E E Berg1, M E Pollard, Q Kang. 1. New Hampshire Bone & Joint Institute, Bedford, New Hampshire, USA.
Abstract
PURPOSE: To evaluate the healing behavior of an interarticular bone tunnel exposed continuously to a synovial environment. TYPE OF STUDY: Experimental in vivo animal model. METHODS: Twenty-six adult rabbits had 3.2-mm diameter tunnels drilled in the femur and tibia of both hind-limb stifle joints parallel to but without violation of the native anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). The animals were euthanized at 1, 2, 4, and 12 weeks postoperatively. Decalcified sections were made of the bone tunnels and new bone formation was computer quantified using histomorphometric methods at each time interval. RESULTS: In this model, bone tunnel healing velocity was most rapid between 1 and 2 weeks after surgery. Both femoral and tibial interosseous tunnels showed substantial bone ingrowth (71% of bone tunnel volume) by 2 weeks postoperatively. The peripheral tunnel segment, that third of the tunnel furthest from the joint surface, healed rapidly and was 99% occluded with bone (99% confidence interval, 93.7% to 100%) at 2 weeks. Tunnel ingrowth was delayed and incomplete in the articular third of the tunnel, especially the femoral side. At 12 weeks, by volume, only 69.1% (99% confidence interval, 52.3% to 85.7%) of the interarticular third of the femoral tunnel was ingrown with new bone. Peripheral third bone tunnel healing was significantly greater than articular third tunnel healing at all time intervals; P <. 005 for the femoral and P <. 05 for the tibial tunnel. CONCLUSIONS: Interarticular bone tunnels heal from the outside in. At 12 weeks, bone healing was slower and incomplete in the articular segment of the tunnel, closest to the joint surface. The same biologic factors that impede intersubstance ACL healing may interfere with bone tunnel healing and be another cause of bone tunnel enlargement after ACL reconstruction.
PURPOSE: To evaluate the healing behavior of an interarticular bone tunnel exposed continuously to a synovial environment. TYPE OF STUDY: Experimental in vivo animal model. METHODS: Twenty-six adult rabbits had 3.2-mm diameter tunnels drilled in the femur and tibia of both hind-limb stifle joints parallel to but without violation of the native anterior cruciate ligament (ACL). The animals were euthanized at 1, 2, 4, and 12 weeks postoperatively. Decalcified sections were made of the bone tunnels and new bone formation was computer quantified using histomorphometric methods at each time interval. RESULTS: In this model, bone tunnel healing velocity was most rapid between 1 and 2 weeks after surgery. Both femoral and tibial interosseous tunnels showed substantial bone ingrowth (71% of bone tunnel volume) by 2 weeks postoperatively. The peripheral tunnel segment, that third of the tunnel furthest from the joint surface, healed rapidly and was 99% occluded with bone (99% confidence interval, 93.7% to 100%) at 2 weeks. Tunnel ingrowth was delayed and incomplete in the articular third of the tunnel, especially the femoral side. At 12 weeks, by volume, only 69.1% (99% confidence interval, 52.3% to 85.7%) of the interarticular third of the femoral tunnel was ingrown with new bone. Peripheral third bone tunnel healing was significantly greater than articular third tunnel healing at all time intervals; P <. 005 for the femoral and P <. 05 for the tibial tunnel. CONCLUSIONS: Interarticular bone tunnels heal from the outside in. At 12 weeks, bone healing was slower and incomplete in the articular segment of the tunnel, closest to the joint surface. The same biologic factors that impede intersubstance ACL healing may interfere with bone tunnel healing and be another cause of bone tunnel enlargement after ACL reconstruction.
Authors: S P Zysk; P Fraunberger; A Veihelmann; M Dörger; T Kalteis; M Maier; C Pellengahr; H J Refior Journal: Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc Date: 2003-09-20 Impact factor: 4.342