PURPOSE OF THE STUDY: Little is known about the impact of posterolateral arthrodesis on adjacent levels. In order to examine this question, we analyzed the radiological evolution of the lumbar spine in patients treated for lumbar stenosis, comparing cases where posterolateral arthrodesis was used with the other cases. Our aim was to determine whether the long-term radiographical modifications were affected by the arthrodesis. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Among our series of patients presenting with lumbar stenosis between 1984 and 1992, we retained two groups: patients in group 1 (n=46) who underwent single-level decompressions at L4-L5 or L4-L5 and L5-S1 level; and patients in group II (n=81) who underwent decompressions on the same levels associated with posterolateral arthrodesis extending from L4 to the sacrum with or without instrumentation. We compared the course of the two levels above the decompression (L2-L3 and L3-L4) between the two groups. We compared three radiological parameters: disc height, intervertebral slipping, and intersegmental mobility. We also examined the correlations between radiological modifications and functional outcome. Mean follow-up for these 127 patients was 9 years. RESULTS: The two groups were comparable for age, gender, follow-up, and presurgical functional score, disc height and intervertebral slipping at equivalent levels. At last follow-up, disc narrowing was observed at L2-L3 and L3-L4; it was significantly greater in the group with complementary arthrodesis. At L3-L4, intervertebral slipping also worsened more in the arthrodesis patients. Use of osteosynthesis significantly increased the risk of developing such radiological lesions. These lesions were associated, solely in the arthrodesis group, with poorer functional outcome. CONCLUSION: Our findings allow the conclusion that, despite the effect of physiological aging, the observed long-term degenerative lesions in patients undergoing treatment of lumbar stenosis are related to the associated arthrodesis which increases their frequency and severity, deteriorating the functional outcome.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY: Little is known about the impact of posterolateral arthrodesis on adjacent levels. In order to examine this question, we analyzed the radiological evolution of the lumbar spine in patients treated for lumbar stenosis, comparing cases where posterolateral arthrodesis was used with the other cases. Our aim was to determine whether the long-term radiographical modifications were affected by the arthrodesis. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Among our series of patients presenting with lumbar stenosis between 1984 and 1992, we retained two groups: patients in group 1 (n=46) who underwent single-level decompressions at L4-L5 or L4-L5 and L5-S1 level; and patients in group II (n=81) who underwent decompressions on the same levels associated with posterolateral arthrodesis extending from L4 to the sacrum with or without instrumentation. We compared the course of the two levels above the decompression (L2-L3 and L3-L4) between the two groups. We compared three radiological parameters: disc height, intervertebral slipping, and intersegmental mobility. We also examined the correlations between radiological modifications and functional outcome. Mean follow-up for these 127 patients was 9 years. RESULTS: The two groups were comparable for age, gender, follow-up, and presurgical functional score, disc height and intervertebral slipping at equivalent levels. At last follow-up, disc narrowing was observed at L2-L3 and L3-L4; it was significantly greater in the group with complementary arthrodesis. At L3-L4, intervertebral slipping also worsened more in the arthrodesis patients. Use of osteosynthesis significantly increased the risk of developing such radiological lesions. These lesions were associated, solely in the arthrodesis group, with poorer functional outcome. CONCLUSION: Our findings allow the conclusion that, despite the effect of physiological aging, the observed long-term degenerative lesions in patients undergoing treatment of lumbar stenosis are related to the associated arthrodesis which increases their frequency and severity, deteriorating the functional outcome.
Authors: Ranjith Babu; Jong G Park; Ankit I Mehta; Tony Shan; Peter M Grossi; Christopher R Brown; William J Richardson; Robert E Isaacs; Carlos A Bagley; Maragatha Kuchibhatla; Oren N Gottfried Journal: Neurosurgery Date: 2012-11 Impact factor: 4.654
Authors: Jeffrey D Coe; Scott H Kitchel; Hans Jörg Meisel; Charles H Wingo; Soo Eon Lee; Tae-Ahn Jahng Journal: J Korean Neurosurg Soc Date: 2012-06-30