| Literature DB >> 35967139 |
Arani Das1, Manoj Prithviraj2, Palani Selvam Mohanraj3.
Abstract
Recent evidence links melatonin hormone and its receptor to the etiology and behavioral manifestation of addiction. The role of exogenous melatonin in addiction treatment is still inconsistent and unclear. The present study aimed to review the literature on randomized clinical trials that evaluated the role of melatonin supplementation, compared to placebo, in the treatment of various substance addictions. The literature searches of relevant articles published in the English language in MEDLINE and Google Scholar databases were performed from inception up to May 2021. We included only randomized clinical trials investigating the effect of melatonin treatment, compared to placebo, on substance addiction-related parameters. Non-randomized clinical trials, observation studies, and animal studies were excluded. The risk of bias-2 was used to assess the quality of the studies. Of 537 articles, 12 randomized control trials (RCT) met our inclusion criteria. Studies have been conducted on substances of addiction including benzodiazepine (BZD), alcohol, nicotine, and opioids. Our results indicated that melatonin treatment had mixed results in improving sleep quality and was not found beneficial in BDZ cessation/discontinuation rate among patients with BDZ dependence. Sleep quality and mental health had improved by melatonin supplements in opioid addiction. In nicotine addiction, melatonin treatment showed effectiveness only on mood changes but not in performance tests. In patients with alcohol use disorder (AUD), melatonin treatment did not show any improvement in sleep quality. We found that the use of exogenous melatonin in substance addiction has mixed results which do not provide sufficient evidence, relative to randomized clinical trials, to establish its role.Entities:
Keywords: addiction; benzodiazepine; melatonin; sleep disturbance; substance abuse
Year: 2022 PMID: 35967139 PMCID: PMC9366042 DOI: 10.7759/cureus.26764
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Cureus ISSN: 2168-8184
Figure 1Risk of Bias summary for included studies
Figure 2Risk of Bias graph for included studies
Figure 3PRISMA flow diagram
PRISMA: Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses
Basic characteristics of included studies
*Data are presented as mean ± SD or median (range).
BZD: benzodiazepine; RCT: randomized control trial; I: intervention group; C: placebo group, MMT: methadone maintenance treatment
| Reference | Country | Population | Substance abuse | Sample size total (I/C) | Age, years* | Gender | Design |
| Baandrup et al. [ | Denmark | Schizophrenia or bipolar disorder | BZD | 80 (40/40) | I: 47.4 ± 8.6 C: 49 ± 12.1 | I: M21, F 19 C: M 24, F16 | RCT |
| Grafinkel et al. [ | Israel | Insomnia | BZD | 34 (18/16) | I: 69 ±11 C: 68 ±16 | I: M14, F4 C: M 11, F5 | RCT |
| Lähteenmäki et al. [ | Finland | Insomnia with long-term BZD use | BZD | 92 (46/46) | I: 66.5 (61- 72) C: 65 (60-70) | I: M19, F 27 C:M 12, F34 | RCT |
| Baandrup et al. [ | Denmark | Schizophrenia or bipolar disorder | BZD | 55 (28/27) | I: 48.8 ± 7.1 C: 49.1 ± 12.2 | I: M14, F14 C: M15, F12 | RCT |
| Gendy et al. [ | Canada | Alcohol use disorder with Insomnia | Alcohol | 60 (30/30) | Not mentioned | I: M23, F7 C: M23, F7 | RCT |
| Zhdanova and Piotrovskaya [ | USA | Smoker (20 cigarettes per day) | Nicotine | 12 | 27.9 ± 3.8 | M6, F6 | RCT, crossover |
| Peles et al. [ | Israel | BZD withdrawal in MMT | BZD | 80 (40/40) | 42.6 ± 1.2 | M56, F24 | RCT, crossover |
| Ghaderi et al. [ | Iran | MMT | Opioid | 54 (26/28) | 25-70 | M54 | RCT |
| Garzón et al. [ | Spain | Insomnia | BZD | 22 | >65 | M7, F15 | RCT, crossover |
| Baandrup et al. [ | Denmark | Schizophrenia or bipolar disorder with long-term BZD use | BZD | 86 (42/44) | 21-74 | I: M23, F19 C: M25, F19 | RCT |
| Baandrup et al. [ | Denmark | Schizophrenia or bipolar disorder with long-term BZD use | BZD | 48 (20/28) | I: 47.7 ± 8.2 C: 45.9 ± 10.3) | I: M 11, F 9 C: M18, F10 | RCT |
| Cardinali et al. [ | Argentina | Insomnia with long-term BZD use | BZD | 45 (24/21) | I: 70.1 ± 16.8 C: 71.0 ± 7.3 | I: M 5, F 19 C: M4, F17 | RCT |
Details of melatonin intervention
PRM: prolonged-release melatonin; CRM: controlled-release melatonin; IRM: immediate-release melatonin; I: intervention group; C: placebo group
| Reference | Melatonin dosage | Administration | Treatment Duration | Follow-up duration |
| Baandrup et al. [ | 2-mg CRM | Once daily | 12 weeks | 6 months |
| Grafinkel et al. [ | 2-mg CRM | Once daily | 12 weeks | 6 months |
| Lähteenmäki et al. [ | 2-mg CRM | Once daily | 4 weeks | 5 months |
| Baandrup et al. [ | 2 mg PRM | Once daily | 24 weeks | No follow-up |
| Gendy et al. [ | 5 mg | Once daily | 4 weeks | No follow-up |
| Zhdanova et al. [ | 0.3 mg | Single dose | 2 day (I: 1 day, C: 1 day) | No follow-up |
| Peles et al. [ | 5 mg | Once daily | 12 weeks (I: 6 weeks, C: 6 weeks) | No follow-up |
| Ghaderi et al. [ | 10 mg | Once daily | 12 weeks | No follow-up |
| Garzón et al. [ | 5 mg | Once daily | 4 months (I: 2months, C: 2months) | No follow-up |
| Baandrup et al. [ | 2 mg | Once daily | 24 weeks | No follow-up |
| Baandrup et al. [ | 2-mg PRM | Once daily | 24 weeks | No follow-up |
| Cardinali et al. [ | 3 mg IRM | Once daily | 6 weeks | No follow-up |
Study outcome and main findings
BACS: brief assessment of cognition in schizophrenia; BWSQ: benzodiazepine withdrawal symptom questionnaire; PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index; BDI: Beck Depression Inventory; BAI: Beck Anxiety Inventory; VAS: visual analog scale; FCRT: four-choice reaction time; SART: simple auditory reaction time; CES-D: Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale; NHSMI: Northside Hospital Sleep Medicine Institute test; GDS: Geriatric Depression Scale; GAS: Goldberg Anxiety Scale
| Reference | Outcome | Main findings |
| Baandrup et al. [ | Global cognitive performance (BACS), quality of life (WHO-five well-being index), subjective well-being (neuroleptic treatment scale), and psychological functioning (personal and social performance scale) | Melatonin did not show any additional effect on cognition, quality of life, subjective well-being, and psychosocial functioning during BDZ dose reduction |
| Grafinkel et al. [ | Benzodiazepine discontinuation rate and Subjective sleep-quality score | Melatonin facilitated discontinuation of BDZ usage and improved subjective sleep quality compared to placebo |
| Lähteenmäki et al. [ | Benzodiazepine abstinence rate, Reduction of BZD usage, and BZD withdrawal symptoms (BWSQ) | Melatonin did not show any superior effect over the placebo |
| Baandrup et al. [ | Sleep efficiency (polysomnography) and sleep quality (PSQI global score) | Melatonin did not affect sleep efficiency but improved sleep quality |
| Gendy et al. [ | Sleep quality (PSQI), depression (BDI), anxiety (BAI) | Melatonin did not show any improvement in sleep quality, depression, or anxiety scores over the placebo group |
| Zhdanova et al. [ | Self-reported ratings of mood, sleepiness, and cigarette craving using 17 VAS and performance tests (FCRT and SART) | Melatonin improved VAS ratings of mood, sleepiness, and cigarette craving but did not show improvement on the performance test. |
| Peles et al. [ | Sleep quality (PSQI), depression (CES-D) | Melatonin did not show any improvement in sleep quality and depression score |
| Ghaderi et al. [ | Sleep quality (PSQI), depression (BDI), anxiety (BAI), erectile functions, and metabolic profile | Melatonin supplement showed beneficial effects on sleep quality, depression, anxiety, erectile functions, and metabolic profile |
| Garzón et al. [ | Sleep quality (NHSMI), depression (GDS), and anxiety (GAS) | Melatonin improved sleep quality, depression, and anxiety scores |
| Baandrup et al. [ | Benzodiazepine dosage, cessation rate, and benzodiazepine withdrawal symptoms (BWSQ-2) | Melatonin did not affect the reduction of benzodiazepine dosage, cessation rate, and benzodiazepine withdrawal symptoms |
| Baandrup et al. [ | Circadian rest-activity cycles (actigraphy measurement) | Melatonin stabilizes circadian rest-activity cycles during benzodiazepine discontinuation |
| Cardinali et al. [ | Sleep quality (quality of morning freshness, daily alertness, sleep quality and readiness to fall asleep, daily sleep onset and offset time) | Melatonin did not show any effect on sleep quality |