| Literature DB >> 26368568 |
Kathryn J Allan1, Holly M Biggs2, Jo E B Halliday1, Rudovick R Kazwala3, Venance P Maro4, Sarah Cleaveland1, John A Crump5.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Leptospirosis is an important but neglected bacterial zoonosis that has been largely overlooked in Africa. In this systematic review, we aimed to summarise and compare current knowledge of: (1) the geographic distribution, prevalence, incidence and diversity of acute human leptospirosis in Africa; and (2) the geographic distribution, host range, prevalence and diversity of Leptospira spp. infection in animal hosts in Africa.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2015 PMID: 26368568 PMCID: PMC4569256 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0003899
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS Negl Trop Dis ISSN: 1935-2727
Full search strategies for database searches (in alphabetical order).
| Database | Publication Date Limits | Search Strategies |
|---|---|---|
| Africa-Index Medicus (World Health Organization Global Health Library) | January 1930-October 2014 | (Leptospirosis OR |
| Africa-Wide:NiPAD (now EBSCO Host Africa Wide Information) | January 1930-October 2014 | (SU (leptospirosis OR leptospira) OR TX (leptospirosis OR leptospira)) AND (AB Africa* OR GE africa OR SU africa OR TI Africa* OR KW africa) |
| BIOSIS Previews | January 1930-October 2014 | Search 1: Topic = (leptospirosis) OR Topic = (leptospira) OR title = (leptospirosis) OR title = (leptospira); Search 2: topic = (Africa*) OR title = (Africa*); Search 3: Combine Search 1 AND Search 2 |
| CAB International: CAB abstracts and Global Health | January 1930-October 2014 | Search 1: Topic = (leptospirosis) OR Topic = (leptospira) OR title = (leptospirosis) OR title = (leptospira); Search 2: topic = (Africa*) OR title = (Africa*); Search 3: Combine Search 1 AND Search 2 |
| Embase (Ovid; including Embase Classic and Embase) | January 1947-October 2014 | ((leptospirosis [sh] OR leptospira [sh] OR leptospirosis [tw] OR leptospira [tw]) AND (africa*[sh] OR africa*[tw])) |
| Pubmed | January 1930-October 2014 | ((leptospirosis[mesh] OR leptospirosis[Text Word] OR leptospira[Text Word] OR leptospira[mesh)) AND (africa[mesh] OR africa*[Text Word])) |
| Web of Science Core Collection | January 1930-October 2014 | Search 1: Topic = (leptospirosis) OR Topic = (leptospira) OR title = (leptospirosis) OR title = (leptospira); Search 2: topic = (Africa*) OR title = (Africa*); Search 3: Combine Search 1 AND Search 2 |
| Zoological Record | January 1930-October 2014 | Search 1: Topic = (leptospirosis) OR Topic = (leptospira) OR title = (leptospirosis) OR title = (leptospira); Search 2: topic = (Africa*) OR title = (Africa*); Search 3: Combine Search 1 AND Search 2 |
Case definitions for study inclusion: Acute human leptospirosis and confirmed animal carrier hosts.
|
|
| Compatible acute illness, plus ≥1 of the following: |
| ≥ 4 fold rise in Microscopic Agglutination Test (MAT) titre between acute and convalescent serum |
| Culture |
| Pathogenic |
| Detection of |
|
|
| Compatible acute illness, plus ≥1 of the following: |
| MAT titre ≥1:400 in single or paired serum samples |
| Presence of IgM antibodies by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) or dipstick |
| Presence of IgM or a fourfold increase in IFA antibody titre in acute and convalescent serum samples |
|
|
| Clinical signs present or absent, plus ≥ 1 of the following: |
| Culture |
| Pathogenic |
| Typing of previously isolated strain |
| Detection of |
Footnotes
* Culture in any of the following media: Ellinghausen-McCullough-Johnson-Harris (+/- 5’Fluorouracil), Fletcher, Korthoff, Stuart, Vervoot or Noguchi culture media.
Fig 1PRISMA flowchart.
Selection of eligible articles for study inclusion.
Fig 2Geographic distribution of acute human leptospirosis and confirmed animal Leptospira spp. infection in Africa.
Summary of eligible cohort and surveillance studies reporting human acute leptospirosis in Africa, 1930–2014.
| Citation | Study year(s) | Country | Setting and study design | Inclusion and exclusion criteria | Diagnostic tests | Number enrolled | Total number of eligible cases | No. of eligible cases: confirmed & probable |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Van Riel et al[ | 1952–54 | Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) | Hospital; retrospective cohort | Clinical suspicion of leptospirosis | Culture (blood) in Vervoort-Korthoff media; Agglutination-lysis (MAT) | 45 | 27 (60 0%) | 5 confirmed, 22 probable |
| Kolochine-Erber & Brygoo[ | 1954–55 | Madagascar | Undefined; prospective cohort | Clinical suspicion of leptospirosis | Agglutination-lysis (MAT) | 40 | 1 (2 5%) | 1 probable |
| Forrester et al[ | 1961–62 | Kenya | Hospital; prospective cohort | Febrile illness unexplained by malaria, dysentery or pneumonia. | MAT | 67 | 6 (9 0%) | All probable |
| Payet et al[ | 1964–65 | Senegal | Hospital; prospective cohort | Clinical suspicion of leptospirosis; mostly defined by jaundice | Agglutination-lysis (MAT) | 53 | 3 (5 7%) | 2 confirmed, 1 probable |
| Silverie et al[ | 1966–67 | Madagascar | Undefined; prospective cohort | Clinical suspicion of leptospirosis | Agglutination-lysis (MAT) | 65 | 7 (10 8%) | All probable |
| De Geus et al[ | 1967 | Kenya | Hospital and health centre; prospective cohort | Febrile illness (temperature ≥ 38°C) without obvious cause; negative malaria smear or no response to anti-malarial treatment | Culture (blood) in Fletcher’s and Cox’s media; MAT | 39 | 7 (17 9%) | 6 confirmed, 1 probable |
| Sankale et al[ | 1967–72 | Senegal | Hospital; retrospective cohort | Inpatients with serum samples tested for leptospirosis | Serum agglutination (MAT) | 134 | 3 (2 2%) | All confirmed |
| De Geus et al[ | 1968–69 | Kenya | Hospital outpatient department and health centre; prospective cohort | Febrile illness (temperature ≥ 38.3°C) without obvious cause; negative malaria smear or no response to anti-malarial treatment | Culture (blood) in Fletcher’s media; MAT | 91 | 10 (11 0%) | All confirmed |
| De Geus et al[ | 1969 | Kenya | Hospital & outpatient department; prospective cohort & case-finding survey | Febrile illness (temperature ≥ 38.3°C) without obvious cause; negative malaria smear or no response to anti-malarial treatment | Culture (blood) in Fletcher’s media; MAT | 281 | 9 (3 2%) | All confirmed |
| Kinebuchi et al[ | NA | Ghana | Hospital; prospective cohort | Clinical suspicion of leptospirosis, mostly defined by hepatitis or jaundice | Culture (blood) in Korthof’s media; MAT | 99 | 13 (13 1%) | 7 confirmed,6 probable |
| Hogerzeil et al[ | 1981–82 | Ghana | Hospital outpatient department; prospective cohort | Group 1: Fever without obvious cause and/or any of the following; jaundice, muscle pains, meningism, conjunctival injection, albuminuria; negative malaria smear | Culture (blood and urine) in Fletcher’s or Ellinghausen-McCullough-Johnson-Harris | Group 1: 88 | Group 1: 4 (4 5%) | Group 1: 3 confirmed; 1 probable |
| Group 2: Jaundice | Group 2: 102 | Group 2: 2 (2 0%) | Group 2: All confirmed | |||||
| Delacollette et al[ | 1985–86 | DRC | Hospital; prospective cohort | Inpatients with black or red urine with confirmed haemoglobinuria | ELISA (unspecified) | 38 | 1 (2 6%) | All probable |
| Pinn[ | 1988–90 | Seychelles | Hospital; prospective cohort | Inpatients with clinical diagnosis of leptospirosis | IgM ELISA | 80 | 58 (72 5%) | All probable |
| Collares-Pereira et al[ | 1993 | Mozambique | Hospital outpatient department; prospective cohort | Outpatients aged 18–50 years with acute febrile illness without obvious cause; negative malaria smear. | MAT | 43 | 1 (2 3%) | 1 probable |
| Yersin et al[ | 1995–96 | Seychelles | Nationwide health care providers; Prospective population-based surveillance | Fever or any of the following without obvious cause: myalgia, liver tenderness, jaundice, acute renal failure, bleeding tendency, radiographic lung infiltrates, or meningism | MAT; PCR ( | 125 | 75 (60 0%) | All confirmed |
| Desvars et al[ | 1998–2008 | Réunion | Hospital; retrospective population-based surveillance | Cases voluntarily reported to Centre National de References de Leptospiroses (Paris, France) | Culture (blood), media not specified; MAT; PCR (target not specified) | NA | 613 cases | All probable |
| Ismail et al[ | 1999–2003 | Egypt | Hospital; retrospective cohort | Group 1: fever (temperature ≥38°C) for ≥3 days in the absence of diarrhoea, pneumonia, typhoid fever, brucellosis or established fever of unknown origin. | IgM ELISA; MAT | Group 1:886 | Group 1: 141 (15 9%) | All probable |
| Group 2: acute hepatitis defined as signs of acute jaundice. | Group 2: 392 | Group 2: 63 (16 1%) | ||||||
| Renault et al[ | 2004–08 | Réunion | Hospital; retrospective population-based surveillance | Hospitalised cases of leptospirosis cases in Réunion reported to the Regional Directorate for Health and Social Affairs/Regional Health Agency of the Indian Ocean. | Confirmed cases: Culture (not specified), MAT or PCR (target not specified) | 240 | 160 (66 7%) | All probable |
| Possible cases: IgM ELISA; MAT titre ≥ 1:50 | ||||||||
| Pages et al[ | 2004–12 | Réunion | Population-based surveillance | Confirmed or probable cases of leptospirosis in Réunion residents reported to the health watch platform of the French Regional Health Agency for the Indian Ocean. | Confirmed cases: Culture (not specified), MAT or PCR (target not specified) | NA | 405 cases | All probable |
| Possible cases: IgM ELISA. | ||||||||
| Ari et al[ | 2005 | Kenya | Community; prospective case-finding | Community members with new onset febrile illness (temperature not defined) or joint pains | IgM ELISA | 12 | 3 (25 0%) | All probable |
| Bertherat et al[ | 2005 | DRC | Community; retrospective case finding | Acute & convalescent patients with respiratory disease in a mining camp | MAT | 82 | 8 (9 8%) | All probable |
| Parker et al[ | 2005–2006 | Egypt | Hospital; prospective cohort | Fever ≥ 2 days or admission temperature ≥38.5°C, aged ≥ 4 years without obvious cause of fever, such as diarrhoea, pneumonia, or clinical diagnosis of typhoid fever or brucellosis. | Culture (blood) in EMJH; MAT; PCR; IgM ELISA | 981 | 194 (19 8%) | 45 confirmed; 149 probable |
| Parker et al[ | 2005–2006 | Egypt | Hospital; prospective cohort | Fever ≥ 2 days or admission temperature ≥38.5°C, aged ≥ 4 years without obvious cause of fever; with laboratory evidence of co-infection with | Culture (blood) in EMJH; MAT; PCR ( | 187 | 152 (81 3%) | All confirmed |
| Murray et al[ | 2005–2007 | Egypt | Hospital; prospective cohort | Fever; aged ≥ 4 years without obvious cause of fever, such as diarrhoea, pneumonia, or clinical diagnosis of typhoid fever or brucellosis. | Culture (blood) in EMJH media; MAT; PCR ( | 2,441 | 98 (4 0%) | All probable |
| Tagoe et al[ | NA | Ghana | Hospital; prospective cohort | Fever ≥ 2 days and temperature ≥38.0°C; aged ≥ 4 years without obvious cause of fever | IgM ELISA; MAT | 166 | 13 (7 8%) | All probable |
| Biggs et al[ | 2007–08 | Tanzania | Hospital; prospective cohort | Inpatients aged ≥13 years with fever (≥38.0°C oral) or inpatients aged 2 months to 12 years with history of fever within 48 hours or admission temperature ≥37.5ºC axillary ≥38.0ºC rectal. | MAT | 831 | 70 (8 4%); | 40 confirmed, 30 probable |
| Bourhy et al[ | 2007–08 | Mayotte | Undefined; prospective cohort | Fever (temperature ≥38°C) for ≤7days and headache and/or myalgia | Culture (blood) in EMJH media; PCR ( | 388 | 53 (13 7%), | All confirmed |
| Bourhy et al[ | 2007–2010 | Mayotte | Undefined; population-based surveillance | Patients for which a blood sample was submitted for leptospirosis diagnosis to the Hospital Centre of Mayotte | Culture (blood) in EMJH media; PCR ( | 2,523 | 198 (7 8%) | All confirmed |
Footnotes
*Figures reported here are based on the number of reported acute leptospirosis cases that met our review case definitions (see Table 1 for case definitions) and therefore may vary from the values reported in the original citations.
** All cases met probable case definitions. An unspecified proportion of positive cases also met the case definition for confirmed cases but exact numbers could not be determined from the available data.
a Patients who refused hospital admission were not investigated.
b Methods describe a change to a case-finding survey partway through the study, but full details not available
c MAT performed in a subset of participants only
d Clinical diagnosis defined as ≥3 of the following: headache or fever (temperature not defined), evidence of liver inflammation (defined as jaundice, tender liver, and/or abnormal liver function tests), evidence of renal inflammation (haematuria and/or abnormal renal function), or evidence of muscle inflammation (tenderness and/or elevated creatine phosphokinase)
e All tested negative for Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi, Brucella spp., and Rickettsia spp.
f All tested negative for Hepatitis A, B, and C.
g In setting of outbreak of acute febrile illness in a well-defined population
h 187 patients were diagnosed with selected co-infections out of a total cohort of 1510 patients with non-specific febrile illness.
ϖ Taken ≥ 9 days of onset of illness
k Also report two imported cases from Comoros and Madagascar respectively
Serogroups of Leptospira isolated from cases of acute human leptospirosis and animal carrier hosts by country.
| Human Studies | Animal Studies | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Serogroup | Country | Host species | Country |
|
| Kenya[ | African grass rat ( | Nigeria[ |
| Cattle ( | Zimbabwe[ | ||
|
| Kenya[ | African grass rat ( | Kenya[ |
|
| Not reported | African giant pouched rat ( | Tanzania[ |
| African grass rat ( | Nigeria[ | ||
| South African pouched mouse ( | Kenya[ | ||
|
| Egypt[ | Cattle ( | Zimbabwe[ |
| Rusty-bellied brush-furred rat ( | Cameroon[ | ||
|
| Egypt[ | Black rat ( | Egypt[ |
| Kenya[ | Brown rat ( | Madagascar[ | |
| South Africa[ | Dogs ( | Egypt[ | |
| Pigs ( | South Africa[ | ||
|
| Ghana[ | Not reported | |
|
| DRC[ | Black rat ( | Egypt[ |
| Egypt[ | Cattle ( | Kenya[ | |
| Mayotte [ | House mouse ( | Egypt[ | |
|
| DRC[ | Cattle ( | Zimbabwe[ |
| Kenya[ | |||
|
| Egypt[ | Brown rat ( | South Africa[ |
| Ghana[ | Cattle ( | Egypt[ | |
| Kenya[ | Egyptian fox ( | Egypt[ | |
| Egyptian mongoose ( | Egypt[ | ||
|
| Mayotte[ | Not reported | |
|
| Egypt[ | Cattle ( | Botswana[ |
| Mayotte[ | Pigs ( | South Africa[ | |
|
| Egypt[ | Black rat ( | Egypt[ |
| Kenya[ | Cattle ( | Nigeria[ | |
| Mayotte[ | |||
|
| Not reported | Black rat ( | Egypt[ |
| Cattle ( | South Africa[ | ||
|
| DRC[ | Cattle ( | Zimbabwe[ |
| Fringe-tailed gerbil ( | Kenya[ | ||
| Pigs ( | Tunisia[ | ||
|
| Egypt[ | Not reported | |
|
| Mayotte[ | Not reported | |
|
| Mayotte[ | Not reported | |
Footnotes
* Cross-reactive isolates
Leptospira species reported in acute human leptospirosis and animal carrier hosts by African country.
| Human Studies | Animal Studies | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Species | Country | Host species | Country |
|
| Kenya[ | African grass rat ( | Nigeria[ |
| Mayotte[ | Black rat ( | Benin[ | |
| Cattle ( | Nigeria[ | ||
| Comoro rousette ( | Comoros[ | ||
| Fringe-tailed gerbil ( | Kenya[ | ||
| Giant African pouched rat ( | Tanzania[ | ||
| Lesser tufted-tailed rat ( | Madagascar[ | ||
| Long-winged bats ( | Madagascar[ | ||
| Madagascar free-tailed bat | Madagascar[ | ||
| Multimammate mouse ( | Benin[ | ||
| Pigs ( | Tunisia[ | ||
| Shrew tenrecs ( | Madagascar[ | ||
| South African pouched mouse ( | Kenya[ | ||
|
| Mayotte[ | Black rat ( | Mayotte[ |
| Shrew tenrec ( | Madagascar[ | ||
|
| Egypt[ | African giant shrew ( | Benin[ |
| Ghana[ | African grass rat ( | Nigeria[ | |
| Kenya[ | Asian house shrew ( | Madagascar[ | |
| Mayotte[ | Banded mongoose ( | Botswana[ | |
| Black rat ( | Egypt[ | ||
| Brown rat ( | Benin[ | ||
| Cattle ( | Botswana[ | ||
| Comoro rousette ( | Comoros[ | ||
| House mouse ( | Kenya[ | ||
| Pigs ( | South Africa[ | ||
| Rusty-bellied brush-furred rat ( | Cameroon[ | ||
|
| Egypt[ | African grass rat ( | Kenya[ |
| Kenya[ | Black rat ( | Mayotte[ | |
| Mayotte[ | Cattle ( | Kenya[ | |
| House mouse ( | Kenya[ | ||
| Shrew ( | Benin[ | ||
| Streaked tenrec ( | Madagascar[ | ||
Footnotes
a methodology includes genetic typing of isolates, DNA sequencing following PCR detection, extrapolation of serovar data with species determined by reference to KIT Leptospira library.
b Miniopterus spp. include Miniopterus gleni, Miniopterus goudoti, Miniopterus griffithsi, Miniopterus mahafaliensis, Miniopterus majori, Miniopterus soroculus
c Microgale spp. include Microgale longicaudata, Microgale majori, Microgale principula
d Described as L. borgpetersenii-like,[35] L. borgpetersenii Group B[86] and recently re-classified as L. mayottensis[134]