| Literature DB >> 25590682 |
Carrie F Nielsen, Sarah Kidd, Ansumana R M Sillah, Edward Davis, Jonathan Mermin, Peter H Kilmarx.
Abstract
As of January 3, 2015, Ebola virus disease (Ebola) has killed more than 2,500 persons in Sierra Leone since the epidemic began there in May 2014. Ebola virus is transmitted principally by direct physical contact with an infected person or their body fluids during the later stages of illness or after death. Contact with the bodies and fluids of persons who have died of Ebola is especially common in West Africa, where family and community members often touch and wash the body of the deceased in preparation for funerals. These cultural practices have been a route of Ebola transmission. In September 2014, CDC, in collaboration with the Sierra Leone Ministry of Health and Sanitation (MOH), assessed burial practices, cemetery management, and adherence to practices recommended to reduce the risk for Ebola virus transmission. The assessment was conducted by directly observing burials and cemetery operations in three high-incidence districts. In addition, a community assessment was conducted to assess the acceptability to the population of safe, nontraditional burial practices and cemetery management intended to reduce the risk for Ebola virus transmission. This report summarizes the results of these assessments, which found that 1) there were not enough burial teams to manage the number of reported deaths, 2) Ebola surveillance, swab collection, and burial team responses to a dead body alert were not coordinated, 3) systematic procedures for testing and reporting of Ebola laboratory results for dead bodies were lacking, 4) cemetery space and management were inadequate, and 5) safe burial practices, as initially implemented, were not well accepted by communities. These findings were used to inform the development of a national standard operating procedure (SOP) for safe, dignified medical burials, released on October 1. A second, national-level, assessment was conducted during October 10-15 to assess burial team practices and training and resource needs for SOP implementation across all 14 districts in Sierra Leone. The national-level assessment confirmed that burial practices, challenges, and needs at the national level were similar to those found during the assessment conducted in the three districts. Recommendations based on the assessments included 1) district-level trainings on the components of the SOP and 2) rapid deployment across the 14 districts of additional trained burial teams supplied with adequate personal protective equipment (PPE), other equipment (e.g., chlorine, chlorine sprayers, body bags, and shovels), and vehicles. Although these assessments were conducted very early on in the response, during October-December national implementation of the SOP and recommendations might have made dignified burial safer and increased community support for these practices; an evaluation of this observation is planned.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2015 PMID: 25590682 PMCID: PMC4584795
Source DB: PubMed Journal: MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep ISSN: 0149-2195 Impact factor: 17.586
FIGURE 1Cumulative number of confirmed Ebola virus disease (Ebola) cases, by district — Sierra Leone, September 21–October 4, 2014
Sources: Sierra Leone Ministry of Health and Sanitation and International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies.
Burial team supervisors’ assessments on burial team composition, practices, challenges, and needs, by district — Sierra Leone, October 1–10, 2014
| District | No. of trained burial teams | No. of persons per team | No. of functional burial teams | How being alerted to a request for a body collection | Average body collection per day | Bodies collected within 24 hours | Cemetery or community burials | Swabs performed by laboratory technician | Challenges and needs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kambia | 1 | 8 (includes grave digger) | 1 | Receiving calls from community and holding center | 1–2 | Yes | Both | No swabs | Would like 1–2 more teams and a coordinator |
| Port Loko | 7 (5 are emergency responder teams, district is split into 2 zones; 3 chiefdoms per team) | 7 (only 2 supervisors) | 7 | Through hotline | 15 | Mostly, except when vehicle challenges occur | Cemetery for bodies collected from health facilities and community burials; district-level grave digger stays at cemetery | Just started October 1 | Just received WHO vehicles but might not be sufficient for rough roads; also only 3 of the teams are being paid regularly |
| Bombali | 2 (3rd team being trained) | 11 | 2 | Getting called directly by community and by surveillance team | 10–15 | 80% | Cemetery 2–3 miles from Makeni and community | Swab team just started on October 2 | Getting support from WHO but still need strong vehicles |
| Koinadugu | 1 (2nd team being trained) | Team 1 = 8 (includes grave digger) | 1 | Called by surveillance team | 2 bodies total | Community | Yes; both bodies were swabbed and negative | Getting 2 more vehicles next week, waiting for 2nd team to start after training | |
| Tonkolili | 1 | 8 | 11 (disagreement on recognition of burial teams) | Most bodies are from holding center, not community | 3 (12 bodies buried in total) | Not all | Cemetery | Not coordinated | Additional teams are working and being paid, but only one has been trained by MOH and it is the only one the supervisor recognizes; need vehicles and more compensation for cemetery land owners |
| Kono | Cannot be reached | ||||||||
| Kenema | 4 | 6 (no supervisor) | 3 | By holding center or surveillance team | 6–7 from holding center, 4 from community; has decreased since treatment center moved | 1–3 days; road access challenges cause delays | All bodies from treatment center buried in Red Cross Cemetery; other cemetery full | Yes; either laboratory technician goes with or they bring body to mortuary, but do not wait for results | Need more vehicles and sometimes the surveillance team uses their sprayers for their surveillance team visits |
| Kailahun | 2 IFRC 4 MOH | 8 | 2 | By DMO and MSF | ≥200 bodies buried to date | Cemetery | Technician just started following IFRC burial teams | Improve communication and coordination between DMO and IFRC | |
| Bo | 4 | 8 | 4 | Surveillance team | 4 | 1–3 days | Cemetery | Yes | Doing OK since WHO sent vehicles; gaining community confidence with swabs |
| Training 5th team this week | Includes grave digger | Getting 4–7 calls per day | Since swabs introduced 2 weeks ago (September 22) | ||||||
| Pujehun | 2, as per the DMO | 8; includes a grave digger | 8 confirmed deaths (unknown); often do not have a body to collect in a given week | Would like more vehicles that can handle rough terrain, fuel, and refresher training | |||||
| Bonthe | 2 | 8 | 1; only have 1 vehicle to get burial team to site, but then they do not transport body anywhere; it is carried to the community site | Do not have a hotline, community leaders call DHMT | 1–2 per week; only 2 bodies collected total | Delays because of road conditions | Community | Sometimes laboratory technician shows up to body | Need vehicles appropriate for body transport and need new spraying equipment, theirs keeps breaking |
| Moyamba | 14 | 8 | 2 | Getting called directly by community and by hotline | 3–4 per day | 1–2 days because distance to get to bodies is far | Both | Only bodies in Moyamba town are swabbed | Would like support for at least 3 more teams, would like vehicles that can handle difficult terrain, fuel; also rainy season is now so would like rain gear |
| 1 trained per chiefdom | Includes grave digger | MOH only paying 2 of the teams | From community and holding center | Additional burial team members being trained to collect swabs, October 9 | |||||
| Western Area | 11 | 12 | 10 | Hotline and called directly | 30–40; approximately 20 buried in King Tom Cemetery daily | No | Cemetery | Some still waiting for results before burying body | Need more burial teams, vehicles, and improved communication and coordination |
Abbreviations: WHO = World Health Organization; MOH = Ministry of Health and Sanitation, Sierra Leone; DMO = District Medical Officer; MSF = Médecins Sans Frontières; IFRC = International Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies; DHMT = District Health Management Team.
FIGURE 2A burial team preparing to collect another body and transport it in the back of truck along with eight other bodies that had already been collected — Sierra Leone, September 2014
FIGURE 3Unmarked graves in an Ebola burial section of a cemetery — Sierra Leone, September 2014
FIGURE 4Dead bodies, personal protective equipment, and medical waste buried together in unmarked graves at an unsafe depth of <2 meters — Sierra Leone, September 2014
FIGURE 5A burial team preparing to wrap a body in a Muslim shroud, illustrating the incorporation of a dignified component of a standard operating procedure for safe, dignified medical burial — Sierra Leone, October 2014