model to the retraction
force[24] decreases sharply as the number
of bound capsid polypeptides increases (Fig. S2B). This is consistent with the occurrence of induced deformations
during DNA compaction, such as kinking or bending.[25,26] Indeed, the control polypeptide C–B, lacking the central
S10 silklike block, known to simply coat but not condense
the DNA,[27] does not show the reduction
of persistence lengths (Fig. S3D).
Identification
of the Nature of Critical Nuclei Required for
Artificial Capsid Formation
In the experiments shown in Figure , nucleation and
growth proceeds unimpeded as the DNA is in a relaxed state for fixed
times, only to be stretched for a short time for imaging purposes.
This precludes the observation of capsid nucleation with high temporal
resolution. Therefore, we performed experiments to quantify polypeptide
binding dynamics at the single-molecule level and at millisecond time
scales. We keep the DNA at a fixed end-to-end distance of 15.5 μm
and continuously monitor the fluorescence along the 16.5 μm
contour length long DNA in the form of kymographs (Figure A). For these experiments,
the fluorescence intensity of one dye molecule was established to
be 12.0 ± 0.5 photons (see Methods and Fig. S4), with which the absolute number of bound
polypeptides can be determined.[28]
Figure 3
Real-time polypeptide
binding. (A) Kymographs showing progressive
peptide binding for two different C–S10–B
concentrations: 50 nM panel (i) and 200 nM panel (ii). The confocal
scanning line-time is 30 ms, the yellow scale bar denotes 2 μm. (B) Cumulative polypeptide binding
over time (data extracted from the kymograph integrated intensity
over time). Average values from six kymographs at 200 nM (green dots)
and five kymographs at 50 nM (yellow dots) are plotted. The data were
fitted with a Langmuir adsorption model resulting in a polypeptide
binding constant of K ≈ 7 × 108 M–1.
Real-time polypeptide
binding. (A) Kymographs showing progressive
peptide binding for two different C–S10–B
concentrations: 50 nM panel (i) and 200 nM panel (ii). The confocal
scanning line-time is 30 ms, the yellow scale bar denotes 2 μm. (B) Cumulative polypeptide binding
over time (data extracted from the kymograph integrated intensity
over time). Average values from six kymographs at 200 nM (green dots)
and five kymographs at 50 nM (yellow dots) are plotted. The data were
fitted with a Langmuir adsorption model resulting in a polypeptide
binding constant of K ≈ 7 × 108 M–1.As DNA compaction progresses,
high forces quickly develop that
most likely decreases polypeptides binding and halts DNA condensation
on the stretched DNA. Indeed, the number of bound capsid polypeptides
as a function of time, shown in Figure B for two polypeptide concentrations, plateaus after
about 5 min, at levels far below saturation (see Figure A). With the assumption that
the stretching mainly influences the maximum number of bound polypeptides,
but not the binding dynamics, these data were analyzed using a simple
reversible Langmuir adsorption kinetics model[29] (Supporting Information). This resulted
in an effective binding free energy of ∼25 times the thermal
energy, which is of the same order of magnitude as earlier estimates
for VLP growth.[9,30]The calibrated kymograph
data yields distributions of the number
of polypeptides involved in each binding event. From Figure A it can be seen that at 50
nM the most frequent cluster size is a trimer, whereas at 200 nM it
is a hexamer. By tracking single traces to obtain mean-square displacements[31] of polypeptide clusters moving on the DNA over
time, we extracted diffusion constants of polypeptide clusters bound
to the DNA as a function of cluster size (Figure B). We find that small clusters slide along
the DNA, while large clusters are essentially immobilized on the DNA.
The mobility of clusters drops to essentially zero for pentameric
and larger oligomers (D ≤ 0.1 × 10–2 μm2/s). The observed decrease of
the diffusion constant with cluster size is much steeper than is expected
for a simple linear scaling of the sliding friction with oligomer
size (see Fig. S3C), suggesting strong
interactions of the large oligomers with the DNA and likely conformational
integration into growing VLPs.
Figure 4
Polypeptide size quantification and their
mobility along the DNA.
(A) Quantification of single photobleaching steps allows an estimation
of the number of polypeptides bound per recorded event. The binding-event
size statistics produces a histogram with a broad range of binding
sizes. At 50 nM, the first observed peak fits with trimer binding
(Gaussian peak, 3.0 ± 0.4 polypeptides). At 200 nM, the first
observed peak fits with hexamer binding (6.0 ± 0.3 polypeptides).
(B) Diffusion constant D of the tracked binding events
in the kymographs reveals an initial, drastic drop with increasing
oligomer size, leveling off for oligomer sizes of ≥5 polypeptides
(gray background area highlights the mobile events, error bars SEM).
Inset: example of single binding events indicating that oligomer growth
is more likely (90% traces) to take place when starting off with a
large cluster (>5-mer, red curve) than with a small cluster (gray
curve in the example, 10% traces).
Polypeptide size quantification and their
mobility along the DNA.
(A) Quantification of single photobleaching steps allows an estimation
of the number of polypeptides bound per recorded event. The binding-event
size statistics produces a histogram with a broad range of binding
sizes. At 50 nM, the first observed peak fits with trimer binding
(Gaussian peak, 3.0 ± 0.4 polypeptides). At 200 nM, the first
observed peak fits with hexamer binding (6.0 ± 0.3 polypeptides).
(B) Diffusion constant D of the tracked binding events
in the kymographs reveals an initial, drastic drop with increasing
oligomer size, leveling off for oligomer sizes of ≥5 polypeptides
(gray background area highlights the mobile events, error bars SEM).
Inset: example of single binding events indicating that oligomer growth
is more likely (90% traces) to take place when starting off with a
large cluster (>5-mer, red curve) than with a small cluster (gray
curve in the example, 10% traces).Further analysis of the intensity of the polypeptide clusters reveals
that those clusters that are smaller than pentamers only grow in 10%
of the cases. For pentameric and larger clusters, this occurs in 90%
of the cases (Figure B, inset). Previously, it has been shown that a minimal number of
polypeptides need to simultaneously bind to the DNA in order to nucleate
particle growth.[21] This should also mean
that for very short DNA, covered by fewer proteins than the critical
nucleus, the binding strength of the proteins should drop to lower
values. Indeed, a bulk electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA)
confirms that binding of the artificial capsid polypeptides is strongly
dependent on the length of the DNA template in the range of 10 bp
to 1000 bp (Fig. S5). Taken together, our
data strongly suggests that preformed oligomers bind to the DNA, and
that pentamers, if bound to the DNA, should be considered as the critical
nuclei for the productive formation of VLPs.
Nature and Dynamics of
DNA Condensation during Capsid Growth
The combined fluorescence
microscopy and optical tweezers experiments
discussed previously are suboptimal for studying capsid growth. This
is because (i) the many nuclei on the long DNA (Fig. S1C) make it difficult to follow growth of each of them,
and (ii) growth of the nuclei cannot be followed over a sufficiently
long time due to photo bleaching. Therefore, as a complementary real-time,
single-particle technique, we apply acoustic force spectroscopy (AFS).
AFS allows us to probe end-to-end distances for short DNA molecules
tethered between a surface and a microbead (see schematic in Figure A) as a function
of time (up to hours), for a fixed low force and with high temporal
resolution (50 Hz).[32] Since the DNA used
in the AFS experiment is short (2.9 kbp ≈ 1 μm), growth
of viruslike particles is initiated from one or at most two nuclei
(Fig. S1A,B), allowing us to follow growth
in much greater detail. Data for multiple DNA strands is acquired
simultaneously, leading to superior statistics.
Figure 5
Acoustic force spectroscopy
reveals particles compaction dynamics.
(A) Illustrative image of the AFS setup. DNA tethered microspheres
are pushed along an acoustically generated pressure gradient (blue/white
background) that applies a long and stable low-force clamp. (B) Decrease
in DNA end-to-end length over time is a measure of the DNA compaction.
The light blue background indicates the flushing in of peptides into
the flow-cell while a stretching force of 15 pN is applied. The gray
background area indicates a constant applied force of 1.5 pN. Inset:
close-up of a compaction trace with the green line of the fit showing
the compaction steps found with a previously developed step finding
algorithm.[33] (C) Step size statistics of
compaction events at different conditions: 50 nM polypeptides–1
μm DNA (top histogram), 1 μM polypeptides–1 μm
DNA (middle histogram), and 1 μM polypeptides–3 μm
DNA (bottom histogram). The negative steps obtained at lower concentration
(top histogram) are decompaction events, which shows a symmetrical
distribution. The compaction event data are fitted with a multi-Gaussian
function, where the distances from peaks-to-peak are equally spaced
and used as one fit parameter.
Acoustic force spectroscopy
reveals particles compaction dynamics.
(A) Illustrative image of the AFS setup. DNA tethered microspheres
are pushed along an acoustically generated pressure gradient (blue/white
background) that applies a long and stable low-force clamp. (B) Decrease
in DNA end-to-end length over time is a measure of the DNA compaction.
The light blue background indicates the flushing in of peptides into
the flow-cell while a stretching force of 15 pN is applied. The gray
background area indicates a constant applied force of 1.5 pN. Inset:
close-up of a compaction trace with the green line of the fit showing
the compaction steps found with a previously developed step finding
algorithm.[33] (C) Step size statistics of
compaction events at different conditions: 50 nM polypeptides–1
μm DNA (top histogram), 1 μM polypeptides–1 μm
DNA (middle histogram), and 1 μM polypeptides–3 μm
DNA (bottom histogram). The negative steps obtained at lower concentration
(top histogram) are decompaction events, which shows a symmetrical
distribution. The compaction event data are fitted with a multi-Gaussian
function, where the distances from peaks-to-peak are equally spaced
and used as one fit parameter.After confirming that results for the effective persistence lengths
obtained from force–extension curves obtained by optical tweezers
agree with those obtained from force–extension curves obtained
by AFS (Fig. S6A,B), we apply AFS to probe
in detail the nature and dynamics of DNA condensation during capsid
growth. The DNA condensation is observed in real-time by measuring
the end-to-end distance of DNA molecules kept at fixed low force of
1.5 pN and in the presence of artificial capsid polypeptides.Surprisingly, we find that DNA condensation into viruslike particles
proceeds in a stepwise fashion (Figure B, inset). A multi-Gaussian distribution with equally
spaced peak distances is fitted to the extracted step sizes. The short
DNA (≈ 1 μm) reveals a sharp peak at a step size of 30
± 1 nm in DNA contour length for both low (50 nM) as high (1
μM) C–S10–B concentrations (Figure C). This shows that
the most probable step size for the condensation process is concentration
independent. At low polypeptide concentrations, we also find decondensation
steps, recorded as negative steps. Remarkably, the most probable step
sizes for condensation and decondensation appear equal, not only at
low forces but also if we increase the tension in order to induce
decondensation (Fig. S6C). Employing a
3-fold longer DNA (8.3 kbp ≈ 3 μm), the step-size distribution
has much less pronounced peaks, which we attribute to the presence
of multiple growing nuclei on the longer DNA. In this case, simultaneous
steps at multiple locations cannot be deconvoluted and are detected
as larger steps (Figure C).
Discussion
The self-assembly pathway of even relatively
simple viruses, such as the tobacco mosaic virus that consists of
a single-stranded RNA packaged by a large number of identical copies
of coat protein, is highly complex. It is only partially understood
and in fact remains the object of controversy.[9] At least in part this is due to the circumstance that capsid assembly
pathways are difficult to address other than with real-time, single-particle
methods. Two unresolved issues are considered in this work: the nature
of the critical nuclei for productive capsid formation and the dynamics
and nature of nucleic acid condensation during capsid growth. For
a simple artificial capsid polypeptide model system, which mimics
essential features of the assembly of the much more complicated natural
tobacco mosaic virus, we have shown that powerful, real-time, single
molecule techniques can be used to successfully address such issues.For these artificial capsid polypeptides, we have shown that a
broad range of preformed polypeptide oligomers can directly bind the
DNA. As described by classical nucleation theory of protein capsids,
a nucleus with a certain critical size has to be reached to trigger
capsid formation, which seems to be true for spherical and rodlike
assemblies alike.[14,21,34,35] We find that binding events of oligomers
consisting of less than five polypeptides typically do not lead to
particle growth. These oligomers, when bound, slide along the DNA
with a mobility that rapidly decreases with increasing oligomer size.
Binding events of oligomers consisting of minimally five polypeptides
seem to be required for triggering nucleocapsid growth. Such oligomers,
when bound to the DNA, are essentially immobile. Therefore, we conclude
that pentamers bound to the DNA template may be considered to be the
critical nuclei for the formation of the artificial capsids. The smaller-sized
oligomers (<5) that can slide along the DNA may assist the growth
process. Indeed, proteins sliding along a nucleic acid molecule during
viral assembly is theoretically shown to considerably accelerate the
self-assembly of natural icosahedral viruses.[36,37]The nature and dynamics of DNA condensation during capsid
growth
was successfully addressed using AFS, for it allows probing end-to-end
distances of multiple short DNAs over prolonged periods of time and
under a precisely controlled low force. Surprisingly, we have established
that DNA condensation into the artificial capsids occurs in discrete
single compaction events, with approximately 30 nm of DNA contour
length being condensed in each compaction event. This characteristic
length of DNA per compaction event seems to be largely independent
of the protein concentration and therefore also independent of nuclei
size. Also, decondensation steps at low protein concentrations show
the same characteristic length, suggesting that this length of DNA
must corresponds to a characteristic structure of condensed DNA in
the rod-shaped artificial viral capsid.The filamentous core
of the VLP is formed by the silklike middle
blocks S10 of the C–S10–B artificial
capsid polypeptide, which assemble into a stack of beta-solenoids
(Figure A,B). Each
beta-solenoid sheet has a dimension of ≈2.0 nm × 2.6 nm
and a height of ≈0.6 nm, as predicted by computer simulations.[38,39] The binding blocks B and stability block C emanate from the filamentous
core. From this we expect that the DNA is confined to a condensation
region extending at most a few nanometers away from the filamentous
core (Figure ), since
the flexible dodecalysine binding blocks B can only extend up to that
distance. Such a structure is consistent with the height of the VLPs
found using AFM imaging in liquid (Fig. S1C), which show an average particle height of ≈9 nm.
Figure 6
Conformation
of condensed DNA. (A) Sheetlike beta-solenoid conformation
of folded silk block S10 = (GAGAGAGQ)10 with
approximate dimensions, as predicted by computer simulations.[38] (B) Filamentous core of the VLPs is formed through
stacking of the sheetlike folded silk blocks. (C) Region of DNA condensation
extends from just outside the filamentous core up to the distance
the flexible oligolysine binding blocks B = K12 can stretch
away from the filamentous core from which they emanate, which is a
few nanometers. Binding to the highly localized binding blocks may
lead to different condensed conformations of the DNA such as a helical
winding around the filamentous core of the VLP, as suggested by the
observation of regular condensation and decondensation steps of 30
nm of DNA contour length.
Conformation
of condensed DNA. (A) Sheetlike beta-solenoid conformation
of folded silk block S10 = (GAGAGAGQ)10 with
approximate dimensions, as predicted by computer simulations.[38] (B) Filamentous core of the VLPs is formed through
stacking of the sheetlike folded silk blocks. (C) Region of DNA condensation
extends from just outside the filamentous core up to the distance
the flexible oligolysine binding blocks B = K12 can stretch
away from the filamentous core from which they emanate, which is a
few nanometers. Binding to the highly localized binding blocks may
lead to different condensed conformations of the DNA such as a helical
winding around the filamentous core of the VLP, as suggested by the
observation of regular condensation and decondensation steps of 30
nm of DNA contour length.The
question arises what conformation the DNA adopts in the condensation
region close to the filamentous core of the VLPs. For DNA packed into
icosahedral spaces such as in T4 and T7 bacteriophages, it has convincingly
been shown that the experimentally observed spool-like DNA configuration
can be explained purely in terms of nanogeometric confinement.[40−42] In other cases, binding to capsid proteins may induce nucleic acid
template deformations that would not be expected on the basis of geometric
confinement alone. For example, the helical arrangement of the RNA
genome in TMV virus particles is dictated by their binding to the
capsid proteins rather than by geometric confinement.[43] For our artificial viruslike particles, it has previously
been shown that particle lengths are roughly one-third of the DNA
contour length.[20] If the DNA conformation
inside the artificial viruslike particles considered here is determined
by geometric nanoconfinement alone, the most plausible conformation
would be that of parallel double stranded DNAs with hairpin bending
defects, as illustrated in Fig. S7. Such
conformations minimize the bending energy of semiflexible chains in
finite length tubular confinement, for tube diameters much less than
the persistence length, as predicted in recent computer simulations[44] and demonstrated by the theoretical estimates
of eqs S10–S12. Such conformations
are also similar to the conformations adopted by DNA confined in nanochannels.[45]However, binding of the DNA to the highly
localized binding blocks
that emanate from the filamentous core may induce strong DNA deformations
that in turn lead to DNA conformations very different from those predicted
for confinement of the DNA in a finite nanotube. Indeed, the observed
30 nm steps are suggestive of a stepwise helical winding of the DNA
around the filamentous core of the viruslike particle during its growth
in the AFS experiment, illustrated in Figure C. If we assume that the characteristic contour
length of 30 nm corresponds to a single helical winding, this would
imply a radius of the helix of 4.5 nm, and a radius of curvature of
5.1 nm, to arrive at a distance between the helical windings of 10
nm, consistent with the observed packing parameter of 3 (Fig. S8). This helical arrangement is large enough
for the DNA to wind around the filamentous core of the VLP yet small
enough to be within the region into which the binding blocks can extend.
Interestingly, a DNA molecule wrapped around histones has a similar
radius of curvature.[46]To summarize,
we have presented a unique combination of complementary,
dynamic techniques for assembly studies of both VLPs and naturally
evolved virus particles. We have used these techniques to address
key issues regarding capsid assembly pathways that are difficult to
address other than with real-time, single-particle methods: the nature
of the critical nuclei for productive capsid formation and the dynamics
and nature of nucleic acid condensation during capsid formation. Albeit
our study focuses on nucleocapsid formation by simple artificial polypeptides,
it does pave the way for the detailed real-time in vitro studies of the assembly of naturally evolved viruses at the single-particle
level.
Methods
Viruslike Particle Capsid Polypeptides
The polypeptide,
C–S10–B, consists of three blocks that each
encode a specific physicochemical functionality, mimicking corresponding
functionalities of viral capsid proteins. Nucleic acid binding is
achieved through interactions with block B that consists of 12 positively
charged lysines. The silklike middle blocks S10 = (GAGAGAGQ)10 fold into a sheetlike beta-solenoid conformation[35,47] (Figure A), and
stacking of these sheets leads to the formation of a rigid protein
filament that forms the core of the VLP.[20] Folding of an initially unfolded silk block into the beta-solenoid
conformation is promoted by docking onto an already existing folded
silk block, such that the formation of the rod-shaped protein core
is a nucleated process.[20,21,35] Finally, a hydrophilic random-coil C, with a collagen-like sequence
C = (GXY)132 (where X and Y are mostly hydrophilic uncharged
amino acids[48]) provides colloidal stability
to the rod-shaped VLPs. Immediately after dissolution, the silk blocks
of C–S10–B polypeptides are still unfolded,
but over time they fold and stack, a process that is strongly promoted
by binding to the nucleic acid templates, such that coassembly with
nucleic acid templates is favored over capsid protein-only assembly.[20] The biosyntethic capsid polypeptides were provided
as lyophilized protein polymer powder (C–S10–B
= 44.7492 kDa), produced as previously described.[20] For additional sample preparation details, see the Supporting Information.
Atomic Force Microscopy
Viruslike particles were imaged
in peak force tapping mode on a Bruker Bioscope catalyst setup, unless
otherwise stated. Peptides and DNA were incubated with a final charge
ratio N/P = 3 (molar ratio between positively charged NH2 groups from the binding block to negatively charged PO3 groups of the DNA template (P)), in 10 mM phosphate buffer at pH
7.5. Viruslike particles were adhered to freshly cleaved mica treated
with 5 mM TRIS and 0.5 mM Mg2+ solution. For additional
info on sample preparation for experiments in air and in liquid, see
the Supporting Information. AFM image processing
was performed with NanoScope Analysis 1.5 software for both a first
order imaging flattening and the particles height estimation.
Optical
Tweezers with Confocal Fluorescence Microscopy
The dual-trap
optical tweezers setup with integrated confocal fluorescence
microscopy (LUMICKS) is similar to an optical setup used for dual-trap
optical trapping experiments in combination with confocal fluorescence
and a microfluidics flow-cell the has been described previously.[49] End-biotinylated bacteriophage λ DNA was
connected to streptavidin-coated polystyrene beads (diameter = 4.5
μm, Spherotech) to generate the DNA constructs, as described
previously.[50] For sample preparation and
kymograph recording settings, see the Supporting Information. Binding of single peptides was followed through
kymograph analysis quantifying their fluorescence signal (average
number of photons) when landing on the DNA. All values were background
corrected. We processed the kymographs through single-molecule tracking
to acquire information on the binding events intensity and mobility.
Photo bleaching allows one to calibrate the intensity of a single
fluorophore (12.0 ± 0.5 photons) by looking at single fluorescence
decrease steps of single photobleached dyes,[28,51−53] see Fig. S3. The one-dimensional
diffusion of protein complexes along the DNA was quantified by tracking
the peptides traces and calculating their diffusion coefficient (D) by using a mean square displacement analysis (MSD).[31] Force–distance curves and confocal fluorescence
data were analyzed using a custom-written MATLAB software, using the
extensible wormlike chain model (eWLC),[54] which describes the dsDNA elastic behavior up to ∼30 pN,
is used to fit FDCs and estimate the DNA effective persistence length Lp: .
Acoustic Force Spectroscopy
The home-built AFS setup[32,55] and the AFS flow-cell (LUMICKS) and tethers preparation[55] have been previously described. The 8.4 kbp
DNA was obtained from a pKYBI vector, as previously described.[55] For the preparation of functionalized DNA samples
and flow-cell preparation, see the Supporting Information. AFS data were analyzed using a custom-written
LABVIEW software, and the step-analysis was performed with a custom-made
change-point analysis software.[33] Processed
data were analyzed using Origin. In the Gaussian fit in Figure C, the peak-to-peak distances
obtained are 22.6 ± 2, 21.3 ± 0.4, and 21 ± 0.3 nm
for the histograms from top to bottom. The light blue backgrounds
highlight the mean of the first two Gaussian peaks. In the main text,
these values are corrected for the force applied during the experiments
and the observed change in the effective Lp, resulting in an average step of 30 nm.
Electrophoretic Mobility
Shift Assay (EMSA)
EMSAs were
performed to determine the effect of the dsDNA length on the protein
binding. For sample preparation details, see the Supporting Information. The samples were loaded on 20% acrylamide
gels in 1× TAE buffer and run at 70 V for 90 min. Gels were in
a gel documentation system and analyzed with ImageJ. the N/P ratio
for 50% binding of DNA (KDapp) by the
protein was calculated fitting the DNA free intensities to the Hill
equation, , with n as the Hill constant.
Authors: Melle T J J M Punter; Armando Hernandez-Garcia; Daniela J Kraft; Renko de Vries; Paul van der Schoot Journal: J Phys Chem B Date: 2016-05-05 Impact factor: 2.991
Authors: Hande E Cingil; Emre B Boz; Giovanni Biondaro; Renko de Vries; Martien A Cohen Stuart; Daniela J Kraft; Paul van der Schoot; Joris Sprakel Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2017-03-28 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: René de Bruijn; Pieta Cornelia Martha Wielstra; Carlos Calcines-Cruz; Tom van Waveren; Armando Hernandez-Garcia; Paul van der Schoot Journal: Biophys J Date: 2022-05-30 Impact factor: 3.699
Authors: Lione Willems; Larissa van Westerveld; Stefan Roberts; Isaac Weitzhandler; Carlos Calcines Cruz; Armando Hernandez-Garcia; Ashutosh Chilkoti; Enrico Mastrobattista; John van der Oost; Renko de Vries Journal: Biomacromolecules Date: 2019-08-29 Impact factor: 6.988