Stefan Kuczera1,2, Mohammad Alipoor1, Fredrik Langkilde1, Stephan E Maier1,3. 1. Institute of Clinical Sciences, Sahlgrenska Academy, Gothenburg University, Gothenburg, Sweden. 2. MedTech West, Sahlgrenska University Hospital, Gothenburg, Sweden. 3. Department of Radiology, Brigham Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Correction of Rician signal bias in magnitude MR images. METHODS: A model-based, iterative fitting procedure is used to simultaneously estimate true signal and underlying Gaussian noise with standard deviation σ g on a pixel-by-pixel basis in magnitude MR images. A precomputed function that relates absolute residuals between measured signals and model fit to σ g is used to iteratively estimate σ g . The feasibility of the method is evaluated and compared to maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) for diffusion signal decay simulations and diffusion-weighted images of the prostate considering 21 linearly spaced b-values from 0 to 3000 s/mm2 . A multidirectional analysis was performed with publically available brain data. RESULTS: Model simulations show that the Rician bias correction algorithm is fast, with an accuracy and precision that is on par to model-based MLE and direct fitting in the case of pure Gaussian noise. Increased accuracy in parameter prediction in a low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) scenario is ideally achieved by using a composite of multiple signal decays from neighboring voxels as input for the algorithm. For patient data, good agreement with high SNR reference data of diffusion in prostate is achieved. CONCLUSIONS: OBSIDIAN is a novel, alternative, simple to implement approach for rapid Rician bias correction applicable in any case where differences between true signal decay and underlying model function can be considered negligible in comparison to noise. The proposed composite fitting approach permits accurate parameter estimation even in typical clinical scenarios with low SNR, which significantly simplifies comparison of complex diffusion parameters among studies.
PURPOSE: Correction of Rician signal bias in magnitude MR images. METHODS: A model-based, iterative fitting procedure is used to simultaneously estimate true signal and underlying Gaussian noise with standard deviation σ g on a pixel-by-pixel basis in magnitude MR images. A precomputed function that relates absolute residuals between measured signals and model fit to σ g is used to iteratively estimate σ g . The feasibility of the method is evaluated and compared to maximum likelihood estimation (MLE) for diffusion signal decay simulations and diffusion-weighted images of the prostate considering 21 linearly spaced b-values from 0 to 3000 s/mm2 . A multidirectional analysis was performed with publically available brain data. RESULTS: Model simulations show that the Rician bias correction algorithm is fast, with an accuracy and precision that is on par to model-based MLE and direct fitting in the case of pure Gaussian noise. Increased accuracy in parameter prediction in a low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) scenario is ideally achieved by using a composite of multiple signal decays from neighboring voxels as input for the algorithm. For patient data, good agreement with high SNR reference data of diffusion in prostate is achieved. CONCLUSIONS: OBSIDIAN is a novel, alternative, simple to implement approach for rapid Rician bias correction applicable in any case where differences between true signal decay and underlying model function can be considered negligible in comparison to noise. The proposed composite fitting approach permits accurate parameter estimation even in typical clinical scenarios with low SNR, which significantly simplifies comparison of complex diffusion parameters among studies.
Authors: Yaniv Assaf; Daniel C Alexander; Derek K Jones; Albero Bizzi; Tim E J Behrens; Chris A Clark; Yoram Cohen; Tim B Dyrby; Petra S Huppi; Thomas R Knoesche; Denis Lebihan; Geoff J M Parker; Cyril Poupon; Debbie Anaby; Alfred Anwander; Leah Bar; Daniel Barazany; Tamar Blumenfeld-Katzir; Silvia De-Santis; Delphine Duclap; Matteo Figini; Elda Fischi; Pamela Guevara; Penny Hubbard; Shir Hofstetter; Saad Jbabdi; Nicolas Kunz; Francois Lazeyras; Alice Lebois; Matthew G Liptrot; Henrik Lundell; Jean-François Mangin; David Moreno Dominguez; Darya Morozov; Jan Schreiber; Kiran Seunarine; Simone Nava; Cyril Poupon; Till Riffert; Efrat Sasson; Benoit Schmitt; Noam Shemesh; Stam N Sotiropoulos; Ido Tavor; Hui Gary Zhang; Feng-Lei Zhou Journal: Neuroimage Date: 2013-05-28 Impact factor: 6.556