| Literature DB >> 35807843 |
David C Noriega-González1, Franchek Drobnic2, Alberto Caballero-García3, Enrique Roche4,5,6, Daniel Perez-Valdecantos7, Alfredo Córdova7.
Abstract
Tendinopathies represent 30-50% of all sports injuries. The tendon response is influenced by the load (volume, intensity, and frequency) that the tendon support, resulting in irritability and pain, among others. The main molecular component of tendons is collagen I (60-85%). The rest consist of glycosaminoglycans-proteoglycans, glycoproteins, and other collagen subtypes. This study's aim was to critically evaluate the efficacy of vitamin C supplementation in the treatment of tendinopathies. At the same time, the study aims to determine the optimal conditions (dose and time) for vitamin C supplementation. A structured search was carried out in the SCOPUS, Medline (PubMed), and Web of Science (WOS) databases. The inclusion criteria took into account studies describing optimal tendon recovery when using vitamin C alone or in combination with other compounds. The study design was considered, including randomized, double-blind controlled, and parallel designs in animal models or humans. The main outcome is that vitamin C supplementation is potentially useful as a therapeutic approach for tendinopathy recovery. Vitamin C supplementation, alone or in combination with other products, increases collagen synthesis with a consequent improvement in the patient's condition. On the other hand, vitamin C deficiency is mainly associated with a decrease in procollagen synthesis and reduced hydroxylation of proline and lysine residues, hindering the tendon repair process.Entities:
Keywords: ascorbic acid; collagen; oxidative stress; tendinopathy; vitamin C
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35807843 PMCID: PMC9267994 DOI: 10.3390/nu14132663
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nutrients ISSN: 2072-6643 Impact factor: 6.706
Figure 1Risk of bias assessment of included studies [3,8,45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58].
Inclusion criteria for study selection.
| Main Criteria | Details |
|---|---|
| Use of vitamin C | Alone or as a supplement with other products |
| Therapeutic results | Restoration of tendon tissue |
| Methodology | Study design: randomized/double-blind controlled/parallel |
| Language | Only in English |
Figure 2Full search strategy to develop the systematic review.
Studies evaluating the effect of vitamin C in humans.
| Reference | Compounds/Intervention | VC Dosage | Route | d | Placebo/Control | Sample/Gender/Sport Practice | Site/Cause of Injury | Tests | Impact on Resolution | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arquer et al. [ | VC, collagen I, MCPg | 60 mg | Oral | 90 | - | 70 | Human | Elbow, Achilles, Knee tendinopathy | VISA-A, VISA-P, PRTEE, US | ⊕ VISA-A, VISA-P, PRTEE ( | |
| Notarmicola et al. [ | Arginine & combination of VC, MSM, collagen, bromelain/Shock wave T | 60 mg | Oral | 60 & 180 | Placebo | 32 | Human | VAS, Ankle-Hindfoot Scale Roles | ⊕ Ankle food scale, ≈ VAS, Better PS | ||
| Balius et al. [ | VC, collagen I, MCPg/Passive stretching or Eccentric exercise | 60 mg | Oral | 84 | - | 59 | Human | Achilles tendinopathy | VISA-A, US | ⊕ VISA-A, Pain perception ( | |
| Shaw et al. [ | VC | 48 mg VC + 5 g Gelatin | Culture media | 3 | Control | 8 | In vitro/Human tissue | Ligament | Histology and biomechanical tests | ⊕ Biomechanical properties ( | - |
| 48 mg VC + 15 g Gelatin | 8 | ⊕ Collagen I, ( | |||||||||
| Martel et al. [ | VC | 500 mg | Oral | 45 | Control | 98 | Human | Rotator cuff arthroscopy repair | ⊕ Tendency to a better repair. ⊕ Oximetry | ||
Symbols and abbreviations used: ⊕: effective; ≈: ineffective; AA: amino acids; d: days; F: females; M: males; MCPg: mucopolygel; MSM: methylsulfonylmethane; NS: non-specified; PRTEE: Patient-Rated Tennis Elbow Evaluation; PS: patient satisfaction; US: Ultrasound; VISA-A: Analog Visual Scale-Achilles; VISA-P: Analog Visual Scale-Patella; VAS: visual analog scale; VC: vitamin C.
Studies evaluating the effect of vitamin C in animal models.
| Reference | Compounds | VC Dosage | Route | Days | Placebo/Control |
| Animal | Injury | Tests | Impact on Resolution | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ömeroğlu et al. [ | VC | 150 mg– | Peritoneal injection all days | 3–10–21 | Control | 42 | Rodents | Achilles C/R | Histology | ⊕ Collagen I, fiber diameter and alignment, Better initial angiogenesis ( | |
| Hung et al. [ | VC | 5 mg/mL | Local injection | 1 | Control | 22 | Chicken | FxDP C/R | Histology and biomechanical tests | ⊕ GSH ( | ⊕ Fibrotic size ( |
| 50 mg/mL | 22 | - | |||||||||
| Lui et al. [ | VC | - | Transplant pretreated connective tissue | 14 | Control | 153 | Rodents | Patellar tendon C/R | Histology, US, CT imaging, and biomechanical tests | ⊕ Cellularity, ⊕ Collagen fibers alignment ⊕ Ossified depot. ( | |
| Kang et al. [ | VC | 1.5 g/L | “ad libitum” | 28 | Control | 7 | Rodents | Achilles tendonitis | Histology, BS | Second Better BS, ⊕ Serum VC | |
| VC ASC | “ad libitum” & Local Injection (ASC) | 7 | ⊕ BS, ⊕ Serum VC ( | ||||||||
| ASC | - | Local Injection (ASC) | 7 | BS better than control group ( | |||||||
| Dincel et al. [ | Hyaluronic acid | 0.075 mg/kg | Local injection | 1 | Control | 16 | Rodents | Achilles C/R | BS, Moving Test, Histology, and biomechanical tests | ⊕ BS | ⊕ Mean force day 15th ( |
| VC | 150 mg | Peritoneal alternate days | 15 & 30 | 16 | ⊕ Mean forcé day 30th ( | ||||||
| Gemalmaz et al. [ | VC | 7.2 mg/kg | Gastric lavage | 21 | Placebo | 16 | Rodents | Achilles C/R | Histology and biomechanical tests | ⊕ PCNA, ⊕TGF-β1 (endotendon). ⊕ biomechanical properties, collagen strength ( | |
| Morikawa et al. [ | VC | 1% | “ad libitum” | 56 | Control | 56 | Rodents | Rotator cuff | Histology | ⊕ histologic changes | |
| Souza et al. [ | VC | ≈0.21 mg (a) | Local injection alternate days | Until days 12 & 20 | Control | 6 | Rodents | Achilles C/R | Histology | ⊕ Achilles function index, | |
| Turkmen et al. [ | VC | ≈0.15 mg (b) | Gastric lavage | Placebo | 20 | Rodents | Achilles C/R | Histology and biomechanical tests | Optimal alignment in collagen fibers, | ||
| Çelik et al. [ | VC | - | Healing clots | 1 | Control | 20 | Rodents | Achilles C/R | Histology and biomechanical tests | ⊕ histologic changes, ⊕ Strength, ⊕ FGF, ⊕ VEGF ( | |
| Oliva et al. [ | VC, BMSC, and T3, alone and in multiple combinations | ≈2.5 μg (c) | Local injection | 1, 2 & 4 | Control | 24 | Rodents | Achilles C/R | Histology | The combination Vitamin C + T3: ⊕ fiber alignment, ( | |
Symbols and abbreviations used: ⊕: effective; ≈: ineffective; ASC: adipose-tissue stem cells; BMSC: bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells; BS: bone score; C/R: cut and repair; CT: Computed Tomography; CTGF: connective tissue growth factor; FGF: Fibroblast Growth Factor; FxDP: flexor digitoris profundus; GSH: reduced glutathione; GSSG: oxidized glutathione; MCPg: mucopolygel; PCNA: proliferating cell nuclear antigen; T3: triiodothyronine; TGF-β1: tansforming growth factor beta 1; TDSC: tendon-derived stem cells; TGF-β1: transforming growth factor-β1; US: Ultrasound; VC: vitamin C; BMSC: bone marrow stromal cell; T3: triiodothyronine; VEGF: vascular Endothelial Growth Factor. (a): 40 μL (30 mM) ≈ 0.21 mg VC; (b): 3 mg Retendo ≈ 0.15 mg VC; (c): 50 μg/mL ≈ 2.5 μg VC. In general, tendon injury occurs together with antioxidant depletion. This could be explained due to the presence of oxidative stress during fibrogenesis because fibroblasts can generate ROS during the phagocytic phase that occurs at the beginning of tendon injury [59]. In this line, decreased levels of GSH, one of the mains intracellular antioxidants, have been reported in a chicken model of tendon adhesion in healing [8]. GSH decrease is accompanied by increases in the oxidized form of glutathione (GSSG). Local injection of VC post-injury at different doses (5 and 50 mg/mL) in chickens reduced the degree of tendon adhesion in healing. In this report [8], 5 mg/mL of VC seems to work better than 50 after 2 weeks. In any case, VC injection was better than using saline solution. However, no significant changes were reported in GSSG after VC injection. Altogether, these results suggest that restrictor adhesion formation may be associated with altered redox modulation. Similar intervention in a rat model seems to support the role of VC in tendinopathy treatment. In this context, local injection of a high dose of VC (150 mg daily) accelerates the healing of the Achilles tendon [3], indicating that local treatment with VC promotes the histological and functional recovery of ruptured Achilles tendons [55]. Moreover, other studies have shown that local inhibition of nitric oxide synthase (NOS) accelerates tendon recovery in tenotomised rats. The positive effect of NOS inhibition on tendon repair demonstrates that nitric oxide (NO) negatively regulates tissue recovery [54]. Altogether, the presented evidence suggests that VC can favor tendon recovery by acting against oxidative stress that occurs in tendon degeneration.