Literature DB >> 24807866

Addressing overdiagnosis and overtreatment in cancer: a prescription for change.

Laura J Esserman1, Ian M Thompson2, Brian Reid3, Peter Nelson3, David F Ransohoff4, H Gilbert Welch5, Shelley Hwang6, Donald A Berry7, Kenneth W Kinzler8, William C Black9, Mina Bissell10, Howard Parnes11, Sudhir Srivastava12.   

Abstract

A vast range of disorders--from indolent to fast-growing lesions--are labelled as cancer. Therefore, we believe that several changes should be made to the approach to cancer screening and care, such as use of new terminology for indolent and precancerous disorders. We propose the term indolent lesion of epithelial origin, or IDLE, for those lesions (currently labelled as cancers) and their precursors that are unlikely to cause harm if they are left untreated. Furthermore, precursors of cancer or high-risk disorders should not have the term cancer in them. The rationale for this change in approach is that indolent lesions with low malignant potential are common, and screening brings indolent lesions and their precursors to clinical attention, which leads to overdiagnosis and, if unrecognised, possible overtreatment. To minimise that potential, new strategies should be adopted to better define and manage IDLEs. Screening guidelines should be revised to lower the chance of detection of minimal-risk IDLEs and inconsequential cancers with the same energy traditionally used to increase the sensitivity of screening tests. Changing the terminology for some of the lesions currently referred to as cancer will allow physicians to shift medicolegal notions and perceived risk to reflect the evolving understanding of biology, be more judicious about when a biopsy should be done, and organise studies and registries that offer observation or less invasive approaches for indolent disease. Emphasis on avoidance of harm while assuring benefit will improve screening and treatment of patients and will be equally effective in the prevention of death from cancer.
Copyright © 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Entities:  

Mesh:

Year:  2014        PMID: 24807866      PMCID: PMC4322920          DOI: 10.1016/S1470-2045(13)70598-9

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Lancet Oncol        ISSN: 1470-2045            Impact factor:   41.316


  74 in total

1.  Cumulative probability of false-positive recall or biopsy recommendation after 10 years of screening mammography: a cohort study.

Authors:  Rebecca A Hubbard; Karla Kerlikowske; Chris I Flowers; Bonnie C Yankaskas; Weiwei Zhu; Diana L Miglioretti
Journal:  Ann Intern Med       Date:  2011-10-18       Impact factor: 25.391

2.  Updated guidelines 2008 for the diagnosis, surveillance and therapy of Barrett's esophagus.

Authors:  Kenneth K Wang; Richard E Sampliner
Journal:  Am J Gastroenterol       Date:  2008-03       Impact factor: 10.864

Review 3.  The World Health Organization/International Society of Urological Pathology consensus classification of urothelial (transitional cell) neoplasms of the urinary bladder. Bladder Consensus Conference Committee.

Authors:  J I Epstein; M B Amin; V R Reuter; F K Mostofi
Journal:  Am J Surg Pathol       Date:  1998-12       Impact factor: 6.394

Review 4.  The role of prevalence in the diagnosis of prostate cancer.

Authors:  Nicolas B Delongchamps; Amar Singh; Gabriel P Haas
Journal:  Cancer Control       Date:  2006-07       Impact factor: 3.302

5.  Biomarker expression and risk of subsequent tumors after initial ductal carcinoma in situ diagnosis.

Authors:  Karla Kerlikowske; Annette M Molinaro; Mona L Gauthier; Hal K Berman; Fred Waldman; James Bennington; Henry Sanchez; Cynthia Jimenez; Kim Stewart; Karen Chew; Britt-Marie Ljung; Thea D Tlsty
Journal:  J Natl Cancer Inst       Date:  2010-04-28       Impact factor: 13.506

6.  Increasing mastectomy rates for early-stage breast cancer? Population-based trends from California.

Authors:  Scarlett Lin Gomez; Daphne Lichtensztajn; Allison W Kurian; Melinda L Telli; Ellen T Chang; Theresa H M Keegan; Sally L Glaser; Christina A Clarke
Journal:  J Clin Oncol       Date:  2010-02-16       Impact factor: 44.544

7.  Melanoma epidemic: an analysis of six decades of data from the Connecticut Tumor Registry.

Authors:  Alan C Geller; Richard W Clapp; Arthur J Sober; Lou Gonsalves; Lloyd Mueller; Cindy L Christiansen; Waqas Shaikh; Donald R Miller
Journal:  J Clin Oncol       Date:  2013-09-16       Impact factor: 44.544

8.  Increasing rates of contralateral prophylactic mastectomy among patients with ductal carcinoma in situ.

Authors:  Todd M Tuttle; Stephanie Jarosek; Elizabeth B Habermann; Amanda Arrington; Anasooya Abraham; Todd J Morris; Beth A Virnig
Journal:  J Clin Oncol       Date:  2009-02-17       Impact factor: 44.544

9.  Reducing false-positive biopsies: a pilot study to reduce benign biopsy rates for BI-RADS 4A/B assessments through testing risk stratification and new thresholds for intervention.

Authors:  Chris I Flowers; Cristina O'Donoghue; Dan Moore; Adeline Goss; Danny Kim; June-Ho Kim; Sjoerd G Elias; Julia Fridland; Laura J Esserman
Journal:  Breast Cancer Res Treat       Date:  2013-06-14       Impact factor: 4.872

10.  Computer-aided diagnosis of skin lesions using conventional digital photography: a reliability and feasibility study.

Authors:  Wen-Yu Chang; Adam Huang; Chung-Yi Yang; Chien-Hung Lee; Yin-Chun Chen; Tian-Yau Wu; Gwo-Shing Chen
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2013-11-04       Impact factor: 3.240

View more
  141 in total

Review 1.  Research Needs for Understanding the Biology of Overdiagnosis in Cancer Screening.

Authors:  Sudhir Srivastava; Brian J Reid; Sharmistha Ghosh; Barnett S Kramer
Journal:  J Cell Physiol       Date:  2016-04-29       Impact factor: 6.384

2.  Cytopathology of Follicular Cell Nodules.

Authors:  Domenico Damiani; Voichita Suciu; Philippe Vielh
Journal:  Endocr Pathol       Date:  2015-12       Impact factor: 3.943

3.  [The 2014 consensus conference of the ISUP on Gleason grading of prostatic carcinoma].

Authors:  G Kristiansen; L Egevad; M Amin; B Delahunt; J R Srigley; P A Humphrey; J I Epstein
Journal:  Pathologe       Date:  2016-02       Impact factor: 1.011

4.  Invasion rather than nuclear features correlates with outcome in encapsulated follicular tumors: further evidence for the reclassification of the encapsulated papillary thyroid carcinoma follicular variant.

Authors:  Ian Ganly; Laura Wang; R Michael Tuttle; Nora Katabi; Gustavo A Ceballos; H Ruben Harach; Ronald Ghossein
Journal:  Hum Pathol       Date:  2015-02-04       Impact factor: 3.466

5.  Noninvasive diagnostic imaging using machine-learning analysis of nanoresolution images of cell surfaces: Detection of bladder cancer.

Authors:  I Sokolov; M E Dokukin; V Kalaparthi; M Miljkovic; A Wang; J D Seigne; P Grivas; E Demidenko
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2018-12-03       Impact factor: 11.205

6.  Skin biopsy utilization and melanoma incidence among Medicare beneficiaries.

Authors:  M A Weinstock; J P Lott; Q Wang; L J Titus; T Onega; H D Nelson; L Pearson; M Piepkorn; R L Barnhill; J G Elmore; A N A Tosteson
Journal:  Br J Dermatol       Date:  2017-03-01       Impact factor: 9.302

7.  Prostate imaging--the future is now: current concepts and future potentials.

Authors:  Felix K-H Chun; Thomas R W Herrmann
Journal:  World J Urol       Date:  2014-08       Impact factor: 4.226

Review 8.  An evolutionary perspective on field cancerization.

Authors:  Kit Curtius; Nicholas A Wright; Trevor A Graham
Journal:  Nat Rev Cancer       Date:  2017-12-08       Impact factor: 60.716

9.  Future-proofing Gleason Grading: What to Call Gleason 6 Prostate Cancer?

Authors:  Stacy Loeb; Francesco Montorsi; James W Catto
Journal:  Eur Urol       Date:  2015-03-11       Impact factor: 20.096

10.  Association of Preferences for Papillary Thyroid Cancer Treatment With Disease Terminology: A Discrete Choice Experiment.

Authors:  Brooke Nickel; Kirsten Howard; Juan P Brito; Alexandra Barratt; Ray Moynihan; Kirsten McCaffery
Journal:  JAMA Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg       Date:  2018-10-01       Impact factor: 6.223

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.