Adriana N Vest1, Giulia Da Poian, Qiao Li, Chengyu Liu, Shamim Nemati, Amit J Shah, Gari D Clifford. 1. Department of Biomedical Informatics, Emory University School of Medicine, Woodruff Memorial Research Bldg, Suite 4100, 101 Woodruff Circle, Atlanta, GA 30322, United States of America. Department of Epidemiology, Rollins School of Public Health at Emory University, 1518 Clifton Road NE, Room 3053, Atlanta, GA 30322, United States of America.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: This work aims to validate a set of data processing methods for variability metrics, which hold promise as potential indicators for autonomic function, prediction of adverse cardiovascular outcomes, psychophysiological status, and general wellness. Although the investigation of heart rate variability (HRV) has been prevalent for several decades, the methods used for preprocessing, windowing, and choosing appropriate parameters lacks consensus among academic and clinical investigators. Moreover, many of the important steps are omitted from publications, preventing reproducibility. APPROACH: To address this, we have compiled a comprehensive and open-source modular toolbox for calculating HRV metrics and other related variability indices, on both raw cardiovascular time series and RR intervals. The software, known as the PhysioNet Cardiovascular Signal Toolbox, is implemented in the MATLAB programming language, with standard (open) input and output formats, and requires no external libraries. The functioning of our software is compared with other widely used and referenced HRV toolboxes to identify important differences. MAIN RESULTS: Our findings demonstrate how modest differences in the approach to HRV analysis can lead to divergent results, a factor that might have contributed to the lack of repeatability of studies and clinical applicability of HRV metrics. SIGNIFICANCE: Existing HRV toolboxes do not include standardized preprocessing, signal quality indices (for noisy segment removal), and abnormal rhythm detection and are therefore likely to lead to significant errors in the presence of moderate to high noise or arrhythmias. We therefore describe the inclusion of validated tools to address these issues. We also make recommendations for default values and testing/reporting.
OBJECTIVE: This work aims to validate a set of data processing methods for variability metrics, which hold promise as potential indicators for autonomic function, prediction of adverse cardiovascular outcomes, psychophysiological status, and general wellness. Although the investigation of heart rate variability (HRV) has been prevalent for several decades, the methods used for preprocessing, windowing, and choosing appropriate parameters lacks consensus among academic and clinical investigators. Moreover, many of the important steps are omitted from publications, preventing reproducibility. APPROACH: To address this, we have compiled a comprehensive and open-source modular toolbox for calculating HRV metrics and other related variability indices, on both raw cardiovascular time series and RR intervals. The software, known as the PhysioNet Cardiovascular Signal Toolbox, is implemented in the MATLAB programming language, with standard (open) input and output formats, and requires no external libraries. The functioning of our software is compared with other widely used and referenced HRV toolboxes to identify important differences. MAIN RESULTS: Our findings demonstrate how modest differences in the approach to HRV analysis can lead to divergent results, a factor that might have contributed to the lack of repeatability of studies and clinical applicability of HRV metrics. SIGNIFICANCE: Existing HRV toolboxes do not include standardized preprocessing, signal quality indices (for noisy segment removal), and abnormal rhythm detection and are therefore likely to lead to significant errors in the presence of moderate to high noise or arrhythmias. We therefore describe the inclusion of validated tools to address these issues. We also make recommendations for default values and testing/reporting.
Authors: Alistair E W Johnson; Joachim Behar; Fernando Andreotti; Gari D Clifford; Julien Oster Journal: Physiol Meas Date: 2015-07-28 Impact factor: 2.833
Authors: Jan W Kantelhardt; Axel Bauer; Aicko Y Schumann; Petra Barthel; Raphael Schneider; Marek Malik; Georg Schmidt Journal: Chaos Date: 2007-03 Impact factor: 3.642
Authors: Silvia M Lobmaier; Nico Mensing van Charante; Enrico Ferrazzi; Dino A Giussani; Caroline J Shaw; Alexander Müller; Javier U Ortiz; Eva Ostermayer; Bernhard Haller; Federico Prefumo; Tiziana Frusca; Kurt Hecher; Birgit Arabin; Baskaran Thilaganathan; Aris T Papageorghiou; Amarnath Bhide; Pasquale Martinelli; Johannes J Duvekot; Jim van Eyck; Gerard H A Visser; Georg Schmidt; Wessel Ganzevoort; Christoph C Lees; Karl T M Schneider Journal: Am J Obstet Gynecol Date: 2016-06-23 Impact factor: 8.661
Authors: Ayse S Cakmak; Giulia Da Poian; Adam Willats; Ammer Haffar; Rami Abdulbaki; Yi-An Ko; Amit J Shah; Viola Vaccarino; Donald L Bliwise; Christopher Rozell; Gari D Clifford Journal: Sleep Date: 2020-08-12 Impact factor: 5.849
Authors: Asim H Gazi; Matthew T Wittbrodt; Anna B Harrison; Srirakshaa Sundararaj; Nil Z Gurel; Jonathon A Nye; Amit J Shah; Viola Vaccarino; J Douglas Bremner; Omer T Inan Journal: IEEE Trans Biomed Eng Date: 2022-01-20 Impact factor: 4.538
Authors: Peter H Charlton; Panicos A Kyriaco; Jonathan Mant; Vaidotas Marozas; Phil Chowienczyk; Jordi Alastruey Journal: Proc IEEE Inst Electr Electron Eng Date: 2022-03-11 Impact factor: 10.961
Authors: Qiao Li; Qichen Li; Ayse S Cakmak; Giulia Da Poian; Donald L Bliwise; Viola Vaccarino; Amit J Shah; Gari D Clifford Journal: Physiol Meas Date: 2021-05-13 Impact factor: 2.833
Authors: Teeranan Pokaprakarn; Rebecca R Kitzmiller; J Randall Moorman; Doug E Lake; Ashok K Krishnamurthy; Michael R Kosorok Journal: IEEE J Biomed Health Inform Date: 2022-02-04 Impact factor: 7.021
Authors: Ayse S Cakmak; Erick A Perez Alday; Giulia Da Poian; Ali Bahrami Rad; Thomas J Metzler; Thomas C Neylan; Stacey L House; Francesca L Beaudoin; Xinming An; Jennifer S Stevens; Donglin Zeng; Sarah D Linnstaedt; Tanja Jovanovic; Laura T Germine; Kenneth A Bollen; Scott L Rauch; Christopher A Lewandowski; Phyllis L Hendry; Sophia Sheikh; Alan B Storrow; Paul I Musey; John P Haran; Christopher W Jones; Brittany E Punches; Robert A Swor; Nina T Gentile; Meghan E McGrath; Mark J Seamon; Kamran Mohiuddin; Anna M Chang; Claire Pearson; Robert M Domeier; Steven E Bruce; Brian J O'Neil; Niels K Rathlev; Leon D Sanchez; Robert H Pietrzak; Jutta Joormann; Deanna M Barch; Diego A Pizzagalli; Steven E Harte; James M Elliott; Ronald C Kessler; Karestan C Koenen; Kerry J Ressler; Samuel A Mclean; Qiao Li; Gari D Clifford Journal: IEEE J Biomed Health Inform Date: 2021-08-06 Impact factor: 7.021
Authors: Erick A Perez Alday; Annie Gu; Amit J Shah; Chad Robichaux; An-Kwok Ian Wong; Chengyu Liu; Feifei Liu; Ali Bahrami Rad; Andoni Elola; Salman Seyedi; Qiao Li; Ashish Sharma; Gari D Clifford; Matthew A Reyna Journal: Physiol Meas Date: 2021-01-01 Impact factor: 2.833
Authors: Kamen A Tsvetanov; Richard N A Henson; P Simon Jones; Henk Mutsaerts; Delia Fuhrmann; Lorraine K Tyler; James B Rowe Journal: Psychophysiology Date: 2020-11-18 Impact factor: 4.016