| Literature DB >> 35041149 |
Dnyanesh N Tipre1, Michal Cidon2, Rex A Moats3.
Abstract
COVID-19 hypoxemic patients although sharing a same etiology (SARS-CoV-2 infection) present themselves quite differently from one another. Patients also respond differently to prescribed medicine and to prone Vs supine bed positions. A severe pulmonary ventilation-perfusion mismatch usually triggers moderate to severe COVID-19 cases. Imaging can aid the physician in assessing severity of COVID-19. Although useful for their portability X-ray and ultrasound serving on the frontline to evaluate lung parenchymal abnormalities are unable to provide information about pulmonary vasculature and blood flow redistribution which is a consequence of hypoxemia in COVID-19. Advanced imaging modalities such as computed tomography, single-photon emission tomography, and electrical impedance tomography use a sharp algorithm visualizing pulmonary ventilation-perfusion mismatch in the abnormal and in the apparently normal parenchyma. Imaging helps to access the severity of infection, lung performance, ventilation-perfusion mismatch, and informs strategies for medical treatment. This review summarizes the capacity of these imaging modalities to assess ventilation-perfusion mismatch in COVID-19. Despite having limitations, these modalities provide vital information on blood volume distribution, pulmonary embolism, pulmonary vasculature and are useful to assess severity of lung disease and effectiveness of treatment in COVID-19 patients.Entities:
Keywords: COVID-19; CT angiography; Electrical impedance tomography; HRCT; SPECT-CT
Mesh:
Year: 2022 PMID: 35041149 PMCID: PMC8764889 DOI: 10.1007/s11307-021-01700-2
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Mol Imaging Biol ISSN: 1536-1632 Impact factor: 3.484
Fig. 1Normal ventilation and perfusion are responsible for gas exchange in alveoli (a). Alveolar sac filled with edema and exudates produces hypoxemia by decreasing the alveolar and arterial oxygen level result in shunt (b). Pulmonary embolism develops high ventilation in proportion to perfusion produce a dead space (c). Hypoperfusion to the apparently normal parenchyma due to vasoconstriction of pulmonary blood vessels results in poor gas exchange (d) and hyperperfusion through dilated capillaries to alveolar sac filled with edema and exudates result in shunt (e)
Fig. 2Normal lung (left) showing smooth blood flow and the effective gas exchange is recognized as normal ventilation and perfusion. COVID-19 infection causes an intense inflammatory reaction (right) results in shunt or dead space or both. Uncontrolled activation of lymphocytes, neutrophil, and pulmonary production of platelets cause lung tissue damages. The virulence in COVID-19 triggers pulmonary microthrombi, endothelial damage, and vascular leakage. The host intends to control the thrombi formation by vigorous fibrinolysis, and degraded fibrin (D-dimer) are released in blood stream. Image
Source—https://doi.org/10.1111/jth.14975
Comparative study of imaging modalities to assess COVID-19 clinical manifestation
| Principle of technique | Transmission tomography | Transmission tomography | Transmission tomography | Emission (SPECT) and transmission (CT) tomography | Transmission tomography |
| Energy source | X-rays produced by single high voltage (125 kVp) tube | X-rays produced by two low and high voltages (80 and 140 kVp) tubes | X-rays produced by single high voltage (120 kVp) tube | Photons (99mTc:140 keV, 81mKr: 190 keV, 123I: 159 keV) emitted by SPECT radiotracer and X-ray from CT tube (30–80 kVp) | Low intensity alternating electrical current |
| Signal production mechanism | Attenuation of X-rays in the lungs | Attenuation of X-rays in the lungs and pulmonary blood vessels | Attenuation of X-rays in the lungs and pulmonary blood vessels | Emission of photons from SPECT radiotracer and attenuation of CT X-rays in the lungs | Resistivity to the electrical current (bioimpedance) produced by air in the lungs during inspiration and expiration |
| Radiation exposure | Exposure to X-rays | Exposure to X-rays | Exposure to X-rays | Exposure to radioactivity and X-rays | No radiation exposure |
| Effective radiation dose | 1 mSv per chest scan | 1.5–3 mSv per chest scan | 7–10 mSv per chest scan | 6–7 mSv per SPECT/CT chest scan | Not applicable |
| Contrast agent | Contrast agent not required. FRI algorithm assesses vasculature on the stack of CT images of ≤ 1-mm thickness | Iodinated contrast agents are used to visualize perfusion and pulmonary embolism in the lungs | Iodinated contrast agents are used to visualize perfusion and pulmonary embolism in the lungs | Contrast agent not required | 5–7.5% w/v hypertonic sodium chloride intravenous bolus injection serves as contrast agent to measure lung perfusion |
| Radiotracers | No radioactivity involved | No radioactivity involved | No radioactivity involved | 99mTc-MAA,99mTc-DTPA, Technegas®, and 81mKr | No radioactivity involved |
| Findings | GGO, consolidation, pleural effusion, fibrosis, and microcystic honeycombing on lung CT images. Using FRI algorithm, redistribution of blood from smaller caliber blood vessels to dilated ones in GGO was observed | GGO and consolidation on transmission scan, hyperperfusion in GGO, and hypoperfusion in apparently normal zone on iodine map; pulmonary infarction and embolism on perfusion scan were observed | GGO and plural abnormalities on transmission scan; perfusion defects in normal and abnormal lung zones and pulmonary embolism may be detected | Decreased radioactivity uptake in the infract zone on perfusion ventilation scan and decreased radioactivity distribution in COPD lungs on ventilation scan | Unequal regional bioimpedance during respiration display ventilation perfusion mismatch, distention, or % collapse of the lung in four quadrants |
| Frequency of scans | One-time scan in asymptomatic to severe patients and follow-up scans in long haulers during rehabilitation process | One time or intermittent scans in moderate to severe patients to assess lung perfusion and pulmonary embolism site | One time or intermittent scans in moderate to severe patients to assess lung perfusion and pulmonary embolism site | One time or intermittent scans in moderate to severe patients to assess lung ventilation, and perfusion | Continuous bedside examination of lung ventilation and perfusion in moderate to severe condition and evaluation of drug therapy |
| Patient group preferred | Adults and pediatric | Adults and pediatric without renal complications when using contrast agents | Adults and pediatric without renal complications when using contrast agents | Adults and only perfusion SPECT scan in pregnancy | Adults, infants, pregnant, pediatric |
HRCT high-resolution computed tomography, U-HRCT ultra high-resolution computed tomography, DECT dual energy computed tomography, CTPA conventional computed tomography pulmonary angiography SPECT-CT single photon emission tomography- computed tomography, EIT electrical impedance tomography, GGO ground-glass opacities, FRI functional respiratory imaging, COPD chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, Tc-MAA Technetium 99mTc macro-aggregated albumin, Tc-DTPA Technetium 99mTc-diethylen-tetraamino-pentaacetate, Technegas® ultra-fine dispersion of 99mTc-carbon, Kr 81 m krypton gas
Fig. 3Functional respiratory imaging on HRCT scans found that the COVID-19 patients had significantly reduced blood volume in the smaller caliber blood vessels (BV5, cross-sectional area < 5 mm2) compared with the long hauler COVID-19 subjects and healthy controls. In the long haulers, the blood vessels remain anomalous for a long time. The mid-size vessels, indicated in yellow (BV5_10, cross-sectional area of 5–10 mm2), seem to remain dilated which could indicate sustained microvascular obstruction and endothelial damage. In acute COVID-19, they had a significantly higher proportion of blood volume within large-caliber vessels (BV10, cross-sectional area of > 10 mm2) and mainly projected towards the posterior part of the lungs. Impaired gas exchange in the lungs seen in COVID-19 may be partially a result of redistribution of blood away from the small-caliber pulmonary vessels. Image
Source—Fluidda Inc
Fig. 4Panels display perfusion CT scans with dual energy CT (4A, 4B, and 4C) and conventional CT (4D) in COVID-19 patients. In panel 4A, (a) Peripheral GGO and consolidation within the right upper lobe and smaller GGO in the posterior left upper lobe (green arrowheads) are accompanied by dilated subsegmental vessels proximal to, and within, the opacities (green arrows). (b) The accompanying pulmonary blood volume image shows higher perfusion (green arrows) in GGO and consolidation. Image
source—10.1016/S1473-3099(20)30367-4. In panel 4B, (a, c) axial CT image shows wedge-shaped bilateral opacities with surrounding GGO; (b) iodine map image shows a triangular peripheral area of decreased perfusion (yellow arrow) in the right lower, distal to pulmonary embolism (red arrow) lobe compatible with pulmonary infarction; (d) iodine map images showing a peripheral, triangular, and hypoperfused area in the left lower lobe (yellow arrow) suggestive of pulmonary infarction. Image source—https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rec.2020.04.013. In panel 4C, (a) axial CT image shows central GGO and peripheral consolidation a right inferior lobe. (b) Axial iodine color map shows high iodine concentrations in consolidations, and hypoperfusion in left medio-basal segment (dotted line), secondary to the thrombosis of corresponding segmental pulmonary artery (white arrow). (c) Axial CT image shows consolidation in a right inferior lobe and GGO in both inferior lobes. (d) Axial iodine color map shows hypoperfused area in the middle lobe (dotted line). Right inferior lobe consolidation shows high and heterogeneous iodine levels. Image source—https://doi.org/10.21037/qims-20-708. In panel 4D, (a) Axial chest CT of the right upper lobe with subpleural pneumonia (red arrows), surrounded by small GGOs. (b) CTPA shows multiple small subpleural perfusion defects (red arrows) and a larger perfusion defect dorsal in the normal ventilated right upper lobe (Δa), due to microvascular obstruction (Δb). Pulmonary emboli in the right pulmonary upper lobe were not observed. Image source—10.1259/bjr.20200718
Fig. 5In panel 5A, the axial images showing decreased radiotracer uptake in both perfusion and ventilation scan (white arrow) in fused SPECT-CT (a, b) indicating low probability of pulmonary embolism. SPECT (c, d) observed defect matches with the posterior segment of the right upper lobe alveolar filling (black arrow) on the CT scan (e). In panel 5B, on coronal images, decreased dual radiotracer uptake (green arrows) in ventilation (a) and perfusion (b) SPECT scans indicates low possibility of pulmonary embolism. Increased tracheobronchial tract uptake of (blue arrows), with marked intensity on the proximal bronchi suggesting tracheobronchitis or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. In panel 5C, the axial SPECT images showing normal perfusion scan (a) and defects in ventilation scan (b) in the posterior segment of the right upper lobe (white arrow) that matches with the GGO on CT scan (c, black arrow). Image
source—https://doi.org/10.1007/s00259-020-04920-w, https://doi.org/10.1007/s00259-020-04834-7
Fig. 6In this study, EIT showed real-time noninvasive bedside ventilation and perfusion in hypoxemic COVID-19 patients with respiratory failure. All the three COVID-19 patients intubated for acute hypoxic respiratory failure (PaO2/FiO2 < 300) had different respiratory system compliance. EIT was used to determine regional ventilation and perfusion distribution. On CT scans, case 1 shows peripheral and basilar GGO, while case 2 and 3 describe diffuse bilateral GGO. In case 1, EIT showed severe right-lung perfusion anomalies, homogenous ventilation, and a moderate decrease in respiratory compliance (40 ml/cm H2O). Case 2 and case 3 showed a progressive decrease of respiratory compliance, without major perfusion disturbances. PaO2/FiO2 means ratio of arterial oxygen partial pressure in mmHg to fractional inspired oxygen expressed as fraction. Image
source—https://doi.org/10.1164/rccm.202005-1801IM