Tuuli A Hakala1, Emma V Yates1, Pavan K Challa1, Zenon Toprakcioglu1, Karthik Nadendla1, Dijana Matak-Vinkovic1, Christopher M Dobson1, Rodrigo Martínez2, Francisco Corzana3, Tuomas P J Knowles1,4, Gonçalo J L Bernardes1,5. 1. Yusuf Hamied Department of Chemistry, University of Cambridge, Lensfield Road, Cambridge CB2 1EW, United Kingdom. 2. Departamento de Química, Universidad de La Rioja, 26006 Logroño, Spain. 3. Departamento de Química, Centro de Investigación en Síntesis Química, Universidad de La Rioja, 26006 Logroño, Spain. 4. Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge, J. J. Thomson Avenue, CB3 0HE Cambridge, United Kingdom. 5. Instituto de Medicina Molecular João Lobo Antunes, Faculdade de Medicina de Universidad de Lisboa, Avenida Prof. Egas Moniz, 1649-028 Lisboa, Portugal.
Abstract
Biomimetics is a design principle within chemistry, biology, and engineering, but chemistry biomimetic approaches have been generally limited to emulating nature's chemical toolkit while emulation of nature's physical toolkit has remained largely unexplored. To begin to explore this, we designed biophysically mimetic microfluidic reactors with characteristic length scales and shear stresses observed within capillaries. We modeled the effect of shear with molecular dynamics studies and showed that this induces specific normally buried residues to become solvent accessible. We then showed using kinetics experiments that rates of reaction of these specific residues in fact increase in a shear-dependent fashion. We applied our results in the creation of a new microfluidic approach for the multidimensional study of cysteine biomarkers. Finally, we used our approach to establish dissociation of the therapeutic antibody trastuzumab in a reducing environment. Our results have implications for the efficacy of existing therapeutic antibodies in blood plasma as well as suggesting in general that biophysically mimetic chemistry is exploited in biology and should be explored as a research area.
Biomimetics is a design principle within chemistry, biology, and engineering, but chemistry biomimetic approaches have been generally limited to emulating nature's chemical toolkit while emulation of nature's physical toolkit has remained largely unexplored. To begin to explore this, we designed biophysically mimetic microfluidic reactors with characteristic length scales and shear stresses observed within capillaries. We modeled the effect of shear with molecular dynamics studies and showed that this induces specific normally buried residues to become solvent accessible. We then showed using kinetics experiments that rates of reaction of these specific residues in fact increase in a shear-dependent fashion. We applied our results in the creation of a new microfluidic approach for the multidimensional study of cysteine biomarkers. Finally, we used our approach to establish dissociation of the therapeutic antibody trastuzumab in a reducing environment. Our results have implications for the efficacy of existing therapeutic antibodies in blood plasma as well as suggesting in general that biophysically mimetic chemistry is exploited in biology and should be explored as a research area.
Biomimetics, the emulation
of nature’s elements, models,
and systems to solve human problems, is a key principle in many scientific
fields including chemistry,[1] biology,[2] and engineering.[3] Within
chemistry, most biomimetic research to date has focused on exploiting
nature’s chemical toolkit.[4] For
example, biomimetic chemical reactions have allowed advances in the
development biologically inspired synthetic transformation reactions,
in the use of mild, aqueous reactions, as well as in the use of biological
cofactors.[5−9] However, within nature, biomolecules are subjected to distinct and
variable conditions and forces which modulate their function. For
example, biomolecules are frequently crowded or confined to small
length scales, both of which can either promote or limit aggregation.[10,11] Additionally, the elasticity of the extracellular matrix has been
shown to control stem cell lineage specification.[12] Proteins within fibroblasts are subjected to contractile
forces as the fibroblast pulls the cell body forward in a crawling
motion through 3D tissue.[13] As another
example, shear stress within the circulatory system has been shown
to alter the signaling pathways of endothelial cells via a mechanosensory
complex,[14] with higher shear stress generally
associated with lower risk of artherosclerosis.[15] Shear stress occurs when forces acting on a single body,
such as a cell or a protein, pull it in different directions at the
same time. Shear stress has also been shown to promote post-translational
modifications, specifically S-nitrosylation.[16] Yet, redeployment of nature’s physical architecture as a
chemical tool remains largely unexplored.We begin to explore
the use of biophysically mimetic forces by
considering shear stress experienced within capillaries. We consider
this from both computational and experimental perspectives. A number
of computational techniques which include Brownian dynamics and lattice-Boltzmann
molecular dynamics (MD) have been developed to model the structural
effect of shear stress on biomolecules.[17−19] The methods were used
to investigate flow-induced unfolding of a β-barrel protein
in different types of flows[20] and stretching
of integrin and ubiquitin.[20−22] In a coarse-grained MD study,
the unfolding of a β-hairpin, a WW domain, and a calcium-binding
domain was reported.[18] A similar coarse-grained
approach was used to study the aggregation of several amyloidogenic
peptides in silico.[23]Here, we follow two different approaches to investigate the dynamics
of biomolecules under these nonequilibrium conditions. In the first,
proteins undergo a simple shear flow[24] that
causes an increase in friction due to random collisions of the protein
with nearby solvent or other solute molecules that exhibit rotational-translational
diffusion. This computational approach has recently been applied to
understand the rheo-NMR experiments performed on several proteins
at the atomic level.[24] Alternatively, we
perform steered MD simulations (SMD).[25,26] In these calculations,
we apply a force to two specific atoms that allows them to move from
an initial position, given by the solved X-ray structure, to a position
that we choose arbitrarily.[27,28] In all calculations,
one of the atoms chosen is the Cα of the cysteine residue or
the Cα or a residue in close proximity to it (see the Supporting Information for details). It is important
to note that this external force does not represent a shear stress
induced by the solvent and ion molecules. However, the two specified
atoms were chosen to capture significant conformational changes around the cysteine residue through trajectories with a
short time scale. Thus, this simple strategy allows us to mimic to
a certain degree the deformation of the proteins subjected to shear
flow. SMD simulations have been used to study amyloid fibril properties,[29] dissociation and association in response to
shear,[30] the importance of hydrogen bonding
in protein conformational locks,[31] and
protein unfolding,[32] among others. The
shear flow simulations and SMD simulations provide complementary views
of the dynamics of biomolecules. In general, the application of both
of these two computational approaches agree in showing marked increases
in the solvent accessible surface area (SASA) of certain residues,
specifically free cysteine residues, rather than global protein unfolding.We next study the impacts of this increase in SASA within a microfluidic
system we designed to replicate the shear stress that has been measured
in human capillaries, providing a minimal model of an artificial capillary.
Within biological systems, proteins are subjected to considerable
shear stress (ranging from force per unit area of 0.28 Pa in postcapillary
venuoles to 9.55 Pa in the smallest diameter capillaries).[33] A maximal shear stress of 9.55 Pa is considerably
higher than shear stresses which have been shown to control the aggregation
of silk proteins.[34] The fluid flow rate
throughout the diameter of the capillary varies, with the highest
fluid flow rate at the middle of the capillary and a zero fluid flow
rate at the capillary walls. Shear stress is maximal at the capillary
walls because the force differential is maximal there. Microfluidic
systems have the key advantage of being able to replicate this behavior
under laminar flow conditions.[35] Microfluidic
systems further allow transformation between space and time for precise
kinetics measurements together with a convenient optical readout.[35] Hence, we survey the range of shear stresses
and associated forces acting on biomolecules within a capillary length
scale microfluidic system we designed to replicate the range of shear
stresses and forces within human capillaries. Specifically, having
observed increases in SASA of particular residues within our MD studies,
we develop an approach to test the effects of this increased solvent
accessibility on the rates of reaction of these and other residues.
We observe that exclusively the residues for which SASA is increased
on application of the shear-mimicking steering force experience increases
in reaction rates, which shows the dependency on the level of shear
applied in the capillary length scale microfluidic device.In
order to demonstrate how this finding provides a dependence
of specific reaction rates on shear stress that can be used, we exploit
the achieved accelerated reaction rates in a microfluidic, multidimensional
cysteine biomarker assay which permits quantitative study of free
and disulfide bonded cysteine residues as this relates to biomolecular
size. Finally, we use our assay to monitor the structural changes
catalyzed by chemical events within the heterooligomeric therapeutic
antibody trastuzumab, with our results suggesting dissociation under
reducing conditions such as blood plasma. We expect our portable and
affordable method to find application in the study of disease biomarkers
and to enable the study of biologics not prone to such dissociation
within blood plasma. Furthermore, we expect our study to prompt establishment
and exploration of biophysically mimetic chemistry, chemical biology,
and biochemistry, in which the variety of forces utilized by nature
to alter biomolecular behavior can be exploited for human purposes.
Results
and Discussion
High shear stresses of up to 9.55 Pa have
been measured within
human capillaries.[33] We questioned what
impacts these may have on proteins transported through the capillary
system and whether any impacts could be exploited as a biophysical
tool.
Nonequilibrium MD Simulations Probe Dynamic Changes on Application
of Shear-Mimicking Steering Force
To study the effect that
shear stress has on the protein structure at the atomic level, we
first accomplished MD simulations that mimic a simple shear flow (named
Couette flow)[24] on several proteins, including
albumin (BSA), β-Lactoglobulin (β-Lac), β-galactosidase
(BLG), and a full length IgG antibody (Tras), as show in Figure and Supporting Fig.s 2–5. We considered the
albumin case was well suited to additional study on the effects of
capillary transport because it is the most abundant serum protein,
is highly conserved, is not glycosylated, and has a single conserved
free cysteine residue (Cys34) which has been shown to undergo S-nitrosylation
and be involved in a binding site for small molecules transported
by albumin.[36] The positions of this residue
and other disulfide bonded cysteine residues are shown in Figure a. We additionally
include the positions of lysine resides, another type of residue prone
to post-translational modifications, and intrinsically fluorescent
tryptophan residues which can be indicative of changes to the structure
of the aromatic protein core.[37]
Figure 1
MD simulations
of BSA in a shear flow. (a) Location of free Cys34
(in red), disulfide bonded Cys (in yellow), Lys (in blue), and Trp
(in green) residues within BSA. (b) Average SASA along 100 ns conventional
MD trajectory for these residues within BSA. (c) Evolution of root-mean-square
displacement (RMSD) values of Cα atoms of BSA along conventional
MD and MD where the protein undergoes a shear flow (2.14 × 106 Pa). (d) Representative snapshots derived from 100 ns (MD
simulations + shear flow) of BSA. (e) Average SASA values derived
from 100 ns conventional trajectory (plain plot) or mimicking a shear
flow (striped plot, shear stress 2.14 × 106 Pa) for
free Cys34, disulfide bonded Cys, Lys, and Trp residues of BSA.
MD simulations
of BSA in a shear flow. (a) Location of free Cys34
(in red), disulfide bonded Cys (in yellow), Lys (in blue), and Trp
(in green) residues within BSA. (b) Average SASA along 100 ns conventional
MD trajectory for these residues within BSA. (c) Evolution of root-mean-square
displacement (RMSD) values of Cα atoms of BSA along conventional
MD and MD where the protein undergoes a shear flow (2.14 × 106 Pa). (d) Representative snapshots derived from 100 ns (MD
simulations + shear flow) of BSA. (e) Average SASA values derived
from 100 ns conventional trajectory (plain plot) or mimicking a shear
flow (striped plot, shear stress 2.14 × 106 Pa) for
free Cys34, disulfide bonded Cys, Lys, and Trp residues of BSA.First, 0.5 μs MD simulations of BSA protein
at equilibrium,
with no shear stress applied, revealed that the SASA values of lysine
residues were significantly higher relative to the other residues
considered (Figure a and Supporting Fig. 1). Subsequently,
this protein was subjected to 100 ns MD simulations, in which a shear
flow of 1.10 × 10–7 nm ps–1 (shear stress = 9.4 Pa, Supporting Fig. 5) was applied to mimic the experimental shear stress (up to 9.55
Pa, see below). This resulted in the random diffusional motion of
the protein rather than structural changes, probably due to the short
simulation time.[24] In fact, structural
fluctuations and partial unfolding of certain regions of BSA protein
were observed only when the theoretical shear stress was set to 2.14
× 106 Pa (Figure c,d). A similar scenario was observed for the rest
of the studied proteins (Supporting Fig.s 2–5). Under these higher shear stress conditions, we observe a 1.5-fold
increase in the SASA value of Cys34 (Figure e). This marked increase in SASA was observed
exclusively in the nonequilibrium MD simulations and not in the equilibrium
(or conventional) MD simulations which were carried out using the
same methods but without the introduction of the external shear flow.
Moreover, we quantitatively confirmed that a free cysteine SASA increase
was positively related to the shear stress (Supporting Fig. 5). An increase in SASA values was also obtained for intrinsically
fluorescent Trp residues (1.4-fold) under these high shear stress
conditions, while there were still no significant changes observed
for Lys and disulfide bonded Cys residues. Similarly, an increase
in the SASA value was observed for free Cys residues in BLG and β-Gal
(Supporting Fig.s 2 and 3, respectively).
In these cases, the MD simulations showed a lower SASA value for disulfide
bonded Cys residues relative to MD simulations without a shear flow.Alternatively, BSA, BLG, β-Gal, and a full length IgG antibody
were also subjected to SMD simulations (Supporting Fig.s 6–12) and gave qualitatively similar results in
terms of SASA values. The SMD simulations allowed us to assess a regime
somewhat closer (force generally less than 200 pN for BSA, as shown
in Supporting Fig. 8) to the experimental
values and still observe changes within the short time scale of the
SMD trajectory. Interestingly, using this technique with BSA protein,
an increase in the SASA value was observed only for Cys34 residue
(1.3-fold increase relative to conventional MD simulations). Although
nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulations have been used to study
changes in protein structure previously, we questioned whether the
increased solvent accessibility we had observed for the free cysteine
residues may be able to be exploited to allow a faster reaction under
biophysically mimietic conditions, for example, by removing a steric
barrier or enhancing the nucleophilic character of the thiol group.
Reaction Rate Acceleration Dependence on Shear in Artificial
Capillary Device
To test whether this increased surface accessibility
results in more rapid reactivity, we performed kinetics experiments
within a microfluidic device designed to provide the shear stress
and forces that have been measured within capillaries. Within microfluidic
systems, fluid is constrained to networks of small channels with characteristic
length scales similar to biological structures.[38] We exploited this feature in order to design our microfluidic
device (Figure a)
to survey the range of shear stresses within capillaries[33] (0.28 to 9.55 Pa, Figure b) and apply corresponding levels of force
(8.04 × 10–5 to 2.74 × 10–3 pN, Figure c) to
a protein.
Figure 2
Biophysically mimetic shear and kinetics measurements. (a) Capillary
scale kinetics device, in which optical fluorescence measurements
along the kinetics loop enable calculation of the rate of reaction
of protein and dye. Varying the device height and flow rate surveys
the range of (b) shear stresses and (c) forces observed in human capillaries
by using albumin for the force calculation. (d) Kinetics of labeling
of Cys34 for 25 and 50 μm device height and (e) 25–100
μL/h flow rate. (f) Dependence of calculated pseudo-first-order
reaction rate constant on shear stress, with the linear fit rate constant
= 11.1 × shear stress + 15.4, with R2 = 0.96. (g) Kinetics of appearance of fluorescence intensity in
a fluorogenic lysine labeling reaction, when moving from bulk to on-chip
and (h) as a function flow rate (i) with the calculated rate constant
plotted against shear stress. (j) Intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence
as a function of flow rate for BSA, free Trp, and BSA + SDS. (k) Recovery
of intrinsic fluorescence signal of BSA and BSA + SDS after the flow
is stopped. All kinetic curves are averages of three separate experiments
and standard deviation is represented by the error bars. AU = arbitrary
units.
Biophysically mimetic shear and kinetics measurements. (a) Capillary
scale kinetics device, in which optical fluorescence measurements
along the kinetics loop enable calculation of the rate of reaction
of protein and dye. Varying the device height and flow rate surveys
the range of (b) shear stresses and (c) forces observed in human capillaries
by using albumin for the force calculation. (d) Kinetics of labeling
of Cys34 for 25 and 50 μm device height and (e) 25–100
μL/h flow rate. (f) Dependence of calculated pseudo-first-order
reaction rate constant on shear stress, with the linear fit rate constant
= 11.1 × shear stress + 15.4, with R2 = 0.96. (g) Kinetics of appearance of fluorescence intensity in
a fluorogenic lysine labeling reaction, when moving from bulk to on-chip
and (h) as a function flow rate (i) with the calculated rate constant
plotted against shear stress. (j) Intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence
as a function of flow rate for BSA, free Trp, and BSA + SDS. (k) Recovery
of intrinsic fluorescence signal of BSA and BSA + SDS after the flow
is stopped. All kinetic curves are averages of three separate experiments
and standard deviation is represented by the error bars. AU = arbitrary
units.Cys34, for which we had observed
a marked increase in SASA under
shearing (Figure e)
and shear mimicking (Supporting Fig. 9)
conditions in our simulations, is a biomarker of oxidative stress,[39] kidney disease, and diabetes mellitus.[40] Oxidation of Cys34 occurs based on reaction
with natural disulfides and thiols without enzymatic support,[41] with the Cys34 reduction state playing a key
role in the binding of small molecules transported by albumin.[36] This allowed us to capture biologically relevant
changes in the behavior of Cys34 as it is exposed to controlled shear
and monitor these changes optically by trapping the reactive thiolate
form with an electrophilic fluorogenic dye, 4-fluoro-7-sulfamoylbenzofurazan
(ABD-F).[42] By controlling our minimal microfluidic
capillary model, we were able to tune precisely the shear stress and
force applied to Cys34 within the capillary range by varying the microfluidic
device height and fluid flow rate. For example, as the device height
decreased from 50 to 25 μm at a constant flow rate of , shear stress increased from 0.65
to 2.16
Pa. We observed that as the device height decreases by a factor of
2, the rate of reaction with ABD-F increased by a factor of 2 from
20.9 ± 1.5 M–1 s–1 to 45.2
± 2.0 M–1 s–1 (Figure d). Interestingly, previous
results[43] had reported that this residue
is reactive only when the protein is subjected to shear stress. However,
we observed reactivity in the absence of flow, which could be expected
since the previous study used a large fluorophore with three negative
charges. Thus, the steric crowding and electrostatic effects of labeling
a buried cysteine residue in this way are likely responsible for the
observed lack of reactivity of Cys34. In contrast, our fluorophore
was significantly smaller and had a lower net charge, which could
favor labeling of the free cysteine in the absence of flow.To quantify the reaction rate changes we had observed (Figure d,e), we plotted
the reaction rate as a function of shear stress (Figure f). Satisfyingly, we observe
a linear relationship (, R2 = 0.96),
which indicated that shear stress applied within our capillary scale
microfluidic kinetics device drove the measured increase in reaction
rate.As a control, we also examined any changes in reaction
rates that
occurred for residues for which we had not observed a significant
increase in solvent accessibility on application of the shear-mimicking
steering force in our MD simulations. To achieve this, we modified
lysine residues with fluorogenic ortho-pthalaldehyde (OPA)[44,45] and monitored the effects of applying the same levels of shear on
the kinetics of the labeling reaction (Figure g,h). Notably, shear stress did not significantly
affect the reaction rate for lysine residues (Figure i).To further assess a possible conformational
change affecting Cys34
but not lysine residues, we examined aromatic residue exposure by
measuring the intrinsic fluorescence intensity of tryptophan residues;
this is solvatochromic with the tryptophan local environment with
fluorescence decreases associated with a decrease in structure.[46]An increase in flow rate to 200 μL/h
decreased tryptophan
FI by 4% (Figure j)
which was reversible after the flow was stopped (Figure k). The fact that the small
change was just detectable over error was consistent with no large
scale structural changes observed in the MD simulation studies under
shear stress conditions (Figure d) as well as the lack of significant SASA increase
for tryptophan residues on application of the steering force (Supporting Fig. 8). No change was observed for
free tryptophan in solution (Figure j).Collectively, our results (Figures and 2) suggest that the force
acting on a protein from the shear stress caused by capillary transport
does not induce large scale structural or unfolding changes, as has
been observed, for example, in amyloid proteins.[34,47] Instead, the shearing force acting on key reactive residues normally
buried within the protein structure promotes local structural changes
that increase the solvent accessibility of these residues, causing
them to react more quickly. This hypothesis would elucidate the mechanism
by which shear stress has been observed to activate signaling pathways,
such as the MAPK, JNK, and ERK pathways[48] as well as suggesting that organisms can use transport through their
vascular system to modulate protein behavior through post-translational
modifications. Interestingly, transport through the gated capillary
network is under hormonal control,[49] lending
further support to the idea of shear-mediated post-translational modification
modulation in response to stimuli such as stress.
Utilizing Rapid
Artificial Capillary Reaction Rate in a Microfluidic
Multidimensional Cysteine Biomarker Tool
Our results suggested
that biophysically mimetic systems may unlock higher reaction rates.
As an application, we developed a multidimensional assay for cysteine
biomarkers that incorporates biomarker size and cysteine reduction
state across native and reducing conditions in a highly portable microfluidic
format.To do this, we first establish a linear relationship
between free cysteine concentration (cysteine residues which are not
disulfide bonded) and fluorescence intensity (FI) of ABD-F labeled
cysteine both on chip (Figure b, filled triangles) and in bulk (Figure c, filled
triangles). Schematics of the on chip and in bulk reactions are shown
in Figure a. Disulfide
bonded cysteine residues are also attractive targets because they
are involved in neurodegenerative diseases, immune response, vascular
inflammation, and cancer aggressiveness.[50,51] However, fluorogenically labeling these residues is challenging
because it requires liberating the thiol nucleophile without the nucleophilic
reducing agent itself reacting with the electrophilic fluorogenic
dye. We observed that in situ reduction of cysteine
disulfide bonds with Tris (2-carboxyethyl) phosphine (TCEP) prior
to reaction with ABD-F did not generate significant background fluorescence,
and the reactions in bulk (Figure b, filled circles) and on chip (Figure c, filled circles) both proceeded quantitatively.
Figure 3
Development
of cysteine biomarker assay. (a) Experiments are carried
out in bulk or on-chip. (b) Fluorescence intensity as a function of
cysteine concentration for BSA, β-lactoglobulin (βLG),
and alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) under native conditions (filled triangles)
and reducing conditions with the addition of TCEP (filled circles)
(b) in bulk and (c) on chip. (d) Combination of the data sets by standardizing
between on-chip and in-bulk fluorescence intensity reveals a linear
fit flourescence intensity = 1.5 × cysteine concentration over
7 orders of magnitude with R2 = 0.98.
(e) Reaction kinetics under native conditions (filled triangles) and
with the addition of TCEP (filled circles) in bulk, (f) on chip, and (g) in bulk after protease digestion. (h) Microfluidic
biomarker device used here and in Figure .
Development
of cysteine biomarker assay. (a) Experiments are carried
out in bulk or on-chip. (b) Fluorescence intensity as a function of
cysteine concentration for BSA, β-lactoglobulin (βLG),
and alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) under native conditions (filled triangles)
and reducing conditions with the addition of TCEP (filled circles)
(b) in bulk and (c) on chip. (d) Combination of the data sets by standardizing
between on-chip and in-bulk fluorescence intensity reveals a linear
fit flourescence intensity = 1.5 × cysteine concentration over
7 orders of magnitude with R2 = 0.98.
(e) Reaction kinetics under native conditions (filled triangles) and
with the addition of TCEP (filled circles) in bulk, (f) on chip, and (g) in bulk after protease digestion. (h) Microfluidic
biomarker device used here and in Figure .
Figure 4
Correlation
of chemical and physical structural changes. (a) Crystal
structures of the proteins and protein complexes used including β-lactoglobulin
(BLG), ADH, β-Gal, BSA, and Tras, with protein chains indicated
colorimetrically. (b) Measured protein and protein complex hydrodynamic
radius as a function of molecular weight under native conditions.
(c) Measured hydrodynamic radius for each protein and protein complex
under native and reducing conditions. (d) Absolute number of available
cysteine residues measured under native and reducing conditions. (e)
Simulated Tras fragment sizes with no dissociation, half antibody
dissociation, or half antibody and heavy and light chain dissociation.
(f) Average SASA values of different residues of Tras derived from
100 ns MD simulations with shear stress (8.54 × 105 Pa).
Combining our data sets (Figure b,c) reveals that our approach is quantitative across
7 orders of magnitude in concentration (Figure d). Data, from both free and disulfide-bonded
cysteine and both on chip and bulk assay formats across all proteins
studied, all fit a single line with a high correlation coefficient
(R2 = 0.98). We performed an unconstrained
linear fit to the double logarithm of the data and obtained the equation
log y = 1.006 log x + 0.019; this
results in the linear equation y = 1.05x with no power dependence, which indicates exceptional linearity
and complete conversion across free and disulfide bonded cysteine
residues and across in bulk and on chip assay formats (Figure d). However, addition of TCEP
retarded the labeling reaction both in bulk (Figure e) and on chip (Figure f). The reaction rate on chip (7.9 ±
0.64 M–1 s–1) was comparable to
the reaction rate when a protease was added to the bulk reaction in Figure g (9.9 ± 0.38
M–1 s–1). Increased solvent accessibility,
achieved by either microfluidic shear stress or protease digestion,
mitigated the reaction retardation effect, which permitted rapid labeling
of cysteine residues on a microfluidic chip in real time, and enabled
this on chip labeling to form part of a larger on chip measurement
strategy.We note that although there are existing approaches
for the labeling
of cysteine biomarkers,[52,53] these generally require
the use of prelabeled proteins. Beneficially, the fluorogenic (fluorescence
generating) feature of our approach means that protein prelabeling
is not required, and accordingly there is no need to purify protein
from unreacted dye. Moreover, any potential impact of the presence
of the label on the protein behavior under observation can be eliminated
when particular on-chip labeling and analysis strategies are applied.
The rapid reaction kinetics and observed quantitative nature of the
labeling reaction (Figures d–f and 3e,f) permitted us to
achieve specifically a latent analysis approach[45] for native microfluidic diffusional sizing in which measurement
of a labeled protein revealed the protein hydrodynamic radius (RH) before it was labeled on chip.[45]Our cysteine biomarker chip design is
shown in Figure h.
Streams of protein and buffer
flowed adjacent to one another within the diffusion channel; mass
transport of protein across the diffusion channel was entirely due
to diffusion which is directly related to protein size (RH).[35] Smaller species diffused
further than larger species, and the detected fluorescence intensity
was ultimately related to protein size in comparison to simulation
(Supporting Fig. 17). Protein that had
diffused across the diffusion channel was labeled via ABD-F reaction
at cysteine residues, with or without the addition of TCEP and in
a buffered solution. Within the labeling loop, proteins were exposed
to shear within the capillary range explored here (Figure b) of 0.44 Pa permitting rapid
reaction within the on chip labeling module. Because both protein
size in a native and reducing environment are available, our approach
enables a novel nondisruptive assessment of the structural effect
of protein disulfide bond cleavage.We validate our assay by
measuring proteins and protein complexes
that vary in molecular weight, structure, and oligomeric state including
dimeric BLG, monomeric BSA, tetrameric alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH),
and tetrameric β-galactosidase (β-Gal) (Figure a). We observe RH, predicted by
scaling laws[54] for all globular proteins
(Figure b) in a native
environment. RH values are comparable
within error in a reducing environment, suggesting that significant
global structural changes have not taken place. Because labeling is
quantitative, when the protein concentration is known the fluorescence
intensity depends exclusively on the number of total or free cysteine
residues within the protein. We calculate the absolute number of cysteine
residues for each protein and protein complex detected under native
and reducing conditions and compare with expected values (Figure d). All of our results
match expected numbers of available cysteines within error.Correlation
of chemical and physical structural changes. (a) Crystal
structures of the proteins and protein complexes used including β-lactoglobulin
(BLG), ADH, β-Gal, BSA, and Tras, with protein chains indicated
colorimetrically. (b) Measured protein and protein complex hydrodynamic
radius as a function of molecular weight under native conditions.
(c) Measured hydrodynamic radius for each protein and protein complex
under native and reducing conditions. (d) Absolute number of available
cysteine residues measured under native and reducing conditions. (e)
Simulated Tras fragment sizes with no dissociation, half antibody
dissociation, or half antibody and heavy and light chain dissociation.
(f) Average SASA values of different residues of Tras derived from
100 ns MD simulations with shear stress (8.54 × 105 Pa).
Therapeutic Antibody Dissociation
in Blood-Plasmalike Reducing
Environment
Finally, having validated our assay, we applied
it to probe the behavior of a biologically relevant system. Trastuzumab
is a humanized IgG monoclonal antibody used in the treatment of human
epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) positive breast[55] and stomach[56] cancers.
Trastuzumab binds to the extracellular domain of HER2, promoting internalization
and downregulation of HER2 mediated cell division.[57] When trastuzumab is administered via intravenous injection,
it passes through capillaries and is in a reducing environment (blood
plasma).[58] We applied our assay in order
to quantify any structural changes that may occur when trasutuzmab
is placed in a reducing environment and confined to the capillary
length scale.In a nonreducing environment, we measured an RH for trasutuzumab which exceeds by about 25%
the RH predicted for globular proteins,
as we expected given its extended conformation. However, interestingly
when trastuzumab was placed in a reducing environment, it is measured RH decreases from 5.0 ± 0.6 nm to 2.8 ±
0.2 nm, suggesting a dissociation event. When trastuzumab was placed
in a reducing environment, the measured absolute number of available
cysteines increased from 0 to 2. This suggested that only cysteine
residues within interchain disulfide bonds are being reduced and labeled,
and reduction of these disulfide bonds was consistent with the apparent
dissociation event.We modeled the trastuzumab antibody, the
trastuzumab half antibody,
and the heavy and light chain fragments of the trasutuzumab half antibody
(Figure e). While
dissociation of a hetero-oligomer like trastuzumab by definition creates
a mixture of different monomers, our diffusional assay preferentially
separates, labels, and detects the smaller species which have diffused
into the labeling region (Supporting Fig. 16). The RH we measured for trastuzumab
under reducing conditions, 2.8 ± 0.2 nm, was in agreement with
the size modeled for trastuzumab light chain fragments (2.9 nm), suggesting
trastuzumab dissociation into both half antibody and heavy and light
chain fragments. MD simulations of Tras carried out with a shear flow
(or alternatively, SMD simulations) showed that the intermolecular
disulfide bridges (heavy and light chain) had a significantly higher
SASA upon application of shear stress than the intramolecular disulfides
(Supporting Fig.s 4 and 12), supporting
the idea that these particular disulfide bonds would have been highly
accessible to the TCEP reducing agent when shear stress was applied
in the microfluidic device. Finally, we performed native mass spectrometry
experiments to directly measure the stoichiometry under reducing,
shearing conditions as in our microfluidic device and in capillaries
(Supporting Fig. 18b). Satisfyingly, we
observed dissociation of the monoclonal antibody into heavy and light
chain fragments in reducing, shearing conditions, as our experiments
and simulations indicated, which was not observed in our control experiments
under nonreducing conditions (Supporting Fig. 18a).
Conclusion
Heavy/light chain dissociation
within a reducing environment, such
as blood plasma, reduces the affinity of trastuzumab and other monoclonal
antibodies.[59] Our experimental and simulation
results, which we confirmed via native mass spectrometry, suggest
that trastuzumab may be dissociated into heavy and light chain components
in plasma, potentially reducing its affinity. Further studies should
use our assay to study dissociation of trastuzumab in plasma. Our
results also suggest that in vivo fluorescence techniques,
for example, involving FRET, should be used to assess the structural
integrity of trasutzumab that has been transported through capillaries
in blood plasma. Finally, our assay can be used to screen and identify
variants of trasutzumab and other monoclonal antibodies which do not
dissociate in a reducing environment and which may retain higher affinity
in plasma. This may be achieved by substituting heavy chains that
form disulfide bonds with higher reduction potentials. Our assay could
also be used in the study of other biologics or disease associated
cysteine biomarkers.Our results further suggest that shear
stress experienced within
microfluidic devices may modulate protein structure and that reaction
rates for some reactions may be accelerated relative to their bulk
counterparts. The research area of nanofluidics could enable particularly
rapid reactivity due to the particularly small channel characteristic
length scales and associated high shear rates, albeit with potential
structural changes.More broadly, we have provided a proof-of-concept
demonstration
of the potential of biophysically mimetic chemistry. We anticipate
that mirroring nature and its use of its physical architecture to
modulate protein function will find broad application in chemistry,
biochemistry, chemical biology, and biotechnology.
Authors: Duncan A White; Alexander K Buell; Tuomas P J Knowles; Mark E Welland; Christopher M Dobson Journal: J Am Chem Soc Date: 2010-04-14 Impact factor: 15.419
Authors: John Dobson; Amit Kumar; Leon F Willis; Roman Tuma; Daniel R Higazi; Richard Turner; David C Lowe; Alison E Ashcroft; Sheena E Radford; Nikil Kapur; David J Brockwell Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2017-04-17 Impact factor: 11.205