Sarah A Holstein1, Vera J Suman2, Philip L McCarthy3. 1. Department of Internal Medicine, Division of Oncology and Hematology, University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, NE, USA. 2. Department of Health Sciences Research, Division of Biomedical Statistics and Informatics, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN, USA. 3. Department of Medicine, Blood and Marrow Transplant Center, Transplant and Cellular Therapy Program, Roswell Park Comprehensive Cancer Center, Buffalo, NY, USA. philip.mccarthy@roswellpark.org.
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: While the traditional gold standard for demonstrating clinical benefit of a therapy has been to show prolongation of overall survival (OS), there are multiple factors which can hinder the use of OS as a primary endpoint in randomized clinical trials (RCTs). Here, we analyze recent myeloma RCTs and evaluate the issues relevant to current and future myeloma RCT design. RECENT FINDINGS: A review of recent phase III RCTs that led to approval of new agents/combinations reveals that none were designed with OS as the primary endpoint, but instead utilized time to progression (TTP) or progression-free survival (PFS). These studies illuminate the inherent difficulties of designing trials with the primary endpoint of OS/PFS in a disease characterized by increasingly prolonged survival times, availability of effective salvage therapies, and competing events such as co-morbid conditions. Alternative primary endpoints other than OS or PFS need to be developed for future myeloma RCTs. Validated surrogate endpoints with novel clinical trial designs will help improve the feasibility of conducting comparative clinical trials in a timely manner.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: While the traditional gold standard for demonstrating clinical benefit of a therapy has been to show prolongation of overall survival (OS), there are multiple factors which can hinder the use of OS as a primary endpoint in randomized clinical trials (RCTs). Here, we analyze recent myeloma RCTs and evaluate the issues relevant to current and future myeloma RCT design. RECENT FINDINGS: A review of recent phase III RCTs that led to approval of new agents/combinations reveals that none were designed with OS as the primary endpoint, but instead utilized time to progression (TTP) or progression-free survival (PFS). These studies illuminate the inherent difficulties of designing trials with the primary endpoint of OS/PFS in a disease characterized by increasingly prolonged survival times, availability of effective salvage therapies, and competing events such as co-morbid conditions. Alternative primary endpoints other than OS or PFS need to be developed for future myeloma RCTs. Validated surrogate endpoints with novel clinical trial designs will help improve the feasibility of conducting comparative clinical trials in a timely manner.
Authors: Sagar Lonial; Meletios Dimopoulos; Antonio Palumbo; Darrell White; Sebastian Grosicki; Ivan Spicka; Adam Walter-Croneck; Philippe Moreau; Maria-Victoria Mateos; Hila Magen; Andrew Belch; Donna Reece; Meral Beksac; Andrew Spencer; Heather Oakervee; Robert Z Orlowski; Masafumi Taniwaki; Christoph Röllig; Hermann Einsele; Ka Lung Wu; Anil Singhal; Jesus San-Miguel; Morio Matsumoto; Jessica Katz; Eric Bleickardt; Valerie Poulart; Kenneth C Anderson; Paul Richardson Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2015-06-02 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Meletios A Dimopoulos; Albert Oriol; Hareth Nahi; Jesus San-Miguel; Nizar J Bahlis; Saad Z Usmani; Neil Rabin; Robert Z Orlowski; Mieczyslaw Komarnicki; Kenshi Suzuki; Torben Plesner; Sung-Soo Yoon; Dina Ben Yehuda; Paul G Richardson; Hartmut Goldschmidt; Donna Reece; Steen Lisby; Nushmia Z Khokhar; Lisa O'Rourke; Christopher Chiu; Xiang Qin; Mary Guckert; Tahamtan Ahmadi; Philippe Moreau Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2016-10-06 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Antonio Palumbo; Asher Chanan-Khan; Katja Weisel; Ajay K Nooka; Tamas Masszi; Meral Beksac; Ivan Spicka; Vania Hungria; Markus Munder; Maria V Mateos; Tomer M Mark; Ming Qi; Jordan Schecter; Himal Amin; Xiang Qin; William Deraedt; Tahamtan Ahmadi; Andrew Spencer; Pieter Sonneveld Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2016-08-25 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Michel Attal; Valerie Lauwers-Cances; Cyrille Hulin; Xavier Leleu; Denis Caillot; Martine Escoffre; Bertrand Arnulf; Margaret Macro; Karim Belhadj; Laurent Garderet; Murielle Roussel; Catherine Payen; Claire Mathiot; Jean P Fermand; Nathalie Meuleman; Sandrine Rollet; Michelle E Maglio; Andrea A Zeytoonjian; Edie A Weller; Nikhil Munshi; Kenneth C Anderson; Paul G Richardson; Thierry Facon; Hervé Avet-Loiseau; Jean-Luc Harousseau; Philippe Moreau Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2017-04-06 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Jesús F San-Miguel; Vânia T M Hungria; Sung-Soo Yoon; Meral Beksac; Meletios Athanasios Dimopoulos; Ashraf Elghandour; Wieslaw Wiktor Jedrzejczak; Andreas Günther; Thanyaphong Na Nakorn; Noppadol Siritanaratkul; Paolo Corradini; Suporn Chuncharunee; Je-Jung Lee; Robert L Schlossman; Tatiana Shelekhova; Kwee Yong; Daryl Tan; Tontanai Numbenjapon; Jamie D Cavenagh; Jian Hou; Richard LeBlanc; Hareth Nahi; Lugui Qiu; Hans Salwender; Stefano Pulini; Philippe Moreau; Krzysztof Warzocha; Darrell White; Joan Bladé; WenMing Chen; Javier de la Rubia; Peter Gimsing; Sagar Lonial; Jonathan L Kaufman; Enrique M Ocio; Ljupco Veskovski; Sang Kyun Sohn; Ming-Chung Wang; Jae Hoon Lee; Hermann Einsele; Monika Sopala; Claudia Corrado; Bourras-Rezki Bengoudifa; Florence Binlich; Paul G Richardson Journal: Lancet Oncol Date: 2014-09-18 Impact factor: 41.316
Authors: Philippe Moreau; Tamás Masszi; Norbert Grzasko; Nizar J Bahlis; Markus Hansson; Ludek Pour; Irwindeep Sandhu; Peter Ganly; Bartrum W Baker; Sharon R Jackson; Anne-Marie Stoppa; David R Simpson; Peter Gimsing; Antonio Palumbo; Laurent Garderet; Michele Cavo; Shaji Kumar; Cyrille Touzeau; Francis K Buadi; Jacob P Laubach; Deborah T Berg; Jianchang Lin; Alessandra Di Bacco; Ai-Min Hui; Helgi van de Velde; Paul G Richardson Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2016-04-28 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Nikhil C Munshi; Herve Avet-Loiseau; Andy C Rawstron; Roger G Owen; J Anthony Child; Anjan Thakurta; Paul Sherrington; Mehmet Kemal Samur; Anna Georgieva; Kenneth C Anderson; Walter M Gregory Journal: JAMA Oncol Date: 2017-01-01 Impact factor: 31.777
Authors: Shaji Kumar; Lawrence Baizer; Natalie S Callander; Sergio A Giralt; Jens Hillengass; Boris Freidlin; Antje Hoering; Paul G Richardson; Elena I Schwartz; Anthony Reiman; Suzanne Lentzsch; Philip L McCarthy; Sundar Jagannath; Andrew J Yee; Richard F Little; Noopur S Raje Journal: Blood Cancer J Date: 2022-06-29 Impact factor: 9.812
Authors: Patrick Daniele; Carla Mamolo; Joseph C Cappelleri; Timothy Bell; Alexander Neuhof; Gabriel Tremblay; Mihaela Musat; Anna Forsythe Journal: PLoS One Date: 2022-05-12 Impact factor: 3.752