| Literature DB >> 35441803 |
Päivi Ventovaara1,2, Margareta Af Sandeberg1,2, Gitte Petersen3, Klas Blomgren1,2, Pernilla Pergert1,2.
Abstract
AIM: To assess experiences of morally distressing situations and perceptions of ethical climate in paediatric oncology care, with a focus on situations that involve children's voices.Entities:
Keywords: ethical climate; moral distress; nurses; oncology; paediatric
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35441803 PMCID: PMC9190683 DOI: 10.1002/nop2.1221
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nurs Open ISSN: 2054-1058
Demographic characteristics of the participants, n = 66
|
| |
|---|---|
| Gender | |
| Female | 65 (98) |
| Male | — |
| Missing | 1 (2) |
| Continued education | |
| Yes | 22 (33) |
| No | 43 (65) |
| Missing | 1 (2) |
| Work experience in paediatrics | |
| <5 years | 31 (47) |
| ≥5 years | 35 (53) |
The Danish MDS‐R items and the proportion of nurses who selected an option above the middle score (>2), suggesting frequent/disturbing experiences of moral distress. The two child‐specific items are marked with †. N = 65
| Abbreviated items |
Scores >2
| |
|---|---|---|
|
Frequency
|
Disturbance
| |
| Not having time to conduct conversations with patients and families in a way you think they should be carried out | 28 (43) | 55 (85) |
| See that … care suffers because of lack of continuity, with many different healthcare providers | 25 (38) | 52 (80) |
| Work in a staffing situation (number/competence level) that you experience as unsafe | 22 (34) | 58 (89) |
| Work with nurses … not as competent as … healthcare requires | 15 (23) | 55 (85) |
| Be unable to provide best possible care … pressures from management to reduce costs | 15 (23) | 57 (88) |
| †Perform painful/unpleasant procedures on school‐aged children who resist such treatment | 14 (22) | 54 (83) |
| Follow family's wishes… life‐sustaining treatment…not in the best interest of the child | 11 (17) | 46 (71) |
| Be expected to care for patients… not feel competent enough to care for | 9 (14) | 56 (86) |
| Feel pressured to perform tests and treatments … unnecessary | 9 (14) | 37 (57) |
| Provide care although parents have unrealistic expectations of healthcare | 7 (11) | 32 (49) |
| See that the quality of patient care suffers because of poor communication within the team | 7 (11) | 57 (88) |
| See inexperienced…professionals perform painful procedures… solely to improve skills | 7 (11) | 53 (82) |
| †Follow family's request not to talk about death… dying child who asks about dying | 6 (9) | 62 (95) |
| Continue to participate in life‐sustaining treatment of a dying child because no one has decided to end that treatment | 6 (9) | 53 (82) |
| Provide inadequate care…not relieve…suffering…physician afraid…will lead to death | 6 (9) | 57 (88) |
| Work with a physician… incompetent in providing healthcare | 5 (8) | 61 (94) |
| See… professionals give ‘false hope’ to parents | 5 (8) | 55 (85) |
| Avoid reporting… discover that a physician or a nurse has made a medical error | 5 (8) | 45 (69) |
| Not to talk about death with a dying child although you think it is necessary | 4 (6) | 56 (86) |
| Take life‐saving actions… only prolong dying | 4 (6) | 50 (77) |
| Decide on care/treatment when you are uncertain about what is right | 3 (5) | 45 (69) |
| Shut eyes to that parents have not received… information… to give their consent to health care… | 3 (5) | 51 (78) |
| Take no action about an ethical issue…because the involved…professional or management requests… | 3 (5) | 55 (85) |
| Follow the family's wishes for the child's care despite…you disagree…afraid of being reported | 2 (3) | 52 (80) |
| Follow physician's request not to discuss… prognosis with parents | 2 (3) | 49 (75) |
| Give an increased dose of sedatives/opiates… believe… hasten death | 1 (2) | 27 (42) |
The Danish HECS‐S items and the proportion of nurses who had selected an option above the middle score (>3), suggesting positive perceptions of ethical climate. The child‐specific item is marked with †. N = 66
|
Scores >3
| |
|---|---|
| Abbreviated items | |
| Co‐workers listen | 63 (95) |
| Competent co‐workers | 60 (91) |
| Parents’ wishes | 60 (91) |
| Physicians and nurses trust | 58 (88) |
| †Patients’ wishes | 51 (77) |
| Openness asking questions, learning | 51 (77) |
| Manager I trust | 51 (77) |
| Physicians and nurses respect each other's opinions | 51 (77) |
| Hospital's values shared | 49 (74) |
| I can practise care as it should be | 44 (67) |
| Feelings and values taken into account | 42 (64) |
| Immediate manager helps | 38 (58) |
| Physicians ask nurses for their opinions | 38 (58) |
| Ethical problems identified | 38 (58) |
| Immediate manager helps my co‐workers | 34 (52) |
| Dealing with ethical problems | 33 (50) |
| Hospital policies help | 29 (44) |
| Conflicts openly dealt with | 27 (41) |