Hao Liang1, Xiao-Bing Zhang, Yifan Lv, Liang Gong, Ruowen Wang, Xiaoyan Zhu, Ronghua Yang, Weihong Tan. 1. Molecular Science and Biomedicine Laboratory, State Key Laboratory of Chemo/Bio-Sensing and Chemometrics, College of Chemistry and Chemical Engineering, College of Biology, Collaborative Innovation Center of Molecular Engineering for Theranostics, Hunan University , Changsha, Hunan 410082, China.
Abstract
CONSPECTUS: DNA performs a vital function as a carrier of genetic code, but in the field of nanotechnology, DNA molecules can catalyze chemical reactions in the cell, that is, DNAzymes, or bind with target-specific ligands, that is, aptamers. These functional DNAs with different modifications have been developed for sensing, imaging, and therapeutic systems. Thus, functional DNAs hold great promise for future applications in nanotechnology and bioanalysis. However, these functional DNAs face challenges, especially in the field of biomedicine. For example, functional DNAs typically require the use of cationic transfection reagents to realize cellular uptake. Such reagents enter the cells, increasing the difficulty of performing bioassays in vivo and potentially damaging the cell's nucleus. To address this obstacle, nanomaterials, such as metallic, carbon, silica, or magnetic materials, have been utilized as DNA carriers or assistants. In this Account, we describe selected examples of functional DNA-containing nanomaterials and their applications from our recent research and those of others. As models, we have chosen to highlight DNA/nanomaterial complexes consisting of gold nanoparticles, graphene oxides, and aptamer-micelles, and we illustrate the potential of such complexes in biosensing, imaging, and medical diagnostics. Under proper conditions, multiple ligand-receptor interactions, decreased steric hindrance, and increased surface roughness can be achieved from a high density of DNA that is bound to the surface of nanomaterials, resulting in a higher affinity for complementary DNA and other targets. In addition, this high density of DNA causes a high local salt concentration and negative charge density, which can prevent DNA degradation. For example, DNAzymes assembled on gold nanoparticles can effectively catalyze chemical reactions even in living cells. And it has been confirmed that DNA-nanomaterial complexes can enter cells more easily than free single-stranded DNA. Nanomaterials can be designed and synthesized in needed sizes and shapes, and they possess unique chemical and physical properties, which make them useful as DNA carriers or assistants, excellent signal reporters, transducers, and amplifiers. When nanomaterials are combined with functional DNAs to create novel assay platforms, highly sensitive biosensing and high-resolution imaging result. For example, gold nanoparticles and graphene oxides can quench fluorescence efficiently to achieve low background and effectively increase the signal-to-background ratio. Meanwhile, gold nanoparticles themselves can be colorimetric reporters because of their different optical absorptions between monodispersion and aggregation. DNA self-assembled nanomaterials contain several properties of both DNA and nanomaterials. Compared with DNA-nanomaterial complexes, DNA self-assembled nanomaterials more closely resemble living beings, and therefore they have lower cytotoxicity at high concentrations. Functional DNA self-assemblies also have high density of DNA for multivalent reaction and three-dimensional nanostructures for cell uptake. Now and in the future, we envision the use of DNA bases in making designer molecules for many challenging applications confronting chemists. With the further development of artificial DNA bases using smart organic synthesis, DNA macromolecules based on elegant molecular assembly approaches are expected to achieve great diversity, additional versatility, and advanced functions.
CONSPECTUS: DNA performs a vital function as a carrier of genetic code, but in the field of nanotechnology, DNA molecules can catalyze chemical reactions in the cell, that is, DNAzymes, or bind with target-specific ligands, that is, aptamers. These functional DNAs with different modifications have been developed for sensing, imaging, and therapeutic systems. Thus, functional DNAs hold great promise for future applications in nanotechnology and bioanalysis. However, these functional DNAs face challenges, especially in the field of biomedicine. For example, functional DNAs typically require the use of cationic transfection reagents to realize cellular uptake. Such reagents enter the cells, increasing the difficulty of performing bioassays in vivo and potentially damaging the cell's nucleus. To address this obstacle, nanomaterials, such as metallic, carbon, silica, or magnetic materials, have been utilized as DNA carriers or assistants. In this Account, we describe selected examples of functional DNA-containing nanomaterials and their applications from our recent research and those of others. As models, we have chosen to highlight DNA/nanomaterial complexes consisting of gold nanoparticles, graphene oxides, and aptamer-micelles, and we illustrate the potential of such complexes in biosensing, imaging, and medical diagnostics. Under proper conditions, multiple ligand-receptor interactions, decreased steric hindrance, and increased surface roughness can be achieved from a high density of DNA that is bound to the surface of nanomaterials, resulting in a higher affinity for complementary DNA and other targets. In addition, this high density of DNA causes a high local salt concentration and negative charge density, which can prevent DNA degradation. For example, DNAzymes assembled on gold nanoparticles can effectively catalyze chemical reactions even in living cells. And it has been confirmed that DNA-nanomaterial complexes can enter cells more easily than free single-stranded DNA. Nanomaterials can be designed and synthesized in needed sizes and shapes, and they possess unique chemical and physical properties, which make them useful as DNA carriers or assistants, excellent signal reporters, transducers, and amplifiers. When nanomaterials are combined with functional DNAs to create novel assay platforms, highly sensitive biosensing and high-resolution imaging result. For example, gold nanoparticles and graphene oxides can quench fluorescence efficiently to achieve low background and effectively increase the signal-to-background ratio. Meanwhile, gold nanoparticles themselves can be colorimetric reporters because of their different optical absorptions between monodispersion and aggregation. DNA self-assembled nanomaterials contain several properties of both DNA and nanomaterials. Compared with DNA-nanomaterial complexes, DNA self-assembled nanomaterials more closely resemble living beings, and therefore they have lower cytotoxicity at high concentrations. Functional DNA self-assemblies also have high density of DNA for multivalent reaction and three-dimensional nanostructures for cell uptake. Now and in the future, we envision the use of DNA bases in making designer molecules for many challenging applications confronting chemists. With the further development of artificial DNA bases using smart organic synthesis, DNA macromolecules based on elegant molecular assembly approaches are expected to achieve great diversity, additional versatility, and advanced functions.
Traditionally, DNA is
a carrier of genetic information, but functional DNAs are also able
to bind specifically with various targets (DNA aptamers) and possess
catalytic activity (DNAzymes) with the ability to regulate gene expression.[1] Such functional DNAs can be designed and selected in vitro, enabling them to play important roles in biological
analysis and clinical diagnostics.Aptamers are single-stranded
oligonucleotides that possess high stability and high affinity and
selectivity for specific targets. Aptamers can be generated through
a technology termed “systematic evolution of ligands by exponential
enrichment” (SELEX). Immense combinatorial libraries that contain
trillions of different sequences are used to select different aptamers
toward a variety of targets, including metal ions, metabolites, proteins,
and even whole cells.[2] The chemical nature
of aptamers is based on the nucleic acid molecule, affording many
distinct advantages in bioapplications, such as small size, nontoxicity,
ease of synthesis and chemical modification with various functional
groups, and facile surface immobilization.[3] In addition, aptamers can be synthesized in vitro through mature solid state synthesis technology, eliminating the
need for an animal source. All of these unique properties suggest
that aptamers are superior to other molecular recognizers, including
antibodies. In particular, these unique properties make aptamers new
recognition elements in novel biosensors, termed aptasensors, which
can be designed by various sensing strategies suited for almost any
kind of target.[4,5] The flexibility offered by aptamers
also improves innovative biochemical applications through imaging.DNAzymes, also called catalytic DNA or deoxyribozymes, are also
functional DNA molecules selected in vitro. They
can catalyze different kinds of chemical and biological reactions,
including cleavage of nucleic acid substrates,[6] ligation,[7] phosphorylation[8] and porphyrin metalation.[9] The active sites of DNAzymes can distinguish substrates at the atomic
level by short DNA strands. Meanwhile, their backbones are negatively
charged and have a certain flexibility that exposes their bases to
the outside, achieving, in turn, highly efficient catalysis. Thus,
in many sensing platforms, DNAzymes have been implemented for the
amplified detection of nucleic acids[10] and
metal ions.[6,11−13]Despite
the utility of SELEX, the discovery of new functional DNAs is a time-consuming
process. As single-stranded oligonucleotides, the ability of DNAs
to change conformation remains limited, even though functional DNAs,
including aptamers and DNAzymes, require the presentation of many
different conformations in order to generate signals that can be controlled
and monitored. Furthermore, functional DNAs are negatively charged
molecules having low binding affinity with the cell membrane, which
complicates entry into living cells[14,15] and thus limits
applications in biochemical assays and medical diagnostics. In the
past few years, different reformational nanomaterials, such as metallic,
carbon, silica, and magnetic nanomaterials, have been developed to
address these problems. Such nanomaterials enhance the use of DNA
in nucleic acids-based biochemical assays since they possess composition-dependent
chemical and physical properties, including unique optical, electronic,
magnetic, and catalytic properties, and they can be designed and synthesized
in unique sizes and shapes. As a consequence, nanomaterials are able
to act as outstanding signal reporters, transducers, and amplifiers.
Meanwhile, nanomaterials generally have a large surface area and can
be chemically modified, leading to high loading efficiency of cargos,
such as DNAs, drugs, or other molecules, to carry out different functions.[16−18] Furthermore, the unusual biocompatibility and overall structural
robustness of nanomaterials make them powerful candidates as delivery
nanovehicles able to protect nucleic acids against nuclease degradation.[19]In this Account, we will review the achievements
made by our group and others in the application of functional DNA-containing
nanomaterials in bioanalysis and biomedicine.
The Assembly
of Functional DNA and Nanomaterials
Functional DNAs can be
simply assembled on a given nanomaterial using methods such as covalent
binding or π–π stacking. Generally, the nanoarchitecture
of this complex contains a nanomaterial core and a monolayer of functional
DNA. In order to take full advantage of the properties of functional
DNA, analytic conditions need to be optimized in order to reduce steric
hindrance and nonspecific adsorption. For example, the introduction
of spacers, such as short DNA, bovineserum albumin (BSA), and poly(ethylene
glycol) (PEG), can separate functional DNA and cover the blank surfaces
of nanomaterials. Systems based on functional DNA-nanomaterial complexes
not only possess the properties of both the functional DNA and the
nanomaterial but also generate several new features, such as high
affinity between the functional DNA–nanomaterial complex and
target, strong degradation resistance, and high cellular uptake. Such
properties can play a key role in biomedical applications. For instance,
highly efficient self-delivery into cancer cells is the first requirement
for exploring the intracellular environment. One study recently demonstrated
that DNA with a 3D nanostructure could enter cells more easily than
linear DNA strands.[14] In addition, the
formation of a 3D DNA/nanomaterial structure via self-assembly results
in a nanoarchitecture that possesses the properties of both nanomaterials
and DNA at the same time.
Gold Nanomaterials
As the most common and stable metallic nanomaterials, gold nanoparticles
(AuNPs) have attracted much attention over the past decade due to
their many features and properties. First, AuNPs can be synthesized
in a straightforward manner, and their size and shape can be tuned
by changing the parameters during synthesis. Second, AuNPs possess
size-related electronic and optical properties that make them superquenchers
and good colorimetric reporters. Third, AuNPs exhibit good biocompatibility,
high intracellular stability, high DNA-loading capacity, and easy
surface modification. Specifically, the strong interaction between
thiol and gold provides an easy-to-handle and low-cost approach for
AuNP modification.Functional DNA-containing nanostructures
based on the incorporation of AuNPs can result in a synergism between
the functional DNAs and AuNPs. For example, the large surface area
of AuNPs can accommodate a high density of DNA bound to the NP surface,
leading to a higher binding strength for complementary targets than
that of single DNA strands of the same sequence,[20] conditions that are favorable for enhancing the efficiency
of catalytic reactions for DNAzyme cleavage. AuNP–aptamer conjugates
can increase affinity to target analytes through multiple ligand–receptor
interactions, increased surface roughness, and ligand density.[21] Meanwhile, the high local salt concentration
and negatively charged surface of DNA-assembled AuNPs can enhance
the degradation resistance of DNA (Figure 1).[22] Taking advantage of the high density
of DNA on AuNPs, DNA–AuNP conjugates gain more cellular uptake.[23] Recently, the Mirkin group[14] demonstrated that three-dimensional nanostructures of DNA,
termed spherical nucleic acids (SNAs), promote intracellular transport
and possess rapid cellular uptake kinetics. As shown in Figure 2, oligonucleotide dimensionality has a significant
influence on endocytosis. High affinity with biotargets and facile
cellular uptake of DNA-assembled AuNPs make them ideal candidates
for biomedical applications.
Figure 1
Comparison of the degradation rates of molecular
DNA and DNA–AuNP systems. (A) Fluorescence-based progress curves
of the enzyme-catalyzed reaction as a function of time. (B) Double
reciprocal (Lineweaver–Burk) plot of the initial degradation
velocity as a function of DNA-duplex concentration, which is used
to calculate the kinetic parameters of the reaction. Reproduced with
permission from ref (22). Copyright 2008 American Chemical Society.
Figure 2
Effect of oligonucleotide dimensionality on endocytosis. (A) Cy5–ssDNAs
cannot enter C166 cells in amounts detectable by confocal microscopy.
(B) However, with their 3D architecture, Cy5–SNAs that contain
the same total DNA concentration can readily enter cells, starting
from binding to the cell membrane 30 min after incubation to populating
the cytosol 2 h after incubation. (C) Encapsulation of Cy5–ssDNAs
with DharmaFECT, a conventional cationic transfection agent, led to
the tracing of the cell border by Cy5–ssDNAs without significant
intracellular accumulation. (D) Hollow Cy5–SNAs enter cells
with kinetics and degree comparable to Cy5–SNAs. Reproduced
with permission from ref (14). Copyright 2013 National Academy of Sciences.
Comparison of the degradation rates of molecular
DNA and DNA–AuNP systems. (A) Fluorescence-based progress curves
of the enzyme-catalyzed reaction as a function of time. (B) Double
reciprocal (Lineweaver–Burk) plot of the initial degradation
velocity as a function of DNA-duplex concentration, which is used
to calculate the kinetic parameters of the reaction. Reproduced with
permission from ref (22). Copyright 2008 American Chemical Society.Effect of oligonucleotide dimensionality on endocytosis. (A) Cy5–ssDNAs
cannot enter C166 cells in amounts detectable by confocal microscopy.
(B) However, with their 3D architecture, Cy5–SNAs that contain
the same total DNA concentration can readily enter cells, starting
from binding to the cell membrane 30 min after incubation to populating
the cytosol 2 h after incubation. (C) Encapsulation of Cy5–ssDNAs
with DharmaFECT, a conventional cationic transfection agent, led to
the tracing of the cell border by Cy5–ssDNAs without significant
intracellular accumulation. (D) Hollow Cy5–SNAs enter cells
with kinetics and degree comparable to Cy5–SNAs. Reproduced
with permission from ref (14). Copyright 2013 National Academy of Sciences.
Carbon Nanomaterials
Single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) and graphene oxide (GO)
have powerful quenching capability for organic dyes. A variety of
complexes, including DNA strands, can be adsorbed noncovalently onto
the surface of SWNTs and GO by virtue of π–π stacking.
Thus, traditional molecular beacon-based fluorescent systems can be
prepared.[24,25] For SWNTs, in 2008 the Yang group reported
a novel self-assembled SWNT–oligonucleotide complex as an efficient
molecular beacon (MB) and demonstrated that it could be utilized in
recognizing and detecting specific DNA sequences in a single step
in homogeneous solution.[24] They first tested
three different nucleic-acid detection methods based on (i) a conventional
MB (1), (ii) the self-assembled carbon-nanotube complex
of 2 (2–SWNT), and (iii) the self-assembled
carbon-nanotube complex of 3 (3–SWNT)
(Table 1). As shown in Figure 3, it can be seen that the SWNTs provided further fluorescence
quenching for MB 1 but more than 98% quenching for concentrations
of 2, which ranged from 50 to 200 nM in their experiment,
proving that ssDNA bound tightly on SWNTs. The experimental results
summarized in Figure 4 showed a rather large
variation in S/B in these assays because of the different background
signals of the probes. In the same year, the Yang group constructed
a new fluorescent sensor based on a ssDNA–SWNT complex for
the detection of both DNA and protein. Human R-thrombin (Tmb) binding
aptamers were self-assembled on SWNTs to detect Tmb in a fluorescent
assay.[25] All these studies illustrate that
the SWNT–oligonucleotide complexes are excellent and universal
fluorescent probes for bioanalysis.
Table 1
Designs of Probes and Target Oligonucleotides
type
sequence
FAM-labeled-MB (1)a
5′-Dabcyl-CCTAGCTCTAAATCACTATGGTCGCGCTAGG-FAM-3′
FAM-labeled-HP
(2)b
5′-CCTAGCTCTAAATCACTATGGTCGCGCTAGG-FAM-3′
FAM-labeled-LN (3)c
5′-CCTAGCTCTAAATCACTATGGTCGCCGATCC-FAM-3′
pc-DNA (4)d
5′-GCGACCATAGTGATTTAGA-3′
sm-DNA(5)e
5′-GCGACCATACTGATTTAGA-3′
Molecular beacon.
Hairpin-structured
probe.
Linear probe.
Perfectly complementary target.
Single-base mismatched target.
Reproduced
with permission from ref (24). Copyright 2008 American Chemical Society.
Figure 3
Fluorescence emission spectra of 1, 2, and 3 in the absence (continuous
lines) and the presence (dotted lines) of SWNTs. The concentrations
of 1–3 were 50 nM, and excitation
wavelength was at 480 nm. Reproduced with permission from ref (24). Copyright 2008 American
Chemical Society.
Figure 4
Comparisons of the signal-to-background
ratio (S/B) of the fluorescent oligonucleotides generated by their
perfectly complementary target 4. Gray bar: S/B of 1–3 generated by 6-fold excess of 4 in the absence of SWNTs. Black bar: S/B of 1–3 generated by 6-fold excess of 4 in the presence of SWNTs. The concentrations of 1–3 were 50 nM. Excitation was at 480 nm, and emission was monitored
at 520 nm. Reproduced with permission from ref (24). Copyright 2008 American
Chemical Society.
Graphene oxide (GO), a water-soluble
derivative of graphene, possesses advantages such as easy synthesis,
good water dispersibility, and facile surface modification. Most sensing
and imaging systems with DNA/GO complexes are based on the fact that
ssDNA with different lengths and conformations can exhibit different
affinities for GO. For fluorescent assays, a rational design based
on DNA–GO complexes can achieve very low background fluorescence.
Moreover, several studies have suggested that GO can be an excellent
vehicle and can also protect DNA on its surface, making GO favorable
for efficient delivery of aptamers into living cells to carry out in situ detection.[26]Molecular beacon.Hairpin-structured
probe.Linear probe.Perfectly complementary target.Single-base mismatched target.Reproduced
with permission from ref (24). Copyright 2008 American Chemical Society.Fluorescence emission spectra of 1, 2, and 3 in the absence (continuous
lines) and the presence (dotted lines) of SWNTs. The concentrations
of 1–3 were 50 nM, and excitation
wavelength was at 480 nm. Reproduced with permission from ref (24). Copyright 2008 American
Chemical Society.Comparisons of the signal-to-background
ratio (S/B) of the fluorescent oligonucleotides generated by their
perfectly complementary target 4. Gray bar: S/B of 1–3 generated by 6-fold excess of 4 in the absence of SWNTs. Black bar: S/B of 1–3 generated by 6-fold excess of 4 in the presence of SWNTs. The concentrations of 1–3 were 50 nM. Excitation was at 480 nm, and emission was monitored
at 520 nm. Reproduced with permission from ref (24). Copyright 2008 American
Chemical Society.
Magnetic
Nanomaterials
In recent years, researchers have developed
various types of magnetic nanoparticles (MNPs). By investigating their
properties and behaviors, the application of MNPs in many important
areas can be improved, including drug delivery, hyperthermia, magnetic
resonance imaging (MRI), tissue engineering and repair, biosensing,
biochemical separation, and bioanalysis. One of the most outstanding
aspects of magnetic nanoparticles is their high-throughput separation
capabilities, which can be combined with aptamers to realize the capture
and concentration of cancer cells in one assay. To accomplish this,
researchers often integrate MNPs with other nanoparticles to construct
multifunctional systems for different applications. Most MNP systems
utilize inorganic nanocrystals ranging from metals and alloys to metal
oxides as their magnetic cores. In order to ensure their tolerance
and biocompatibility, as well as specific localization at the biological
target site, the surface of MNPs can be coated with a few atomic layers
of a metal oxide, such as silica, or inorganic metal, such as gold,
making MNPs suitable for further functionalization by the attachment
of various bioactive molecules.
Functional
DNA Self-Assembled Nanomaterials
DNA is naturally water-soluble
and biocompatible. Moreover, it is relatively simple to synthesize
DNA with a commercial synthesizer. Recently, DNA has emerged as a
favorable material for constructing DNA nanostructures with promising
applications in biomedicine and biotechnology. For functional DNAs,
multivalent interaction can result in better affinity and selectivity
in contrast to monovalent interaction in the design of high-performance
ligands. In 2008, we assembled two thrombin-binding aptamers together,
and the aptamer assembly proved to be a high-performance inhibitor
for treating various diseases related to blood clotting disorders
under optimized conditions.[27] Bivalent
interaction of the aptamer assembly with thrombin, which increases
overall binding affinity, is proposed as the mechanism for the enhanced
inhibition. The binding affinity is directly related to kinetic parameters,
such as kon′ and koff′. As demonstrated
in Figure 5, the increased thrombin inhibition
potency of the aptamer assembly originates from the kinetic changes
caused by cooperative binding.
Figure 5
Comparison of binding kinetics. (a) Cartoon to describe kon′ measurement. (b) Cartoon to describe koff′ measurement.
(c) Real-time fluorescence signal change of kon′ measurement.
After thrombin was added, each sample mixture showed fluorescence
decay. The decreasing rate was comparable in both cases. According
to the calculation of the initial reaction rate, Bi-8S (bivalent nucleic
acid candidate, Bi-xS, where x is
the number of spacer bases linking two aptamers) exhibited a kon′ 1.2 times faster than that of 15Apt, a thrombin aptamer 15 bases
long. (d) Real-time fluorescence signal change of koff′ measurement. Free 15Apt molecular beacon aptamer (MBA, green line)
showed very rapid hybridization kinetics with its target DNA. Thrombin-bound
15Apt MBA (blue) showed slower hybridization kinetics compared with
the free form. Interestingly, thrombin-bound Bi-8S MBA (red) showed
a dissociation rate that was 51.7 times slower. The ka′ of
the 15Apt domain of Bi-8S is about 62 times stronger than that of
free 15Apt. Reproduced with permission from ref (27). Copyright 2008 National
Academy of Sciences.
Inspired by amphiphilic block
copolymers, which can self-assemble into different morphologies, the
copolymer that contains a hydrophilic DNA segment and a hydrophobic
organic polymer unit can form a DNA micelle under certain conditions.
Compared with DNA-conjugated nanoparticles, DNA micelles have no inorganic
cores, which would be cytotoxic at high concentrations, and the time
required to synthesize DNA micelles can generally be abbreviated.
In order to endow DNA micelles with more applicable properties and
functions, we chose an aptamer to replace general DNA and conjugated
it with a hydrophobic lipid tail. In 2010, we demonstrated that the
aptamers in aptamer–micelle conjugates could still recognize
their specific targets.[28] Figure 6 shows that aptamer TDO5 was unable to bind with
Ramos cells at physiological temperature. However, the TDO5–micelle
conjugate displayed high affinity and selectivity for its target Ramos
cells, as a result of densely packed aptamers that could enhance affinity
for the target.
Figure 6
(A) Schematic illustration of aptamer–micelle formation. (B)
Flow cytometric assay to monitor the binding of free TDO5 (250 nM)
with Ramos cells (target cells) and HL60 (control cells) at 37 °C
for 5 min. The blue and black curves represent the background binding
of unselected DNA library or library–micelle. The purple and
red curves represent the binding of TDO5 or TDO5–micelle. Reproduced
with permission from ref (28). Copyright 2010 National Academy of Sciences.
Instead of conventionally used short DNA, long
DNA building blocks generated via rolling circle replication (RCR)
can also form nanoarchitectures, such as DNA nanoflowers (NFs). RCR
is an isothermal enzymatic reaction involving the replication of many
circular genomic DNAs. These assemblies display higher biostability
than complexes composed of many different DNA strands with sophisticated
designs. The dense DNA packaging in NFs presumably affords the ability
to resist nuclease degradation, denaturation, or dissociation at extremely
low concentration.Comparison of binding kinetics. (a) Cartoon to describe kon′ measurement. (b) Cartoon to describe koff′ measurement.
(c) Real-time fluorescence signal change of kon′ measurement.
After thrombin was added, each sample mixture showed fluorescence
decay. The decreasing rate was comparable in both cases. According
to the calculation of the initial reaction rate, Bi-8S (bivalent nucleic
acid candidate, Bi-xS, where x is
the number of spacer bases linking two aptamers) exhibited a kon′ 1.2 times faster than that of 15Apt, a thrombin aptamer 15 bases
long. (d) Real-time fluorescence signal change of koff′ measurement. Free 15Apt molecular beacon aptamer (MBA, green line)
showed very rapid hybridization kinetics with its target DNA. Thrombin-bound
15Apt MBA (blue) showed slower hybridization kinetics compared with
the free form. Interestingly, thrombin-bound Bi-8S MBA (red) showed
a dissociation rate that was 51.7 times slower. The ka′ of
the 15Apt domain of Bi-8S is about 62 times stronger than that of
free 15Apt. Reproduced with permission from ref (27). Copyright 2008 National
Academy of Sciences.(A) Schematic illustration of aptamer–micelle formation. (B)
Flow cytometric assay to monitor the binding of free TDO5 (250 nM)
with Ramos cells (target cells) and HL60 (control cells) at 37 °C
for 5 min. The blue and black curves represent the background binding
of unselected DNA library or library–micelle. The purple and
red curves represent the binding of TDO5 or TDO5–micelle. Reproduced
with permission from ref (28). Copyright 2010 National Academy of Sciences.
Applications in Biosensing,
Imaging, Drug Delivery, and Therapy
Because of the advantages
of functional DNA-containing nanomaterials, as discussed above, multifunctional
systems can be constructed to improve biomedical applications, including
biosensing, imaging, drug delivery, and clinical therapy. For example,
in fluorescent assays, aptamers can serve as recognition moieties
and control the distance between quenchers, such as AuNPs and GO,
and fluorophores via their conformational changes. Thus, two types
of fluorescent sensors can be designed. If fluorescence is quenched
in the absence of target but restored in the presence of target, the
sensor is termed “turn-on”.[14,25,26] On the other hand, if fluorescence is activated
in the absence of targets but quenched in their presence, the sensor
is termed “turn-off”. Fluorescence “turn-off”
sensors may report false positive results caused by other quenchers
in practical samples and are undesirable for practical analytical
applications.
Functional DNA-Assembled Gold Nanomaterials
AuNP–DNA conjugates are stable in serum and can enter cells
without transfection reagents. Based on their special electronic properties,
AuNPs display “superquenching” ability for fluorescence
via long-range resonance energy transfer.[29] The Mirkin group reported aptamer–AuNP complexes, termed
aptamer nanoflares, and detected intracellular ATP levels.[30] DNA polymers assembled on AuNPs can be variously
designed, for example by labeling with imaging fluorescent tags or
the simultaneous loading of recognition elements and anticancer drugs.[31] The AuNP–DNA conjugates show high stability
and good biocompatibility, and the size of the complex can be controlled
by changing the length of the self-assembled DNA biopolymer shell,
which might provide a new and highly effective means for transporting
cargos. Recently, the Lu group developed a novel DNAzyme–gold
nanoparticle probe, which, for the first time, could be successfully
applied to detect target analytes in living cells.[32] The 39E DNAzyme, which has exceptional selectivity and
sensitivity for the uranyl ion (UO22+), was
chosen as an initial demonstration, and AuNP was chosen to be the
carrier for cellular delivery of the DNAzyme. The assembly strategy
of this novel system is shown in Figure 7.
In the presence of uranyl, cleavage of the fluorophore-labeled substrate
strand is catalyzed by DNAzyme. The shorter product strand labeled
with Cy3 is released, and fluorescence is simultaneously recovered.
Subsequently, this DNAzyme–AuNP probe was demonstrated to easily
enter cells and serve as a metal ion sensor in the cellular environment.
Figure 7
Design
of a fluorescent DNAzyme immobilized on AuNPs as a selective probe
of uranyl inside live cells. Reproduced with permission from ref (32). Copyright 2013 American
Chemical Society.
Design
of a fluorescent DNAzyme immobilized on AuNPs as a selective probe
of uranyl inside live cells. Reproduced with permission from ref (32). Copyright 2013 American
Chemical Society.Owing to their remarkable
optical properties, AuNPs can also be used as brilliant colorimetric
reporters.[33] In terms of color changes
resulting from the aggregation of AuNPs, aptamer-assembled AuNPs have
provided more efficient biosensors for proteins and cancer cells.
We have developed a colorimetric assay for the direct detection of
diseased cells based on cancer cell aptamer-conjugated AuNPs (ACGNPs).[34] Figure 8 shows ACGNPs
bound to target cells with high specificity, despite the occurrence
of some nonspecific binding and nonbinding, neither of which could
dramatically alter the color of the assay solution as a consequence
of the negligible increase in absorption and scattering of ACGNPs.
These results implied that this colorimetric approach was very sensitive
for the detection of target cancer cells and that ACGNPs could provide
a direct visualization of cancer cells by assembling on a cell membrane
surface to induce spectral changes.
Figure 8
Schematic representation
of the ACGNP-based colorimetric assay. Reproduced with permission
from ref (34). Copyright
2008 American Chemical Society.
By change of the aspect ratio, gold nanoparticles may become
nanorods, which present strong absorption in the near-infrared region.
Taking advantage of this phenomenon, gold nanorods (AuNRs) are emerging
as efficient photothermal therapy (PTT) nanomaterials.[35−37] Compared with photothermal therapy alone, a combinatorial PTT/photodynamic
therapy (PDT) approach can enhance therapeutic efficacy.[36] Figure 9 shows the integration
of DNA–AuNRs with a photosensitizer for use in multimodal cancer
therapy. In order to manipulate the quenching and recovery of photosensitizer
fluorescence, the aptamer, poly T, and 8bt-cDNA were designed for
the probes, which were assembled on AuNRs, thus achieving controlled
singlet oxygen generation (SOG) for PDT. The strategy of utilizing
a highly selective aptamer combined with the synergistic effect of
PTT and PDT promises to be a more efficient therapeutic regimen against
cancer cells than nonspecific methods using either PTT or PDT alone.
Figure 9
Schematic representation of aptamer switch
probe (ASP)–photosensitizer–AuNRs for PTT and PDT. Reproduced
with permission from ref (36). Copyright 2012 American Chemical Society.
Schematic representation
of the ACGNP-based colorimetric assay. Reproduced with permission
from ref (34). Copyright
2008 American Chemical Society.Schematic representation of aptamer switch
probe (ASP)–photosensitizer–AuNRs for PTT and PDT. Reproduced
with permission from ref (36). Copyright 2012 American Chemical Society.
Functional DNA-Assembled
Carbon Nanomaterials
Among the various properties of single-walled
carbon nanotubes (SWNT) and GO, the construction of sensitive systems
for biosensing and imaging takes advantage of their excellent fluorescence
quenching. In 2011, we demonstrated that SWNTs could be an excellent
nanoquencher for lanthanide ion compounds.[38] We first demonstrated the feasibility of this hypothesis and then
constructed a label-free and time-resolved luminescence sensing platform
for the detection of protein in complex biological fluids. The sensing
approach was based on the noncovalent assembly of SWNTs and aptamers,
the quenching ability of the SWNT complex for rare-earth chelates,
and the restoration of the luminescence signal in the presence of
target. Furthermore, the long lifetime of Eu3+ luminescence
made it favorable for discriminating background signal in complex
biological samples. With such unique properties, this time-resolved
luminescence assay approach could achieve a low limit of detection
under conditions of high autofluorescence without sample pretreatment.An intracellular ATP probe based on an aptamer/graphene oxide nanocomplex
has been used to monitor graphene in living cells and probe ATP in situ.[26] However, because of
the fetal bovine serum (FBS) used in culture medium and the presence
of intracellular proteins, some nonspecific desorption can occur.
To overcome this problem, an ATP aptamer molecular beacon (AAMB) has
been used to substitute for the ATP aptamer, as reported by the Li
group. We have also constructed an internal reference platform for
a semiquantitative assay for intracellular ATP imaging.
Functional DNA-Assembled Magnetic Nanomaterials
MNPs
can enhance the magnetic resonance (MR) signal of protons from surrounding
water molecules.[39] Aggregation of aptamer-conjugated
MNPs is caused by their binding to target cells, which induces the
coupling of magnetic spin moments and generates strong local magnetic
fields. Such strong local magnetic fields lead to inhomogeneities
that accelerate the spin-dephasing of adjacent water protons. In response,
the spin–spin relaxation time (T2) of the surrounding water protons correspondingly decreases. Thus,
aggregation of MNPs can be detected by ΔT2 changes. Capitalizing on this phenomenon, we have developed
magnetic relaxation switches (MRSw) for the detection of specific
targets. Figure 10 illustrates how aptamer-conjugated
magnetic nanoparticles (ACMNPs) can reversibly self-assemble when
binding to the same targets.[40] The dense
packing of aptamers on ACMNPs creates a multivalent effect for target
binding that results in high sensitivity and specificity of this system
in complex biological systems, including serum, plasma, and whole
blood. Furthermore, by use of an array of ACMNPs, recognition patterns
were generated for multiple types of cancer cells, thus creating a
cellular molecular profile that allows not only the identification
of cancer cells, but also the ability to differentiate between cancer
and normal cells.
Figure 10
Schematic illustration
of a magnetic nanosensor used for cancer cell detection and pattern
recognition. (a) The magnetic nanoparticles conjugated with aptamers
have highly specific binding to their target cells. Without target
cells, ACMNPs are well dispersed, resulting in a high T2 of surrounding water protons. The addition of target
cells leads to the aggregation of magnetic nanoparticles, decreasing
the T2 of adjacent water protons. (b)
Distinct recognition patterns generated for various cell lines with
different receptor expression levels using the magnetic nanosensor.
The cell line with the most abundant (A cell) receptors gives the
largest ΔT2, followed by the cell
line with the medium number of receptors (B cell), and the smallest
ΔT2 was obtained for the cell line
with the lowest receptor expression level (C cell). Reproduced with
permission from ref (40). Copyright 2012 American Chemical Society.
MNPs can be useful alternatives to porous
silica nanoparticles as nanovehicles for drug delivery.[41] By means of acid etching, a porous hollow magnetite
nanoparticle (PHMNP) can be generated and loaded with the anticancer
drug doxorubicin (DOX) in its hollow interior as a carrier. In this
system, aptamers were used as targeting moieties. However, instead
of straightforward modification onto the surface of PHMNPs, a heterobiofunctional
PEG ligand with a catechol group on one end and a carboxyl group on
the other end served as a linker assembled onto the surface of PHMNPs
for conjugation with special aptamers. This nanostructure was named
as a smart multifunctional nanostructure (SMN) and was successfully
utilized for targeted chemotherapy and magnetic resonance imaging
(MRI). The acidic environment of lysosomes facilitated the release
of DOX from the acid-labile pores of SMNs, and the release of DOX
enabled efficient killing of target cancer cells.Schematic illustration
of a magnetic nanosensor used for cancer cell detection and pattern
recognition. (a) The magnetic nanoparticles conjugated with aptamers
have highly specific binding to their target cells. Without target
cells, ACMNPs are well dispersed, resulting in a high T2 of surrounding water protons. The addition of target
cells leads to the aggregation of magnetic nanoparticles, decreasing
the T2 of adjacent water protons. (b)
Distinct recognition patterns generated for various cell lines with
different receptor expression levels using the magnetic nanosensor.
The cell line with the most abundant (A cell) receptors gives the
largest ΔT2, followed by the cell
line with the medium number of receptors (B cell), and the smallest
ΔT2 was obtained for the cell line
with the lowest receptor expression level (C cell). Reproduced with
permission from ref (40). Copyright 2012 American Chemical Society.
Functional DNA Self-Assembled Nanomaterials
Functional DNA self-assembled nanomaterials, as distinct from the
above-mentioned complexes, need no inorganic scaffold to form a 3D
nanostructure. Combining DNA hybridization with a cross-linking reaction,
we constructed a multifunctional and programmable aptamer nanoassembly
structure.[42] In Figure 11, an X-shaped core connector came from predesigned base-pair
hybridization of four single-stranded DNAs, and three Y-shaped DNA
functional domains were designed to link with the core connector.
Targeting aptamers and acrydite-groups could be incorporated in different
domains, as well as intercalated anticancer drugs, therapeutic antisense
oligonucleotides, or other functional groups. Thus, each nanoassembly
building unit was composed of one core connector and three functional
domains. The acrydite-modified building units were further photo-cross-linked
to form different nanostructures with controllable diameters. These
nanostructures exhibited several remarkable features: facile modular
design, facile assembly and preparation, high programmability, excellent
biostability and biocompatibility, and selective recognition and transportation.
Figure 11
Schematic
illustration of the multifunctional self-assembled nanoassembly building
units and photo-cross-linked nanoassembly structure. Reproduced with
permission from ref (42). Copyright 2013 American Chemical Society.
Schematic
illustration of the multifunctional self-assembled nanoassembly building
units and photo-cross-linked nanoassembly structure. Reproduced with
permission from ref (42). Copyright 2013 American Chemical Society.Without Watson–Crick base-pairing, DNA can also grow
together to form elongated DNA building blocks via liquid crystallization
and dense packaging. Primer, circular template, and DNA polymerase
participate in a DNA replication reaction to generate elongated DNA.
Consequently, DNA NFs based on RCR completely consisted of deoxynucleotides,
and their sizes were readily tunable over a wide range by simply adjusting
such parameters as assembly time and template sequences. The circular
template in our study was integrated with an antisense oligonucleotide
aptamer sequence and drug loading sites. The resultant multifunctional
NFs can be valuable tools for the recognition of targets and the simultaneous
delivery of dyes and drugs.[43]Functional
DNA–micelles contain both hydrophilic and hydrophobic segments
that self-assemble under certain conditions. Compared with aptamer-assembled
AuNP and aptamer-GO complexes, respectively, the synthesis of aptamer–micelles
is less time-consuming and produces fewer false positive signals.
Recently, we reported an aptamer–micelle system for intracellular
molecule detection.[44] An aptamer was designed
as a molecular beacon (MB) able to quench and restore fluorescence,
as shown in Figure 12. This MB was modified
with a lipid tail to form the nanostructure of micelle flares. In
the presence of ATP, the conformation of the MB containing the ATP
aptamer was altered, leading to the restoration of fluorescence. Therefore,
intracellular detection and imaging of ATP could be achieved in real
time.
Figure 12
Working principle of switchable aptamer–micelle flares. Reproduced
with permission from ref (44). Copyright 2013 American Chemical Society.
Working principle of switchable aptamer–micelle flares. Reproduced
with permission from ref (44). Copyright 2013 American Chemical Society.
Future Perspectives
Combining the unique properties of both DNAs and such classical nanomaterials
as AuNPs or GOs, functional DNA-containing nanomaterials can serve
as smart biosensing, imaging, and therapy systems. Recent advances
in functional DNA nanotechnology have shown the versatility and tremendous
potential of functional DNA–nanomaterial complexes. However,
some challenges lie ahead. For example, compared with buffer solutions,
the intracellular environment is obviously much more complex. As such,
nanomaterials used as scaffolding may adsorb some nontarget organic
molecules or biomolecules in living cells, resulting in false signals.
To address this issue, existing functional DNA-containing nanomaterials
require more artful modifications to optimize their 3D nanostructures
and surfaces, for example, by introducing spacers into the scaffold
and changing the charge on the nanomaterial’s surface.Meanwhile, researchers are working on the development of composite
nanomaterials that possess remarkable properties, but with very low
biological toxicity, for various bioassays. From a natural perspective,
DNA self-assemblies, such as DNA–micelles and DNA nanoflowers,
may be ideal platforms for intracellular assays. Moreover, by smart
organic synthesis, artificial DNA bases would enrich this field with
innovative properties and can also give rise to novel choreographed
approaches of functional DNA self-assembly. Multimodality and clinical
practicality are trends in the development of functional DNA-containing
nanomaterial systems of the future, with more attention on improving
their sensing capabilities for environmental monitoring, medical diagnostics,
and therapeutics.
Authors: Suwussa Bamrungsap; Tao Chen; Mohammed Ibrahim Shukoor; Zhuo Chen; Kwame Sefah; Yan Chen; Weihong Tan Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2012-04-06 Impact factor: 15.881
Authors: Chung Hang J Choi; Liangliang Hao; Suguna P Narayan; Evelyn Auyeung; Chad A Mirkin Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2013-04-23 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Cuichen Wu; Tao Chen; Da Han; Mingxu You; Lu Peng; Sena Cansiz; Guizhi Zhu; Chunmei Li; Xiangling Xiong; Elizabeth Jimenez; Chaoyong James Yang; Weihong Tan Journal: ACS Nano Date: 2013-06-14 Impact factor: 15.881
Authors: Brandon Roark; Jenna A Tan; Anna Ivanina; Morgan Chandler; Jose Castaneda; Ho Shin Kim; Shriram Jawahar; Mathias Viard; Strahinja Talic; Kristin L Wustholz; Yaroslava G Yingling; Marcus Jones; Kirill A Afonin Journal: ACS Sens Date: 2016-10-31 Impact factor: 7.711
Authors: Lorena Parlea; Anu Puri; Wojciech Kasprzak; Eckart Bindewald; Paul Zakrevsky; Emily Satterwhite; Kenya Joseph; Kirill A Afonin; Bruce A Shapiro Journal: ACS Comb Sci Date: 2016-08-26 Impact factor: 3.784