S H Cho1, Y M Sung, M S Kim. 1. Department of Radiology, Gil Hospital, Gachon University of Medicine and Science, Incheon, Republic of Korea.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to review the prevalence and radiological features of rib fractures missed on initial chest CT evaluation, and to examine the diagnostic value of additional coronal images in a large series of trauma patients. METHODS: 130 patients who presented to an emergency room for blunt chest trauma underwent multidetector row CT of the thorax within the first hour during their stay, and had follow-up CT or bone scans as diagnostic gold standards. Images were evaluated on two separate occasions: once with axial images and once with both axial and coronal images. The detection rates of missed rib fractures were compared between readings using a non-parametric method of clustered data. In the cases of missed rib fractures, the shapes, locations and associated fractures were evaluated. RESULTS: 58 rib fractures were missed with axial images only and 52 were missed with both axial and coronal images (p=0.088). The most common shape of missed rib fractures was buckled (56.9%), and the anterior arc (55.2%) was most commonly involved. 21 (36.2%) missed rib fractures had combined fractures on the same ribs, and 38 (65.5%) were accompanied by fracture on neighbouring ribs. CONCLUSION: Missed rib fractures are not uncommon, and radiologists should be familiar with buckle fractures, which are frequently missed. Additional coronal imagescan be helpful in the diagnosis of rib fractures that are not seen on axial images.
OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study was to review the prevalence and radiological features of rib fractures missed on initial chest CT evaluation, and to examine the diagnostic value of additional coronal images in a large series of traumapatients. METHODS: 130 patients who presented to an emergency room for blunt chest trauma underwent multidetector row CT of the thorax within the first hour during their stay, and had follow-up CT or bone scans as diagnostic gold standards. Images were evaluated on two separate occasions: once with axial images and once with both axial and coronal images. The detection rates of missed rib fractures were compared between readings using a non-parametric method of clustered data. In the cases of missed rib fractures, the shapes, locations and associated fractures were evaluated. RESULTS: 58 rib fractures were missed with axial images only and 52 were missed with both axial and coronal images (p=0.088). The most common shape of missed rib fractures was buckled (56.9%), and the anterior arc (55.2%) was most commonly involved. 21 (36.2%) missed rib fractures had combined fractures on the same ribs, and 38 (65.5%) were accompanied by fracture on neighbouring ribs. CONCLUSION: Missed rib fractures are not uncommon, and radiologists should be familiar with buckle fractures, which are frequently missed. Additional coronal imagescan be helpful in the diagnosis of rib fractures that are not seen on axial images.
Authors: R K Zeman; P M Berman; P M Silverman; W J Davros; C Cooper; A O Kladakis; M N Gomes Journal: AJR Am J Roentgenol Date: 1995-06 Impact factor: 3.959
Authors: B M Thompson; W Finger; D Tonsfeldt; C Aprahamian; P Troiano; G Hendley; J Mateer; H Stueven Journal: Ann Emerg Med Date: 1986-03 Impact factor: 5.721
Authors: Helmut Ringl; Mathias Lazar; Michael Töpker; Ramona Woitek; Helmut Prosch; Ulrika Asenbaum; Csilla Balassy; Daniel Toth; Michael Weber; Stefan Hajdu; Grzegorz Soza; Andreas Wimmer; Thomas Mang Journal: Eur Radiol Date: 2015-02-14 Impact factor: 5.315
Authors: Xavier Tomas; Catherine Facenda; Nuno Vaz; Edgar Augusto Castañeda; Montserrat Del Amo; Ana Isabel Garcia-Diez; Jaime Pomes Journal: Quant Imaging Med Surg Date: 2017-08
Authors: Timothy J Amrhein; William Mostertz; Maria Gisele Matheus; Genevieve Maass-Bolles; Komal Sharma; Heather R Collins; Peter G Kranz Journal: Emerg Radiol Date: 2016-09-12
Authors: Sami K Kishawi; Vanessa P Ho; Katelynn C Bachman; Christine E Alvarado; Stephanie G Worrell; Luis M Argote-Greene; Philip A Linden; Christopher W Towe Journal: J Surg Res Date: 2021-07-27 Impact factor: 2.192