Majid Aljoghaiman1,2, Amanda Martyniuk1, Forough Farrokhyar3, Aleksa Cenic1, Edward Kachur1. 1. Division of Neurosurgery, Department of Surgery, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada. 2. Division of Neurosurgery, Department of Surgery, King Faisal University, Alahsa, Saudi Arabia. 3. Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Office of Surgical Research Services, Surgical Research Methodology, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Lumbar discectomy is a common spinal procedure. The purpose of this survey is to ascertain neurosurgeons' practices in the surgical management of one-level lumbar discectomies in the Canadian adult population and to determine changes over a 10-year period. METHODS: One-page questionnaire distributed electronically to neurosurgeons in Canada and results were compared with similarly completed survey from 2007. RESULTS: A total of 109 completed surveys were returned representing 43.8% response rate. This is compared to 112 completed surveys in 2007 reaching 64.4% response rate. Statistically significant differences between the two points in time were noted. There was an increase in spine fellowship training [26 (33.3%) 2017 vs. 15 (15.3%) 2007 (P=0.007)], use of pre-operative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) [65 (83.3%) 2017 vs. 27 (27.6%) 2007] (P<0.001), use of intramuscular injection [58 (74.4%) 2017 vs. 43 (43.9%) 2007 (P<0.001)], use of both microscope and loupes [20 (25.6%) 2017 vs. 3 (3.1%) 2007 (P<0.001)], use of tubular retraction [26 (33.3%) 2017 vs. 12 (12.2%) 2007 (P=0.001)], use of fibrin glue for a durotomy [72 (92.3%) 2017 vs. 75 (76.5%) 2007 (P=0.007)]. There was an increased rate of same-day discharge in 2017 [46 (59.0%) vs. 18 (18.4%) 2007 (P<0.001)], and quicker return to work [62.8% in 6 weeks or less vs. 39.7% (P=0.003)]. No statistical differences were noted with pre-incision localization, pre-op antibiotics, pre-incision local anesthetic use, use of fat graft or epidural steroids. In either survey the majority would not perform lumbar discectomy on a patient whose primary complaint is back pain. CONCLUSIONS: Our survey identified changes in practice patterns amongst Canadian neurosurgeons with respect to performing one-level lumbar discectomy over the past 10 years. These changes include increased preference for minimally invasive surgical technique, same-day discharge and sooner return to work. Randomized trials would be helpful to provide evidence regarding which practices are associated with better outcomes. 2020 Journal of Spine Surgery. All rights reserved.
BACKGROUND: Lumbar discectomy is a common spinal procedure. The purpose of this survey is to ascertain neurosurgeons' practices in the surgical management of one-level lumbar discectomies in the Canadian adult population and to determine changes over a 10-year period. METHODS: One-page questionnaire distributed electronically to neurosurgeons in Canada and results were compared with similarly completed survey from 2007. RESULTS: A total of 109 completed surveys were returned representing 43.8% response rate. This is compared to 112 completed surveys in 2007 reaching 64.4% response rate. Statistically significant differences between the two points in time were noted. There was an increase in spine fellowship training [26 (33.3%) 2017 vs. 15 (15.3%) 2007 (P=0.007)], use of pre-operative magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) [65 (83.3%) 2017 vs. 27 (27.6%) 2007] (P<0.001), use of intramuscular injection [58 (74.4%) 2017 vs. 43 (43.9%) 2007 (P<0.001)], use of both microscope and loupes [20 (25.6%) 2017 vs. 3 (3.1%) 2007 (P<0.001)], use of tubular retraction [26 (33.3%) 2017 vs. 12 (12.2%) 2007 (P=0.001)], use of fibrin glue for a durotomy [72 (92.3%) 2017 vs. 75 (76.5%) 2007 (P=0.007)]. There was an increased rate of same-day discharge in 2017 [46 (59.0%) vs. 18 (18.4%) 2007 (P<0.001)], and quicker return to work [62.8% in 6 weeks or less vs. 39.7% (P=0.003)]. No statistical differences were noted with pre-incision localization, pre-op antibiotics, pre-incision local anesthetic use, use of fat graft or epidural steroids. In either survey the majority would not perform lumbar discectomy on a patient whose primary complaint is back pain. CONCLUSIONS: Our survey identified changes in practice patterns amongst Canadian neurosurgeons with respect to performing one-level lumbar discectomy over the past 10 years. These changes include increased preference for minimally invasive surgical technique, same-day discharge and sooner return to work. Randomized trials would be helpful to provide evidence regarding which practices are associated with better outcomes. 2020 Journal of Spine Surgery. All rights reserved.
Authors: R H Wittenberg; A Lütke; D Longwitz; K H Greskötter; R E Willburger; K Schmidt; C Plafki; R Steffen Journal: Int Orthop Date: 1998 Impact factor: 3.075
Authors: Martin N Stienen; Holger Joswig; Ivan Chau; Marian C Neidert; David Bellut; Thomas Wälchli; Karl Schaller; Oliver P Gautschi Journal: J Neurosurg Spine Date: 2017-12-15
Authors: Oluwaseun O Akinduro; Brandon A Miller; Diogo C Haussen; Gustavo Pradilla; Faiz U Ahmad Journal: Neurosurg Focus Date: 2015-10 Impact factor: 4.047
Authors: Brian T Jankowitz; Dave S Atteberry; Peter C Gerszten; Patricia Karausky; Boyle C Cheng; Ryan Faught; William C Welch Journal: Eur Spine J Date: 2009-03-13 Impact factor: 3.134
Authors: D Scott Kreiner; Steven W Hwang; John E Easa; Daniel K Resnick; Jamie L Baisden; Shay Bess; Charles H Cho; Michael J DePalma; Paul Dougherty; Robert Fernand; Gary Ghiselli; Amgad S Hanna; Tim Lamer; Anthony J Lisi; Daniel J Mazanec; Richard J Meagher; Robert C Nucci; Rakesh D Patel; Jonathan N Sembrano; Anil K Sharma; Jeffrey T Summers; Christopher K Taleghani; William L Tontz; John F Toton Journal: Spine J Date: 2013-11-14 Impact factor: 4.166