BACKGROUND: Oxidized zirconium (OxZr) femoral heads were introduced in hip arthroplasty to reduce wear of the polyethylene compared with metallic heads and to reduce fracture risk compared with ceramic heads. Severe scratches have been reported on OxZr heads in patients undergoing revision for instability, but whether these scratches contribute to increased acetabular polyethylene wear remains unclear. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) How is the polyethylene of the acetabular liner affected by damage on the opposing OxZr head? (2) How does damage to the head affect the degree of polyethylene wear? METHODS: We assessed damage and deformation on all retrieved highly crosslinked liners that had articulated against OxZr heads collected at one institution between 2006 and 2013. Two observers used a visual subjective scoring system to assess polyethylene damage on the surface of the 42 retrieved liners. Polyethylene components were also laser scanned to measure dimensional changes to the liner. These outcomes were compared with the severity of scratching on the surface of the articulating OxZr head. We also used a 12-station hip simulator to measure wear over five million cycles (MCs) of pristine liners articulating against nine retrieved OxZr heads with varying degrees of scratching representing a spectrum of little to severe damage and three retrieved ceramic heads with severe metal transfer. RESULTS: Seventeen of the OxZr heads showed severe damage, of which 14 heads had been revised for dislocation. The retrieved liners that had articulated with these heads had greater damage scores for abrasion (mean score 0.4 versus 1.6; p = 0.008) and embedded debris (mean score 0.4 versus 1.4; p = 0.006) compared with liners that had articulated with less damaged heads. Four severely damaged OxZr heads wore at a higher rate than the others in the study with weight loss of 37.7 mg, 30.0 mg, 14.4 mg, and 2.6 mg after the first MC and a steady increase through testing to 5 MCs. Conversely, neither OxZr heads with less damage nor ceramic heads with severe metal transfer produced appreciable wear. CONCLUSIONS: Surface scratching of OxZr heads from recurrent dislocation and reduction maneuvers leads to increased wear of the crosslinked polyethylene used as a bearing surface. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Patients in whom such instability occurs in the presence of an OxZr head should be followed closely for the possibility of more severe wear.
BACKGROUND: Oxidized zirconium (OxZr) femoral heads were introduced in hip arthroplasty to reduce wear of the polyethylene compared with metallic heads and to reduce fracture risk compared with ceramic heads. Severe scratches have been reported on OxZr heads in patients undergoing revision for instability, but whether these scratches contribute to increased acetabular polyethylene wear remains unclear. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) How is the polyethylene of the acetabular liner affected by damage on the opposing OxZr head? (2) How does damage to the head affect the degree of polyethylene wear? METHODS: We assessed damage and deformation on all retrieved highly crosslinked liners that had articulated against OxZr heads collected at one institution between 2006 and 2013. Two observers used a visual subjective scoring system to assess polyethylene damage on the surface of the 42 retrieved liners. Polyethylene components were also laser scanned to measure dimensional changes to the liner. These outcomes were compared with the severity of scratching on the surface of the articulating OxZr head. We also used a 12-station hip simulator to measure wear over five million cycles (MCs) of pristine liners articulating against nine retrieved OxZr heads with varying degrees of scratching representing a spectrum of little to severe damage and three retrieved ceramic heads with severe metal transfer. RESULTS: Seventeen of the OxZr heads showed severe damage, of which 14 heads had been revised for dislocation. The retrieved liners that had articulated with these heads had greater damage scores for abrasion (mean score 0.4 versus 1.6; p = 0.008) and embedded debris (mean score 0.4 versus 1.4; p = 0.006) compared with liners that had articulated with less damaged heads. Four severely damaged OxZr heads wore at a higher rate than the others in the study with weight loss of 37.7 mg, 30.0 mg, 14.4 mg, and 2.6 mg after the first MC and a steady increase through testing to 5 MCs. Conversely, neither OxZr heads with less damage nor ceramic heads with severe metal transfer produced appreciable wear. CONCLUSIONS: Surface scratching of OxZr heads from recurrent dislocation and reduction maneuvers leads to increased wear of the crosslinked polyethylene used as a bearing surface. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Patients in whom such instability occurs in the presence of an OxZr head should be followed closely for the possibility of more severe wear.
Authors: Sok Chuen Tan; Adrian C K Lau; Christopher Del Balso; James L Howard; Brent A Lanting; Matthew G Teeter Journal: J Arthroplasty Date: 2016-02-27 Impact factor: 4.757
Authors: Matthew F Koff; Christina Esposito; Parina Shah; Mauro Miranda; Elexis Baral; Kara Fields; Thomas Bauer; Douglas E Padgett; Timothy Wright; Hollis G Potter Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2019-01 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Alberto V Carli; Anay R Patel; Michael B Cross; David J Mayman; Kaitlin M Carroll; Paul M Pellicci; Seth A Jerabek Journal: SICOT J Date: 2020-05-07