Cong Wang1, Beibei Fu1, Xiaotao Zhang1, Rongjin Li1, Huanli Dong2, Wenping Hu1. 1. Tianjin Key Laboratory of Molecular Optoelectronic Sciences, Department of Chemistry, School of Science, Tianjin University and Collaborative Innovation Center of Chemical Science and Engineering (Tianjin), Tianjin 300072, China. 2. Beijing National Laboratory for Molecular Sciences, Key Laboratory of Organic Solids, Institute of Chemistry, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, China.
Abstract
Organic electronics with π-conjugated organic semiconductors are promising candidates for the next electronics revolution. For the conductive channel, the large-area two-dimensional (2D) crystals of organic semiconductors (2DCOS) serve as useful scaffolds for modern organic electronics, benefiting not only from long-range order and low defect density nature but also from unique charge transport characteristic and photoelectrical properties. Meanwhile, the solution process with advantages of cost-effectiveness and room temperature compatibility is the foundation of high-throughput print electrical devices. Herein, we will give an insightful overview to witness the huge advances in 2DCOS over the past decade. First, the typical influencing factors and state-of-the-art assembly strategies of the solution-process for large-area 2DCOS over sub-millimeter even to wafer size are discussed accompanying rational evaluation. Then, the charge transport characteristics and contact resistance of 2DCOS-based transistors are explored. Following this, beyond single transistors, the p-n junction devices and planar integrated circuits based on 2DCOS are also emphasized. Furthermore, the burgeoning phototransistors (OPTs) based on crystals in the 2D limits are elaborated. Next, we emphasized the unique and enhanced photoelectrical properties based on a hybrid system with other 2D van der Waals solids. Finally, frontier insights and opportunities are proposed, promoting further research in this field.
Organic electronics with π-conjugated organic semiconductors are promin class="Chemical">sing candidates for the next electronics revolution. For the conductive channel, the large-area two-dimenn class="Chemical">sional (2D) crystals of organic semiconductors (2DCOS) serve as useful scaffolds for modern organic electronics, benefiting not only from long-range order and low defect density nature but also from unique charge transport characteristic and photoelectrical properties. Meanwhile, the solution process with advantages of cost-effectiveness and room temperature compatibility is the foundation of high-throughput print electrical devices. Herein, we will give an insightful overview to witness the huge advances in 2DCOS over the past decade. First, the typical influencing factors and state-of-the-art assembly strategies of the solution-process for large-area 2DCOS over sub-millimeter even to wafer size are discussed accompanying rational evaluation. Then, the charge transport characteristics and contact resistance of 2DCOS-based transistors are explored. Following this, beyond single transistors, the p-n junction devices and planar integrated circuits based on 2DCOS are also emphasized. Furthermore, the burgeoning phototransistors (OPTs) based on crystals in the 2D limits are elaborated. Next, we emphasized the unique and enhanced photoelectrical properties based on a hybrid system with other 2D van der Waals solids. Finally, frontier insights and opportunities are proposed, promoting further research in this field.
Organic field-effect trann class="Chemical">sistors
(OFETs) and photoelectric devices
un class="Chemical">sing π-conjugated organic semiconductors as active layers have
attracted increasing attention for next-generation flexible and printable
electronics.[1−3] Although intensive research efforts, from material
design to process engineering, have been devoted to achieving progress
in performance, traditional bulk polycrystalline or amorphous thin
films still face vital challenges due to intrinsic properties as well
as serious device performance impediments in high-density integrated
circuits.[4,5] Because of their lack of grain boundaries
and extremely low defect densities, organic single crystals, in which
organic semiconductor molecules are periodically arranged by relatively
weak noncovalent bonds (such as van der Waals forces and hydrogen
bonds), have been regarded as model systems for improving performance
and revealing structure–property relationships.[6−8] The charge mobility has been optimized over 10 cm2 V–1 s–1,[9−13] and studies of anisotropic charge transport typically
reveal the dominant crystal orientation.[14−16] However, because
of their weak intermolecular interactions, organic semiconductor molecules
are commonly assembled into micro/nano single crystals with disordered
distribution and random orientation with respect to the substrate,
limiting their practical applications.
Large-area, two-dimenn class="Chemical">sional
(n class="Chemical">2D) crystals of organic semiconductors,
named 2DCOS, whose thicknesses scale down to the monolayer or few
monolayers over sub-millimeter to wafer sizes, are promising candidates
to satisfy the expected demand for modern organic field-effect devices.[17] Benefiting from long-range ordered molecular
packing and suppressed bulk contact resistance, large-area 2DCOS could
serve as useful scaffolds for logic circuits, with encouraging carrier
transport and high-speed switching characteristics.[16,18,19] In addition, compared to thick crystals,
2DCOS with controllable numbers of layers have significant advantages
in studies of basic problems, such as the question of the intrinsic
conduction mechanism, as well as in the construction of photoelectric
devices that achieve groundbreaking functionalities.[20,21] Nonetheless, traditional epitaxial growth methods for 2D materials
not only affect the molecular packing closest to the interface through
van der Waals forces, but also limit the size of the crystals. Strict
growth conditions and high costs are also obstacles to practical commercial
applications. Alternatively, assembly treatments in solution allow
large-scale production of semiconductor crystals in ambient conditions
without a vacuum, representing an important way to reduce industrialization
costs and promote the development of crystal engineering.
As
early as in 2011, the first millimeter-sized monolayer n class="Chemical">2DCOS
were prepared successfully by the Hu group via a solution self-assembly
process, and their mobility already exceeded 1 cm2 V–1s –1.[22] The need for performance modulation has greatly promoted the development
of various solution assembly processes to obtain large-area 2DCOS
persistently in the past decade. Although novel features of ultrathinsingle crystals have been described in many outstanding reviews,[23−26] the 2DCOS over millimeter to wafer size that have flourished in
recent years are rarely mentioned. Meanwhile, the solution-processed,
large-area crystals are often mentioned as subsections in many comprehensive
reviews covering 2D functional materials,[27] organic crystalline semiconductors in electronics, and flexible
devices.[7,28,29] Therefore,
with the rapid development of this emerging field, a systematic and
specialized review on 2DCOS with a large lateral size is imperative.
In this outlook, we will focus on the fabrication of large-area 2DCOS
via the solution assembly process, as well as their optoelectrical
field-effect devices (Figure ). We start in Section 2 with the
critical factors affecting the solution process and discuss representative
self-assembly and confined-assembly techniques for large-area 2DCOS.
Next, we emphasize the electrical properties of 2DCOS approaching
millimeter to wafer sizes, including charge transport characteristics,
carrier injection behavior of individual transistors, and integration
of devices beyond single OFETs. In Section 4, the most recent organic phototransistors (OPTs) based on ultrathin2DCOS are illustrated, mainly focusing on peculiar single-crystal
characteristics in the 2D limit. In Section 5, interfacing 2DCOS with other 2D van der Waals solids (vdWs) will
be emphasized according to the unique and enhanced photoelectrical
properties. Finally, on the basis of current progress, we predict
challenges to be encountered and the orientation of future development
in this promising field.
Figure 1
An overview concept, including the solution-processed
self-assembly
and confined-assembly for 2DCOS, as well as their photoelectrical
devices in the main text.
An overview concept, including the solution-processed
self-assembly
and confined-assembly for n class="Chemical">2DCOS, as well as their photoelectrical
devices in the main text.
Solution-Based Techniques for Fabricating Ultrathin,
Large-Area 2DCOS
Driven by the potential applications for
next-generation electronics,
a number of solution-based techniques concerning large-n class="Chemical">size n class="Chemical">2DCOS
with mono- or a few molecular layers have been recently developed.
These π-conjugated organic small molecules, with excellent self-organizing
behavior and good solubility in a variety of organic solvents, are
particularly appropriate for efficient fabrication of high-performance,
ultrathin 2DCOS by solution methods.[30] This
section is tripartite: it introduces (i) the solution-based assembly
processing parameters, (ii) the self-assembly techniques for growing
large-area 2DCOS, and (iii) the confined-assembly techniques toward
fabricating ultrathinlarge-area 2DCOS. It is our hope that the methods
described here can inspire controlled assembly of large-scale 2DCOS.
Solution-Based Assembly Processing Parameters
In n class="Chemical">simple
solution-based processes, it is worth pointing out that
the aggregation, crystallinity, and grain n class="Chemical">size of the solution-processed
crystals are sensitively affected by the external conditions. Undoubtedly,
they are all key parameters for tuning the kinetics of crystal assembly,
affecting the final morphology of 2DCOS. In this section, we summarize
the influence of each parameter on the solution assembly process,
which would help to guide the assembly of 2DCOS using the solution-processing
techniques.
Concentration Effect
The concentration
of solution can influence the nucleation and growth rate, which in
turn influences the likelihood for the molecules to be packed with
each other via intermolecular interactions.[31] Low nucleation denn class="Chemical">sities, when couple with pronounced growth rates,
play a crucial role in reducing the denn class="Chemical">sity of the grain boundaries
and ultimately lead to large crystalline domain sizes.[32] More interestingly, the thickness of the 2DCOS
can also be controlled by adjusting the concentration of the solution.
For instance, Jiang and co-workers reported that the 2DCOS thickness
can be tuned from 3.5 to 14.5 nm (corresponding to 1–4 layers)
by varying the concentration of 1,4-bis((5′-hexyl-2,2′-bithiophen-5-yl)ethynyl)benzene
(HTEB).[22]
Temperature
Effect
The substrate
temperature can influence the molecular thermodynamics by changing
the interactions between the molecule and the substrate.[33] For example, by exploiting the van der Waals
interactions (vdW) at the molecule–substrate interface, the
Li group successfully controlled the morphology of n class="Chemical">2DCOS with a clear
number of layers in a self-assembled-growth manner by tuning the annealing
temperature.[34] Because the upper-layer
molecules are less thermodynamically stable than the bottom molecules,
the monolayer n class="Chemical">2,7-dioctyl[1]benzothieno[3,2-b][1]benzothiophene
(C8-BTBT) can be more accurately controlled than bilayer
C8-BTBT from the perspective of molecular dynamics.
Solvent Effect
In solution-based
self-assembly processes, molecular aggregation occurs when the molecule–molecule
interactions are stronger than the solvent–molecule interactions.[35,36] The typical “good” solvents are n class="Chemical">benzene-type reagents,
such as n class="Chemical">toluene, chlorobenzene, and dichlorobenzene, while the “poor”
solvents include methanol, water, and ethanol. Poor solvents have
weak molecule–solvent interactions, which could help molecular
aggregation and promote crystallization.[37] By increasing the crystallization driving force at the gas/solution
interface, use of “poor solvents” result in higher lateral
growth rates at the gas/solution interface. For example, Hiromi et
al. developed a method that combined a poor solvent technique with
inkjet printing to produce highly crystalline 2DCOS.[38] The authors used 1,2-dichlorobenzene (DCB) as the good
solvent and N,N-dimethylformamide
(DMF) as the “poor solvent”, triggering the controlled
formation of exceptional uniform single-crystal thin films at that
grew the liquid/air interfaces.
Substrate
Effect
Substrates for
the solution-processed assembly can be categorized into two categories:
solid substrates (e.g., n class="Chemical">silicon) and liquid substrates (e.g., n class="Chemical">water).
Liquid substrates will be discussed in detail in Section 2.2.2. For solid substrates, surface tension and roughness
significantly affect the crystallization process and determine the
assembly of morphology. Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) are regarded
as an effective surface modification strategy for changing surface
roughness and wettability to affect the crystallization process.[39] For example, the modification of SiO2 substrate with PTS-SAMs increased the substrate surface energy and
reduce the contact angle, thereby making the substrate hydrophilic
and improving the crystallinity of the deposited organic films.[40]
Surfactant Effect
In the past few
decades, surfactant-assisted self-assembly has been successfully applied
to morphology control in the solution assembly process for organic
semiconductors.[41] Typically, the surfactant
possesses hydrophilic and hydrophobic structures, which enhance the
spread area of the solution on the substrate.[42] The surfactant limits the diffusion of molecules in a direction
perpendicular to the lamellar plane, which provides in effect a limited
2D space for the growth of large-area continuous 2DCOS.
Annealing Effect
The thermal annealing
and solvent vapor annealing are the n class="Chemical">simple yet highly efficient postprocesn class="Chemical">sing
route to improve the crystalline degree of the film following vapor
deposition or spin coating.[43] The thermal
annealing could give energy to the molecules, leading to enlarging
the single crystalline domains caused by the reorganization of the
organic molecules in the thin films via self-assembly.[44] Most of the reported solvent vapor annealing
is carried out at the room temperature.[45] During the solvent vapor annealing, predeposited thin films are
partially dissolved in the solvent vapor and reorganized to increase
crystalline grain sizes,[46] which could
prevent thermal damage of the organic semiconductors.
Self-Assembly Techniques for Growing Large-Area
2DCOS
Self-assembly, which is a spontaneous assembly process
driven by molecular interactions, has been developed into one of the
most efficient ways to grow n class="Chemical">2DCOS.[47] It
is generally conn class="Chemical">sidered that 2DCOS obtained using self-assembly techniques
will be of high quality since the self-assembly is free from external
forces.[26,28] At present, high-quality self-assembly techniques
are performed primarily on two substrates. The first one focuses on
“phase separation” molecular structure engineering toward
2DCOS by the drop-casting method on the solid substrate. The second
part deals with the solution epitaxy method, which is a facile, general,
and effective method for growing millimeter- or centimeter-sized 2DCOS
on the solution surface.
“Phase Separation”
Molecular
Engineering toward 2DCOS by Drop-Casting
In a drop-casting
process, organic crystals are held together by weak noncovalent interactions,
which implies that the morphologies and dimenn class="Chemical">sions of the crystals
are directly controlled by the molecule structure (Figure a).[48,49] At present, “phase separation” molecular engineering
has been widely applied in the assembly of n class="Chemical">ultrathin 2DCOS, for two
primary reasons.[50] (i) The rigid core of
the molecule provides strong in-plane π–π overlap
that forms a well-balanced 2D network, ideal for expansion into large-area
2Dcrystal films. (ii) The soft alkyl chains on sides of the rigid
core foster weak alkyl···alkyl interactions do duty
for the separation layer, resulting in 2DCOS with mono- to few-layers
thickness. To date, there are three types of organic semiconductors
with “phase separation” molecular structures: planar
p-type semiconductors, planar n-type semiconductors, and nonplanar
p-type semiconductors, as shown in Figure , top.
Figure 2
Representative semiconductors with a “phase
separation”
molecule structure discussed herein include planar p-type semiconductor,
planar n-type semiconductor, and nonplanar p-type semiconductor. (a)
Schematic diagram of a drop-casting technique for growing 2DCOS with
the “phase separation” molecule structure. (b, c) POM
of the 3Se-2N 2DCOS on SiO2/Si substrate. Reproduced with
permission from ref (50). Copyright 2019, Wiley-VCH.
Representative semiconductors with a “phase
separation”
molecule structure discussed herein include planar p-type semiconductor,
planar n-type semiconductor, and nonplanar p-type semiconductor. (a)
Schematic diagram of a drop-casting technique for growing n class="Chemical">2DCOS with
the “phase separation” molecule structure. (b, c) POM
of the 3Se-2N n class="Chemical">2DCOS on SiO2/Si substrate. Reproduced with
permission from ref (50). Copyright 2019, Wiley-VCH.
In 2011, Jiang et al. applied the n class="Chemical">HTEB molecule to produce n class="Chemical">ultrathin
2DCOS with millimeter-scale on various substrates by a simple drop-casting
method.[22,51] The key to success was the HTEB molecule
structure, in which π–π and C–H···π
interactions ensured strong laminar layer interactions for efficient
self-assembled 2D growth, and in which the long alkyl substituents
drive separate out-of-plane interlayer interactions. In the subsequent
reports, a variety of organic molecules were prepared into large-area
ultrathin 2DCOS, including 2,6-bis(4-hexylphenyl)anthracene (C6-DPA) and dioctyl-substituted dibenzo[d,d′]thieno[3,2-b;4,5-b′]dithiophenes
(C8-DBTDT).[50,52−54] In order to
further promote the development of materials for large-area 2DCOS,
a novel “phase separation” molecular design strategy
was recently reported by Fu and co-workers.[50] As shown in Figure b,c, the extended π-conjugated network (3Se-2N) increased exchange
(e.g., π–π stacking, C–H···π
interactions, and hydrogen bonding forces) beyond the bowl-shaped
molecule using only dense convex–concave π–π
stacking, which offered 2D network interactions and enabled millimeter-sized
single crystals.
Attractively, drop-casting methods toward n class="Chemical">2DCOS
are also suitable
for fabricating n-type semiconductors with “phase separated”
molecular structures. Recently, Weitz and co-workers reported that
n class="Chemical">ultrathin (2–5 nm), large-area (hundreds of microns) 2DCOS
of N,N′-di((S)-1-methylpentyl)-1,7(6)-dicyano-perylene-3,4:9,10-bis(dicarboximide)
(PDI1MPCN2) were successfully prepared by drop-casting techniques.[55] Furthermore, derivatives of naphthalene diimides
fused with 2-(1,3-dithiol-2-ylidene)malononitrile (NDI3HU-DTYM2) and
branched alkyl chains 5-alkyl-4H-thieno[3,4-c]pyrrole-4,6(5H)-dione moieties (2DQTT-o-B)
also confirmed the effectiveness of the method.[50,56,57]
An class="Chemical">side from the planar organic semiconductors,
nonplanar aromatic
backbones can be exploited to obtain a “phase separation”
molecule structure, representing an innovative molecular engineering
strategy for fabricating n class="Chemical">ultrathin 2DCOS. In the Zhang group, various
long alkyl chains were attached to fullerene materials to afford the
separation layer, resulting in 2DCOS with thicknesses of 5–6
nm.[58] Other typical examples of nonplanar
organic semiconductors with brickwork arrangements are hexabenzoperylene
derivatives (CR-HBPs).[59] The molecules
are closely packed with two-dimensional π–π interactions,
and the propyl group enables the phase separation interactions, helping
to form the ultrathin 2DCOS.
In short, the “phase separation”
molecule structure
offers a facile method for the growth of large-scale n class="Chemical">ultrathin 2DCOS
by n class="Chemical">simple drop-casting. However, since the crystallization relies
on the molecular structure, this method is more sensitive to external
conditions, and the crystals usually grow randomly on the substrate
with uncontrolled positions and orientations. Moreover, because the
insulating soft alkyl chains may depress the semiconducting properties
of organic semiconductors, designing the appropriate alkyl chain length
to allow for the large-area 2DCOS self-assembly while simultaneously
guaranteeing excellent electrical performance is still a challenge.
Solution-Epitaxy
Epitaxy technology
is one of the most effective methods to achieve high-quality crystal
growth in inorganic semiconductors.[60] Recently,
this method has been extended to the assembly of controllable, high-quality,
and n class="Chemical">ultrathin 2DCOS.[21,61] A fundamental prerequisite for
epitaxy is accurate lattice matching with the substrate. However,
it is hard to find crystalline substrates that match organic lattices,
limiting the possibilities for the 2DCOS fabrication. Considering
this, Xu et al. developed a novel approach for assembling 2DCOS at
the water/air interface, named “solution epitaxy”, schematically
depicted in Figure a.[62] This method has two pivotal operations.
(i) The water surface acts as an ideal growth substrate because the
coffee-ring effect is effectively suppressed at the water surface
by elimination of the pinned three-phase contact line, resulting in
a uniform 2DCOS.[63] (ii) Small 2DCOS as
seed crystals is another pivotal operation. The small-sized 2DCOS
were first obtained on the water surface by drop-casting and then
they serve as seed crystals for further epitaxy growth by dropping
the additional solution onto the water surface. Encouraged by this
approach, a wide range of organic semiconductors were effectively
assembled into high-quality large-sized 2DCOS by epitaxy growth. As
a typical example, the characterization over an entire centimeter-sized
dihexyl-substituted dibenzo[d,d′]thieno[3,2-b;4,5-b′]dithiophenes (C6-DBTDT) 2DCOS indicated the ultrathinsingle-crystalline nature shown
in Figure b–g.[62] Besides the C6-DBTDT molecule, many
p-type organic semiconductors have been grown into large-area 2DCOS,
including C6-DPA, dihexyl-substituted pentathienoacene
(C6-PTA), perylene, and 1,4-bis(4-methylstyryl)benzene
(p-MSB).[62,64] Soon after their initial
report, the same group further extended this method to the growth
of n-type semiconductor with a large lateral size and low defect density.
They successfully prepared millimeter-sized n-type furan-thiophene
quinoidal compound (TFT-CN) 2DCOS with only 2–3 molecular layers
(Figure h–m).
Impressively, a competitive field-effect electron mobility (1.36 cm2 V–1 s–1) and high responsivity
of near-infrared organic phototransistors (OPTs) based on TFT-CN were
obtained.[65]
Figure 3
(a) Schematic illustration
of growing large-area 2DCOS by “solution
epitaxy” method and (b, c) morphology characterization and
(d–g) structure analysis of p-type C6-DBTDT 2DCOS.
Reproduced with permission from ref (62). Copyright 2016, Wiley-VCH. (h, i) morphology
characterization and (j–m) structure analysis of a 2DCOS of
n-type TFT-CN 2DCOS via “solution epitaxy” method. Reproduced
with permission from ref (65). Copyright 2018, Wiley-VCH.
(a) Schematic illustration
of growing large-area 2DCOS by “solution
epitaxy” method and (b, c) morphology characterization and
(d–g) structure analysis of p-type C6-DBTDT2DCOS.
Reproduced with permission from ref (62). Copyright 2016, Wiley-VCH. (h, i) morphology
characterization and (j–m) structure analysis of a 2DCOS of
n-type TFT-CN2DCOS via “solution epitaxy” method. Reproduced
with permission from ref (65). Copyright 2018, Wiley-VCH.Because of the free-standing nature of the fabricated n class="Chemical">2DCOS by
this outstanding method, it offers further opportunities for manufacturing
of integrated devices. Wang et al. successfully fabricated a p–n
junction based onn class="Chemical">C8-BTBT (p-type) and a furan-thiophene
quinoidal compound (TFT-CN, n-type), via secondary transfer technology.[66] Through a simple drop-casting method, single
crystal 2DCOS films of p- and n-type semiconductors, respectively,
were grown on the water surface. Then, the as-prepared 2DCOS were
sequentially transferred to dielectric substrates, and the p–n
junction was formed by the alignment.
That said, despite numerous
reports on the assembly of n class="Chemical">2DCOS, disadvantages
remain with the solution epitaxy method in its current form. (i) n class="Chemical">Ultrathin
2DCOS with a defined layer still remain to grow challenging due to
the viscosity of water. (ii) The quasi-equilibrium condition needs
several hours to be established. (iii) The transfer of 2DCOS from
water can hamper the effectiveness of water-soluble substrates (i.e.,
water-soluble dielectric layers).
Compared with self-assembly methods, which are mainly
controlled via molecular organization, confined-assembly processes
control the assembly kinetics via external forces. When un class="Chemical">sing confined-assembly
to grow crystals, the number of spatial degrees of freedom for the
solute molecules is reduced, affecting the rates of solute molecules
diffun class="Chemical">sion and precipitation from solution.[67] In this section, we will discuss two aspects of confined-assembly:
(i) how to promote the 2D growth of organic crystals by space-confined
assembly, which makes use of solution droplets in 2D confined spaces,
and (ii) how to develop 2DCOS from directional-confined assembly,
which forces the crystal to grow along a given direction.
Space-Confined Assembly
Organic
molecules can move freely in solution, and this behavior makes crystals
grow randomly on the substrate. At present, in typical space-confined
environments, the assembly is concentrated along the solid/solid or
air/n class="Chemical">water interfaces. Inpan> the solid/solid case, Nakayama and co-workers
achieved monolayer or few-layer large n class="Chemical">2DCOS by 2D space-confined assembly.[11] A piece of plastic or silicon was placed onto
a silicon substrate with an angle between them of less than 30°,
resulting in a 2D confined space.
The semiconductor/dielectric
interface with a low-energy/hydrophobic is advantageous in minimizing
the number of electron traps producing high electronic performance.[68] However, it is difficult to assembly n class="Chemical">2DCOS on
the low-energy surface by solution assembly methods n class="Chemical">since dewetting
of surface occurs. Considering this, Shi and co-workers. developed
a modified solid/solid 2D space-confined assembly method, named a
gravity-assisted space-confined, to overcome this problem so that
dewetting dielectrics could be used for the crystal growth, as shown
in Figure a–e.[69] Because of the force of gravity on the top substrate,
a 2D space was formed between the two substrates. Because the chlorobenzene
solvent has better wetting properties solvent on the benzocyclobutene
(BCB)-modified top substrate than on the hydrophobic octadecyltrichlorosilane
(OTS)-treated bottom substrate, monolayer molecular crystals to grew
on the top BCB-treated substrates over centimeter-sized areas.
Figure 4
(a) Schematic
illustration of growing large-area 2DCOS by the solid/solid
space-confined assembly method. The abbreviation of MMC represents
monolayer molecular crystals. (b) Optical microscopy image and (c)
corresponding AFM and (d, e) HR-AFM image of the 2DCOS on BCB-treated
SiO2/Si substrate. Reproduced with permission from ref (69). (f) Sketches of the air/water
2D space-confined assembly method for the growth and transfer of 2DCOS.
Picture showing the spreading area of organic solution on (g) deionized
water or (h) water with a phase transfer surfactant. (i, j) Optical
microscopy images of 2DCOS of C6-DPA. Reproduced with permission
from ref (70). Copyright
2018, American Chemical Society.
(a) Schematic
illustration of growing n class="Gene">large-area 2DCOS by the solid/solid
space-confined assembly method. The abbreviation of MMC represents
monolayer molecular crystals. (b) Optical microscopy image and (c)
corresponding AFM and (d, e) HR-AFM image of the 2DCOS on BCB-treated
SiO2/Si substrate. Reproduced with permission from ref (69). (f) Sketches of the air/water2D space-confined assembly method for the growth and transfer of 2DCOS.
Picture showing the spreading area of organic solution on (g) deionized
water or (h) water with a phase transfer surfactant. (i, j) Optical
microscopy images of 2DCOS of C6-DPA. Reproduced with permission
from ref (70). Copyright
2018, American Chemical Society.
Ben class="Chemical">sides the solid/solid space-confined method, space-confined assembly
can also be realized at the air/n class="Chemical">water interface. In 2018, Wang and
co-workers demonstrated that the phase transfer surfactants could
control the interfacial tension between the water/solution and the
spreading area of the solvent, leading to the desired 2D space-confinement
for growth of 2DCOS as shown in Figure f–j.[70] However, the
dynamical movement of the whole solution on the water surface, caused
by the low viscosity of water, posed challenges to the fixed position
and layer-defined growth of 2DCOS. To overcome this difficulty, a
modified air/liquid interface was reported by the same group.[71] They used high viscosity glycerol, instead of
water, which served as a viscous liquid substrate, leading the organic
solution to have a fixed position. More interestingly, by adjusting
the ratio of glycerol in the liquid matrix, the formation of crystals
from bulk sizes down to the monolayer was precisely controlled.
Orientation-Force-Directed Assembly
Orientation-force-directed
assembly refers to large-area fabrication
tactics which adn class="Chemical">opt an oriented external force on the substrates for
controlling the orientation as den class="Chemical">sired. In this strategy, external
forces such as gravitational forces, shearing forces, and capillary
forces are utilized to guide the movement direction of the solution
realizing high crystal quality with a high degree of orientation.
Here, in a typical orientation-force example, the assembly is divided
into the vertical gravity and horizontal orientation-force-directed
assembly.
n class="Chemical">Dip-coating is a popular approach for fabricating
well-alignpan>ed molecular crystals.[72−74] Inpan> a typical process,
a substrate is immersed into the solution and then is withdrawnpan>, accompanied
by precipitation and crystallization as the substrate is withdrawnpan>.
Li and co-workers used the solvent, solution concentration, and recesn class="Chemical">sion
rate as the main parameters to balance the pulling speed, nucleation
and assembly rate, which played critical roles in the crystallization
process, as shown in Figure a.[75] By externally controlling
the pulling speed of the substrate from solution, Gelinck and co-workers
produced 6,13-bis(triisopropylsilylethynyl) pentacene (TIPS-PEN) 2D
crystals which exhibited uniform morphology up to size of a centimeter.[76] In addition, preparation of large-scale ultrathin2DCOS requires not only control of the crystallization process, but
also the selection of organic semiconductors with appropriate molecular
structures. Tian et al. reported an asymmetric molecule, a novel thienoacene-based
conjugated oligomer (BTTT-T-C12) as a candidate semiconductor to prepare
2DCOS with 2–6 mm lateral dimensions via a dip-coating method
(Figure b–c).[77] The asymmetric molecule may suppress the crystal
growth along the normal to the substrate surface, forming much larger
grains than its symmetric counterparts[78] and is therefore beneficial for growing ultrathin 2DCOS.
Figure 5
(a) Schematic
illustration of the dip-coating processes and the
key factors influencing the growth of ultrathin film in dip-coating.
Reproduced with permission from ref (75). Copyright 2016, American Chemical Society.
(b) Optical micrographs and (c) crossed polarizers of the BTTT-T-C12
2DCOS. Reproduced with permission from ref (77). Copyright 2012, The Royal Society of Chemistry.
(d) Schematic illustration of solution-shearing method. Reproduced
with permission from ref (79). Copyright 2020, Wiley-VCH. (e) Optical microscopy characterization
of the HTEB films and (f) its corresponding AFM image, and the Δ5 representation the thickness of 2DCOS. Reproduced with permission
from ref (90). Copyright
2014, The Royal Society of Chemistry. (g) Sketches illustration of
the fabrication process by the floating-coffee-ring method. (h) Optical
microscopy image and (i) its high-resolution AFM images of 2L C8-BTBT 2DCOS. (g–i) Reproduced with permission from
ref (85). Copyright
2016, Wiley-VCH.
(a) Schematic
illustration of the dip-coating processes and the
key factors influencing the growth of ultrathin film in dip-coating.
Reproduced with permission from ref (75). Copyright 2016, American Chemical Society.
(b) Optical micrographs and (c) crossed polarizers of the BTTT-T-C122DCOS. Reproduced with permission from ref (77). Copyright 2012, The Royal Society of Chemistry.
(d) Schematic illustration of solution-shearing method. Reproduced
with permission from ref (79). Copyright 2020, Wiley-VCH. (e) Optical microscopy characterization
of the HTEB films and (f) its corresponding AFM image, and the Δ5 representation the thickness of 2DCOS. Reproduced with permission
from ref (90). Copyright
2014, The Royal Society of Chemistry. (g) Sketches illustration of
the fabrication process by the floating-coffee-ring method. (h) Optical
microscopy image and (i) its high-resolution AFM images of 2L C8-BTBT2DCOS. (g–i) Reproduced with permission from
ref (85). Copyright
2016, Wiley-VCH.Compared with the vertical
gravity-directed orientation force of
n class="Chemical">dip-coating methods, the solution-shearing[79−84] and floating coffee ring-driven assembly[85] methods utilize movement of the orientation force in the horizontal
direction to assembly the organic semiconductor. Generally, the solution-shearing
method involves dragging a solution meniscus that forms between the
substrate and the top element, such as a bar or a blade, via the movement
of the top element or the substrate, as seen in Figure d.[86,87] Recently, Akifumi et
al. successfully prepared n class="Chemical">2DCOS with lateral dimensions of wafer-scales
by a modified solution-shearing method, using 3,11-dioctyldinaphtho[2,3-d:2′,3′-d′]benzo[1,2-b:4,5-b′]dithiophene
(C8-DNBDT-NW), which has good solubility.[19] Solution-shearing methods are also beneficial for assembly
ultrathin 2DCOS,[88,89] which respond quickly to external
stimulation, providing a promising platform for sensing applications.
In a typically example, Hu et al. reported a monolayer HTEB2DCOS
via solution-shearing method for highly sensitive and reversible gas
sensors application (Figure e,f).[90] Because of external forces,
the solution-shearing speed can also modify the molecular packing
through lattice strain, which is used to improve the charge transport
properties by increasing intermolecular interactions.[91] Giri et al. fabricated 6,13-bis(triisopropylsilylethynyl)
pentacene (TIPS-pentacene) thin-film crystallites by a solution-shearing
method, which showed an increase in charge carrier mobility from 0.8
to 4.6 cm2 V–1 s–1 along
with the decreased the π–π stacking distance from
3.33 to 3.08 Å, aiding a high-mobility device.[92]
Another effective method utilizing the orientation-force-directed
assembly in the horizontal direction is called a floating-coffee-ring-driven
assembly.[85,93] Usually, the lateral crystalline domain
n class="Chemical">size is suppressed due to the coffee-ring effect. However, the coffee-ring
phenomenon can also be used subtly to induce mass transport of dispersed
organic molecules to the edge of the solution, achieving large-area
n class="Chemical">2DCOS growth. Wang et al. proposed a method that combined the technique
of “poor solvent” crystallization with floating-coffee-ring-driven
assembly technology to produce 2D molecular crystalline semiconductors
(Figure g–i).[85] The key to success was that, near the solvent
edge, the evaporation-driven flow of the good solvent resulted in
a floating-coffee-ring effect in the poor solvent; it also to create
positions for the crystallization of the organic semiconductor that
supported high crystal growth rate.
Electrical
Characteristics Based on 2DCOS
Single OFETs: Intrinsic
Charge Transport,
Optimized Contact Resistance, and High Mobility
OFETs are
three-terminal switching electronic components modulated by an electric
field applied to a gate terminal, which use organic semiconductors
as the conducting channel. It is understandable that the gate-induced
carrier concentration in bulk channels decays exponentially with increan class="Chemical">sing
vertical distance from the dielectric layer, and charge transport
occurs in the first few molecular layers near the dielectric interface,
as shownpan> in Figure a, top.[17] Hence, carrier transport studies
in the n class="Chemical">2D limit provide a platform to directly probe intrinsic carrier
transport properties at the interface.
Figure 6
(a) Schematics of transistors
based on HTEB bulk (top, left) and
monolayer (top, right), as well as their corresponding band structures
and density of states (bottom). The embedded molecules represent only
a schematic of the stack, and the alkyl side chains are omitted. The
purple dots stand for the omitted multilayer molecules. Reproduced
with permission from ref (69). (b) Contact resistance diagram of bulk device (top), and
resistance evaluation for different molecular layers (bottom). The Rc is extracted by the transmission-line model
according to the intercept of the function of the width-normalized
total device resistance (RtotalW) versus the channel length. Reproduced with permission
from ref (104). Copyright
2019, Royal Society of Chemistry. (c) A histogram summary of charge
carrier mobility for representative large-area 2DCOS in the past few
years. It should be stated that the values in the histogram are the
average mobility of the devices. The μm-sized represents the
size smaller than 1 mm2; the mm-sized represents the size
range from 1 mm2 to 1 cm2; the cm-sized represents
the crystal size over 1 cm2.
(a) Schematics of trann class="Chemical">sistors
based onn class="Chemical">HTEB bulk (top, left) and
monolayer (top, right), as well as their corresponding band structures
and density of states (bottom). The embedded molecules represent only
a schematic of the stack, and the alkyl side chains are omitted. The
purple dots stand for the omitted multilayer molecules. Reproduced
with permission from ref (69). (b) Contact resistance diagram of bulk device (top), and
resistance evaluation for different molecular layers (bottom). The Rc is extracted by the transmission-line model
according to the intercept of the function of the width-normalized
total device resistance (RtotalW) versus the channel length. Reproduced with permission
from ref (104). Copyright
2019, Royal Society of Chemistry. (c) A histogram summary of charge
carrier mobility for representative large-area 2DCOS in the past few
years. It should be stated that the values in the histogram are the
average mobility of the devices. The μm-sized represents the
size smaller than 1 mm2; the mm-sized represents the size
range from 1 mm2 to 1 cm2; the cm-sized represents
the crystal size over 1 cm2.
n class="Chemical">Since organic molecules bind by weak van der Waals forces and many
grain boundaries exist in polycrystalline films, thermally activated
transport characteristics are often observed, in which mobility is
pon class="Chemical">sitively correlated with temperature.[94] Nevertheless, it has been verified that intrinsic extended-state
conduction (band-like transport) is possible with highly crystalline
films without static disorder.[12,95] The realization of
intrinsic transport in monolayer crystals is a challenging task because
the degree of the disorder and the number of surface trap states are
typically larger than in the bulk. To investigate the factors that
influence transport physics, Chan et al. fabricated monolayer and
multilayer 2,9-didecyldinaphtho[2,3-b:2′,3′-f]thieno[3,2-b]thiophene (C10-DNTT) 2DCOS, which had the expected molecular arrangements.[84] Band-like transport took place in the multilayer
channel, and thermal activation behavior was observed in the monolayer
under cryogenic conditions. With the exception of molecular packing,
it can be deduced that the closest interfacial conducting layer may
also be perturbed by polar functional groups, such as hydroxyl groups
on SiO2 dielectric. Impressively, Jiang et al. suggested
the possibility of band-like transport in organic materials close
to room temperature even at the monolayer limit using the BCB dielectric.[69] The initial increase of mobility upon cooling
between 200 and 300 K indicated band-like transport in monolayer dicyanomethylene-substituted
fused tetrathienoquinoid (CMUT). By way of contrast, similar band-like
charge transport characteristics were not found in the device based
on bare SiO2 dielectric. In addition, as shown in Figure a, bottom, the simulated
band structure of the monolayer CUMT was more disperse than that of
bulk crystals, which was also consistent with band-like intrinsic
transport.
Contact ren class="Chemical">sistance (Rc, which represents
width-normalized contact ren class="Chemical">sistance to offset the influence of the
channel width) is another property that affects the performance of
OFETs, which not only hinders the operation speeds of the device,
but also obstructs the optimization of device power consumption. In
the commonly used bottom-gate/top-contact configuration, the typical
contact resistance ranges from 104 to 106 Ω·cm,
following the nonlinearity of the current–voltage relationship
after the linear region.[96] Apparently,
as shown in Figure b, top, the contact resistance can be divided into the following
two parts. One part is the interfacial injection resistance (Rc,int) caused by the carrier injection potential
barrier between the metal electrode and semiconductor, and the other
is the bulk injection resistance (Rc,bulk), which refers to the interlayer injection resistance in the vertical
direction of the semiconductor layer.[97] The former, as reported in the literature, can be optimized using
many effective tactics, including contact metal work function adjustment
by a self-assembled monolayer[98,99] and efficient interfacial
doping between the channel and the electrode.[100−103] For the latter, it is accepted that the thinner channel offers reduced Rc,bulk, but the continuity of the channel should
be maintained. Thanks to the long-range coherent arrangement and the
effective transport of oriented molecules in the 2D limit, the 2DCOS
can be regarded as a candidate channel for transistor fabrication
and a medium to explore the relationship between channel thickness
and contact resistance.[18] Jiang and co-workers
assessed the resistance of devices based on monolayer, 4-layer, and
15-layer 2DCOS, and a gradually increasing trend was found, as shown
in Figure b, bottom.[104] Furthermore, when combined with the interfacial
layer F4-TCNQ (2,3,5,6-tetrafluoro-7,7,8,8-tetracyanoquinodimethane),
bilayer C8-BTBT2DCOS-based devices exhibited total resistance
down to 46.9 Ω·cm, providing a platform for subsequent
high-frequency transistors (see Section 3.2.2).
As summarized in Figure c, in the past few years, solution-processed large-area
2DCOS
with excellent charge transport properties have been developed rapidly
from micrometer-sized crystals to centimeter-sized and even wafer-sized
crystalline films. Hu et al. first reported that devices based on
millimeter-sized monolayer crystals of HTEB exhibited mobility superior
to bulk channels (beyond 1 cm2 V–1 s–1) and long-term stability over 300 days in the atmosphere.[22] Afterward, free-standing centimeter-sized C6-DBTDT2DCOS fabricated by “solution epitaxy”
methods showed average mobilities as high as 2.8 cm2 V–1 s–1.[62] Takeya et al. achieved wafer-sized bilayer C8-DNBDT-NWsingle crystals with an excellent, highest mobility of 13 cm2 V–1 s–1, providing a foundation
for subsequent integrated applications.[19]Compared with n class="Species">p-type 2DCOS, the development of n-type trann class="Chemical">sistors
lags behind and is still struggling to catch up.[55,105] Wang et al. fabricated millimeter-sized n-type 2DCOS by combining
the molecular design strategy with an effective free-standing preparation
method.[65] A competitive average electron
mobility (1.04 cm2 V–1 s–1) was obtained in air. However, it has been verified that conventional
dielectrics with hydroxyl groups, for which electrochemical trapping
of electrons by silanol groups at the interface occurs, will hinder
the electron transport.[68] In the Jiang
group, the hydroxyl-free BCB-modified SiO2 showed reduced
electron traps at the semiconductor/dielectric interface and dipole-induced
disorder. As a result, the monolayer 2DCOS were estimated to possess
a maximum electron mobility of 1.24 cm2 V–1 s–1, which is one of the highest values in monolayer
n-type transistors.[69]
Though great
successes around planar charge transport characteristics,
vertical ren class="Chemical">sistance characteristics, and charge mobility have been
achieved in OFETs based onn class="Chemical">ultrathin large-area 2DCOS, further progress
is needed. The surface charge accumulated thickness and charge trap
states in OFETs are still confounding. Compared with inorganic materials,
organic materials are hobbled by innately poor stability and especially
serious intolerance to water, oxygen, and organic solvents. Because
of their large volume-to-surface ratios, the stability of 2Dsingle
crystals is more inviting.
Beyond Single OFETs Based
on 2DCOS
The previous discusn class="Chemical">sion has mostly been focused
on unique and exceptional
electronic properties of n class="Chemical">single-component solution-processed 2DCOS.
It is nonetheless essential to probe the deeper device physics and
explore functional integrated circuits beyond a single OFET. Integration
applications can be divided into heterogeneous junction devices, in
which p- and n-type semiconductors stack directly, and integrated
circuits, in which an OFET connects to other components or interconnections.
For the former, ultrathin 2DCOS can be used as the bottom layer to
construct a smooth junction for the novel devices. In the latter,
because of their excellent carrier transport abilities, high-frequency
complementary circuits based on 2DCOS can be expected.
p–n Junctions
The p–n
junctions, joining a p-type semiconductor for holes and ann-type
semiconductor together for electron transport, plays a pivotal, fundamental
role in contemporary electronics.[106] As
a built-in electric field is induced at the interface between the
p- and n-type materials, novel electronic and n class="Chemical">optoelectronic properties
far beyond the corresponding n class="Chemical">single components are expected. That
said, the thick underlying bulk of the p–n junction will screen
the electrostatic field, making an inferior gate field regulation
on the upper semiconductor. This drawback can be compensated for by
using ultrathin2D materials.[107] Benefiting
from their ultrathin characteristics, which allow good electrostatic
control over the junction, and from their single-crystal nature, which
allows exploration of intrinsic charge transport properties, monolayer
or few-layer 2DCOS can be considered as candidates for effective p–n
junction devices, including gate controllable rectifiers, balanced
ambipolar OFETs, and enhanced light-controlled transistors (see Section 4).
The first use of a p–n
junction that we will introduce is a gate-controllable current rectifier.
Devices based onn class="Chemical">2DCOS are usually constructed un class="Chemical">sing lateral junctions,
in which two 2DCOS are joined face-to-face to create partial overlap,
and the source and drain electrodes are connected, respectively, to
the p- and n-type materials. A typical example of a p–n junction
gate-controlled rectifier was reported by the Jiang group.[69] The 2,6-diphenylanthracene (DPA) crystal as
a p-type component was transferred onto a monolayer n-type CMUT by
a mechanical transfer method, and thus a lateral p–n junction
was successfully fabricated, as shown in Figure a. In comparison, thick bottom semiconductors
(larger than 30 nm) caused cracks in the upper semiconductor at the
edge of the junction and failed in constructing lateral p–n
junctions. In the intermediate voltage region near |Vg| ≈ |Vd|/2, the current
peak appeared with maximum rectification ratios of 4 × 105. The peak of the current in the intermediate region can be
explained by an increase of the interlayer recombination rate under
a gate field in which the holes and electrons are simultaneously induced
in the p-type and n-type materials, respectively, and its dependence
on a gate field or any other external stimulus.
Figure 7
(a) The device structure
diagram (left), the fluorescence microscope
photograph (middle) and electrical properties of gate-controlled rectifier
(right). Reproduced with permission from ref (69). (b) The schematic of
ambipolar transistor based on 2DCOS (left) and transfer curves for
ambipolar transport (middle and right). Reproduced with permission
from ref (66). Copyright
2019, Science China Press and Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of
Springer Nature. (c) The device diagram (left) and high-frequency
rectifying characteristics of a diode-connected 2DCOS-based OFET circuit
(middle and right). Reproduced with permission from (19).
(a) The device structure
diagram (left), the fluorescence microscope
photograph (middle) and electrical properties of gate-controlled rectifier
(right). Reproduced with permisn class="Chemical">sion from ref (69). (b) The schematic of
ambipolar trann class="Chemical">sistor based on 2DCOS (left) and transfer curves for
ambipolar transport (middle and right). Reproduced with permission
from ref (66). Copyright
2019, Science China Press and Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of
Springer Nature. (c) The device diagram (left) and high-frequency
rectifying characteristics of a diode-connected 2DCOS-based OFET circuit
(middle and right). Reproduced with permission from (19).
Another important application is so-called ambipolar OFETs, in
which one of the n class="Chemical">2DCOS completely covers the other, and the source
and drain electrodes are n class="Chemical">simultaneously mounted above the p–n
junction region. In the Hu group, high-quality p–n junctions
based on two kinds of 2DOCS were successfully fabricated by the facile
process known as the “secondary transfer method’’.
These p–n junctions realized ambipolar transport of both electrons
and holes, as shown in Figure b.[66] Furthermore, in order to obtain
well-balanced hole and electron mobilities, Li et al. controlled two
factors that affect the performance of the device, which were contact
resistance and charge carrier scattering, by tuning the thicknesses
of the p- and n-type layers.[108] When the
bottom TFT-CN (n-type) and top C6-DPA (p-type) 2DCOS were
tuned simultaneously, well-balanced ambipolar charge characteristics
were obtained, with hole mobilities up to 0.87 cm2 V–1 s–1 and electron mobilities up
to 0.82 cm2 V–1 s–1, proving the layered crystal engineering strategy and achieving
balanced ambipolar double-channel OFETs.
Despite the promin class="Chemical">sing
experiments discussed in this section, which
show the differentiating properties and uniqueness of n class="Chemical">2DCOS p–n
junction devices, the extent and mechanisms of charge transfer at
the junction interface still need further study. In addition, the
preparation of p–n junctions still remain at the size range
of micrometers to millimeters. In order to achieve high performance
in integration applications, the production of wafer-sized crystalline
p–n junctions with well-controlled interfaces is required.
High-Speed Circuits
Functional
electronics, such as radio frequency identification (RFID) tags and
digital logic circuits, require several trann class="Chemical">sistors to connect with
each other to achieve data communication and exchange. As a fundamental
prerequin class="Chemical">site, such devices require the OFETs to have high enough operating
speeds to drive the entire circuit. For example, near-field communication
RFID tags should respond at 13.56 MHz, and thus for OFETs, it is a
meaningful, significant goal to realize operating speeds of at least
tens of MHz.[109] To realize high-speed transistors
with high cutoff frequencies, it is essential to improve the effective
mobilities in short-channel devices.[110] However, as the channel length is reduced, device performance is
suppressed by the contact resistance, which raises the injection barrier,
as well as by the poor long-range order of organic semiconductors.[111] Low contact resistance and coherent carrier
transport characteristics in ultrathin 2DCOS make them promising candidates
for short-channel high-frequency devices.[112] In Takeya’s recent research, the effective mobility, extracted
from a transfer curve based on C8-DNBDT-NW2DCOS with bilayers
(2L) in 3 μm short-channel transistors, was estimated to be
2.7 cm2 V–1 s–1, as
shown in Figure c.[19] Together with the ultralow contact resistance
(46.9 Ω·cm, as mentioned in section
3.1), the VDS-normalized cutoff
frequency reached 20 MHz, which is among the highest values for solution-processed
transistors. Furthermore, a high-speed rectifier with diode-connected
2L-2DCOS OFETs, exhibited operation up to 29 MHz, which is two times
higher than that needed for near-field communication RFID tags.
The second requirement for OFETs in high-density circuits is excellent
noise properties, which are responn class="Chemical">sible for further improving the
circuit stability and durability when signals propagate between devices.
Among the various sources of electronic noise, the flicker noise (1/f noise) or excess noise, which is caused by carrier density
fluctuations in the active devices, can be regarded as the main contributor.[113,114] Many pioneering studies have been executed on the flicker noise
feature of the polymer[115] or small molecular
polycrystalline films[116] and organic single
crystals from physical vapor sublimation.[117] These results have verified that (i) lower flicker noise is beneficial
for charge transport and stability and that (ii) enhanced crystallinity
and flatness (microstructure) have positive impacts on device noise.
However, the hopping transport mechanism commonly explored in traditional
disordered polycrystalline films hinders the study of noise sources
and the development of low-noise devices. Recently, Watanabe et al.
made a breakthrough in using ultrathinC8-DNBDT-NW2DCOS
as semiconductor layers to study their noise characteristics.[118] Thanks to its low trap-state density (8.3 ×
1018 eV–1 cm–3), fitting
by the McWorther model, and the high hole mobility (13.6 cm2 V–1 s–1) arising from its coherent
band-like transport nature, the amplitude of 1/f was
demonstrated to be as low as 6 × 10–6 μm2 Hz–1, which is lower than that for any
other solution-processed semiconductors and 2–3 orders of magnitude
lower than that for inorganic van der Waals materials.[119]
Furthermore, solution-processed high-quality
n class="Chemical">2DCOS over large area
is capable of practical use in organic logic circuits because of their
satisfying reproducibility and good uniformity. Uno et al. realized
parallel-serial delay-type flip-flop (DFF) organic circuits by connecting
p-type (C10-DNBDT-NW) and n-type (BASF Gn class="Chemical">SID104031-1) 2DCOS,
which operated with extremely fast response times of about 37 μs.[120] Yamamura et al. fabricated digital temperature
sensor circuits composed of DFF circuits and wireless RFID tags, using
alternating p-type and n-type line-shaped crystalline films combined
in particular orientations.[121] These excellent
results will accelerate the development of organic logic circuits
using solution-process techniques and promote practical applications
of organic electronic products. In the future, large-area patterned
2DCOS with controllable orientations and well-defined positions need
further study in order to reduce interference and variability between
devices, as well as achieve more complex circuits.
Emerging Insights in Phototransistors in the
2D Limits
OPTs are receiving much attention for their wide
range of uses
in imaging, motion monitoring, night vin class="Chemical">sion equipment, remote sensing,
and so on. In OPTs, the photogenerated electron–hole pairs
in the photoactive channel are separated by an external vertical electric
field and eventually collected by the drain electrodes, thereby affecting
the electrical channel properties of the transistors. The figures
of merit for evaluating the OPTs are available in other comprehensive
reviews.[122,123] Herein, we will focus on a few
novel effects of the photoelectrical response that benefit from the
ultrathin characteristics of OPTs and their long-range ordered molecular
arrangements.
First, we note that the charge transport properties
of the channels
in OPTs greatly affect the separation, transmisn class="Chemical">sion, and collection
of photogenerated carriers. In a typical example, Ji et al. obtained
a series of OPTs with different mobilities by controlling the thickness
of DPA films from 10 to 30 nm, as shown in Figure a.[124] Under the
same lighting conditions, the changes in photosensitivity (P) and photoresponsivity (R) were consistent
with the trend in mobility, confirming that higher mobility contributes
to higher optical performance. Moreover, compared to the hopping modes
seen with small localization lengths,[125] longer exciton diffusion lengths and greater separation efficiencies
are expected due to band-like transport with stronger electron cloud
overlap,[126] which provides more photogenerated
free carriers and enhanced light modulation.
Figure 8
(a) The device scheme
(left, top) based on DPA films from 10 to
30 nm and their photoresponse characteristics (right) with different
light intensities and photoresponse mapping (left, bottom). Reproduced
with permission from ref (124). (b) The photogating effect of the devices based on monolayer
(top) or bilayer (bottom) 2DCOS. Reproduced with permission from ref (50). Copyright 2019, Wiley-VCH.
(c) The carrier distribution and dark current diagram in both bulk
and ultrathin channel. Reproduced with permission from ref (65). Copyright 2018, Wiley-VCH.
(d) The energy level diagram of PTCDA/pentacene 2DCOS junction (left,
top), absorption spectrum (right, top) and their photoresponse properties
(bottom). Reproduced with permission from ref (128). Copyright 2017, American
Chemical Society.
(a) The device scheme
(left, top) based onn class="Chemical">DPA films from 10 to
30 nm and their photoresponse characteristics (right) with different
light intenn class="Chemical">sities and photoresponse mapping (left, bottom). Reproduced
with permission from ref (124). (b) The photogating effect of the devices based on monolayer
(top) or bilayer (bottom) 2DCOS. Reproduced with permission from ref (50). Copyright 2019, Wiley-VCH.
(c) The carrier distribution and dark current diagram in both bulk
and ultrathin channel. Reproduced with permission from ref (65). Copyright 2018, Wiley-VCH.
(d) The energy level diagram of PTCDA/pentacene2DCOS junction (left,
top), absorption spectrum (right, top) and their photoresponse properties
(bottom). Reproduced with permission from ref (128). Copyright 2017, American
Chemical Society.
The second effect to
discuss is the photogating effect. Photogating,
a conductance modulation through a photoinduced gate voltage, is considered
a way to improve the n class="Chemical">optical response of 2D organic OPTs, especially
responsivity. Different from the conventional photoconductive effect,
the photogating effect is caused by photogenerated minority carriers
(holes for n-type semiconductors or electrons for p-type semiconductors)
stationed at the traps on the crystal surface or at crystal/insulator
interface, which create an additional gate voltage and result in a
threshold voltage shift (ΔVth, more
negative for n-type channels or more positive for p-type channels).[127] Intuitively, in the ultrathin limit, the low
light absorption of 2DCOS makes them unsuitable as direct replacements
for thin-film semiconductors. However, the large surface-to-volume
ratio and the reduction in screening improve the trapping capabilities
of 2DCOS, resulting in excellent electrical tunability by localized
fields and enhanced performance through applied gate voltages. For
example, as shown in Figure b, Fu et al. successfully fabricated an ultrasensitive OPT
based on 2DCOS with few monolayers.[50] The
OPTs based on the 2L-2DCOS showed photosensitivity (P, the value of which is equal to Iph divided
by Idark) up to 2.58 × 107 and responsivities reaching 1.91 × 104 A W–1. In comparison, the threshold
voltages of devices based on 1L-2DCOSshifted to the positive side
of those of 2L-2DCOS, indicating stronger doping effects in the thinner
crystals.
Furthermore, in order to meet the requirements for
high specific
detectivity (D*) and detection at low noise levels,
suppresn class="Chemical">sion of the dark current and improvement of the on/off ratio
are critical. The charge transport dilemma for n class="Chemical">2D channels and thick
channels is described in Figure c. As discussed in the previous section, the carrier
density in the channel decreases exponentially with increasing distance
from the semiconductor/insulator interface in the “on”
state of the device. Similarly, the gate field mainly depletes a few-nanometer-long
region near the interface in the “off” state.[71] As a result, 2DCOS-based devices usually exhibit
high on/off ratios and weak signals in the “off” state
due to their thin channels and can be operated in full depletion.[123] For example, Hu et al. recently fabricated
near-infrared-sensitive OPTs based on high-quality TFT-CN2DCOS with
thicknesses of 4.8 nm.[65] Because of efficient
carrier injection and intrinsic, defect-free carrier transport, the
device showed excellent responsivity (9 × 104 A W–1) and EQE (106 %). Impressively, compared
with thick crystals (thickness of 32 nm), the dark current of the
2DCOS-based device was 1 order of magnitude lower (0.3 pA vs 3 pA),
leading to an ultrahigh detectivity of 6 × 1014 Jones,
which was among the best performances in current studies.
Finally,
as mentioned above, n class="Chemical">single-component devices dominated
by the photogating effect suffer from trade-offs in the photoresponn class="Chemical">sivity
and response time. Because of the lack of a built-in electric field,
the high responsivity generally arises from long-lived trap-state-induced
excitons (usually lasting in the range of hundreds of milliseconds
to a few seconds).[30] Cao et al. demonstrated
that interfacing 2DCOS with other high-mobility materials can counterbalance
this contradiction.[20] As the thickness
of the 2DCOS is equivalent to the exciton diffusion length in organic
semiconductors, an effective separation of photogenerated electron
pairs can be achieved at the interface. Furthermore, Wang et al. fabricated
OPTs using a perylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxylic dianhydride (PTCDA)
and pentacene2D crystalline heterostructure as the light-absorbing
layer (Figure d).[128] The device achieved a good balance between
a high responsivity of 105 A W–1 and
a response time as low as 28 μs, which are 1 and 2 orders of
magnitude better, respectively, than those of other solution-processed
organic/grapheneOPTs.[129,130]
Although many
novel devices and excellent performance characteristics
have been demonstrated, there are still many challenges in photoelectric
control of n class="Chemical">2D organic crystals. (i) Because of their nearly transparent
nature, high-mobility n class="Chemical">2DCOS with efficient light absorption should
be broadly explored, and the device structures and interfaces need
further optimization to obtain practical devices with good trade-offs.
(ii) The underlying photophysical questions, including the length
of the exciton diffusion between different molecular layers of organic
single crystals, are still not clear. The separation and transmission
mechanisms of photogenerated excitons are only inferred theoretically
and lack accurate experimental data.
Hybrid
System with Other 2D Van Der Waals Solids
n class="Chemical">2D vdWs, such as
semin class="Chemical">metallic graphene, semiconductive transition
metal dichalcogenides (TMDs), insulated few-layer crystals of hexagonal
boron nitride (hBN), possess new opportunities for device concepts
and applications due to their unique properties beyond bulk materials.
The hybrid system of organic molecules and 2D vdWs appears to design
many predictable functions successfully, which have been summarized
in some professional reviews.[131,132] However, the organic
counterparts are mainly concentrated on amorphous films and micro-/nanocrystals.
In parallel with the efforts on 2DCOS, interfacing ultrathin 2DCOS
with other 2D vdWs solids have recently emerged, which provide a molecular
level pristine heterogeneous interface for exploring the charge transfer,[20] tunneling effect,[133] and other transport physics.[134,135] Moreover, most reports
have focused on the assembly of organic molecules directly on the
surface of 2D vdWs. In this process, organic molecules can form self-assembled
ordered structures to construct controllable long-range ordered organic–inorganic
van der Waals heterojunctions.
In the Wang group, a series of
works on the heterogeneous interface
between n class="Chemical">ultrathin molecular crystals and n class="Chemical">2D vdWs have been reported.[18,20,101,136] Typically, the interfacial layer of molecules that do not contribute
to conductance is clearly characterized, lying prone on the substrate
in a different arrangement from the bulk packing.[101] Above the interfacial layer, the first monolayer C8-BTBT standing on hBN insulation could reach ∼10 cm2 V–1 s–1, indicating the
pristine, ultrasmooth interface between C8-BTBT and hBN.
Different from graphene and hBN, MoS2 was not the π-conjugated
system so that the first molecular layer was tilted at a greater angle
to the MoS2.[133] Gate-controlled
vertical 2DC8-BTBT/MoS2 heterostructures exhibited
electrical properties distinct from those of a single-component channel.
In the range of gate that permitted both hole and electron injection,
an interfacial recombination resulted in the current peak; as the
forward gate voltage continued to increase, the electrons accumulated
in MoS2 and crossed ultrathin molecular crystals through
the tunneling effect, which was rarely reported in bulk heterojunction.
In addition, the interactions between the 2D vdWs and molecules could
adjust by controlling the electronic state of 2D vdWs templates. Cho
et al. demonstrated that the linear dependence nucleation sites of
organic molecules on carrier densities[137] and first realized the controlled layer-by-layer growth of fullerenes
on electrical-doped graphene in the case of suppressing charge transfer.[138] As a result, the Fermi-level pinning in heterojunction
disappeared, and the charge injection in barristors of fullerene/graphene
approached ideal Schottky–Mott limits.
For the phototrann class="Chemical">sistors,
n class="Chemical">graphene with an excellent charge transport
property can make up for the short exciton diffusion length of organic
semiconductors in a hybrid system. Liu et al. fabricated monocrystalline
films with high order and controllable layers on graphene and explored
the photoelectric characteristics.[20] In
this C8-BTBT/graphene heterojunction device, electrons
spontaneously move from graphene to molecular layers, and a built-in
electric field is directed from the graphene to molecules. Under the
illumination, photogenerated electrons moved toward graphene to form
n-doped channel. Despite the monolayer thickness, responsivity reached
up to 104 A W–1 and short response time
of 25 ms. The recovery time after turning off the light and photoconductive
gain of the device increased as the film thickened to seven layers
with a linear relationship, which was due to the increasing barrier
of charge transport between layers resulting in a prolonged recombination
process.
Future Directions and Perspectives
Over the past decade, explon class="Chemical">sive progress has been achieved in the
area of solution-processed large-n class="Chemical">size ultrathin 2DCOS, from fundamental
research to next-generation printable electronics. In this outlook,
we are committed to provide overall progress in this emerging field
around effective fabricated protocols for large-area 2DCOS via solution
assembly process, electrical performance in gate field-controlled
device, their burgeoning photoelectric device, and their hybrid system
with other 2D vdWs. Despite the remarkable advances achieved in large-area
2DCOS and their applications in OFET-based electronic and optoelectronic
devices, representing a new research frontier in the evolution of
technology, the current research on large-area crystals in the 2D
limit is far from mature.
Because of their definite molecular
weights and clear conformations,
high-mobility small-molecule n class="Chemical">2DCOS are playing vital roles in revealing
carrier transport characteristics at interfaces and in aiding fundamental
investigations of emerging functional photoelectronic devices. However,
because of the severe entanglement between molecular chains, the preparation
of conjugated n class="Chemical">polymer-based 2DCOS remains a major challenge, limiting
abundant basic research of physical properties. Fortunately, micrometer-sized
quasi-2Dpolymer semiconductor crystals have been successfully fabricated
by topochemical polymerization in a previously reported advance.[16] Successful strategies are urgently needed to
fabricate high-quality 2D conjugated polymersingle crystals over
large areas because of their excellent charge transport properties
along conjugated molecular chains (as compared to intermolecular orbit
coupling), which may provide more opportunities for high-speed logic
circuits.
Additionally, most n class="Chemical">single-crystal circuits are currently
implemented
with an entire crystal, leading to intersections and crosstalk between
adjacent components as well as lumped leakage current. Thus, high-precin class="Chemical">sion
patterned arrays of organic crystals represent a vital procedure for
realizing accurate data acquisition and low power consumption in organic
circuits. However, because of their intolerance toward high temperatures
and organic solvents, the 2DCOS are incompatible with traditional
solvents in multistep solvent treatment photolithography techniques.
Up to this point, template-assisted methods have been explored to
control the pattern and growth of organic crystals.[139] The challenge lies in further processing the 2DCOS to obtain
the desired large-area patterns for functional circuits without affecting
the carrier transport.
Finally, the most serious obstacles to
practical applications of
n class="Chemical">2DCOS-based devices are stability and long-term durability. The relatively
low stability results from several aspects: (i) the nonpern class="Chemical">sistence
of organic materials during the storage and transportation, (ii) the
sensitivity of most organic semiconductors, especially n-type organic
semiconductors, to water and oxygen in air, leading to limited electron
transport and performance decays over time, and (iii) the greater
susceptibility of ultrathin 2DCOS to interfacial trap states compared
with thick single crystals. The induced charge applied by the dielectric
layers can fill the traps, causing bias instability that is harmful
to the stable operation of the circuit. Therefore, one of the key
challenges in this field is to develop environmentally stable organic
materials and explore reliable methods for encapsulation, so as to
significantly extend the materials’ stability.
Authors: Sangmoo Choi; Canek Fuentes-Hernandez; Cheng-Yin Wang; Talha M Khan; Felipe A Larrain; Yadong Zhang; Stephen Barlow; Seth R Marder; Bernard Kippelen Journal: ACS Appl Mater Interfaces Date: 2016-09-12 Impact factor: 9.229