Marie Moulton1,2, Katie Lappé1,3, Sonja E Raaum1,4, Caroline K Milne1,5, Candace J Chow1,6. 1. All authors are with the University of Utah School of Medicine. 2. is Internal Medicine Chief Medical Resident, Department of Internal Medicine. 3. is Associate Professor, Department of Internal Medicine. 4. is Assistant Professor, Department of Internal Medicine. 5. is Professor, Department of Internal Medicine. 6. is Assistant Professor, Internal Medicine, and Director of Education Research.
Abstract
Background: The personal statement is an integral part of a residency application but little guidance exists for medical students about what content to include. Objective: We use the framework of isomorphism, the process by which institutions model themselves after one another, to understand what internal medicine program directors (PDs) and associate program directors (APDs) recommend be included in the personal statement and how programs use personal statements in their selection of applicants to interview and rank. Methods: Semi-structured phone interviews were conducted between August and October 2020 with 13 academic PDs and APDs, who were selected for participation based on program size and geographic location. Interviews were recorded, transcribed, and coded using content analysis. Results: Effective personal statements should be well-written, present unique information, and demonstrate fit with a residency program. PDs and APDs recommended against expressing lack of interest in a program or highlighting negative personal characteristics. PDs and APDs used personal statements to distinguish between applicants and noted that personal statements help programs form an impression of the applicant. Consensus among PDs and APDs about what personal statements should include and how they are used indicates that isomorphism influences the match process. Conclusions: Our study found that the personal statement is a valued part of the residency application when it includes unique attributes and reveals personal values that align with that of the program. Additionally, PDs and APDs noted that when applicants highlight their unique characteristics, it can help distinguish themselves from others.
Background: The personal statement is an integral part of a residency application but little guidance exists for medical students about what content to include. Objective: We use the framework of isomorphism, the process by which institutions model themselves after one another, to understand what internal medicine program directors (PDs) and associate program directors (APDs) recommend be included in the personal statement and how programs use personal statements in their selection of applicants to interview and rank. Methods: Semi-structured phone interviews were conducted between August and October 2020 with 13 academic PDs and APDs, who were selected for participation based on program size and geographic location. Interviews were recorded, transcribed, and coded using content analysis. Results: Effective personal statements should be well-written, present unique information, and demonstrate fit with a residency program. PDs and APDs recommended against expressing lack of interest in a program or highlighting negative personal characteristics. PDs and APDs used personal statements to distinguish between applicants and noted that personal statements help programs form an impression of the applicant. Consensus among PDs and APDs about what personal statements should include and how they are used indicates that isomorphism influences the match process. Conclusions: Our study found that the personal statement is a valued part of the residency application when it includes unique attributes and reveals personal values that align with that of the program. Additionally, PDs and APDs noted that when applicants highlight their unique characteristics, it can help distinguish themselves from others.
Authors: Steven V Angus; Christopher M Williams; Emily A Stewart; Michelle Sweet; Michael Kisielewski; Lisa L Willett Journal: Acad Med Date: 2020-04 Impact factor: 6.893