| Literature DB >> 28805671 |
Juliet M Pullar1, Anitra C Carr2, Margreet C M Vissers3.
Abstract
The primary function of the skin is to act as a barrier against insults from the environment, and its unique structure reflects this. The skin is composed of two layers: the epidermal outer layer is highly cellular and provides the barrier function, and the inner dermal layer ensures strength and elasticity and gives nutritional support to the epidermis. Normal skin contains high concentrations of vitamin C, which supports important and well-known functions, stimulating collagen synthesis and assisting in antioxidant protection against UV-induced photodamage. This knowledge is often used as a rationale for the addition of vitamin C to topical applications, but the efficacy of such treatment, as opposed to optimising dietary vitamin C intake, is poorly understood. This review discusses the potential roles for vitamin C in skin health and summarises the in vitro and in vivo research to date. We compare the efficacy of nutritional intake of vitamin C versus topical application, identify the areas where lack of evidence limits our understanding of the potential benefits of vitamin C on skin health, and suggest which skin properties are most likely to benefit from improved nutritional vitamin C intake.Entities:
Keywords: UV protection; ascorbate; collagen; dermis; epidermis; skin aging; skin barrier function; vitamin C status; wound healing
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2017 PMID: 28805671 PMCID: PMC5579659 DOI: 10.3390/nu9080866
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nutrients ISSN: 2072-6643 Impact factor: 5.717
Figure 1Micrograph of human breast skin sample, showing the full depth of the dermis (pink staining) in comparison to the thin layer of epidermis (purple staining). The scale bar indicates 200 µm. A zoomed-in image is shown within the box. The stratum corneum, the outermost layer of the epidermis, is indicated by the arrows, with its characteristic basket-weave structure. The collagen bundles in the dermis are very clear, as are the scattered purple-stained fibroblasts that generate this structure.
Figure 2Delivery of nutrients to the skin. The location of the vitamin C transport proteins SVCT1 and SVCT2 are indicated. Red arrows depict nutrient flow from the blood vessels in the dermis to the epidermal layer. Nutrients delivered by topical application would need to penetrate the barrier formed by the stratum corneum.
Vitamin C content of human skin and a comparison with other tissues.
| Tissue | Vitamin C Content (mg/100 g Wet Weight) | References |
|---|---|---|
| Adrenal glands | 30–40 | [ |
| Pituitary glands | 40–50 | [ |
| Liver | 10–16 | [ |
| Spleen | 10–15 | [ |
| Lungs | 7 | [ |
| Kidneys | 5–15 | [ |
| Heart muscle | 5–15 | [ |
| Skeletal muscle | 3–4 | [ |
| Brain | 13–15 | [ |
| Skin-epidermis | 6–64 | [ |
| Skin-dermis | 3–13 | [ |
Figure 3Structure of the dermis. Higher magnification of H&E-stained dermis, showing the irregular nature of the bundled collagen fibres (pink stained) and sparse presence of the fibroblasts (blue nuclear staining). Vitamin C present in the fibroblasts supports the synthesis of the collagen fibres.
Figure 4The central role for vitamin C and other antioxidants pertinent to the skin. The interdependence of vitamins E and C, and glutathione, in the scavenging of free radicals and regeneration of the reduced antioxidants, is shown. Vitamin E is in the lipid fraction of the cell, whereas vitamin C and glutathione are water-soluble and present in the cytosol.
Summary of key in vitro studies investigating potential effects of vitamin C on the skin.
| Study Description | Measured Parameters | Outcome and Comment | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vit. C effects on collagen and elastin synthesis in human skin fibroblasts and vascular smooth muscle cells. | Monitored vit. C time of exposure and dose on collagen synthesis and gene expression, and elastin synthesis and gene regulation. | Vit. C exposure increased collagen, decreased elastin. Stabilization of collagen mRNA, lesser stability of elastin mRNA, and repression of elastin gene transcription. | [ |
| Effect of vit. C on collagen synthesis and SVCT2 expression in human skin fibroblasts. Vit. C added to culture medium for 5 days. | Vit. C uptake measured into cells, collagen I and IV measured with RT-PCR and ELISA, and RT-PCR for SVCT2. | Vit. C increased collagen I and IV, and increased SVCT2 expression. | [ |
| Effect of vit. C on elastin generation by fibroblasts from normal human skin, stretch-marked skin, keloids and dermal fat. | Immunohistochemistry and western blotting for detection of elastin and precursors. | 50 and 200 µM vit. C increased elastin production, 800 µM inhibited. No measures of vit. C uptake into cells. | [ |
| Vit. C addition to cultures of rat keratinocytes (REK). | Effect on differentiation and stratum corneum formation. | Morphology showed enhanced stratum corneum structure, increased keratohyalin granules and organization of intercellular lipid lamellae in the interstices of the stratum corneum. Increased profilaggrin and filaggrin. | [ |
| Effect of vit. C on human keratinocyte (HaCaT) cell line differentiation in vitro. | Measured development of cornified envelope (CE), gene expression. | CE formation and keratinocyte differentiation induced by vit. C, suggesting a role in formation of stratum corneum and barrier formation in vivo. | [ |
| Effect of vit. C supplementation on gene expression in human skin fibroblasts. | Total RNA nano assay, for genetic profiling, with and without vit. C in culture medium. | Increased gene expression for DNA replication and repair and cell cycle progression. Increased mitogenic stimulation and cell motility in the context of wound healing. Faster repair of damaged DNA bases. | [ |
| Effect of vit. C on dermal epidermal junction in skin model (keratinocytes and fibroblasts). | Keratinocyte organisation, fibroblast number, basement membrane protein deposition and mRNA expression. | Vit. C improved keratinocyte and basement membrane organisation. Increased fibroblast number, saw deposition of basement membrane proteins. | [ |
| Effect of vit. C on cultured skin models—combined human epidermal keratinocytes and dermal fibroblasts. | Monitored morphology, lipid composition. | Vit. C, but not vit. E, improved epidermal morphology, ceramide production and phospholipid layer formation. | [ |
| Effect of vit. C on UVA irradiation of primary cultures of human keratinocytes. | Vit. C added in low concentrations, monitored MDA, TBA, GSH, cell viability, IL-1, IL-6 generation. | Vit. C improved resistance to UVA, decreased MDA and TBA levels, increased GSH levels, decreased IL-1 and IL-6 levels. | [ |
| Effect of vit. C uptake into human keratinocyte (HaCaT) cell line on outcome to UV irradiation. | Accumulation of vit. C in keratinocytes, antioxidant capacity by DHDCF and apoptosis induction by UV irradiation. | Keratinocytes accumulated mM levels of vit. C, increasing antioxidant status and protecting against apoptosis. | [ |
| Effect of UVB on vit. C uptake into human keratinocyte cell line (HaCaT) and effects on inflammatory gene expression. | Cellular vit. C measured by HPLC, mRNA expression for chemokines, western blotting for SVCT localisation. | Vit. C uptake was increased with UVB irradiation, chemokine expression decreased with vit. C uptake. | [ |
| Effect of antioxidant mixtures of vit. C, vit. E and ferulic acid on exposure of cultured normal human keratinocytes to ozone. | Cell viability, proliferation, HNE, protein carbonyls, Nrf2, NFkappaB activation, IL-8 generation. | Vit. C-containing mixtures inhibited toxicity. The presence of vit. E provided additional protection against HNE and protein carbonyls. | [ |
| Protection of cultured skin cells against ozone exposure with vit. C, vit. E, and resveratrol. 3-D culture of human dermis—fibroblasts with collagen I + III. | Cell death, HNE levels, expression of transcription factors Nrf-2 and NfkappaB | Extensive protection against cell damage with mixtures containing vit. C. Increased expression of antioxidant proteins. Additional effect of vit. E + C. No effect with Vit. E alone. | [ |
Skin ailments, their causes and evidence from in vitro and in vivo studies for association with vitamin C levels.
| Type of Skin Damage | Cause | Skin Structure Affected | Evidence of Protection by Vitamin C | References |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sunburn | Acute and excessive UV exposure. | Cell death of all skin cells, with associated inflammation. | Improving skin vitamin C and vitamin E levels can improve resistance to UV exposure. | [ |
| Photoaging, oxidant-induced damage | Chronic UV overexposure, cigarette smoking. | Damaged collagen and elastin matrix, thinning of the epidermal layer. | Decreased signs of aging with higher fruit and vegetable intake. Protection inferred from studies with acute UV exposure. | [ |
| Hyperpigmentation | Chronic UV exposure and environmental stresses. | Excessive pigment formation and propagation of melanocytes in the epidermis. | Nutrition studies showing improved skin colour with higher fruit and vegetable intake. | Reviewed in [ |
| Wrinkle formation | Natural aging, oxidative stress, UV exposure, smoking, medical treatments. | Dermal layer changes, deterioration of collagen and elastic fibres. | Lessening of wrinkle depth following vitamin C supplementation. Increased collagen formation by fibroblasts in cell culture. | [ |
| Skin sagging | Natural aging, oxidative stress damage, extreme weight loss. | Loss of elastin and collagen fibres, thinning of skin layers, loss of muscle tone. | Improved skin tightness in individuals with higher fruit and vegetable intake. | Reviewed in [ |
| Loss of colour | Natural aging, UV exposure, illness. | Thinning of skin layers, loss of melanocytes or decreased melanin formation, loss of vasculature in dermis. | Improved skin tone with high fruit and vegetable intake. | Reviewed in [ |
| Surface roughness | Chemical and UV exposure, physical abrasion, allergy and inflammation. | Stratum corneum, loss of skin moisture barrier function. | Vitamin C enhances production of barrier lipids in cell culture. | [ |
| Dry skin | Medications, illness, extreme temperature, low humidity and wind exposure. | Stratum corneum, loss of skin barrier lipids and natural moisturising factor. | Vitamin C enhances production of barrier lipids in cell culture. | [ |
| Excessive scar formation, generation of keloids | Ineffective wound healing. | Fibroblast function, collagen and elastin formation. | Supplementation improves wound healing, prevents keloid formation in vivo, enhances collagen formation by fibroblasts in vitro. | [ |
| Poor wound healing, thickening rough skin | Vitamin C deficiency. | All skin cell functions, collagen formation. | Direct association Vitamin C deficiency prevents wound healing. | [ |
| Inflammatory skin lesions | Allergic and auto-inflammation. | Skin barrier integrity, underlying inflammation and swelling. | Nutrition support, decreased levels associated with loss of barrier lipid ceramide. | [ |
Summary of key and recent in vivo studies providing evidence of vitamin C effects in the skin.
| Study Description | Measured Parameters | Outcome and Comment | References |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dietary supplementation of pregnant female rats. Addition of 1.25 mg/mL vitamin C to drinking water for duration of gestation. | Monitored collagen and elastin content of uterosacral ligaments by histology staining and subjective assessment. | Increased collagen production in vit.- C-supplemented rats, decreased elastin loss. Implied prevention of pelvic organ prolapse and stress urinary incontinence. | [ |
| Wound healing in guinea pigs following supplementation with moderate and high-dose vit. C. | Dorsal wound healing rate and strength of repair monitored. | Increased vit. C associated with faster wound recovery and strength of skin integrity. Small sample size limited stats. | [ |
| Topical application of vit. C and vit. E-containing cream to nude mice, followed by UV irradiation. | Measured melanocyte differentiation post-irradiation. Change of skin colour—tanning, inflammation. | UVR-induced proliferation and melanogenesis of melanocytes were reduced by vit. C and E. Melanocyte population and confluence reduced when vit. C present. | [ |
| Cultured skin—human keratinocytes and fibroblasts attached to collagen-glycosamino-glycan substrates, incubated for five weeks ± 0.1 mM vit. C, and then grafted to athymic mice. | Collagen IV, collagen VII and laminin 5 synthesis, epidermal barrier formation and skin graft take in athymic nude mice. | Increased cell viability and basement membrane development in vitro, better graft ability in vivo. | [ |
| 90-day oral supplementation with a fermented papaya preparation or an antioxidant cocktail (10 mg trans-resveratrol, 60 μg selenium, 10 mg vitamin E, 50 mg vitamin C) in 60 healthy non-smoker males and females aged 40–65 years, all with clinical signs of skin aging. | Skin surface, brown spots, skin evenness, skin moisture, elasticity (face), lipid peroxidation, superoxide dismutase levels, nitric oxide (NO) generation, and the expression levels of key genes (outer forearm sample). | Improved skin elasticity, moisture and antioxidant capacity with both fermented papaya and antioxidant cocktail. Increased effect of papaya extract and on gene expression. No baseline measures in study population. Antioxidant components of the fermented papaya unknown and direct link with vit. C not available. | [ |
| Intervention with 47 men aged 30–45 given oral supplement of 54 mg or 22 mg of vit. C, 28 mg tomato extract, 27 mg grape seed extract, 210 mg of marine complex, 4 mg zinc gluconate for 180 days. | Subjective assessment of appearance and objective measures of collagen and elastin (histology and measurement in biopsy material). | Improvement in erythema, hydration, radiance, and overall appearance. Decreased intensity of general skin spots, UV spots, and brown spots, improved skin texture and appearance of pores. Increased collagen (43%–57%) and elastin (20%–31%). | [ |
| Supplementation of 33 healthy men and women (aged 22–50), with placebo, 100 mg vit. C or 180 mg vit. C daily for four weeks. | EPR measurement of TEMPO scavenging in skin on arm. Raman resonance spectroscopy for skin carotenoids. | Improved oxygen radical scavenging with vit. C supplementation, dose dependency indicated and rapid response (obvious within two weeks). | [ |
| Three month supplementation of 12 males and six females (21–77 y) with 2 g vit. C and 1000 IU D-alpha-tocopherol. | Measured blood vitamin levels before and after, skin resilience to UVB, detection of DNA crosslinks in skin biopsy. | Serum vit. C and vit. E doubled during intervention (implies sub-saturation at baseline). Minimal erythema dose increased with supplementation, DNA damage halved. | [ |
| Investigation of antioxidant capacity in human skin before and after UV irradiation; effect of supplementation with 500 mg vit. C per day. | Measurement of erythema and antioxidant levels following UVB irradiation. | Vit. C and E levels increased, but levels not realistic (plasma vit. C 21 µM before and 26 µM after 500 mg daily). Skin MDA and glutathione content lowered, no effect on MED. | [ |
| Topical application of vit. C cream in advance of application of hair dye product p-phenylenediamine. | Visual assessment of allergic reaction following patch application on volunteer skin (on back). | Decreased or ablation of dermatitis and allergic response due to local antioxidant action of vit. C in cream. | [ |
| Clinical study applying vit. C in liposomes to human skin (abdomen), then exposure to UV irradiation. | Measured penetration through skin layers, delivery of vit. C, loss of Trolox, TNFalpha and Il-1beta. | Increased vit. C levels in epidermis and dermis with liposomes. Protection against UV increased over liposomes alone. | [ |
| Microneedle skin patches to deliver vit. C into the skin assessed on areas of slight wrinkle formation (around eyes). | Global Photodamage Score by visual inspection. Skin replica analysis and skin assessment by visiometer. | Slightly improved photodamage score and lessening of wrinkles after 12 weeks of treatment with vit. C-loaded patches. | [ |
| Vit. C-based solution containing Rosa moschata oil rich in vitamins A, C, E, essential fatty acids /placebo moisturizer cream applied to facial skin of 60 healthy female subjects for 40–60 days. | Ultrasound monitoring thickness of the epidermis and dermis, and low (LEP), medium (MEP), high echogenic pixels (HEP), reflecting hydration, inflammatory processes, elastin and collagen degeneration (LEP), and structure of collagen, elastin and microfibrils (MEP and LEP). | Data suggest epidermis but not the dermis increased in thickness. Increase in MEP and HEP (collagen and elastin synthesis) and decreased LEP (inflammation and collagen degeneration). No vit. C status measurements in skin of individuals. | [ |
| In vivo study with 30 healthy adults. Protective effect of SPF30 sunscreen with and without anti-oxidants (vit. E, grape seed extract, ubiquinone and vit. C) against Infra-Red A irradiation on previously unexposed skin (buttock). | Skin biopsy analysis; mRNA and RT-PCR for matrix metalloprotein-1 (MMP-1) expression 24 h post irradiation. | Sunscreen plus antioxidants protected skin against MMP-1 increase, sunscreen alone did not. No indication of levels of antioxidants, or whether they were able to penetrate into skin layers. Multi-component antioxidant mix. | [ |
| In vivo study of 15 healthy adults. Protective effect of vitamin C mixtures (vit. C, vit. E, ferulic acid OR vitamin C, phoretin, ferulic acid) on ozone exposure on forearms. | Skin biopsy analysis; 4-HNE and 8-iso prostaglandin levels, immunofluorescence for NF-kB p65, cyclooxygenase-2, matrix metalloprotein-9 (MMP-9), type III collagen. After 5 days of 0.8 ppm ozone for 3h/d. | Vitamin C mixture reduced ozone induced elevation in lipid peroxidation products, NF-kB p65, cyclooxygenase-2 expression and completely prevented MMP-9 induction by ozone. No indication of levels of antioxidants, or whether they were able to penetrate into skin layers. Multi-component antioxidant mix. | [ |
| Test of topical silicone gel with vit. C on scar formation in a population of 80 Asian people. Gel applied for six months after operation. | Scar formation monitored by modified Vancouver Scar Scale (VSS) as well as erythema and melanin indices by spectrophotometer. | Vit. C decreased scar elevation and erythema, decreased melanin index. Improved wound healing (stitch removal). | [ |