| Literature DB >> 35083564 |
Alice B Gottlieb1, Alvin F Wells2, Joseph F Merola3.
Abstract
Telemedicine encompasses a variety of modalities that allow for the remote assessment and treatment of patients. The technologies, services, and tools available for telemedicine in the USA are increasingly becoming an integral part of the healthcare system to bridge the gaps in care that can arise from geographic and/or socioeconomic obstacles and provider shortages. Telemedicine can be applied to a spectrum of clinical areas, including rheumatic diseases. Psoriatic arthritis (PsA) is a chronic, inflammatory, multisystem disease with predominately skin and joint manifestations. PsA is often misdiagnosed and/or undiagnosed, which can lead to worse patient outcomes, including irreversible joint erosion and damage. The difficulties in diagnosing and managing PsA are confounded by the emergence and increased use of telemedicine because of the COVID-19 pandemic. Telemedicine presents the opportunity to increase access to healthcare by rheumatologists and dermatologists to improve training and education regarding PsA and to decrease time attributed to office visits associated with PsA. However, challenges in diagnosing PsA without a thorough in-person physical examination by a trained rheumatologist or dermatologist exist. We provide an overview of the ways telemedicine can be incorporated into clinical care and optimized for patients with PsA; characteristic clinical features of PsA, with a focus on skin and joint signs and symptoms; screening tools to be used in routine clinical care; assessments that can be used to evaluate quality of life, functional ability, and disease activity in PsA; and resources and recommendations for the development of future telemedicine use in rheumatology and dermatology. Key Points • Patients with psoriatic arthritis (PsA) are often misdiagnosed and/or undiagnosed. • Telemedicine can improve access to healthcare by rheumatologists and dermatologists. • Telemedicine can be incorporated into clinical care and optimized for managing PsA.Entities:
Keywords: Clinical practice; Dermatology; Psoriatic arthritis; Rheumatology; Telemedicine
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35083564 PMCID: PMC8791553 DOI: 10.1007/s10067-022-06077-3
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clin Rheumatol ISSN: 0770-3198 Impact factor: 3.650
Benefits and challenges of telemedicine in rheumatology and dermatology
| Benefits | Challenges | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Increased access to care | • Patients can be assessed by rheumatologists and dermatologists sooner -Patients can be screened to determine whether an in-person visit is necessary - Patients could be diagnosed and begin treatment faster • Patients can maintain social distancing and prevent the risk of exposure to the COVID-19 • Rapid follow-up for test results feedback • Access to healthcare outside of normal clinic hours • Patients in remote/rural areas have more opportunities to see specialists • Real-time access to electronic screening tools and PRO measures | Financial barriers | • Lack of funding for telemedicine services and tools can be an obstacle to widespread use • Increased costs can be accrued with the need for training to adapt to telemedicine (billing, implementation of e-tools, etc.) • Patient financial means may limit access to reliable internet and tools to ensure quality images and/or video |
| Increased cost-effectiveness and decreased time spent | • Patients have decreased travel time and expenses with virtual appointments • Healthcare providers who may travel to remote/rural clinics will avoid travel time and expenses • Patients with more severe disease disability can avoid the physical toll of an in-person visit • Decreased in-office visits for patients who need routine monitoring • Reduction in participating site management with the use of mobile devices and virtual visits for clinical trial monitoring and communications | Assurance of quality care | • In the absence of a thorough physical examination, a diagnosis of PsA may be difficult - Particularly with skin assessment, areas hidden from camera may not be evaluated appropriately (e.g., scalp) - Distinction of enthesitis may be difficult for patients to self-assess • A standardized and widely accepted teleconsultation evaluation may be needed to ensure quality diagnosis of PsA • Interpreters may not be available for patients who need communication support • Patients may not feel comfortable with virtual examination of certain body parts (e.g., genitals, breasts) • Diagnostic tests are not readily available with telemedicine |
| Education and training | • General clinicians can learn more about diagnosis of PsA with the ability to attend telemedicine consultations • Increased training and tutorials regarding how to efficiently diagnosis early PsA can be available • Patients can learn more about their disease and treatment regimen | Clinical and staff support | • Widespread acceptance and advocacy of clinical and support staff is needed for optimal success of telemedicine • Healthcare providers may be cautious of potential HIPAA violations or security breaches • Providers and clinical staff will need to stay up to date on laws and regulations for virtual patient care |
| Improved communication | • Immediate feedback is possible • Referring clinician has the potential to attend the referral appointment virtually • Increased monitoring of patient status available with electronic PROs can facilitate better shared decision-making between rheumatologists or dermatologists and patients | Technology barriers | • All patients may not have access to high-quality technology to facilitate an optimal evaluation • Patients unfamiliar with and/or who find the use of technology difficult may have trouble setting up virtual tools and/or accessing EMR patient portals, which may leave them unsatisfied with telemedicine |
| Patient satisfaction | • Good patient satisfaction with telemedicine consultations has been reported | ||
EMR electronic medical record; HIPAA Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act; PRO patient-reported outcome; PsA psoriatic arthritis
High-level screening assessments of PsA disease domains
| Disease domain | Assessment tool |
|---|---|
| Psoriasis skin involvement | • Video • Photos • BSA “palm rule” • Self-administered PASI and other validated self-assessments • Directed questioning about areas of the body not visible on video (e.g., scalp, genitals) |
| Nail disease | • Video • Photos (e.g., pitting, onycholysis, onychomycosis) |
| Dactylitis | • Video • Photos • Clinician-guided examination focused on digits • Inquire about “sausage digits,” redness, warmth to touch, tenderness, and swelling |
| Enthesitis | • Video • Photos • Clinician-guided examination focused on commonly affected entheses • Inquire about redness and swelling at insertion sites |
| Peripheral arthritis | • Video (assessment of visible swelling) • Clinician-guided musculoskeletal examination focused on commonly affected joints • Inquire about swelling and tenderness at joints • Inquire about functional limitations, prolonged stiffness, and other features suggesting active inflammatory arthritis, enthesitis |
| Axial disease | • Video • Clinician-guided musculoskeletal examination focused on commonly affected areas of the spine; spinal mobility tests • Inquire about back pain and stiffness, particularly details on whether improved with movement or interrupts sleep • Remote scheduling and review of imaging |
BSA body surface area; PASI Psoriasis Area and Severity Index; PsA psoriatic arthritis
Screening tools for the diagnosis of PsA and assessments for quality of life, functional ability, and disease activity measures to evaluate the disease impact
| Screening tool | Description |
|---|---|
| PEST | • Self-assessment tool of 5 questions about symptoms and history and a sketch of a mannequin for patients to highlight which joints are affected • Convenient, fast to complete, and available for free • Cutoff for PsA is a score of 3 • Specificity of 78% and high sensitivity (92%) • PEST was reported to be favorable to EARP and PASE in the trade-off between sensitivity and specificity to detect PsA |
| PSA | • • Teaching tool developed for the recognition of early PsA • Convenient and helpful for a rapid assessment in routine clinical settings |
| PRO measure | |
| RAPID-3 | • RAPID-3 includes an assessment of physical function and a PtGA for pain and for global health - Score cutoff recommendations for RAPID-3 range from 0–3.0 for remission and 3.1–6.0 for low, 6.1–12.0 for moderate, and 12.1–30 for high severity • RAPID-3 is available online: |
| PsAID questionnaires | • PsAID questionnaires are used to evaluate the impact of PsA on patients’ lives that can be grouped into 3 categories based on impact: physical, related to skin, and psychological and social • PsAID-9 is the short version for use in clinical trials - PASS cutoff for PsAID-9 score is 4 with a 3.6-point change • PsAID-9 is available online: • The PsAID-12 long version for use in clinical practice - PASS cutoff for PsAID-12 score is 4 with a 3.0-point change - Provisionally endorsed as a core PRO measure for health-related QoL in PsA clinical trials • PsAID-12 is available online: |
| HAQ-DI | • HAQ-DI is composed of 20 questions in 8 categories that encompass a comprehensive set of routine activities to assess functional ability • The scores from each category are averaged into an overall HAQ-DI score (0–3) • HAQ-DI is available online: |
EARP Early Arthritis for Psoriatic Patients; HAQ-DI Health Assessment Questionnaire Disability Index; PASE Psoriatic Arthritis Screening and Evaluation; PASS patient-acceptable symptom state; PEST Psoriasis Epidemiology Screening Tool; PRO patient-reported outcome; PsA psoriatic arthritis; PsAID Psoriatic Arthritis Impact of Disease; PtGA patient global assessment; QoL quality of life; RAPID-3 Routine Assessment of Patient Index Data 3
Guidelines and resources for rheumatologists and dermatologists for best telemedicine practices
| COVID-19 practice and advocacy resources (ACR) | The ACR compiled resources for providers containing detailed information: • Fact sheet with coding and practical guidelines • List of temporary changes made by commercial payers to their telemedicine policies • Quick coding references guides • List of telemedicine platforms available for use by rheumatology practices • A chart with details on malpractice coverage for telemedicine services The ACR also compiled information for patients on telemedicine use during COVID-19 Available online: |
| Telemedicine quick guide and implementation playbook (AMA) | The AMA compiled resources to support clinicians and practices to expedite the implementation of telemedicine: Quick guide: Implementation playbook: |
| Telemedicine payment policies (AMA) | The AMA compiled a list of COVID-19 telemedicine payment policies comparing insurance providers Available online: |
| Quick-start guide to telehealth during a health crisis (ATA) | The ATA developed a detailed guide to help healthcare providers initiate telemedicine during a health crisis Available online: |
| HIPAA rules and enforcement (OCR) | The OCR provides a list of HIPAA-compliant vendors and updates the enforcement of HIPAA requirements Available online: |
| List of executive orders for licensure (FSMB) | The FSMB tracks current executive orders related to state licensure Available online: |
| Teledermatology toolkit (AAD) | The AAD compiled a toolkit for healthcare providers to navigate the use of telemedicine Available online: |
| How to prepare for a telemedicine appointment (AAD) | The AAD put together simple steps to help patients prepare for telemedicine appointments Available online: |
| Guidance for patients during COVID-19 outbreak (EULAR) | EULAR provided treatment guidance for patients who are treated with immunosuppressive drugs, including DMARDs Available online: |
| Telemedicine resources for providers and patients (HRSA) | HRSA of HHS provided information about the latest information and resources for general telemedicine policies and procedures Available online: |
| Healthcare provider fact sheet for Medicare telemedicine (CMS) | Summary of changes to Medicare coverage and payment of virtual services Available online: |
| How to prepare for a rheumatology telemedicine visit during the coronavirus pandemic (CreakyJoints) | CreakyJoints put together patient-focused information to help patients prepare for telemedicine appointments Available online: |
AAD American Academy of Dermatology; ACR American College of Rheumatology; AMA American Medical Association; ATA American Telemedicine Association; CMS Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services; DMARD disease-modifying antirheumatic drug; EULAR European League Against Rheumatism; FSMB Federation of State Medical Boards; HHS US Department of Health and Human Services; HIPAA Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act; HRSA Health Resources and Services Administration; OCR Office of Civil Rights
• • • |