BACKGROUND: Exercise is recommended for weight management, yet exercise produces less weight loss than expected, which is called weight compensation. The mechanisms for weight compensation are unclear. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to identify the mechanisms responsible for compensation. METHODS: In a randomized controlled trial conducted at an academic research center, adults (n = 198) with overweight or obesity were randomized for 24 wk to a no-exercise control group or 1 of 2 supervised exercise groups: 8 kcal/kg of body weight/wk (KKW) or 20 KKW. Outcome assessment occurred at weeks 0 and 24. Energy intake, activity, and resting metabolic rate (RMR) were measured with doubly labeled water (DLW; with and without adjustments for change in RMR), armband accelerometers, and indirect calorimetry, respectively. Appetite and compensatory health beliefs were measured by self-report. RESULTS: A per-protocol analysis included 171 participants (72.5% women; mean ±SD baseline body mass index: 31.5 ± 4.7 kg/m2). Significant (P < 0.01) compensation occurred in the 8 KKW (mean: 1.5 kg; 95% CI: 0.9, 2.2 kg) and 20 KKW (mean: 2.7 kg; 95% CI: 2.0, 3.5 kg) groups, and compensation differed significantly between the exercise groups (P = 0.01). Energy intake by adjusted DLW increased significantly (P < 0.05) in the 8 KKW (mean: 90.7 kcal/d; 95% CI: 35.1, 146.4 kcal/d) and 20 KKW (mean: 123.6 kcal/d; 95% CI: 64.5, 182.7 kcal/d) groups compared with control (mean: -2.3 kcal/d; 95% CI: -58.0, 53.5 kcal/d). Results were similar without DLW adjustment. RMR and physical activity (excluding structured exercise) did not differentially change among the 3 groups. Participants with higher compared with lower compensation reported increased appetite ratings and beliefs that healthy behaviors can compensate for unhealthy behaviors. Furthermore, they increased craving for sweet foods, increased sleep disturbance, and had worsening bodily pain. CONCLUSIONS: Compensation resulted from increased energy intake and concomitant increases in appetite, which can be treated with dietary or pharmacological interventions. Compensation was not due to activity or metabolic changes. This trial was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT01264406.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: Exercise is recommended for weight management, yet exercise produces less weight loss than expected, which is called weight compensation. The mechanisms for weight compensation are unclear. OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to identify the mechanisms responsible for compensation. METHODS: In a randomized controlled trial conducted at an academic research center, adults (n = 198) with overweight or obesity were randomized for 24 wk to a no-exercise control group or 1 of 2 supervised exercise groups: 8 kcal/kg of body weight/wk (KKW) or 20 KKW. Outcome assessment occurred at weeks 0 and 24. Energy intake, activity, and resting metabolic rate (RMR) were measured with doubly labeled water (DLW; with and without adjustments for change in RMR), armband accelerometers, and indirect calorimetry, respectively. Appetite and compensatory health beliefs were measured by self-report. RESULTS: A per-protocol analysis included 171 participants (72.5% women; mean ± SD baseline body mass index: 31.5 ± 4.7 kg/m2). Significant (P < 0.01) compensation occurred in the 8 KKW (mean: 1.5 kg; 95% CI: 0.9, 2.2 kg) and 20 KKW (mean: 2.7 kg; 95% CI: 2.0, 3.5 kg) groups, and compensation differed significantly between the exercise groups (P = 0.01). Energy intake by adjusted DLW increased significantly (P < 0.05) in the 8 KKW (mean: 90.7 kcal/d; 95% CI: 35.1, 146.4 kcal/d) and 20 KKW (mean: 123.6 kcal/d; 95% CI: 64.5, 182.7 kcal/d) groups compared with control (mean: -2.3 kcal/d; 95% CI: -58.0, 53.5 kcal/d). Results were similar without DLW adjustment. RMR and physical activity (excluding structured exercise) did not differentially change among the 3 groups. Participants with higher compared with lower compensation reported increased appetite ratings and beliefs that healthy behaviors can compensate for unhealthy behaviors. Furthermore, they increased craving for sweet foods, increased sleep disturbance, and had worsening bodily pain. CONCLUSIONS: Compensation resulted from increased energy intake and concomitant increases in appetite, which can be treated with dietary or pharmacological interventions. Compensation was not due to activity or metabolic changes. This trial was registered at clinicaltrials.gov as NCT01264406.
Authors: Joseph E Donnelly; James O Hill; Dennis J Jacobsen; Jeffrey Potteiger; Debra K Sullivan; Susan L Johnson; Kate Heelan; Mary Hise; Paul V Fennessey; Bakary Sonko; Teresa Sharp; John M Jakicic; Steven N Blair; Zung V Tran; Matthew Mayo; Cheryl Gibson; Richard A Washburn Journal: Arch Intern Med Date: 2003-06-09
Authors: Emily Qualls-Creekmore; Kara L Marlatt; Esther Aarts; Annadora Bruce-Keller; Tim S Church; Karine Clément; Jennifer O Fisher; Penny Gordon-Larsen; Christopher D Morrison; Helen E Raybould; Donna H Ryan; Philip R Schauer; Alan C Spector; Maartje S Spetter; Garret D Stuber; Hans-Rudolf Berthoud; Eric Ravussin Journal: Obesity (Silver Spring) Date: 2020-06-10 Impact factor: 5.002
Authors: S Nicole Fearnbach; Neil M Johannsen; Candice A Myers; John W Apolzan; William D Johnson; Conrad P Earnest; Jennifer C Rood; Catrine Tudor-Locke; Melissa N Harris; Timothy S Church; Corby K Martin Journal: J Appl Physiol (1985) Date: 2020-07-16
Authors: Rebecca J Crochiere; Stephanie G Kerrigan; Elizabeth W Lampe; Stephanie M Manasse; Ross D Crosby; Meghan L Butryn; Evan M Forman Journal: Health Psychol Date: 2020-01-09 Impact factor: 4.267
Authors: Nicholas T Broskey; Corby K Martin; Jeffrey H Burton; Timothy S Church; Eric Ravussin; Leanne M Redman Journal: Med Sci Sports Exerc Date: 2021-10-01
Authors: Lauren T Ptomey; Robert N Montgomery; Anna M Gorczyca; Amanda N Szabo-Reed; Debra K Sullivan; Mary Hastert; Rachel Ns Foster; Richard A Washburn; Joseph E Donnelly Journal: Br J Nutr Date: 2022-03-07 Impact factor: 4.125
Authors: Christoph Höchsmann; James L Dorling; John W Apolzan; Neil M Johannsen; Daniel S Hsia; Corby K Martin Journal: Obesity (Silver Spring) Date: 2020-03-06 Impact factor: 5.002
Authors: Jennifer M Blankenship; Rebecca C Rosenberg; Corey A Rynders; Edward L Melanson; Victoria A Catenacci; Seth A Creasy Journal: Int J Sports Med Date: 2021-05-25 Impact factor: 2.997
Authors: James L Dorling; Christoph Höchsmann; S Nicole Fearnbach; John W Apolzan; Daniel S Hsia; Neil M Johannsen; Tim S Church; Corby K Martin Journal: Med Sci Sports Exerc Date: 2021-08-01