ESHRE PGT Consortium data collection XVI-XVIII: cycles from 2013 to 2015.

STUDY QUESTION: What are the trends and developments in preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) in 2013-2015 as compared to previous years? SUMMARY ANSWER: The main trends observed in the retrospective data collections 2013-2015, representing valuable data on PGT activity in (mainly) Europe, are the increased application of trophectoderm biopsy at the cost of cleavage stage biopsy and the continuing expansion of comprehensive testing technology in PGT for chromosomal structural rearrangements and for aneuploidies (PGT-SR and PGT-A). WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Since it was established in 1997, the ESHRE PGT Consortium has been collecting data from international PGT centres. To date, 15 data sets and an overview of the first 10 years of data collections have been published. STUDY DESIGN SIZE DURATION: Collection of (mainly) European data by the PGT Consortium for ESHRE. The data for PGT cycles performed between 1 January 2013 and 31 December 2015 were provided by participating centres on a voluntary basis. For the collection of cycle, pregnancy and baby data, separate, pre-designed MS Excel tables were used. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS SETTING
METHODS: Data were submitted by 59, 60 and 59 centres respectively for 2013, 2014 and 2015 (full PGT Consortium members). Records with incomplete or inconsistent data were excluded from the calculations. Corrections, calculations, figures and tables were made by expert co-authors. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: For data collection XVI/XVII/XVIII, 59/60/59 centres reported data on 8164/9769/11 120 cycles with oocyte retrieval: 5020/6278/7155 cycles for PGT-A, 2026/2243/2661 cycles for PGT for monogenic/single gene defects, 1039/1189/1231 cycles for PGT-SR and 79/59/73 cycles for sexing for X-linked diseases. From 2013 until 2015, the uptake of biopsy at the blastocyst stage was mainly observed in cycles for PGT-A (from 23% to 36%) and PGT-SR (from 22% to 36%), alongside the increased application of comprehensive testing technology (from 66% to 75% in PGT-A and from 36% to 58% in PGT-SR). LIMITATIONS REASONS FOR CAUTION: The findings apply to the 59/60/59 participating centres and may not represent worldwide trends in PGT. Data were collected retrospectively and no details of the follow-up on PGT pregnancies and babies born were provided. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE
FINDINGS: Being the largest data collection on PGT worldwide, detailed information about ongoing developments in the field is provided. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTERESTS: The study has no external funding and all costs are covered by ESHRE. There are no competing interests declared. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.

Introduction

The ESHRE PGT Consortium was established in 1997: its main objectives are to collect prospective and retrospective data, produce consensus guidelines for preimplantation genetic testing (PGT) laboratories and to promote best practice.

Recently, the PGT consortium in collaboration with the ESHRE Special Interest Group Embryology issued four consensus papers on Recommendations for good practice in Preimplantation Genetic Testing (ESHRE PGT Consortium Steering Committee, 2020; ESHRE PGT Consortium and SIG-Embryology Biopsy Working Group, 2020; ESHRE PGT-M Working Group, 2020; ESHRE PGT-SR/PGT-A Working Group, 2020).

To date, 15 data collections have been published, covering all aspects of PGT (Geraedts , 2000; ESHRE PGD Consortium Steering Committee, 2002; Sermon , 2007; Harper , 2008, 2010a,b; Goossens , 2009, 2012; Moutou ; De Rycke , 2017). A 10-year overview of PGT was published in 2012 (Harper ). No other data of this magnitude exists in the literature.

As of 2017, the International Committee for Monitoring Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ICMART) revised terms and definitions were adopted. They comprise PGT for monogenic/single gene defects (PGT-M) for monogenic diseases, PGT for chromosomal structural rearrangements (PGT-SR) for chromosomal structural rearrangements and PGT for aneuploidies (PGT-A) for aneuploidies (Zegers-Hochschild ). Previous Consortium data collections included a separate file for PGT cycles performed for sexing for X-linked diseases and it was decided to keep this format. Traditionally, PGT cycles for chromosomal numerical aberrations of high genetic risk have been included in what currently is the PGT-SR category, and this structure was maintained as well.

This article will present summary data from PGT cycles performed between 1 January 2013 and 31 December 2015 in terms of overall trends, highlighting how the practice of PGT has evolved over the collection period. As such, these data collections have a different format compared to that of previous years. Due to a huge increase in the number of PGT cycles reported to the ESHRE PGT Consortium each year, alongside the ever growing complexity of the PGT treatments, it has become extremely difficult to mine the data and produce accurate tables. The FileMakerPro database that has been used up until data collection XV, has proven to be no longer fit for purpose and efforts have been undertaken to create a new database that will meet current needs and allows centres to register and analyse their PGT data in real time. However, the data collection rejuvenation project has faced significant setbacks causing serious delay for the data collections of the following years. At the same time, new techniques in both the IVF and genetic laboratories were being developed and implemented, changing the PGT landscape and the way PGT cycles were being managed. In an effort to record this transition period, members of the ESHRE PGT Consortium were asked to submit summary data on PGT cycles performed in the years 2013–2015. Concurrently, a questionnaire was sent to ESHRE PGT Consortium members to try and make an inventory of the uptake of innovations in ART and genetic diagnostic technologies in PGT practice.

The present manuscript is based on these data.

Materials and methods

The report includes PGT treatments started between 1 January 2013 and 31 December 2015, and covers data on PGT indication, biopsy method, diagnostic technology, efficiency of the different procedures and clinical PGT outcome in terms of positive hCG and positive heartbeat.

Summary data on PGT cycles for 2013, 2014 and 2015 were provided by 59/60/59 Consortium members, respectively, the majority of which are based in European countries. Data cover the following treatment modalities: PGT-A, PGT-M, PGT-SR and PGT for sexing for X-linked diseases.

For the collection of the data, representatives of the participating PGT centres were asked to anonymize their data, import them in pre-designed MS Excel tables and send these to the ESHRE Central Office Science Manager. Initial curation of the submitted data allowed the identification of omissions and any ambivalent data entries. If data were incomplete or inconsistencies were detected, the ESHRE Science Manager contacted the centres’ representative for clarification. Any remaining records with incomplete or inconsistent data were excluded from further processing. Data from all participating centres were subsequently collated and processed by expert members of the ESHRE PGT Consortium Steering Committee for in-depth analysis.

The terminology used in this report was based on the glossary of ICMART (Zegers-Hochschild ). A clinical pregnancy was defined as a pregnancy diagnosed by ultrasonographic visualization of one or more gestational sacs or definitive clinical signs of pregnancy.

To study additional trends in the management and workflow of PGT cycles, two questionnaires were sent to ESHRE PGT Consortium members. The first at the end of 2013 addressing cycles carried out between 1 January and 1 October 2013 and the second 2 years later, addressing a comparable period.

Results

This report includes data from 59 centres, presented in Tables I–IV and Figs 1–6. The nature of the summary data provided by the ESHRE PGT Consortium members for 2013–2015 does not allow the calculation of cumulative data for collections I–XVIII.

Table I

Overview of overall PGT treatment cycles in 2013–2015.

	PGT-overall			PGT-A			PGT-M			PGT-SR			PGT for sexing for X-linked diseases
	2013	2014	2015	2013	2014	2015	2013	2014	2015	2013	2014	2015	2013	2014	2015
Cycles to OR	8164	9769	11 120	5020	6278	7155	2026	2243	2661	1039	1189	1231	79	59	73
ART method	8164	9758	11 114	5020	6277	7155	2026	2234	2655	1039	1189	1231	79	58	73
IVF	280 (3)	198 (2)	143 (1)	166 (3)	117 (2)	95 (1)	0	0	0	94 (9)	72 (6)	39 (3)	20 (25)	9 (16)	9 (12)
ICSI	7213 (88)	9133 (94)	10 449 (94)	4515 (90)	6079 (97)	6948 (97)	1802 (89)	1943 (87)	2356 (89)	856 (82)	1068 (90)	1093 (89)	40 (51)	43 (74)	52 (71)
IVF + ICSI	246 (3)	335 (3)	371 (3)	0	0	0	206 (10)	291 (13)	299 (11)	29 (3)	38 (3)	60 (5)	11 (14)	6 (10)	12 (16)
Unknown	425 (5)	92 (1)	151 (1)	339 (7)	81 (1)	112 (2)	18 (1)	0	0	60 (6)	11 (1)	39 (3)	8 (10)	0	0
Cycles to PGT	7800	9159	10 292	4780	5819	6512	1952	2143	2524	989	1141	1187	79	56	69
FISH only	2087 (27)	1696 (19)	1380 (13)	1400 (29)	1088 (19)	872 (13)	0	1 (<1)	3 (<1)	627 (63)	568 (50)	464 (39)	60 (76)	39 (70)	41 (59)
PCR only	1814 (23)	1885 (21)	2215 (22)	16 (<1)	0	4 (<1)	1775 (91)	1872 (87)	2194 (87)	7 (1)	4 (<1)	10 (1)	16 (20)	9 (16)	7 (10)
qPCR	222 (3)	584 (6)	783 (8)	219 (5)	463 (8)	728 (11)	0	111 (5)	25 (1)	3 (<1)	10 (1)	30 (3)	0	0	0
WGA
+ PCR	123 (2)	89 (1)	106 (1)	0	8	10 (<1)	123 (6)	80 (4)	96 (4)	0	1 (<1)	0	0	0	0
+ qPCR	0	0	3 (<1)	0	0	0	0	0	3 (<1)	0	0	0	0	0	0
+ SNP Array	2 (<1)	32 (<1)	121 (1)	2 (<1)	2 (<1)	0	0	16 (1)	96 (4)	0	14 (1)	25 (2)	0	0	0
+ CGH Array	3513 (45)	4718 (52)	5061 (49)	3104 (65)	4127 (71)	4322 (66)	54 (3)	63 (3)	100 (4)	352 (36)	520 (46)	618 (52)	3 (4)	8 (14)	21 (30)
+ NGS	39 (1)	155 (2)	623 (6)	39 (1)	131 (2)	576 (9)	0	0	7	0	24 (2)	40 (3)	0	0	0
Biopsy method	7800	9141	10 292	4780	5819	6512	1952	2143	2522	989	1123	1187	79	56	71
Polar body	771 (10)	657 (7)	626 (6)	687 (14)	593 (10)	547 (8)	63 (3)	53 (2)	64 (3)	21 (2)	11 (1)	15 (1)	0	0	0
Cleavage stage	5423 (70)	5935 (65)	6007 (58)	2865 (60)	3229 (55)	3057 (47)	1739 (89)	1834 (86)	2149 (85)	745 (75)	818 (73)	743 (63)	74 (94)	54 (96)	58 (82)
Morula day4	154 (2)	184 (20	591 (6)	145 (3)	184 (3)	591 (9)	0	0	0	9 (1)	0	0	0	0	0
Blastocyst	1452 (19)	2365 (26)	3068 (30)	1083 (23)	1813 (31)	2317 (36)	150 (8)	256 (12)	309 (12)	214 (22)	294 (26)	429 (36)	5 (6)	2 (4)	13 (18)
Embryology
Successfully biopsied	39 492	46 534	49 505	22 741	27 612	29 217	11 588	12 651	14 592	4748	5998	5310	415	273	386
Diagnosed	36 922 (93)	43 037 (92)	43 562 (88)	21 760 (96)	26 212 (95)	25 198 (86)	10 327 (89)	11 129 (88)	13 053 (90)	4480 (94)	5450 (91)	4953 (93)	355 (86)	246 (90)	358 (93)
Transferable	12 118 (33)	14 153 (33)	15 352 (35)	6152 (28)	7799 (30)	7934 (31)	4594 (44)	4832 (43)	5916 (45)	1203 (27)	1410 (26)	1378 (28)	169 (48)	112 (46)	124 (35)
Transferred	6997 (58)	7568 (53)	6969 (45)	4171 (68)	4706 (60)	3875 (489)	1966 (42)	1974 (41)	2303 (39)	786 (65)	834 (59)	742 (54)	74 (44)	54 (48)	49 (40)
Clinical outcome
Cycles to ET	5052	5617	5641	2892	3392	3295	1456	1560	1718	652	632	591	52	33	37
hCG positive	2340	2750	2841	1440	1819	1757	594	654	823	280	265	252	26	12	9
Positive heart beat	2104	2418	2219	1354	1680	1443	496	514	576	234	215	193	20	9	7

Data are presented as number (%). % are calculated per total of ART method, cycles to PGT or biopsy method. In the embryology section, % are calculated per total of the row above.

CGH, comparative genomic hybridization; ET, embryo transfer; NGS, next-generation sequencing; OR, oocyte retrieval; PGT, preimplantation genetic testing; PGT-A, PGT for aneuploidies; PGT-M, PGT for monogenic/single gene defects; PGT-SR, PGT for chromosomal structural rearrangements; qPCR, quantitative PCR; SNP, single-nucleotide polymorphism; WGA, whole genome amplification.

Table IV

Overview of indications for PGT-SR in 2013–2015.

	2013	2014	2015
Robertsonian translocation, male carrier	178 (17)	225 (19)	166 (13)
Robertsonian translocation, female carrier	74 (7)	108 (9)	127 (10)
Reciprocal translocation, male carrier	350 (34)	352 (30)	371 (30)
Reciprocal translocation, female carrier	290 (28)	332 (28)	393 (32)
Deletion	38 (4)	29 (2)	21 (2)
Inversion	60 (6)	74 (6)	82 (7)
Other	30 (3)	54 (5)	71 (6)
Unknown	19 (2)	15 (1)	0
Total	1039	1189	1231

Data are given as number (%).

Table I provides an overview of the current data collection and covers a total of 8164 cycles in 2013, 9769 cycles in 2014 and 11 120 cycles in 2015, indicating a continuing expansion of treatment numbers in the participating centres. As seen in Fig. 1, PGT-A cycles account for the majority of PGT treatments and distribution among the various PGT indication categories has remained stable over the data collection period.

Figure 1.

Distribution of PGT indications in 2013–2015. In 2013, preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies (PGT-A), monogenic/single gene defects (PGT-M), chromosomal structural rearrangements (PGT-SR) and PGT for X-linked diseases (XL-D) accounted for 61%, 25%, 13% and 1% of total number of PGT cycles, respectively. In 2014, PGT-A, PGT-M, PGT-SR and PGT for XL-D accounted for 64%, 23%, 12% and <1% of total number of PGT cycles, respectively. In 2015, PGT-A, PGT-M, PGT-SR and PGT for XL-D accounted for 64%, 24%, 11% and <1% of total number of PGT cycles, respectively.

For all PGT indications, ICSI was the method most often used for fertilization. It was used almost exclusively in PGT-M (either for all available oocytes or a proportion thereof). It was used the least in PGT for sexing for X-linked diseases (Table I). These figures do not differ significantly from the ones reported in the previous data collection (80% in PGT-SR, 99% in PGT-M, 80% in PGT-A and 66% in X-linked disorders).

For the total number of cycles to biopsy in 2013, 2014 and 2015, cleavage-stage biopsy was still the most common method applied (70%, 65% and 58%, respectively). However, as shown in Fig. 2 and Table I, remarkable differences were noted for the individual PGT indication categories. In PGT-M and PGT for sexing for X-linked diseases, cleavage stage biopsy was performed for the vast majority of cases during the whole collection period, whereas in PGT-SR and PGT-A, the percentage of cycles performed with blastocyst biopsy steadily increased over the years and amounted to 36% in the data collection of 2015.

Figure 2.

Distribution of biopsy stage in 2013–2015. (A) Overall, (B) PGT-A, (C) PGT-M, (D) PGT-SR, (E) PGT for sexing for X-linked diseases. PB, polar body, d4, day 4. Exact numbers and percentages can be found in Table I.

PGT-A

Supplementary Table SI summarizes the 5020, 6278 and 7155 PGT-A cycles to oocyte retrieval (OR) per indication in 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively. Table II shows the different indications for the PGT-A cycles performed. Advanced maternal age (AMA) is by far the most common indication for PGT-A (44%, 47% and 51% in 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively), followed by repeated implantation failure (RIF) in combination with AMA and recurrent miscarriage (RM) in combination with AMA. Other indications were RIF and RM as a single indication, severe male factor, previous abnormal pregnancies and carrier status of abnormal karyotype. A small number of PGT-A cycles was performed as an integrated part of an oocyte donation treatment and a growing number (compared to previous data collections) of PGT-A cycles was performed without a reported medical indication.

Table II

Overview of indications for PGT-A in 2013–2015.

	2013	2014	2015
AMA	2189 (43.6)	2936 (46.8)	3636 (50.8)
AMA + RM	561 (11.2)	503 (8.0)	563 (7.9)
AMA + RIF	550 (11.0)	673 (10.7)	702 (9.8)
RM	346 (6.9)	394 (6.3)	376 (5.3)
RIF	361 (7.2)	358 (5.7)	416 (5.8)
SMF	298 (5.9)	436 (6.9)	395 (5.5)
Previous abnormal pregnancies	91 (1.8)	122 (1.9)	102 (1.4)
Carrier status of abnormal karyotype	98 (2.0)	90 (1.4)	65 (0.9)
Ovum donation	85 (1.7)	101 (1.6)	131 (1.8)
No indication	327 (6.5)	562 (9.0)	372 (5.2)
Other	114 (2.3)	103 (1.6)	397 (5.5)
Total	5020 (100.0)	6278 (100.0)	7155 (100.0)

Data are given as number (%).

AMA, advanced maternal age; RIF, repeated implantation failure; RM, recurrent miscarriage; SMF, severe male factor.

In 90–97% of all cycles to OR, ICSI was used for fertilization (Table I), a figure that is similar to the one from previous data sets. The vast majority of cycles to OR (≥91%) had embryos available for biopsy. The majority of biopsies were still performed at cleavage stage, with blastocyst biopsy advancing and accounting for 36% of all PGT-A cycles in 2015 (Fig. 2B).

FISH as the genetic analysis was greatly outnumbered by quantitative PCR and comprehensive, whole genome amplification (WGA)-based methodologies, the latter of which amounted to 75% of cases in 2015 (Fig. 3B).

Figure 3.

Method of PGT analysis in 2013–2015. (A) Overall, (B) PGT-A, (C) PGT-M, (D) PGT-SR, (E) PGT for sexing for X-linked diseases. qPCR, quantitative PCR; WGA, whole genome amplification. Exact numbers and percentages can be found in Table I.

Of the embryos that were successfully biopsied, 96% in 2013 and 95% in 2014 gave a diagnosis. For unknown reasons, this figure was remarkably lower in 2015 (86%) (Table I). In general, about 30% of diagnosed embryos were genetically transferable (Fig. 4) and between 50% and 68% of these were actually transferred. As the percentage of transferred embryos was lower compared to previous data collections and decreasing over the years, this parameter might be confounded by the fact that some participants only recorded fresh embryo transfers whereas trophectoderm (TE) biopsy in combination with comprehensive diagnosis usually requires cryopreservation of embryos and transfer in a subsequent frozen cycle.

Figure 4.

Percentage of genetically transferable embryos per number of embryos diagnosed in 2013–2015. Exact numbers and percentages can be found in Table I.

From the 3-year total of 18 453 cycles to OR, only 52% resulted in an embryo transfer procedure (Fig. 5). This is lower than the mean percentage reported in previous data sets (62%), which again might be explained by the missing frozen embryo transfers.

Figure 5.

Percentage of cycles to embryo transfer per number of oocyte retrievals in 2013–2015. Exact numbers can be found in Table I.

A positive hCG was obtained in 5016 cycles (3-year total), with a positive heartbeat in 4477 cycles (24% per OR and 47% per embryo transfer) (Fig. 6). Historically, the clinical pregnancy rate is stable at around 20% per OR and 30% per embryo transfer procedure. Not surprisingly, the poorest outcome was obtained for AMA + RIF, with a 20% clinical pregnancy rate per OR and 41% per embryo transfer (Supplementary Table SI).

Figure 6.

Clinical pregnancy rate per oocyte retrieval (A) and per embryo transfer (B) in 2013–2015. ET, embryo transfer. Exact numbers can be found in Table I.

No parameters further downstream (i.e. implantation rate, delivery rate, miscarriage rate) could be calculated because of too many missing data.

PGT-M

Supplementary Table SII summarizes the 2026, 2243 and 2661 PGT-M cycles to OR per indication in 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively. Half of all the PGT-M cycles was performed for an autosomal dominant disease, followed by an autosomal recessive indication, which accounted for 26% of PGT-M cycles (Table III).

Table III

Overview of indications for PGT-M in 2013–2015.

	2013	2014	2015
Autosomal recessive	552 (27)	564 (25)	659 (25)
Autosomal dominant	981 (48)	1189 (53)	1339 (50)
X-linked (no sexing)	319 (16)	330 (15)	374 (14)
HLA only	16 (1)	7 (0)	15 (1)
HLA + monogenic disorder	99 (5)	101 (5)	70 (3)
Other	59 (3)	38 (2)	204 (8)
Other PGD + PGS	0 (0)	14 (1)	0 (0)
Total	2026	2243	2661

Data are given as number (%).

PGS, preimplantation genetic screening.

In all cycles to OR, ICSI was used for fertilization (for all or part of the oocytes), a figure that is similar to the one from previous data sets. Nearly all cycles to OR (96%) had embryos available for biopsy, which was most commonly applied to cleavage-stage embryos (86%) (Fig. 2C) and PCR still being the most widely used first-line method of DNA amplification (88%) (Fig. 3C). The uptake of blastocyst biopsy remained low compared to other indications (8% in 2013 and 12% in 2015), as did the use of comprehensive diagnostic technology (9% in 2013 and 12% in 2015).

Of the embryos successfully biopsied, 88–90% gave a diagnostic result, of which on average 44% was genetically transferable (Fig. 4). As was to be expected, the lowest chance of a transferable embryo was found in the HLA and HLA plus monogenic disorder group (Supplementary Table SII). Of all transferable embryos, between 39% and 42% were actually transferred, either in a fresh or a frozen cycle.

From the 3-year total of 6930 cycles to OR, 68% resulted in an embryo transfer procedure, the highest proportion among the different PGT categories. This is slightly higher than the mean percentage reported in previous data sets (64%).

A positive hCG was obtained in 2071 cycles (3-year total), with a positive heartbeat in 1586 cycles (23% per OR and 34% per embryo transfer) (Fig. 6). Historically, the clinical pregnancy rate is stable at around 24% per OR and 30% per embryo transfer procedure.

No parameters further downstream (i.e. implantation rate, delivery rate, miscarriage rate) could be calculated because of too many missing data.

PGT-SR

Supplementary Table SIII summarizes the 1039, 1189 and 1231 PGT-SR cycles to OR per indication in 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively.

As for previous years, data from 2013 to 2015 showed that PGT for reciprocal translocations was performed more often than for any other type of structural rearrangement (62%, 58% and 62%, respectively, Table IV). For reciprocal translocations, the number of cycles performed for female carriers was very similar to that for male carriers, whereas for Robertsonian translocations (24%, 28% and 23% of total), the number of cycles performed for male carriers was roughly 2-fold that of female carriers.

In 82–90% of all cycles to OR, ICSI was used for fertilization, a figure that is similar to the one from previous data sets. Nearly all cycles to OR (≥95%) had embryos available for biopsy, which was most commonly applied to cleavage-stage embryos (75% in 2013, 73% in 2014 and 63% in 2015). Biopsy at the blastocyst stage gained ground and increased from 22% in 2013 to 36% in 2015 (Fig. 2D). The downward trend in the use of FISH as diagnostic methodology continued and accounted for only 39% of cycles to analysis in data collection 2015. Comprehensive, WGA-based technology steadily increased its share from 36% to 58% between 2013 and 2015 (Fig. 3D).

Of the embryos successfully biopsied, 91–94% gave a diagnostic result, of which only one out of four was genetically transferable (Fig. 4). This figure has remained stable over the years. As was to be expected, the lowest percentage of transferable embryos was found in the reciprocal translocation group (on average 23% for male and 20% for female carriers). Of all transferable embryos, between 54% and 65% were actually transferred, either in a fresh or a frozen cycle.

From the 3-year total of 3459 cycles to OR, only 54% resulted in an embryo transfer procedure (Fig. 5). This is lower than the mean percentage reported in previous data sets (64%).

A positive hCG was obtained in 797 cycles (3-year total), with a positive heartbeat in 642 cycles (19% per OR and 34% per embryo transfer) (Fig. 6). Historically, the clinical pregnancy rate is stable at around 18% per OR and 28% per embryo transfer procedure.

The poorest outcome, 13% positive heartbeat per OR, was found in the group of deletion carriers. This is linked with the lowest percentage of transferable embryos available for this group.

No parameters further downstream (i.e. implantation rate, delivery rate, miscarriage rate) could be calculated because of too many missing data.

PGT cycles for sexing for X-linked diseases

Supplementary Table SIV summarizes the 79, 59 and 73 PGT-sexing for X-linked diseases cycles to OR in 2013, 2014 and 2015, respectively.

As holds true for the other PGT categories, the majority of cycles for X-linked diseases was performed with ICSI (64%) (Table I). Biopsy was primarily performed at cleavage-stage (82% in 2015, Fig. 2E) and FISH, although declining, was still the most frequently used method (59% in 2015, Fig. 3E); PCR was applied in 10% and WGA/array comparative genomic hybridization (CGH) showed a steep increase in 2015 and was applied in 30% of cycles.

Of the embryos successfully biopsied, 89% gave a diagnostic result, of which 42% were transferable. Half of the cycles to OR resulted in an embryo transfer. A positive hCG was obtained in 47 cycles, with a positive heartbeat in 36 cycles, yielding a clinical pregnancy rate of 17% per OR and 30% per embryo transfer, comparable to previous data sets (20% per OR and 30% per embryo transfer).

No parameters further downstream (i.e. implantation rate, delivery rate, miscarriage rate) could be calculated because of too many missing data.

Pregnancies and babies

The pre-designed Excel tables included parameters on pregnancies and babies, but as there was too many missing data, results no longer reflected reality. From previous data collections it was known that many centres have difficulties with collecting these data and they are often missing or inconsistent. However, follow-up of the children born after PGT remains of great importance.

Misdiagnoses

No misdiagnoses were reported in the current dataset.

Trends in the management and workflow of PGT cycles

Forty PGT centres participated in both questionnaires, reporting on practices and technologies applied in PGT. Apart from the previously described trends that also emerged from the data collections, the following parameters were noteworthy: numerous intra- and inter-departmental set-ups for the collaborative provision of ART and genetic diagnosis required for a PGT service were identified. Many centres had achieved accreditation by 2015: 71% of IVF units and 68% of diagnostic units. The use of time-lapse technology in PGT increased from 21% of PGT cycles in 2013 to 25% in 2015. Oocyte and embryo vitrification before biopsy showed a decline from 7% to 2% and from 12% to 3% of PGT cycles, respectively. By 2015, the use of Acidic Tyrode’s solution for zona breaching was almost fully replaced by laser-assisted zona drilling, the latter practice covering 98% of all PGT cycles. A switch in embryo transfer strategy from classic ‘fresh embryo transfer’ towards a ‘biopsy and freeze all’ strategy was observed concurrent with the increased uptake of TE biopsy.

Discussion

This data report of the ESHRE PGT Consortium involves summary data from three consecutive calendar years, 2013–2015. The most time-consuming step in data processing involves data ‘cleaning’: inconsistent and missing data need to be followed up by (multiple rounds of) contact between the relevant centre and ESHRE’s Science Manager. Increasing volumes of more complex data prompted the Consortium to sort out a new database structure. As data analysis had fallen behind due to serious delay during this procedure it was decided to collect summary PGT data from multiple years in order to record the major changes that had occurred during the period of technical transition in both the IVF and genetics labs.

Nevertheless, fewer participants than usual contributed to the current data set. We are confident, however, that the data presented is robust and reliably reflects the major trends in PGT at the time. Data submission is a time-consuming activity and the steering committee greatly acknowledges the effort of all contributing centres.

With a proportion of 61% of all reported PGT cycles in 2013 and 64% in 2014 and 2015, the relevant contribution of PGT-A to the ESHRE PGT Consortium data set has increased, following years of stability at 52% (De Rycke ).

The majority of centres contributing PGT-A data to the current data set (75%) have moved away from targeted FISH analysis on cleavage stage embryos to applying comprehensive, WGA-based technology on either cleavage stage embryos (64% in 2015) or blastocysts (36% in 2015). Such was suggested by the ESHRE PGT Consortium in the consensus paper that was published in 2010 (Harper ,b). The major indication for PGT-A remains AMA, although an increasing proportion of cycles is being performed without a recorded medical indication.

The uptake of new technologies is much slower in PGT-M. The proportion of cycles with blastocyst biopsy comprised 12% of the total number performed in 2015 and this is reflected by the 12% cycles performed with comprehensive diagnostic technology.

Targeted (short tandem repeat marker) analysis works well with a single cell (Day 3) biopsy while single-cell WGA may suffer from allele dropout and be less suitable as input for comprehensive testing strategies. Apparently, the need to change the PGT procedure is less urgent for the detection of monogenic disease than it is for other PGT indications.

Widespread application of new technologies is visible in PGT-SR, albeit less strong than in PGT-A, and the uptake of blastocyst biopsy (7% in 2012, 22% in 2013 and 36% in 2015) goes hand in hand with that of comprehensive diagnostics (13% in 2012, 36% in 2013 and 58% in 2015). Comprehensive diagnostics provide a generic platform, circumventing the need to develop locus-and family-specific tests, but consumables and equipment are relatively expensive.

Turning from cleavage stage to blastocyst biopsy places high demands on the embryo culture system and because of time restrains is usually combined with embryo vitrification and embryo transfer in a deferred cycle.

The number of genetically transferable embryos has not decreased, despite the fact that comprehensive analysis involves copy number calling of the non-indication chromosomes alongside the analysis of the indication chromosomes.

As PGT for sex selection for X-linked diseases does not fit any of the ICMART 2017 PGT categories it is evaluated as a separate entity. An increasing proportion of cycles for X-linked diseases is being performed with mutation detection rather than sex selection. For those cycles that still are being performed with sex selection, new technologies are on the rise. Where comprehensive technology (i.e. array CGH) used to be applied in a small minority of cases (4% in 2013), in 2015 it is used in 30% of cycles performed.

The retrospective data collections 2013–2015 represent valuable data on PGT activity in (mainly) Europe. The main trends observed in this ESHRE PGT Consortium report are the increased application of TE biopsy followed by a ‘vitrify all’ strategy and a deferred frozen embryo transfer, at the cost of cleavage stage biopsy combined with a fresh embryo transfer and the continuing expansion of comprehensive testing technology in all PGT categories, but in particular in PGT-SR and PGT-A.

Supplementary data

Supplementary data are available at Human Reproduction Open online.

Click here for additional data file.