| Literature DB >> 32093001 |
Henry B Ogden1, Robert B Child2, Joanne L Fallowfield3, Simon K Delves3, Caroline S Westwood1, Joseph D Layden1.
Abstract
Exertional heat stroke (EHS) is a life-threatening medical condition involving thermoregulatory failure and is the most severe condition along a continuum of heat-related illnesses. Current EHS policy guidance principally advocates a thermoregulatory management approach, despite growing recognition that gastrointestinal (GI) microbial translocation contributes to disease pathophysiology. Contemporary research has focused to understand the relevance of GI barrier integrity and strategies to maintain it during periods of exertional-heat stress. GI barrier integrity can be assessed non-invasively using a variety of in vivo techniques, including active inert mixed-weight molecular probe recovery tests and passive biomarkers indicative of GI structural integrity loss or microbial translocation. Strenuous exercise is strongly characterised to disrupt GI barrier integrity, and aspects of this response correlate with the corresponding magnitude of thermal strain. The aetiology of GI barrier integrity loss following exertional-heat stress is poorly understood, though may directly relate to localised hyperthermia, splanchnic hypoperfusion-mediated ischemic injury, and neuroendocrine-immune alterations. Nutritional countermeasures to maintain GI barrier integrity following exertional-heat stress provide a promising approach to mitigate EHS. The focus of this review is to evaluate: (1) the GI paradigm of exertional heat stroke; (2) techniques to assess GI barrier integrity; (3) typical GI barrier integrity responses to exertional-heat stress; (4) the aetiology of GI barrier integrity loss following exertional-heat stress; and (5) nutritional countermeasures to maintain GI barrier integrity in response to exertional-heat stress.Entities:
Keywords: exercise; gut; nutrition; sport; supplement
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32093001 PMCID: PMC7071449 DOI: 10.3390/nu12020537
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nutrients ISSN: 2072-6643 Impact factor: 5.717
Figure 1The gastrointestinal paradigm of exertional heat stroke.
Overview of in vivo techniques to assess GI barrier integrity.
| Technique | Sample | Method | Site | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||
| Dual-Sugar Absorption Test (DSAT) | Urine or blood | HPLC (+) MS | Small GI Integrity | Gold-standard. High reliability. Time-consuming (5 h urine, >2.5 h blood). No standard protocol with exercise. Well studied. |
| Multi-Sugar Absorption Test (MSAT) | Urine or blood | HLPC (+) MS | Entire GI Integrity | Gold-Standard. Segmental GI integrity. Time-consuming (5 h urine, >2.5 h blood). No standard protocol with exercise. Few studies. |
| Polyethylene Glycol (PEG) Absorption Test | Urine | HLPC (+) MS | Entire GI Integrity | Validated against MSAT. Can include multiple weight PEGs (e.g., 100, 400, 1000, 4000 kDa). Time-consuming (5 h urine). Few studies. |
|
| ||||
| Intestinal Fatty Acid Binding Protein (I-FABP) | Urine or Blood | ELISA | Epithelial injury | Tissue specific (duodenum and jejunum). Short half-life (11 min). Weak correlations with DSAT. Well studied. |
| Ileal Bile-Acid Binding Protein (I-BABP) | Urine or Blood | ELISA | Epithelial injury | Tissue specific (ileum). Few studies. Weak correlations with I-FABP. Few studies. |
| Diamine Oxidase (DAO), α-Glutathione s-Transferase (α-GST), Smooth Muscle 22 (SM22) | Blood | ELISA | Epithelial injury | Non-tissue specific. Few studies. |
| Claudin-3 (CLDN3) | Urine or Blood | ELISA | TJ Integrity | Non-tissue specific. Few studies. |
| Zonulin | Blood or Faeces | ELISA | TJ Integrity | Non-tissue specific. Assay cross-reactivity (complement C3). Moderate studies. |
| Endotoxin (LPS) | Blood | LAL assay | MT | Tissue specific. Sample contamination causes false-positives. Hepatic removal and receptor binding cause false-negatives. Well studied. |
| LPS Binding Protein (LBP) | Blood | ELISA | MT | Tissue specific. Lower risk of false-positives than endotoxin. Indirect marker of endotoxin exposure. Influenced by hepatic production. Long half-life (12–14 h). Few studies. |
| Soluable-CD14 (sCD14-ST) | Blood | ELISA | MT | Tissue specific. Lower risk of false positives than endotoxin. Influenced by hepatic production and monocytes shedding. Few studies. |
| D-lactate | Blood | ELISA | MT | Predominately tissue specific. Potentially influenced by methylglyoxal metabolism. Few studies. |
| 16s Bacterial rDNA (bactDNA) | Blood | Real-time PCR assay | MT | Tissue specific. Novel. Lower risk of false-positives than endotoxin. Few studies. |
Abbreviations: HPLC, high performance liquid chromatography; MS, mass spectrometry; ELISA, enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay; LAL, limulus amoebocyte lysate assay; PCR, polymerase chain reaction.
Influence of acute exercise-(heat) stress on small-intestine DSAT responses.
| Author | Subjects | Exercise Protocol | Peak TCore (°C) | Mean HR (bpm) | Biofluid, DSAT L/R or L/M (Timepoint) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| van Nieuwenhoven et al. [ | 10 male (MT) | 90 min cycling at 70% Wattmax (fasted) in Tamb 19 °C (RH = N/A) | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.007 s |
| van Nieuwenhoven et al. [ | 10 male (MT) | 90 min cycling at 70% Wattmax (fasted) in Tamb 19 °C (RH = N/A) | 38.8 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.008 nb,c |
| Nieman et al. [ | 20 male and female (UT) | 45 min walking uphill (5% grade) at 60% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | 132 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.009 nb,c |
| Smetanka et al. [ | 8 male (HT) | Chicago marathon (42.2 km) in Tamb (fed) 22 °C (48% RH) | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.020 ns |
| Shing et al. [ | 10 male (HT) | ~33 min running to fatigue at 80% VE (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (40% RH) | 39.4 | 172 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.022 nb,c |
| Janssen-Duijghuijsen et al. [ | 11 male (HT) | 90 min cycling at 50% wattmax (fed) in Tamb not reported following a sleep-low glycogen depletion regime | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): ~0.022 ns Plasma L/R (1 h): ~0.110 s |
| Snipe et al. [ | 6 male and 4 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 22 °C (44% RH) | 38.5 | ~150 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.025 nb |
| Snipe et al. [ | 6 male and 4 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 30 °C (25% RH) | 38.6 | ~155 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.026 nb |
| van Wijck et al. [ | 10 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (2 h): 0.027 nb,c |
| Buchman et al. [ | 17 male and 2 female | Competitive Marathon (fed) in Tamb 2 °C with freezing rain | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (6 h): 0.030 ns,c |
| Ryan et al. [ | 7 males (MT) | 60 min running at 68% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | Urine L/M (6 h): 0.029 ns |
| van Nieuwenh-oven et al. [ | 9 male and 1 female (MT) | 90 min cycling at 70% Wattmax (fasted) in Tamb 19 °C (RH = N/A) | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.030 ns |
| van Wijck et al. [ | 9 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (2 h): 0.030 s,c |
| Pugh et al. [ | 11 male (MT-HT) | 18 × 400 m sprint at 120% VO2max (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (2h): 0.030 ns Serum L/R (2 h): ~0.051 s |
| Snipe and Costa [ | 11 male (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (25% RH) | 39.1 | ~150 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.030 nb |
| Snipe and Costa [ | 13 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (25% RH) | 38.8 | ~155 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.028 nb |
| Snipe et al. (Part B) [ | 6 male and 4 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (26% RH) | 39.6 | ~170 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.032 nb |
| Snipe et al. [ | 6 male and 5 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (30% RH) | 39.3 | 159 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.034 nb,c |
| March et al. [ | 9 male (MT) | 20 min running at 80% VO2peak (fasted) in Tamb 22 °C (37% RH) | 38.4 | 170 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.035 s,c |
| Pals et al. (Part A) [ | 5 male and 1 female (MT) | 60 min running at 40% VO2peak (fasted) in Tamb 22 °C (50% RH) | 38.0 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.036 ns |
| Marchbank et al. [ | 12 male (MT) | 20 min running to fatigue at 80% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb not reported | 38.3 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.038 s,c |
| van Nieuwenh-oven et al. [ | 9 male and 1 female (MT) | 90 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 19 °C (RH = N/A) | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.040 s |
| van Wijck et al. [ | 6 male (HT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.040 ns Plasma L/R (2.4 h): 0.060 s |
| Lambert et al. (Part A) [ | 11 male and 9 female (MT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 22 °C (48% RH) | 38.5 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.049 ns,c |
| Lambert et al. [ | 13 male and 4 female (HT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 22 °C (48% RH) | 38.3 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.050 nb,c |
| Zuhl et al. [ | 4 male and 3 female (LT/MT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 30 °C (12–20% RH) | 39.4 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.060 nb,c |
| Zuhl et al. [ | 2 male and 5 female (LT/MT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 30 °C (12–20% RH) | 39.5 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.060 nb,c |
| Lambert et al. (Part B) [ | 11 male and 9 female (MT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 22 °C (48% RH) without fluid ingestion | 38.5 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.063 s,c |
| Pals et al. (Part B) [ | 5 male and 1 female (MT) | 60 min running at 40% VO2peak (fasted) in Tamb 22 °C (50% RH) | 38.7 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.064 ns |
| Lambert et al. [ | 8 male (MT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 22 °C (48% RH) | 38.3 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.065 nb,c |
| Buchman et al. [ | 15 male and female (LT-HT) | Road marathon (42.2 km) (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | Urine L/M (6 h): 0.070 ns,c |
| Pugh et al. [ | 10 male (MT) | 60 min at 70% VO2max running (fasted) in Tamb 30 °C (4–45% RH) | 38.5 | 82.5% of max | Serum L/R (2 h): ~0.080 s,c |
| Pugh et al. [ | 10 male and 2 female (MT) | 42.4 km track marathon (247 ± 47 min; fed) in Tamb 16–17 °C (N/A RH) | N/A | ~160 | Serum L/R (1 h) 0.081 (37%) s,c |
| Lambert et al. [ | 12 female (LT-HT) | Hawaii Ironman (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.087 nb |
| Davison et al. [ | 8 male (MT/HT) | 20 min running to fatigue at 80% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb not reported | 39.3 | ~170 | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.098 s,c |
| Janssen-Duijghuijsen et al. [ | 4 male and 6 female (LT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | Plasma L/R (1 h): ~0.100 s |
| Lambert et al. [ | 29 male (LT-HT) | Hawaii Ironman (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.105 nb |
| Pals et al. (Part C) [ | 5 male and 1 female (MT) | 60 min running at 40% VO2peak (fasted) in Tamb 22 °C (50% RH) | 39.6 | N/A | Urine L/R (5 h): 0.107 s |
LT = Low-trained (35–49 mL·kg·min−1 VO2max); MT = Moderate-trained (50–59 mL·kg·min−1 VO2max); HT = High-trained (60+ mL·kg·min−1 VO2max). s = significant change post-exercise (p < 0.05); ns = non-significant change post-exercise (p > 0.05); nb = no baseline resting data to compare against; c = control/placebo trial of study.
Influence of acute exercise-(heat) stress on systemic I-FABP concentrations.
| Author | Subjects | Exercise Protocol | Peak TCore (°C) | Mean HR (bpm) | I-FABP (Δ Pre-to-Post Exercise) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Janssen-Duijghuijsen et al. [ | 11 male (HT) | 90 min cycling at 50% wattmax (fed) in Tamb not reported following a “sleep-low” glycogen depletion regime | N/A | N/A | ~−90 pg·mL−1 (~−65%) c |
| Kartaram et al. (Part A) [ | 15 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 50% wattmax (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | ~-50 pg·mL−1 (~−10%) ns |
| Lee and Thake (Part A) [ | 7 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 50% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 18 °C (35% RH) on day one of temperate acclimation | 37.9 | 133 | 28 pg·mL−1 (8%) ns,c |
| Trommelen et al. [ | 10 male (HT) | 180 min cycling at 50% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb 18–22 °C (55–65% RH) | N/A | N/A | N/A pg·mL−1 (20%) ns,c |
| Edinburgh et al. (Part A) [ | 12 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 50% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 18 °C (35% RH) | N/A | N/A | 70 pg·mL−1 (34%) s |
| Edinburgh et al. (Part B) [ | 12 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 50% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 18 °C (35% RH) | N/A | N/A | 88 pg·mL−1 (20%) s |
| Osborne et al. (Part A) [ | 8 male (MT-HT) | 30 min cycling at 50/70% Wattmax, then 30 min at 50% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb 20 °C (55% RH) | 38.5 | 139 | 138 pg·mL−1 (29%) ns |
| Salvador et al. 2019 [ | 12 male (MT-HT) | 120 min cycling at 60% VO2max (fed) then 30–40 min (20 km) time trial in Tamb not reported | 37.9 | ~168 | N/A pg·mL−1 (~50%) s, c |
| van Wijck et al. [ | 10 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | 153 pg·mL−1 (72%) s |
| Nava et al. [ | 7 male and 4 female (LT-MT) | 56 min mixed intensity (~55% VO2max) discontinuous firefighting exercises (fed) in Tamb 38 °C (35% RH) on day one of two | 38.7 | ~161 | ~160 pg·mL−1 (23%) ns, c |
| Van Wijck et al. [ | 9 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | 179 pg·mL−1 (61%) s |
| Lee et al. (Part C) [ | 7 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 50% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 18 °C (35% RH) and FiO2 = 0.14% on day one of hypoxic acclimation | 38.2 | 149 | 193 pg·mL−1 (43%) s,c |
| Lis et al. [ | 13 male and female (MT) | 45 min cycling at 70% wattmax and 15 min cycling time trial (fed) in 20 °C (40% RH) | N/A | 168 | 210 pg·mL−1 (223%) s,c |
| Pugh et al. [ | 10 male (MT) | 60 min at 70% VO2max running (fasted) in Tamb 30 °C (4–45% RH) | 38.5 | 82.5% of HR max | 250 pg·mL−1 (71%) s,c |
| Snipe et al. (Part A) [ | 6 male and 4 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 22 °C (44% RH) | 38.5 | ~150 | 274 pg·mL−1 (127%) s |
| Sheahen et al. (Part A) [ | 12 male (MT) | 45 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 20 °C (40% RH) | 38.2 | 165 | 281 pg·mL−1 (49%) s |
| Lee et al. (Part B) [ | 7 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 50% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 40 °C (25% RH) on day one of heat acclimation | 38.7 | 151 | 282 pg·mL−1 (76%) s,c |
| Morrison et al. (Part B) [ | 8 male (UT) | 30 min cycling at 50% heart rate reserve (HRR), 30 min jogging at 80% HRR and 30 min running time trial (fed) in Tamb 30 °C (50% RH) | 38.6 | N/A | 283 pg·mL−1 (276%) s,c |
| Barberio et al. [ | 9 male (MT) | ~24 min running at 78% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 40 °C (40% RH) prior to heat acclimation | 39.0 | N/A | 297 pg·mL−1 (46%) s,c |
| Hill et al. [ | 10 male (MT) | 60 min running at 65% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | ~170 | 300 pg·mL−1 (50%) ns,c |
| van Wijck et al. [ | 15 male (HT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | 306 pg·mL−1 (61%) s |
| Kashima et al. [ | 5 male and 3 female (MT) | 30 intermittent 20 s cycle sprints at 120% wattmax, with 40 s recovery between each (fed) in 23 °C (40% RH) | N/A | 150 | 343 pg·mL−1 (266%) s |
| Pugh et al. [ | 11 male (MT-HT) | 18 × 400 m sprint at 120% VO2max (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | 348 pg·mL−1 (72%) s |
| March et al. [ | 9 male (MT) | 20 min running at 80% VO2peak (fasted) in Tamb 22 °C (37% RH) | 38.4 | 170 | 350 pg·mL−1 (61%) s,c |
| Janssen-Duijghuijsen et al. [ | 4 male and 6 female (LT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | ~350 pg·mL−1 (~77%) s,c |
| Sheahen et al. (Part B) [ | 12 male (MT) | 45 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 30 °C (40% RH) | 38.3 | 163 | 369 pg·mL−1 (63%) s |
| Costa et al. [ | 11 male (MT-HT) | 120 min running at 70% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 25 °C (35% RH) | N/A | 148 | 371 pg·mL−1 (86%) ns,c |
| Osborne et al. [ | 12 male (MT-HT) | 33 min (20 km) cycling time trial (fasted) in 35 °C (50% RH) | 39 | 167 | 441 pg·mL−1 (83%) s,c |
| Kartaram et al. (Part B) [ | 15 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | ~500 pg·mL−1 (~66%) s |
| Kartaram et al. (Part C) [ | 15 male (MT) | 60 min cycling at 85/55% wattmax (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | ~500 pg·mL−1 (~66%) s |
| McKenna et al. [ | 10 male (MT) | 46 min running at 95% VE threshold (fasted) in Tamb 40 °C (50% RH) | 39.7 | N/A | 516 pg·mL−1 (52%) s,c |
| Karhu et al. [ | 17 male (MT-HT) | 90 min running at 80% of best 10 km race time (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | 531 pg·mL−1 (151%) s |
| Snipe and Costa [ | 6 male and 6 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 30 °C (35% RH) | 38.8 | 160 | 573 pg·mL−1 (184%) s,c |
| Snipe et al. (Part B) [ | 6 male and 4 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 30 °C (25% RH) | 38.6 | ~155 | ~580 pg·mL−1 (184%) |
| Hill et al. [ | 10 male (MT) | 60 min running at 65% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb not reported (FiO2 = 13.5%) | N/A | ~170 | 700 pg·mL−1 (168%) ns,c |
| Osborne et al. (Part B) [ | 8 Male (MT-HT) | 30 min cycling at 50/70% Wattmax, then 30 min at 50% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb 35 °C (53% RH) | 39.5 | 159 | 608 pg·mL−1 (140%) s |
| Szymanski et al. [ | 6 male and 2 female (LT/MT) | 60 min running at 68% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 37 °C (25% RH) | 39.0 | 174 | 800 pg·mL−1 (87%) s,c |
| Morrison et al. (Part A) [ | 7 male (HT) | 30 min cycling at 50% heart rate reserve (HRR), 30 min jogging at 80% HRR and 30 min running time trial (fed) in Tamb 30 °C (50% RH) | 38.6 | N/A | 806 pg·mL−1 (663%) s,c |
| Snipe et al. [ | 6 male and 5 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (30% RH) | 39.3 | 159 | 897 pg·mL−1 (288%) s,c |
| Snipe et al. (Part B) [ | 6 male and 4 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (26% RH) | 39.6 | ~170 | 1230 pg·mL−1 (432%) s |
| Pugh et al. [ | 10 male and 2 female (MT) | 42.4 km track marathon (247 ± 47 min; fed) in Tamb 16-17 °C (N/A RH) | N/A | ~160 | 1246 pg·mL−1 (371%) s, c |
| March et al. [ | 12 male (MT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 30 °C (60% RH) | 39.3 | 170 | 1263 pg·mL−1 (407%) s, c |
| Snipe and Costa [ | 11 male (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (25% RH) | 39.1 | ~150 | 1389 pg·mL−1 (479%) s |
| Snipe et al. [ | 13 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (25% RH) | 38.8 | ~155 | 1445 pg·mL−1 (479%) s |
| Jonvik et al. [ | 16 male (HT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | 1745 pg·mL−1 (249%) s |
| Gaskell et al. [ | 10 male and 8 female (MT-HT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (25% RH) | 38.6 | ~151 | 1805 pg·mL−1 (710%) s, c |
LT = Low-trained (35–49 mL·kg·min−1 VO2max); MT = Moderate-trained (50–59 mL·kg·min−1 VO2max); HT = High-trained (60+ mL·kg·min−1 VO2max). s = significant change post-exercise (p < 0.05); ns = non-significant change post-exercise (p > 0.05); c = control/placebo trial of study.
Influence of acute exercise-(heat) stress on systemic gastrointestinal microbial translocation responses.
| Author | Subjects | Exercise Protocol | Peak TCore (°C) | Mean HR (bpm) | Endotoxin (Δ Pre-to-Post Exercise) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Antunes et al. [ | 19 male (MT) | 56 ± 7 min cycling at 90% of first ventilatory threshold (fasted) in 22.1 °C (55% RH) | N/A | 141 | −3 pg·mL−1 (−3%) ns |
| Yeh et al. (Part B) [ | 15 male and 1 female (LT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 22 °C (66% RH) | 38.4 | ~145 | −1.1 pg·mL−1 (−10%) ns |
| Zuhl et al. [ | 2 male and 5 female (LT/MT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 30 °C (12–20% RH) | 39.5 | N/A | −0.2 pg·mL−1 (−7%) ns,c |
| Osborne et al. (Part A) [ | 8 Male (MT-HT) | 30 min cycling at 50/70% Wattmax, then 30 min at 50% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb 20 °C (55% RH) | 38.5 | 165 | 0.1 pg·mL−1 (1%) ns,# |
| Osborne et al. (Part B) [ | 8 Male (MT-HT) | 30 min cycling at 50/70% Wattmax, then 30 min at 50% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb 35 °C (53% RH) | 39.5 | 182 | 0.2 pg·mL−1 (1%) s,# |
| Karhu et al. [ | 17 males (MT-HT) | 90 min running at 80% of best 10 km race time (fed) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | 0.3 pg·mL−1 (~1%) ns,c |
| Kuennen et al. [ | 8 male (MT) | 100 min walking (6.3 km·h−1) at 50% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb 46.5 °C (20% RH) | 39.3 | N/A | ~0.5 pg·mL−1 (10%) ns,c |
| Ng et al. [ | 30 males (HT) | Half-marathon (fed) in Tamb 27 °C (84% RH) | 40.7 | 172 | 0.6 pg·mL−1 (32%) s |
| Jeukendrup et al. [ | 29 male and 1 female (HT) | Ironman (3.8 km swim; 185 km cycle; 42.2 km run) (fed) in Tamb 9–32 °C | N/A | N/A | 1.7 pg·mL−1 (666%) s |
| Guy et al. [ | 20 male (LT-MT) | 10 min cycling at 50%, 60%, and 70% wattmax, then 5 km (fasted) in Tamb 35 °C (70% RH) | 38.9 | 160 | 2 pg·mL−1 (9%) ns |
| Selkirk et al. (Part B) [ | 12 male (HT) | To fatigue (~122 min) uphill walk at 4.5 km.h−1 (fasted) in Tamb 40 °C (30% RH) | 39.7 | 156 | ~3 pg·mL−1 (200%) s |
| Shing et al. [ | 10 male (HT) | ~33 min running to fatigue at 80% VE (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (40% RH) | 39.4 | 172 | 4 pg·mL−1 (15%) s |
| Snipe et al. (Part A) [ | 6 male and 4 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 22 °C (44% RH) | 38.5 | ~150 | 4.1 pg·mL−1 (5%) ns |
| Yeh et al. (Part B) [ | 15 male and 1 female (LT) | 60 min running at 70% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 33 °C (50% RH) | 39.3 | ~145 | 5 pg·mL−1 (54%) s |
| Antunes et al. (Part B) [ | 19 male (MT) | 45 ± 18 min cycling at midpoint between first and second ventilatory threshold (fasted) in 22.1 °C (55% RH) | N/A | 162 | 5 pg·mL−1 (7%) ns |
| Antunes et al. (Part C) [ | 19 male (MT) | 10 ± 9 min cycling at midpoint between second ventilatory threshold and maximal aerobic power (fasted) in 22.1 °C (55% RH) | N/A | 180 | 6 pg·mL−1 (5%) ns |
| Ashton et al. [ | 10 males (LT) | VO2max test (~15 min) on cycle ergometer (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | 9.4 pg·mL−1 (72%) s |
| Snipe et al. (Part B) [ | 6 male and 4 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (26% RH) | 39.6 | ~170 | 9.8 pg·mL−1 (11%) s |
| Gill et al. [ | 8 male (MT-HT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 32 °C (34% RH) | 38.6 | 165 | 10 pg·mL−1 (4%) ns, c |
| Snipe et al. [ | 6 male and 5 female (MT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (30% RH) | 39.3 | 159 | 10 pg·mL−1 (N/A%) nb |
| Selkirk et al. (Part A) [ | 11 male (LT-MT) | To fatigue (~106 min) uphill walk at 4.5 km.h−1 (fasted) in Tamb 40 °C (30% RH) | 39.1 | 164 | ~10 pg·mL−1 (300%) s |
| Lim et al. (Part B) [ | 9 male (HT) | To fatigue (time not given) at 70% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (40% RH) | 39.5 | N/A | 13 pg·mL−1 (92%) s,c |
| Guy et al. [ | 8 male (LT) | 10 min cycling at 50%, 60%, and 70% wattmax, then 5 km (fasted) in Tamb 35 °C (70% RH) | 38.6 | 161 | 16 pg·mL−1 (9%) ns,c,# |
| Gill et al. [ | 13 male and 6 female (HT) | Multistage ultra-marathon stage 1 (37 km) (fed) in Tamb 32–40 °C (32–40% RH) | N/A | N/A | 40 pg·mL−1 (14%) s |
| Barberio et al. [ | 9 male (MT) | ~24 min running at 78% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 40 °C (40% RH) prior to heat acclimation | 39.0 | N/A | 40 pg·mL−1 (57%) s,c |
| Moss et al. [ | 9 male (HT) | 45 min cycling at 40% PPO (unstated prandial state) in Tamb 40 °C (50% RH) prior to heat acclimation | 38.9 | 153 | 52 pg·mL−1 (27%) s,c |
| Costa et al. [ | 11 male (MT-HT) | 120 min running at 70% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 25 °C (35% RH) | N/A | 148 | 96 pg·mL−1 (46%) ns,c,# |
| Gill et al. [ | 14 male and 3 female (HT) | 24 h ultramarathon (fed) in Tamb 0-20 °C (54–82% RH) | N/A | N/A | 122 pg·mL−1 (37%) s,# |
| Machado et al. (Part A) [ | 9 male (MT) | 60 min running at 50% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | 130 pg·mL−1 (33%) ns,# |
| Machado et al. (Part B) [ | 9 male (MT) | 60 min running at 50% VO2max (fasted) in Tamb not reported (FIO2 = 13.5%) | N/A | N/A | 250 pg·mL−1 (48%) s,# |
| Gaskell et al. [ | 10 male and 8 female (MT-HT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (25% RH) | 38.6 | ~151 | LBP ~−2 µg·mL−1 (N/A%) ns,c |
| Selkirk et al. (Part A) [ | 11 male (HT) | To fatigue (~163 min) uphill walk at 4.5 km.h−1 (fasted) in Tamb 40 °C (30% RH) | 39.1 | 164 | LBP ~0 µg·mL−1 (0%) ns |
| Moncada-Jiminez et al. [ | 11 male (MT-HT) | 135-min laboratory duathlon at 71% VO2max (15km run and 30km cycle) (fasted) in Tamb not reported | 38.5 | N/A | LBP ~0.59 µg·mL−1 (22%) s,c |
| Selkirk et al. (Part B) [ | 12 male (LT-MT) | To fatigue (~106 min) uphill walk at 4.5 km.h−1 (fasted) in Tamb 40 °C (30% RH) | 39.7 | 156 | LBP ~1.5 µg·mL−1 (15%) s |
| Jonvik et al. [ | 16 male (HT) | 60 min cycling at 70% wattmax (fasted) in Tamb not reported | N/A | N/A | LBP 1.6 µg·mL−1 (13%) s |
| Costa et al. [ | 11 male (MT-HT) | 120 min running at 70% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 25 °C (35% RH) | N/A | 148 | sCD14-ST 0.05 µg·mL−1 (N/A%) ns,c |
| Gaskell et al. [ | 10 male and 8 female (MT-HT) | 120 min running at 60% VO2max (fed) in Tamb 35 °C (25% RH) | 38.6 | ~151 | sCD14-ST 0.1 µg·mL−1 (N/A%) s,c |
| Stuempfle et al. [ | 15 male and 5 female (MT) | 161-km ultramarathon (26.8 ± 2.4 h; fed) in Tamb 0–30 °C (N/A RH) | 38.3 | N/A | sCD14-ST 0.6 µg·mL−1 (63%) s |
| Pugh et al. [ | 10 male and 2 female (MT) | 42.4 km track marathon (4.1 ± 0.8 h; fed) in Tamb 16–17 °C (N/A RH) | N/A | ~160 | sCD14-ST 5.4 µg·mL−1 (164%) s,c |
LT = Low-trained (35–49 mL·kg·min−1 VO2max); MT = Moderate-trained (50–59 mL·kg·min−1 VO2max); HT = High-trained (60+ mL·kg·min−1 VO2max). s = significant change post-exercise (p < 0.05); ns = non-significant change post-exercise (p > 0.05); nb = no baseline resting data to compare with; c = control/placebo trial of study. # Where data have been converted from EU·mL−1 to pg·mL−1 through standard conversions (1 EU·mL−1 = 100 pg·mL−1).
Evidence basis of nutritional supplements to help protect exercise-induced GI barrier integrity loss.
| Nutrient | Evidence | Dosing | Consensus and Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|
|
| Cell: − − | 30–108 g·kg·h−1 liquid multi-transportable CHO. | Effects of pre- exercise CHO status or solid CHO ingestion unknown. Greater exploration on CHO timing and types required. |
|
| Cell: + + + − | 0.25–0.9 g·kg·FFM.−1 given 1–2 h pre-exercise. | Dose ≥ 0.25 g·kg·FFM−1 appears favourable. High doses poorly tolerated in some individuals. No evidence during prolonged exercise or on MT. |
|
| Cell: + + + + | 20 g·day−1 for 14 days pre-exercise | Potentially useful following less demanding exercise. No effects with short-term supplementation. Certain formulations might be more beneficial. |
|
| Cell: + + | More evidence required | No benefits of |
|
| Cell: + − | More evidence required | Contrasting results between formulations. Multi-strain probiotics seem favourable. Negative responses have been reported. Further evidence required. |
|
| Cell: + + − − | 3 days of 0.5 g·day−1 of curcumin. Quercetin not recommended | Contrasting results between formulations. Only two human exercise studies. Further evidence required. |
|
| Cell: + + + | 75 mg·day−1 for ≥ 2 days | Unknown effects in severe exercise situations. A 150 mg·day−1 dose warrants research. Only one human exercise study. Further evidence required. |