Jianfeng Xu1,2, W Kyle Resurreccion3, Zhuqing Shi3, Jun Wei3, Chi-Hsiung Wang3, S Lilly Zheng3,4, Peter J Hulick5, Ashley E Ross6, Christian P Pavlovich7, Brian T Helfand3,4, William B Isaacs7. 1. Program for Personalized Cancer Care, NorthShore University HealthSystem, Evanston, IL, USA. jxu8088@gmail.com. 2. Department of Surgery, NorthShore University HealthSystem, Evanston, IL, USA. jxu8088@gmail.com. 3. Program for Personalized Cancer Care, NorthShore University HealthSystem, Evanston, IL, USA. 4. Department of Surgery, NorthShore University HealthSystem, Evanston, IL, USA. 5. Department of Medicine, NorthShore University HealthSystem, Evanston, IL, USA. 6. Department of Urology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, USA. 7. The Brady Urological Institute, The Johns Hopkins School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Many studies on prostate cancer (PCa) germline variants have been published in the last 15 years. This review critically assesses their clinical validity and explores their utility in prediction of PCa detection rates from prostate biopsy. METHODS: An integrative review was performed to (1) critically synthesize findings on PCa germline studies from published papers since 2016, including risk-associated single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), polygenic risk score methods such as genetic risk score (GRS), and rare pathogenic mutations (RPMs); (2) exemplify the findings in a large population-based cohort from the UK Biobank (UKB); (3) identify gaps for implementing inherited risk assessment in clinic based on experience from a healthcare system; (4) evaluate available GRS data on their clinical utility in predicting PCa detection rates from prostate biopsies; and (5) describe a prospective germline-based biopsy trial to address existing gaps. RESULTS: SNP-based GRS and RPMs in four genes (HOXB13, BRCA2, ATM, and CHEK2) were significantly and consistently associated with PCa risk in large well-designed studies. In the UKB, positive family history, RPMs in the four implicated genes, and a high GRS (>1.5) identified 8.12%, 1.61%, and 17.38% of men to be at elevated PCa risk, respectively, with hazard ratios of 1.84, 2.74, and 2.39, respectively. Additionally, the performance of GRS for predicting PCa detection rate on prostate biopsy was consistently supported in several retrospective analyses of transrectal ultrasound (TRUS)-biopsy cohorts. Prospective studies evaluating the performance of all three inherited measures in predicting PCa detection rate from contemporary multiparametric MRI (mpMRI)-based biopsy are lacking. A multicenter germline-based biopsy trial to address these gaps is warranted. CONCLUSIONS: The complementary performance of three inherited risk measures in PCa risk stratification is consistently supported. Their clinical utility in predicting PCa detection rate, if confirmed in prospective clinical trials, may improve current decision-making for prostate biopsy.
BACKGROUND: Many studies on prostate cancer (PCa) germline variants have been published in the last 15 years. This review critically assesses their clinical validity and explores their utility in prediction of PCa detection rates from prostate biopsy. METHODS: An integrative review was performed to (1) critically synthesize findings on PCa germline studies from published papers since 2016, including risk-associated single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), polygenic risk score methods such as genetic risk score (GRS), and rare pathogenic mutations (RPMs); (2) exemplify the findings in a large population-based cohort from the UK Biobank (UKB); (3) identify gaps for implementing inherited risk assessment in clinic based on experience from a healthcare system; (4) evaluate available GRS data on their clinical utility in predicting PCa detection rates from prostate biopsies; and (5) describe a prospective germline-based biopsy trial to address existing gaps. RESULTS: SNP-based GRS and RPMs in four genes (HOXB13, BRCA2, ATM, and CHEK2) were significantly and consistently associated with PCa risk in large well-designed studies. In the UKB, positive family history, RPMs in the four implicated genes, and a high GRS (>1.5) identified 8.12%, 1.61%, and 17.38% of men to be at elevated PCa risk, respectively, with hazard ratios of 1.84, 2.74, and 2.39, respectively. Additionally, the performance of GRS for predicting PCa detection rate on prostate biopsy was consistently supported in several retrospective analyses of transrectal ultrasound (TRUS)-biopsy cohorts. Prospective studies evaluating the performance of all three inherited measures in predicting PCa detection rate from contemporary multiparametric MRI (mpMRI)-based biopsy are lacking. A multicenter germline-based biopsy trial to address these gaps is warranted. CONCLUSIONS: The complementary performance of three inherited risk measures in PCa risk stratification is consistently supported. Their clinical utility in predicting PCa detection rate, if confirmed in prospective clinical trials, may improve current decision-making for prostate biopsy.
Authors: Laufey T Amundadottir; Patrick Sulem; Julius Gudmundsson; Agnar Helgason; Adam Baker; Bjarni A Agnarsson; Asgeir Sigurdsson; Kristrun R Benediktsdottir; Jean-Baptiste Cazier; Jesus Sainz; Margret Jakobsdottir; Jelena Kostic; Droplaug N Magnusdottir; Shyamali Ghosh; Kari Agnarsson; Birgitta Birgisdottir; Louise Le Roux; Adalheidur Olafsdottir; Thorarinn Blondal; Margret Andresdottir; Olafia Svandis Gretarsdottir; Jon T Bergthorsson; Daniel Gudbjartsson; Arnaldur Gylfason; Gudmar Thorleifsson; Andrei Manolescu; Kristleifur Kristjansson; Gudmundur Geirsson; Helgi Isaksson; Julie Douglas; Jan-Erik Johansson; Katarina Bälter; Fredrik Wiklund; James E Montie; Xiaoying Yu; Brian K Suarez; Carole Ober; Kathleen A Cooney; Henrik Gronberg; William J Catalona; Gudmundur V Einarsson; Rosa B Barkardottir; Jeffrey R Gulcher; Augustine Kong; Unnur Thorsteinsdottir; Kari Stefansson Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2006-05-07 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Julius Gudmundsson; Patrick Sulem; Valgerdur Steinthorsdottir; Jon T Bergthorsson; Gudmar Thorleifsson; Andrei Manolescu; Thorunn Rafnar; Daniel Gudbjartsson; Bjarni A Agnarsson; Adam Baker; Asgeir Sigurdsson; Kristrun R Benediktsdottir; Margret Jakobsdottir; Thorarinn Blondal; Simon N Stacey; Agnar Helgason; Steinunn Gunnarsdottir; Adalheidur Olafsdottir; Kari T Kristinsson; Birgitta Birgisdottir; Shyamali Ghosh; Steinunn Thorlacius; Dana Magnusdottir; Gerdur Stefansdottir; Kristleifur Kristjansson; Yu Bagger; Robert L Wilensky; Muredach P Reilly; Andrew D Morris; Charlotte H Kimber; Adebowale Adeyemo; Yuanxiu Chen; Jie Zhou; Wing-Yee So; Peter C Y Tong; Maggie C Y Ng; Torben Hansen; Gitte Andersen; Knut Borch-Johnsen; Torben Jorgensen; Alejandro Tres; Fernando Fuertes; Manuel Ruiz-Echarri; Laura Asin; Berta Saez; Erica van Boven; Siem Klaver; Dorine W Swinkels; Katja K Aben; Theresa Graif; John Cashy; Brian K Suarez; Onco van Vierssen Trip; Michael L Frigge; Carole Ober; Marten H Hofker; Cisca Wijmenga; Claus Christiansen; Daniel J Rader; Colin N A Palmer; Charles Rotimi; Juliana C N Chan; Oluf Pedersen; Gunnar Sigurdsson; Rafn Benediktsson; Eirikur Jonsson; Gudmundur V Einarsson; Jose I Mayordomo; William J Catalona; Lambertus A Kiemeney; Rosa B Barkardottir; Jeffrey R Gulcher; Unnur Thorsteinsdottir; Augustine Kong; Kari Stefansson Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2007-07-01 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Julius Gudmundsson; Patrick Sulem; Thorunn Rafnar; Jon T Bergthorsson; Andrei Manolescu; Daniel Gudbjartsson; Bjarni A Agnarsson; Asgeir Sigurdsson; Kristrun R Benediktsdottir; Thorarinn Blondal; Margret Jakobsdottir; Simon N Stacey; Jelena Kostic; Kari T Kristinsson; Birgitta Birgisdottir; Shyamali Ghosh; Droplaug N Magnusdottir; Steinunn Thorlacius; Gudmar Thorleifsson; S Lilly Zheng; Jielin Sun; Bao-Li Chang; J Bradford Elmore; Joan P Breyer; Kate M McReynolds; Kevin M Bradley; Brian L Yaspan; Fredrik Wiklund; Par Stattin; Sara Lindström; Hans-Olov Adami; Shannon K McDonnell; Daniel J Schaid; Julie M Cunningham; Liang Wang; James R Cerhan; Jennifer L St Sauver; Sara D Isaacs; Kathleen E Wiley; Alan W Partin; Patrick C Walsh; Sonia Polo; Manuel Ruiz-Echarri; Sebastian Navarrete; Fernando Fuertes; Berta Saez; Javier Godino; Philip C Weijerman; Dorine W Swinkels; Katja K Aben; J Alfred Witjes; Brian K Suarez; Brian T Helfand; Michael L Frigge; Kristleifur Kristjansson; Carole Ober; Eirikur Jonsson; Gudmundur V Einarsson; Jianfeng Xu; Henrik Gronberg; Jeffrey R Smith; Stephen N Thibodeau; William B Isaacs; William J Catalona; Jose I Mayordomo; Lambertus A Kiemeney; Rosa B Barkardottir; Jeffrey R Gulcher; Unnur Thorsteinsdottir; Augustine Kong; Kari Stefansson Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2008-02-10 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Ali Amin Al Olama; Zsofia Kote-Jarai; Graham G Giles; Michelle Guy; Jonathan Morrison; Gianluca Severi; Daniel A Leongamornlert; Malgorzata Tymrakiewicz; Sameer Jhavar; Ed Saunders; John L Hopper; Melissa C Southey; Kenneth R Muir; Dallas R English; David P Dearnaley; Audrey T Ardern-Jones; Amanda L Hall; Lynne T O'Brien; Rosemary A Wilkinson; Emma Sawyer; Artitaya Lophatananon; Alan Horwich; Robert A Huddart; Vincent S Khoo; Christopher C Parker; Christopher J Woodhouse; Alan Thompson; Tim Christmas; Chris Ogden; Colin Cooper; Jenny L Donovan; Freddie C Hamdy; David E Neal; Rosalind A Eeles; Douglas F Easton Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2009-09-20 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Julius Gudmundsson; Patrick Sulem; Andrei Manolescu; Laufey T Amundadottir; Daniel Gudbjartsson; Agnar Helgason; Thorunn Rafnar; Jon T Bergthorsson; Bjarni A Agnarsson; Adam Baker; Asgeir Sigurdsson; Kristrun R Benediktsdottir; Margret Jakobsdottir; Jianfeng Xu; Thorarinn Blondal; Jelena Kostic; Jielin Sun; Shyamali Ghosh; Simon N Stacey; Magali Mouy; Jona Saemundsdottir; Valgerdur M Backman; Kristleifur Kristjansson; Alejandro Tres; Alan W Partin; Marjo T Albers-Akkers; Javier Godino-Ivan Marcos; Patrick C Walsh; Dorine W Swinkels; Sebastian Navarrete; Sarah D Isaacs; Katja K Aben; Theresa Graif; John Cashy; Manuel Ruiz-Echarri; Kathleen E Wiley; Brian K Suarez; J Alfred Witjes; Mike Frigge; Carole Ober; Eirikur Jonsson; Gudmundur V Einarsson; Jose I Mayordomo; Lambertus A Kiemeney; William B Isaacs; William J Catalona; Rosa B Barkardottir; Jeffrey R Gulcher; Unnur Thorsteinsdottir; Augustine Kong; Kari Stefansson Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2007-04-01 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Meredith Yeager; Nick Orr; Richard B Hayes; Kevin B Jacobs; Peter Kraft; Sholom Wacholder; Mark J Minichiello; Paul Fearnhead; Kai Yu; Nilanjan Chatterjee; Zhaoming Wang; Robert Welch; Brian J Staats; Eugenia E Calle; Heather Spencer Feigelson; Michael J Thun; Carmen Rodriguez; Demetrius Albanes; Jarmo Virtamo; Stephanie Weinstein; Fredrick R Schumacher; Edward Giovannucci; Walter C Willett; Geraldine Cancel-Tassin; Olivier Cussenot; Antoine Valeri; Gerald L Andriole; Edward P Gelmann; Margaret Tucker; Daniela S Gerhard; Joseph F Fraumeni; Robert Hoover; David J Hunter; Stephen J Chanock; Gilles Thomas Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2007-04-01 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Jielin Sun; Siqun Lilly Zheng; Fredrik Wiklund; Sarah D Isaacs; Lina D Purcell; Zhengrong Gao; Fang-Chi Hsu; Seong-Tae Kim; Wennuan Liu; Yi Zhu; Pär Stattin; Hans-Olov Adami; Kathleen E Wiley; Latchezar Dimitrov; Jishan Sun; Tao Li; Aubrey R Turner; Tamara S Adams; Jan Adolfsson; Jan-Erik Johansson; James Lowey; Bruce J Trock; Alan W Partin; Patrick C Walsh; Jeffrey M Trent; David Duggan; John Carpten; Bao-Li Chang; Henrik Grönberg; William B Isaacs; Jianfeng Xu Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2008-08-31 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Rosalind A Eeles; Zsofia Kote-Jarai; Graham G Giles; Ali Amin Al Olama; Michelle Guy; Sarah K Jugurnauth; Shani Mulholland; Daniel A Leongamornlert; Stephen M Edwards; Jonathan Morrison; Helen I Field; Melissa C Southey; Gianluca Severi; Jenny L Donovan; Freddie C Hamdy; David P Dearnaley; Kenneth R Muir; Charmaine Smith; Melisa Bagnato; Audrey T Ardern-Jones; Amanda L Hall; Lynne T O'Brien; Beatrice N Gehr-Swain; Rosemary A Wilkinson; Angie Cox; Sarah Lewis; Paul M Brown; Sameer G Jhavar; Malgorzata Tymrakiewicz; Artitaya Lophatananon; Sarah L Bryant; Alan Horwich; Robert A Huddart; Vincent S Khoo; Christopher C Parker; Christopher J Woodhouse; Alan Thompson; Tim Christmas; Chris Ogden; Cyril Fisher; Charles Jamieson; Colin S Cooper; Dallas R English; John L Hopper; David E Neal; Douglas F Easton Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2008-02-10 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Gilles Thomas; Kevin B Jacobs; Meredith Yeager; Peter Kraft; Sholom Wacholder; Nick Orr; Kai Yu; Nilanjan Chatterjee; Robert Welch; Amy Hutchinson; Andrew Crenshaw; Geraldine Cancel-Tassin; Brian J Staats; Zhaoming Wang; Jesus Gonzalez-Bosquet; Jun Fang; Xiang Deng; Sonja I Berndt; Eugenia E Calle; Heather Spencer Feigelson; Michael J Thun; Carmen Rodriguez; Demetrius Albanes; Jarmo Virtamo; Stephanie Weinstein; Fredrick R Schumacher; Edward Giovannucci; Walter C Willett; Olivier Cussenot; Antoine Valeri; Gerald L Andriole; E David Crawford; Margaret Tucker; Daniela S Gerhard; Joseph F Fraumeni; Robert Hoover; Richard B Hayes; David J Hunter; Stephen J Chanock Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2008-02-10 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Meredith Yeager; Nilanjan Chatterjee; Julia Ciampa; Kevin B Jacobs; Jesus Gonzalez-Bosquet; Richard B Hayes; Peter Kraft; Sholom Wacholder; Nick Orr; Sonja Berndt; Kai Yu; Amy Hutchinson; Zhaoming Wang; Laufey Amundadottir; Heather Spencer Feigelson; Michael J Thun; W Ryan Diver; Demetrius Albanes; Jarmo Virtamo; Stephanie Weinstein; Fredrick R Schumacher; Geraldine Cancel-Tassin; Olivier Cussenot; Antoine Valeri; Gerald L Andriole; E David Crawford; Christopher A Haiman; Brian Henderson; Laurence Kolonel; Loic Le Marchand; Afshan Siddiq; Elio Riboli; Timothy J Key; Rudolf Kaaks; William Isaacs; Sarah Isaacs; Kathleen E Wiley; Henrik Gronberg; Fredrik Wiklund; Pär Stattin; Jianfeng Xu; S Lilly Zheng; Jielin Sun; Lars J Vatten; Kristian Hveem; Merethe Kumle; Margaret Tucker; Daniela S Gerhard; Robert N Hoover; Joseph F Fraumeni; David J Hunter; Gilles Thomas; Stephen J Chanock Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2009-09-20 Impact factor: 38.330