| Literature DB >> 34945748 |
Marianna Mazza1,2, Emanuele Caroppo3, Domenico De Berardis4,5, Giuseppe Marano1, Carla Avallone1, Georgios D Kotzalidis1,6, Delfina Janiri1, Lorenzo Moccia1, Alessio Simonetti1, Eliana Conte1, Giovanni Martinotti5, Luigi Janiri1, Gabriele Sani1.
Abstract
Early detection and prompt treatment of psychosis is of the utmost importance. The great variability in clinical onset, illness course, and response to pharmacological and psychosocial treatment is in great part gender-related. Our aim has been to review narratively the literature focusing on gender related differences in the psychoses, i.e., schizophrenia spectrum disorders. We searched the PubMed/Medline, Scopus, Embase, and ScienceDirect databases on 31 July 2021, focusing on recent research regarding sex differences in early psychosis. Although women, compared to men, tend to have better overall functioning at psychotic symptom onset, they often present with more mood symptoms, may undergo misdiagnosis and delay in treatment and are at a higher risk for antipsychotic drug-induced metabolic and endocrine-induced side effects. Furthermore, women with schizophrenia spectrum disorders have more than double the odds of having physical comorbidities than men. Tailored treatment plans delivered by healthcare services should consider gender differences in patients with a diagnosis of psychosis, with a particular attention to early phases of disease in the context of the staging model of psychosis onset.Entities:
Keywords: gender differences; personalized treatment; psychosis; schizophrenia; women
Year: 2021 PMID: 34945748 PMCID: PMC8705671 DOI: 10.3390/jpm11121279
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Pers Med ISSN: 2075-4426
Figure 1PRISMA Flow diagram of literature search, (http://www.prisma-statement.org/, accessed on 31st July 2021). * Consider, if feasible to do so, reporting the number of records identified from each database or register searched (rather than the total number across all databases/registers). ** If automation tools were used, indicate how many records were excluded by a human and how many were excluded by automation tools. From: Page MJ, McKenzie JE, Bossuyt PM, Boutron I, Hoffmann TC, Mulrow, CD, et al. The PRISMA 2020 statement: an updated guideline for reporting systematic reviews. BMJ 2021;372:Nn71. doi: 10.1136/bmj.n71.
Summary of included studies focusing on gender differences in schizophrenia and related psychotic disorders.
| Study | Population | Study Type/Design | Results |
|---|---|---|---|
| González-Rodríguez et al., 2016 [ | 64 women with schizophrenia | 12-week antipsychotic treatment | 42 responders; time since menopause negatively associated with antipsychotic response |
| Spitz et al., 2017 [ | 126 at-risk and 94 FEP patients | Cross-sectional self-rated and clinician-rated assessment of positive and negative symptoms | Low agreement between self- and clinician-rated assessment; higher association with positive symptoms in FEP compared to at-risk and in women with respect to men, which became not significant after correction for multiple testing |
| Ittig et al., 2017 [ | 116 antipsychotic-naïve at-risk; 49 FEP patients | Blood sampling; prolactin assay | Hyperprolactinemia in 32% of at-risk and 35% of FEP patients; higher prolactin levels in women |
| Ferrari et al., 2018 [ | 25 FEP service users | Interview (in-depth) about help-seeking; cross-sectional | Women had more difficulties in accessing care; men had more difficulties in speaking about their symptoms |
| Egloff et al., 2018 [ | 65 at-risk (48 (73.8%) male; age = 25.1 ± 6.32) and 50 FEP (37 (74%) male; age = 27 ± 6.56) patients; 70 HCs (27 (38.6%) male; age = 26 ± 4.97) | 3T MRI to test for reversal of sexual dimorphism of subcortical volumes in psychosis | Men had larger total brain ( |
| Menghini-Müller et al., 2019 [ | 336 at-risk participants (159 women) from 11 European centers | Cross-sectional assessment of clinical symptoms, drug use, comorbidity, and functioning | Men had more negative symptoms and current cannabis use than women; women scored higher on general psychopathology and more mood and anxiety comorbidity. No gender differences in global functioning. Correction for multiple testing abolished all significance |
| Dama et al., 2019 [ | 569 patients | Longitudinal study; demographics at baseline; positive, negative and total symptoms after 1 and 2 years | Men less educated and longer DUP, poorer premorbid functioning, more substance use, more negative symptoms, and poorer socio-occupational functioning than women. Women more remitting than men after 2 years of treatment and better functioning after 1 year. Results did not persist after adjustment for age at onset and confounders |
| Li, et al., 2019 [ | 360 FEP patients | Cross-sectional assessment of cognition through a comprehensive neurocognitive battery | Memory and working memory correlated with age at onset, negative symptoms, and adverse events in women. Processing speed correlated with antipsychotic dosage in men and adverse events in women. Selective attention correlated with reality distortion and negative symptoms in women, and age at onset and education in men. Executive function correlated with age at onset and reality distortion in women. All cognitive domains significantly correlated with educational level and functioning in both genders. Negative symptoms explained significant variability in cognition in both genders, while reality distortion, adverse events and mood symptoms differentiated between genders |
| Tong et al., 2019 [ | 60 female patients (mean age 24.57 ± 8.28) with recent-onset (5 years) psychotic spectrum disorder | Cross-sectional assessment of cognition through a cognitive battery, of perceived cognitive decline through the SCIS, and psychotic and depressive symptoms | SCIS not correlated with objective cognitive testing; SCIS positively correlated with depression and positive symptoms. Positive symptoms and depression together explained 31.9% of the total variance in SCIS; depression significantly predicted SCIS. Negative symptoms predicted memory test performance and correlated with it |
| Šimunović Filipčić et al., 2020 [ | 329 SSD patients; 837 HCs (general population) | Primary outcome: Prevalence of CPM | Women with SSD >3-fold odds for having CPM than men; in HCs, gender-related odds about the same. Prevalence of chronic disease in younger SSD women significantly higher than HCs, not in younger SSD men |
| Ayesa-Arriola et al., 2020 [ | 209 FEP patients (95 females and 114 males) | Clinical, cognitive, functioning, premorbid, and sociodemographic variables assessed at baseline (first contact), 1-, 3-, and 10-year follow-ups | At baseline, female age older than men, better premorbid adjustment, higher IQ, and better occupational status. Cannabis and alcohol consumption more frequent in men. During 1–3 years, women showed a better response to low antipsychotic doses and higher rates of recovery than men (50% vs. 30.8%). At 10-year follow-up, more females continued living independently and had partners, while schizophrenia diagnoses and cannabis consumption continued to be more frequent among men. Less negative symptoms in women |
| Rosen et al., 2020 [ | 152 male and 90 female referrals (88% at CHR; 35% converters) | Symptoms assessed cross-sectionally with the SIPS | All referrals: males, more negative and disorganization symptoms; among CHR converters: females, more perceptual abnormalities, bizarre thinking, and odd behavior; males, greater emotional blunting. Suspiciousness and disorganized communication predicted psychosis in males, trouble with focus and attention predicted psychosis in females |
| Studerus, et al., 2021 [ | 31 CHR (3 women), age 23.7 ± 4.82 years, 87 FEP patients (31 women), age 25.7 ± 9.15 years, and 45 HCs (21 women), age 28.0 ± 10.2 years from one Swiss (Basel) and one Spanish (Barcelona) center | Cross-sectional; blood withdrawal for prolactin assay and simultaneous completion of PSS | CHR and FEP patients scored higher PSS and had higher prolactin levels than HCs. Hyperprolactinemia in 26% of CHR and 45% of FEP patients. PSS scores correlated with mood symptoms. PSS scores did not correlate with prolactin levels. No gender-related differences in prolactin levels or perceived stress |
| Lähteenvuo et al., 2021 [ | 45,476 patients with schizophrenia aged <46 years at cohort entry, from one Swedish and one Finnish national cohort (more men in both cohorts, 58.2% and 52.5%, respectively; SUD, 30.90% Sweden [men, 70.4%], 26.28% Finland [men, 71.9%]) | Longitudinal; SUD prevalence assessment (not smoking), Cox regression on risk of psychiatric hospitalization and all-cause and cause-specific mortality in SUD compared with no SUD during 22-year (1996–2017, Finland) and 11-year (2006–2016, Sweden) follow-ups | Similar results for the two Scandinavian cohorts. SUD prevalence 26% in Finland and 31% in Sweden. Multi-SUD, 4164 (48%) in Finland and 3268 (67%) in Sweden; AUD, 3846 (45%) in Finland and 1002 (21%) in Sweden; cannabis use disorder next greater frequency. SUD comorbidity associated with 50–100% increase in hospitalization and mortality with respect to no SUD. SUD more prevalent among men than among women |
| Irving et al., 2021 [ | 3350 FEP patients (62% males) at the South London and Maudsley NHS Trust with onset between 1 April 2007 and 31 March 2017 | Cross-sectional; positive, negative, depressive, manic, and disorganization symptoms at initial clinical presentation; logistic regression | Poverty of thought, negative symptoms, social withdrawal, poverty of speech, aggression, grandiosity, paranoia and agitation more prevalent in men; tearfulness, low energy, reduced appetite, low mood, pressured speech, mood instability, flight of ideas, guilt, mutism, insomnia, poor concentration, tangentiality and elation more prevalent in women. Negative symptoms more common among men, depressive and manic symptoms more common among women even after adjusting for SUD |
| García-Rizo et al., 2021 [ | 491 drug-naïve FEP patients, aged 30.96 ± 9.96 years (213 women, aged 34.77 ± 10.80 years; 278 men, aged 28.03 ± 8.15) | Prolactin levels assessed through immunochemiluminescent automated assays to correlate with CRP, blood cell count, lipid and hepatic profile, and fasting glucose, stratified by sex | Prolactin was significantly correlated with CRP, LDL, AST in women and with HDL and eosinophil count in men. Women older than men. Prolactin levels higher in men than in women |
| Vázquez-Reyes et al., 2021 [ | 100 close relatives of patients with schizophrenia and related psychotic disorders; 64 men (64%), 36 women (36%); mean age during 2003–2007 38.26 ± 10.65; range = 18–65 years, during 2014-2017 51.42 ± 10.51; range = 30–77 years | Completion of SFS and the BPI during 2003–2007 and 2014–2017. Student’s | No deterioration in social functioning or behavior problems. Women scored higher on withdrawal/social engagement, interpersonal behavior, independence-performance, independence-competence, and total social functioning, with no significant differences in behavior problems. Previous social functioning, underactivity/social withdrawal and education are predictive factors in the course of social functioning |
Abbreviations: ANOVA, analysis of variance; AST, Aspartate Transaminase; AUD, alcohol use disorder; BPI, Behaviour Problems Inventory; CHR, clinical high risk for psychosis; CPM, chronic physical multi-morbidities; CRP, C-reactive protein; DUP, duration of untreated psychosis; FEP, first-episode psychosis; GM, gray matter; HCs, healthy controls; HDL, High-Density Lipoprotein; LDL, Low-Density Lipoprotein; MRI, magnetic resonance imaging; PSS, 10-item Perceived Stress Scale; SCIS, Subjective Cognitive Impairment Scale; SFS, Social Functioning Scale; SIPS, Structured Interview for Psychosis-Risk Syndromes; SSD, schizophrenia spectrum disorder; SUD, substance use disorder; T, Tesla; WM, white matter; ±, plus-minus standard deviation.