| Literature DB >> 31790375 |
James E Sharman1, Eoin O'Brien, Bruce Alpert, Aletta E Schutte, Christian Delles, Michael Hecht Olsen, Roland Asmar, Neil Atkins, Eduardo Barbosa, David Calhoun, Norm R C Campbell, John Chalmers, Ivor Benjamin, Garry Jennings, Stéphane Laurent, Pierre Boutouyrie, Patricio Lopez-Jaramillo, Richard J McManus, Anastasia S Mihailidou, Pedro Ordunez, Raj Padwal, Paolo Palatini, Gianfranco Parati, Neil Poulter, Michael K Rakotz, Clive Rosendorff, Francesca Saladini, Angelo Scuteri, Weimar Sebba Barroso, Myeong-Chan Cho, Ki-Chul Sung, Raymond R Townsend, Ji-Guang Wang, Tine Willum Hansen, Gregory Wozniak, George Stergiou.
Abstract
: The Lancet Commission on Hypertension identified that a key action to address the worldwide burden of high blood pressure (BP) was to improve the quality of BP measurements by using BP devices that have been validated for accuracy. Currently, there are over 3000 commercially available BP devices, but many do not have published data on accuracy testing according to established scientific standards. This problem is enabled through weak or absent regulations that allow clearance of devices for commercial use without formal validation. In addition, new BP technologies have emerged (e.g. cuffless sensors) for which there is no scientific consensus regarding BP measurement accuracy standards. Altogether, these issues contribute to the widespread availability of clinic and home BP devices with limited or uncertain accuracy, leading to inappropriate hypertension diagnosis, management and drug treatment on a global scale. The most significant problems relating to the accuracy of BP devices can be resolved by the regulatory requirement for mandatory independent validation of BP devices according to the universally-accepted International Organisation for Standardization Standard. This is a primary recommendation for which there is an urgent international need. Other key recommendations are development of validation standards specifically for new BP technologies and online lists of accurate devices that are accessible to consumers and health professionals. Recommendations are aligned with WHO policies on medical devices and universal healthcare. Adherence to recommendations would increase the global availability of accurate BP devices and result in better diagnosis and treatment of hypertension, thus decreasing the worldwide burden from high BP.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2020 PMID: 31790375 PMCID: PMC6919228 DOI: 10.1097/HJH.0000000000002246
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Hypertens ISSN: 0263-6352 Impact factor: 4.776
Summary of regulatory and validation study problems, results and consequences related to accuracy of blood pressure devices
| Problem | Result | Overall consequences |
| Not mandatory for manufacturers to use a specific standard to assess BP measuring device accuracy | Variable methods used to assess and report on the accuracy of BP measuring devices | |
| Not mandatory for validation testing to be performed by independent parties | Internal company testing performed with questionable expertise and conflict of interest | |
| Several published validation studies deviate from established protocols | Questionable results and unjustified conclusions of studies evaluating BP monitors | |
| Several BP devices have passed regulatory requirements for sale but failed independent validation of measurement accuracy | Erroneous messaging with respect to the accuracy of individual BP devices | |
| BP devices may fail to produce accurate readings in people with large or small arms but still used in such cases | Individuals with too small or too large arms may have inaccurate BP evaluation | |
| The assumption that a BP device ‘cleared’ by regulatory authorities and commercially available is accurate | Confusion as to which BP device available on the market has acceptable accuracy | 1. Inaccurate BP devices are widely available for sale and use by clinicians and the general public who are unaware of the problem 2. Incorrect diagnosis and treatment decisions are made 3. Opportunity is lost to perform best-practice clinical care and increase the efficacy of cardiovascular disease prevention |
| Regulatory requirements focus on safety rather than accuracy (performance) | BP devices perform well with regard to safety but may not be accurate | |
| Results of BP devices that fail validation studies may not be published | Lack of widespread communication and transparency on the results of validation studies | |
| Exact BP device used in the validation study is unclear | Confusion as to whether the BP device has undergone validation testing | |
| Unethical companies are selling cheap home BP devices online with false validation credentials | Consumers may favour purchase of cheap products, and this could have particular impact among people in lower income countries | |
| Consumer organizations do not give due attention to BP device accuracy | Inappropriate advice on best BP devices to use is promulgated to the general public |
BP, blood pressure.
Recommendations and required actions by key stakeholders for the global improvement of blood pressure device accuracy standards
| Recommendations | Key stakeholders to effect actions | Actions |
| Convergence towards the global regulatory requirement for mandatory independent validation of BP devices according to the universally accepted ISO Standard (ISO 81060-2:2018) with publication preferably in a peer reviewed journal | Government regulatory organizations (e.g. US Food and Drug Administration, European Database on Medical Devices, Australian Therapeutic Goods Administration) | Legislate for mandatory independent validation of BP devices according to the ISO Standard before approval for sale Stipulate that validation studies of BP devices are registered in an accepted repository before approval for sale Regulate enforcement of the ISO Standard Monitor compliance with the ISO Standard Support efforts of the WHO to implement WHA resolutions to ensure effective use and strengthened regulatory systems for BP devices |
| Nongovernment organizations (e.g. hypertension societies, cardiovascular advocacy groups) | Develop repositories for the registration of BP device validation studies conducted around the world (similar concept to ClinicalTrials.gov) Certify research facilities for performing BP device validation studies Advocate and lobby to legislate for use of the ISO Standard Endorse the use of BP devices that have passed validation according to the ISO Standard Educate members on the importance of using BP devices that have passed the ISO Standard Educate patients on the importance of BP device accuracy and access to validated devices | |
| Researchers | Register BP device validation studies in an accepted repository Transfer knowledge on BP device accuracy for the benefit of the wider scientific, clinical and general community | |
| Health professionals | Only use validated BP devices in clinical practice Ensure ongoing accuracy of BP devices used in clinical practice by undertaking maintenance checks according to the manufacturer's instructions Educate patients to only use validated BP devices for self-home monitoring | |
| Peer reviewed journals | Only accept articles in which BP has been measured using devices that have passed validation according to the ISO Standard | |
| Manufacturers | Evaluate the accuracy of BP devices using the ISO Standard through independent researchers Publish results of validation testing on company websites Use a specific common identifier for each BP device that may be sold by distributors under different names Provide instructions to purchasers on the process for regular maintenance of the specific device purchased | |
| Consumers | Only purchase BP devices that have passed validation Ensure ongoing accuracy of BP device by undertaking regular maintenance according to the manufacturer's instructions Only purchase BP devices when accuracy can be confirmed through accredited online lists | |
| Development of specific standards for the validation of new BP measuring technologies that cannot be tested using the ISO Standard (ISO 81060-2:2019) | Nongovernment organizations | Develop international standards specifically for new BP measuring technologies that cannot be tested using the current ISO Standards Endorse the use of international standards for new BP measuring technologies |
| Government organizations | Legislate for mandatory independent validation of new BP devices according to the ISO Standard (developed by nongovernment organizations) before approval for sale Regulate enforcement of the international standards Monitor compliance with the international standards | |
| Researchers and biomedical engineers | Participate in the development of international standards for new BP measuring technologies Develop new technologies to accurately measure BP Conduct research to determine the ability of new BP technologies to enhance clinical care | |
| Health professionals | Avoid using new BP measuring technologies until proven to enhance clinical care | |
| Accredited online lists of BP devices detailing the published results of the validation studies | Government and nongovernment organizations | Endorse and promote accredited online lists of BP devices Develop and maintain one universally accepted accredited list of BP devices Promote access to the accredited online lists of BP devices through the WHO Essential Medicines and Health Products Program |
| Researchers | Participate in expert advisory groups to oversee the scientific credibility of accredited online lists of BP devices |
BP, blood pressure; ISO, International Organization for Standardization.
aWHA, World Health Assembly resolutions WHA60.29 and WHA67.20 https://www.who.int/healthsystems/WHA60_29.pdf and http://apps.who.int/gb/ebwha/pdf_files/WHA67/A67_R20-en.pdf.
bCurrent online lists of BP devices and validation information can be found at https://bihsoc.org/bp-monitors/, https://hypertension.ca/hypertension-and-you/managing-hypertension/measuring-blood-pressure/devices/ https://medaval.ie/device-category/blood-pressure-monitors/ and https://stridebp.org/.
cWHO Essential Medicines and Health Products Program https://www.who.int/medicines/about/en/.
dPAHO, Pan American Health Organisation, Strategic Fund https://www.paho.org/hq/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=12167:faqs-strategic-fund&Itemid=1694&lang=en#1.