A E Thorson1,2, G F Deen3, K T Bernstein4, W J Liu5, F Yamba3, N Habib1, F R Sesay6, P Gaillard1, T A Massaquoi6, S L R McDonald1, Y Zhang5, K N Durski7, S Singaravelu7, E Ervin4, H Liu5, A Coursier7, J E Marrinan1, A Ariyarajah7, M Carino1, P Formenty7, U Ströher4, M Lamunu7, G Wu5, F Sahr6, W Xu5, B Knust4, N Broutet1. 1. UNDP/UNFPA/UNICEF/WHO/World Bank Special Programme of Research, Development and Research Training in Human Reproduction, Department of Sexual and Reproductive Health and Research, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland. 2. Department of Global Public Health, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden. 3. Sierra Leone Ministry of Health and Sanitation, Freetown, Sierra Leone. 4. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia, United States of America. 5. National Institute for Viral Disease Control and Prevention, Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Beijing, China. 6. Sierra Leone Ministry of Defense, Freetown, Sierra Leone. 7. Department of Health Emergency Interventions, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Sexual transmission chains of Ebola virus (EBOV) have been verified and linked to EBOV RNA persistence in semen, post-recovery. The rate of semen persistence over time, including the average duration of persistence among Ebola virus disease (EVD) survivors, is not well known. This cohort study aimed to analyze population estimates of EBOV RNA persistence rates in semen over time, and associated risk factors in a population of survivors from Sierra Leone. METHODS AND FINDINGS: In this cohort study from May 2015 to April 2017 in Sierra Leone, recruitment was conducted in 2 phases; the first enrolled 100 male participants from the Western Area District in the capital of Freetown, and the second enrolled 120 men from the Western Area District and from Lungi, Port Loko District. Mean age of participants was 31 years. The men provided semen for testing, analyzed by quantitative reverse transcription PCR (qRT-PCR) for the presence of EBOV RNA. Follow-up occurred every 2 weeks until the endpoint, defined as 2 consecutive negative qRT-PCR results of semen specimen testing for EBOV RNA. Participants were matched with the Sierra Leone EVD case database to retrieve cycle threshold (Ct) values from the qRT-PCR analysis done in blood during acute disease. A purposive sampling strategy was used, and the included sample composition was compared to the national EVD survivor database to understand deviations from the general male survivor population. At 180 days (6 months) after Ebola treatment unit (ETU) discharge, the EBOV RNA semen positive rate was 75.4% (95% CI 66.9%-82.0%). The median persistence duration was 204 days, with 50% of men having cleared their semen of EBOV RNA after this time. At 270 days, persistence was 26.8% (95% CI 20.0%-34.2%), and at 360 days, 6.0% (95% CI 3.1%-10.2%). Longer persistence was significantly associated with severe acute disease, with probability of persistence in this population at 1 year at 10.1% (95% CI 4.6%-19.8%) compared to the probability approaching 0% for those with mild acute disease. Age showed a dose-response pattern, where the youngest men (≤25 years) were 3.17 (95% CI 1.60, 6.29) times more likely to be EBOV RNA negative in semen, and men aged 26-35 years were 1.85 (95% CI 1.04, 3.28) times more likely to be negative, than men aged >35 years. Among participants with both severe acute EVD and a higher age (>35 years), persistence remained above 20% (95% CI 6.0%-50.6%) at 1 year. Uptake of safe sex recommendations 3 months after ETU discharge was low among a third of survivors. The sample was largely representative of male survivors in Sierra Leone. A limitation of this study is the lack of knowledge about infectiousness. CONCLUSIONS: In this study we observed that EBOV RNA persistence in semen was a frequent phenomenon, with high population rates over time. This finding will inform forthcoming updated recommendations on risk reduction strategies relating to sexual transmission of EBOV. Our findings support implementation of a semen testing program as part of epidemic preparedness and response. Further, the results will enable planning of the magnitude of testing and targeted counseling needs over time.
BACKGROUND: Sexual transmission chains of Ebola virus (EBOV) have been verified and linked to EBOV RNA persistence in semen, post-recovery. The rate of semen persistence over time, including the average duration of persistence among Ebola virus disease (EVD) survivors, is not well known. This cohort study aimed to analyze population estimates of EBOV RNA persistence rates in semen over time, and associated risk factors in a population of survivors from Sierra Leone. METHODS AND FINDINGS: In this cohort study from May 2015 to April 2017 in Sierra Leone, recruitment was conducted in 2 phases; the first enrolled 100 male participants from the Western Area District in the capital of Freetown, and the second enrolled 120 men from the Western Area District and from Lungi, Port Loko District. Mean age of participants was 31 years. The men provided semen for testing, analyzed by quantitative reverse transcription PCR (qRT-PCR) for the presence of EBOV RNA. Follow-up occurred every 2 weeks until the endpoint, defined as 2 consecutive negative qRT-PCR results of semen specimen testing for EBOV RNA. Participants were matched with the Sierra Leone EVD case database to retrieve cycle threshold (Ct) values from the qRT-PCR analysis done in blood during acute disease. A purposive sampling strategy was used, and the included sample composition was compared to the national EVD survivor database to understand deviations from the general male survivor population. At 180 days (6 months) after Ebola treatment unit (ETU) discharge, the EBOV RNA semen positive rate was 75.4% (95% CI 66.9%-82.0%). The median persistence duration was 204 days, with 50% of men having cleared their semen of EBOV RNA after this time. At 270 days, persistence was 26.8% (95% CI 20.0%-34.2%), and at 360 days, 6.0% (95% CI 3.1%-10.2%). Longer persistence was significantly associated with severe acute disease, with probability of persistence in this population at 1 year at 10.1% (95% CI 4.6%-19.8%) compared to the probability approaching 0% for those with mild acute disease. Age showed a dose-response pattern, where the youngest men (≤25 years) were 3.17 (95% CI 1.60, 6.29) times more likely to be EBOV RNA negative in semen, and men aged 26-35 years were 1.85 (95% CI 1.04, 3.28) times more likely to be negative, than men aged >35 years. Among participants with both severe acute EVD and a higher age (>35 years), persistence remained above 20% (95% CI 6.0%-50.6%) at 1 year. Uptake of safe sex recommendations 3 months after ETU discharge was low among a third of survivors. The sample was largely representative of male survivors in Sierra Leone. A limitation of this study is the lack of knowledge about infectiousness. CONCLUSIONS: In this study we observed that EBOV RNA persistence in semen was a frequent phenomenon, with high population rates over time. This finding will inform forthcoming updated recommendations on risk reduction strategies relating to sexual transmission of EBOV. Our findings support implementation of a semen testing program as part of epidemic preparedness and response. Further, the results will enable planning of the magnitude of testing and targeted counseling needs over time.
Authors: Bobbie R Erickson; Tara K Sealy; Tim Flietstra; Laura Morgan; Brima Kargbo; Victor E Matt-Lebby; Aridth Gibbons; Ayan K Chakrabarti; James Graziano; Lance Presser; Mike Flint; Brian H Bird; Shelley Brown; John D Klena; Dianna M Blau; Aaron C Brault; Jessica A Belser; Johanna S Salzer; Amy J Schuh; Michael Lo; Marko Zivcec; Rachael A Priestley; Meredith Pyle; Christin Goodman; Scott Bearden; Brian R Amman; Alison Basile; Éric Bergeron; Michael D Bowen; Kimberly A Dodd; Molly M Freeman; Laura K McMullan; Christopher D Paddock; Brandy J Russell; Angela J Sanchez; Jonathan S Towner; David Wang; Galina E Zemtsova; Robyn A Stoddard; Maryann Turnsek; Lisa Wiggleton Guerrero; Shannon L Emery; Janae Stovall; Markus H Kainulainen; Jamie L Perniciaro; Slavica Mijatovic-Rustempasic; Gulchekhra Shakirova; Jörn Winter; Christopher Sexton; Feng Liu; Kimetha Slater; Raydel Anderson; Lauren Andersen; Cheng-Feng Chiang; Wen-Pin Tzeng; Samuel J Crowe; Matthew J Maenner; Christina F Spiropoulou; Stuart T Nichol; Ute Ströher Journal: J Infect Dis Date: 2016-08-31 Impact factor: 5.226
Authors: Suzanne E Mate; Jeffrey R Kugelman; Tolbert G Nyenswah; Jason T Ladner; Michael R Wiley; Thierry Cordier-Lassalle; Athalia Christie; Gary P Schroth; Stephen M Gross; Gloria J Davies-Wayne; Shivam A Shinde; Ratnesh Murugan; Sonpon B Sieh; Moses Badio; Lawrence Fakoli; Fahn Taweh; Emmie de Wit; Neeltje van Doremalen; Vincent J Munster; James Pettitt; Karla Prieto; Ben W Humrighouse; Ute Ströher; Joseph W DiClaro; Lisa E Hensley; Randal J Schoepp; David Safronetz; Joseph Fair; Jens H Kuhn; David J Blackley; A Scott Laney; Desmond E Williams; Terrence Lo; Alex Gasasira; Stuart T Nichol; Pierre Formenty; Francis N Kateh; Kevin M De Cock; Fatorma Bolay; Mariano Sanchez-Lockhart; Gustavo Palacios Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2015-10-14 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Timothy M Uyeki; Bobbie Rae Erickson; Shelley Brown; Anita K McElroy; Deborah Cannon; Aridth Gibbons; Tara Sealy; Markus H Kainulainen; Amy J Schuh; Colleen S Kraft; Aneesh K Mehta; G Marshall Lyon; Jay B Varkey; Bruce S Ribner; Richard T Ellison; Ellie Carmody; Gerard J Nau; Christina Spiropoulou; Stuart T Nichol; Ute Ströher Journal: Clin Infect Dis Date: 2016-04-03 Impact factor: 9.079
Authors: Gibrilla F Deen; Nathalie Broutet; Wenbo Xu; Barbara Knust; Foday R Sesay; Suzanna L R McDonald; Elizabeth Ervin; Jaclyn E Marrinan; Philippe Gaillard; Ndema Habib; Hongtu Liu; William Liu; Anna E Thorson; Francis Yamba; Thomas A Massaquoi; Faustin James; Archchun Ariyarajah; Christine Ross; Kyle Bernstein; Antoine Coursier; John Klena; Marylin Carino; Alie H Wurie; Yong Zhang; Marion S Dumbuya; Neetu Abad; Baimba Idriss; Teodora Wi; Sarah D Bennett; Tina Davies; Faiqa K Ebrahim; Elissa Meites; Dhamari Naidoo; Samuel J Smith; Patricia Ongpin; Tasneem Malik; Anshu Banerjee; Bobbie R Erickson; Yongjian Liu; Yang Liu; Ke Xu; Aaron Brault; Kara N Durski; Jörn Winter; Tara Sealy; Stuart T Nichol; Margaret Lamunu; James Bangura; Sihem Landoulsi; Amara Jambai; Oliver Morgan; Guizhen Wu; Mifang Liang; Qiudong Su; Yu Lan; Yanzhe Hao; Pierre Formenty; Ute Ströher; Foday Sahr Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2015-10-14 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Neetu Abad; Tasneem Malik; Archchun Ariyarajah; Patricia Ongpin; Matthew Hogben; Suzanna L R McDonald; Jaclyn Marrinan; Thomas Massaquoi; Anna Thorson; Elizabeth Ervin; Kyle Bernstein; Christine Ross; William J Liu; Karen Kroeger; Kara N Durski; Nathalie Broutet; Barbara Knust; Gibrilla F Deen Journal: PLoS Negl Trop Dis Date: 2017-09-11
Authors: William A Fischer; Jerry Brown; David Alain Wohl; Amy James Loftis; Sam Tozay; Edwina Reeves; Korto Pewu; Galapaki Gorvego; Saturday Quellie; Coleen K Cunningham; Carson Merenbloom; Sonia Napravnik; Karine Dube; David Adjasoo; Erin Jones; Korlia Bonarwolo; David Hoover Journal: Open Forum Infect Dis Date: 2017-07-22 Impact factor: 3.835
Authors: Saskia Den Boon; Barbara J Marston; Tolbert G Nyenswah; Amara Jambai; Moumie Barry; Sakoba Keita; Kara Durski; Schabbethai S Senesie; Devin Perkins; Anita Shah; Hugh H Green; Esther L Hamblion; Margaret Lamunu; Alex Gasasira; Nuha O Mahmoud; Mamadou H Djingarey; Oliver Morgan; Ian Crozier; Christopher Dye Journal: Emerg Infect Dis Date: 2019-02-17 Impact factor: 6.883
Authors: David X Liu; Timothy K Cooper; Donna L Perry; Louis M Huzella; Amanda M W Hischak; Randy J Hart; Nejra Isic; Russell Byrum; Danny Ragland; Marisa St Claire; Kurt Cooper; Rebecca Reeder; James Logue; Peter B Jahrling; Michael R Holbrook; Richard S Bennett; Lisa E Hensley Journal: Am J Pathol Date: 2021-10-06 Impact factor: 4.307
Authors: Rui Pedro Galão; Harry Wilson; Kristina L Schierhorn; Franka Debeljak; Bianca S Bodmer; Daniel Goldhill; Thomas Hoenen; Sam J Wilson; Chad M Swanson; Stuart J D Neil Journal: PLoS Pathog Date: 2022-05-09 Impact factor: 6.823
Authors: Francoise A Gourronc; Michael R Rebagliati; Breanna Kramer-Riesberg; Anthony M Fleck; J J Patten; Kathleen Geohegan-Barek; Kelly N Messingham; Robert A Davey; Wendy Maury; Aloysius J Klingelhutz Journal: Virology Date: 2022-05-27 Impact factor: 3.513
Authors: Alice Curwen; Scott Jones; Ceri Stayley; Laura Eden; Heather McKay; Peers Davies; Fiona Lovatt; Stephen Dunham; Rachael Tarlinton Journal: Vet Rec Open Date: 2022-06-20
Authors: Nicolas Huot; Cyril Planchais; Vanessa Contreras; Beatrice Jacquelin; Caroline Petitdemange; Marie Lazzerini; Pierre Rosenbaum; Félix Rey; R Keith Reeves; Roger Le Grand; Hugo Mouquet; Michaela Müller-Trutwin Journal: Res Sq Date: 2022-04-25
Authors: Alpha Kabinet Keita; Fara R Koundouno; Martin Faye; Ariane Düx; Julia Hinzmann; Haby Diallo; Ahidjo Ayouba; Frederic Le Marcis; Barré Soropogui; Kékoura Ifono; Moussa M Diagne; Mamadou S Sow; Joseph A Bore; Sebastien Calvignac-Spencer; Nicole Vidal; Jacob Camara; Mamadou B Keita; Annick Renevey; Amadou Diallo; Abdoul K Soumah; Saa L Millimono; Almudena Mari-Saez; Mamadou Diop; Ahmadou Doré; Fodé Y Soumah; Kaka Kourouma; Nathalie J Vielle; Cheikh Loucoubar; Ibrahima Camara; Karifa Kourouma; Giuditta Annibaldis; Assaïtou Bah; Anke Thielebein; Meike Pahlmann; Steven T Pullan; Miles W Carroll; Joshua Quick; Pierre Formenty; Anais Legand; Karla Pietro; Michael R Wiley; Noel Tordo; Christophe Peyrefitte; John T McCrone; Andrew Rambaut; Youssouf Sidibé; Mamadou D Barry; Madeleine Kourouma; Cé D Saouromou; Mamadou Condé; Moussa Baldé; Moriba Povogui; Sakoba Keita; Mandiou Diakite; Mamadou S Bah; Amadou Sidibe; Dembo Diakite; Fodé B Sako; Fodé A Traore; Georges A Ki-Zerbo; Philippe Lemey; Stephan Günther; Liana E Kafetzopoulou; Amadou A Sall; Eric Delaporte; Sophie Duraffour; Ousmane Faye; Fabian H Leendertz; Martine Peeters; Abdoulaye Toure; N' Faly Magassouba Journal: Nature Date: 2021-09-15 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Rafael K Campos; Vidyleison N Camargos; Sasha R Azar; Clint A Haines; Eduardo J Eyzaguirre; Shannan L Rossi Journal: Microorganisms Date: 2021-06-17
Authors: Robert J Watson; Julia Tree; Susan A Fotheringham; Yper Hall; Xiaofeng Dong; Kimberley Steeds; Jade Gouriet; Francisco J Salguero; Christopher Burton; James Pitman; Linda Easterbrook; Kevin S Richards; Jane Burton; Kevin Bewley; Christine Bruce; Julian A Hiscox; Miles W Carroll; Simon G P Funnell Journal: J Virol Date: 2021-09-29 Impact factor: 5.103