| Literature DB >> 30466427 |
Diantha Soemantri1, Geoff Mccoll2, Agnes Dodds3.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Reflection on learning is an essential component of effective learning. Deconstructing the components of reflection on learning using a self-regulated learning (SRL) framework, allows the assessment of students' ability to reflect on their learning. The aim of this study was to validate an instrument to measure medical students' reflection on their learning.Entities:
Keywords: Instrument; MSLQ; Medical students; Reflection on learning
Mesh:
Year: 2018 PMID: 30466427 PMCID: PMC6251170 DOI: 10.1186/s12909-018-1384-y
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Med Educ ISSN: 1472-6920 Impact factor: 2.463
Fig. 1Flowchart of the inclusion/exclusion process for articles retrieved from PubMed
Fig. 2Flowchart of the inclusion/exclusion process for articles retrieved from ERIC
Modifications of MSLQ selected items
| Original item | Modified item |
|---|---|
| When a theory, interpretation, or conclusion is presented in class or in the readings, I try to decide if there is good supporting evidence | When a theory, interpretation, or conclusion is presented in |
| Whenever I read or hear an assertion or conclusion in this class, I think about possible alternatives | Whenever I read or hear an assertion or conclusion in this |
| Even if I have trouble learning the material in this class I try to do the work on my own, without help from anyone | Even if I have trouble learning the material in this |
| I ask the instructor to clarify concepts I don’t understand well | I ask the |
| When I can’t understand the material in this course, I ask another student in this class for help | When I can’t understand the material in this course, I ask another student in this |
| I try to identify students in this class whom I can ask for help if necessary | I try to identify students in this |
| During class time I often miss important points because I’m thinking of other things | During |
| When I become confused about something I’m reading for this class, I go back and try to figure it out | When I become confused about something I’m reading for this |
| If course readings are difficult to understand, I change the way I read the material |
|
| I ask myself questions to make sure I understand the material I have been studying in this class | I ask myself questions to make sure I understand the material I have been studying in this |
| I try to change the way I study in order to fit the course requirements and the instructor’s teaching style | I try to change the way I study in order to fit the course requirements |
| I often find that I have been reading for this class but don’t know what it was all about |
|
| When I study for this class, I set goals for myself in order to direct my activities in each study period | When I study for this |
| If I get confused taking notes in class, I make sure I sort it out afterwards | If I get confused taking notes |
| I believe I will receive an excellent grade in this class | I believe I will receive an excellent grade in this |
| I’m certain I can understand the most difficult material presented in the readings for the course | I’m certain I can understand the most difficult material presented in the |
| I’m confident I can understand the most complex material presented by the instructor in this course | I’m confident I can understand the most complex material presented by the |
| I expect to do well in this class | I expect to do well in this |
| I’m certain I can master the skills being taught in this class | I’m certain I can master the skills being taught in this |
| Considering the difficulty of this course, the teacher, and my skills, I think I will do well in this class | Considering the difficulty of this course, the teacher, and my skills, I think I will do well in this |
| In a class like this, I prefer course material that really challenges me so I can learn new things. | In a |
| In a class like this, I prefer course material that arouses my curiosity, even if it is difficult to learn. | In a |
| When I have the opportunity in this class, I choose course assignments that I can learn from even if they don’t guarantee a good grade. |
|
Sentences or words in italic were the modifications
34-item modified MSLQ subscales, items distribution and reliability coefficient for each subscale
| Subscale | Item | Alpha (internal consistency) coefficient | Guttman split-half reliability coefficient | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MD ( | MBBS ( | MD (n = 306) | MBBS (n = 248) | ||
| Internal goal orientation | 1,6,9,20 | .541 | .609 | .426 | .479 |
| Self-efficacy | 5,10,18,21,26,30,34 | .908 | .827 | .899 | .856 |
| Critical thinking | 3,8,17,25,29 | .693 | .735 | .703 | .709 |
| Self-regulation | 2,4,7,12,14,19,23,24,28,31,33 | .756 | .777 | .716 | .698 |
| Help seeking | 13,15,22,27 | .476 | .361 | .386 | .189 |
| Peer learning | 11,16,32 | .665 | .605 | .622 | .565 |
Summary of principal component analysis with direct oblimin rotation for the 34-item modified MSLQ on combined MD and MBBS groups (n = 554)
| Item | Pattern matrix | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SR | SO | CT | FS | ||
| 7 | When I become confused about something I’m reading for this course, I go back and try to sort it out | .742 | −.055 | −.045 | .027 |
| 2 | When studying for this course, I try to determine which concepts I don’t understand well | .677 | .016 | .020 | −.022 |
| 15 | Even if I have trouble learning the material in this course I try to work things out for myself | −.630 | .129 | .056 | .058 |
| 6 | The most satisfying thing for me in this course is reaching an understanding of the content as thoroughly as possible | .590 | −.067 | .025 | .003 |
| 19 | If I get confused taking notes or learning clinical skills in the course, I make sure I sort it out afterwards | .573 | −.146 | −.119 | .174 |
| 31 | When studying for this course, I try to think through a topic and decide what I am supposed to learn from it rather than just reading it over | .438 | −.049 | .185 | .233 |
| 1 | In this course, I am more interested in understanding the material than getting a good grade | .358 | .083 | .295 | −.152 |
| 23 | If course materials are difficult to understand, I read them in a different way | .336 | −.042 | .257 | .192 |
| 14 | Before I study new course material thoroughly, I often skim it to see how it is organized | .310 | .191 | .291 | .164 |
| 10 | I’m confident I can do well on the assessment in this course | −.092 | −.837 | .020 | .085 |
| 21 | I believe I will receive an excellent grade in this course | −.193 | −.822 | .057 | .117 |
| 34 | I expect to do well in this course | .014 | −.783 | −.112 | .133 |
| 26 | I’m confident I can understand the most complex material presented by the teachers in this course | .062 | −.752 | .181 | −.089 |
| 30 | I’m certain I can master the skills being taught in this course | .220 | −.691 | −.033 | −.015 |
| 5 | I’m confident I understand the most difficult learning material presented in this course | .063 | −.653 | .167 | −.053 |
| 18 | I’m confident I can learn the basic concepts taught in this course | .403 | −.525 | −.131 | −.048 |
| 20 | In a course like this, I prefer material that really challenges me so I can learn new things | .095 | −.421 | .385 | −.049 |
| 9 | In a course like this, I prefer material that arouses my curiosity, even if it is difficult to learn | .115 | −.350 | .327 | −.128 |
| 17 | When a theory, interpretation, or conclusion is presented in the course, I try to find if there is good supporting evidence | −.126 | .009 | .693 | .109 |
| 29 | Whenever I read or hear an assertion or conclusion in this course, I think about possible alternatives | −.045 | −.146 | .691 | .035 |
| 25 | I try to play around with ideas of my own related to what I am learning in this course | −.047 | −.173 | .634 | .093 |
| 3 | I often find myself questioning things I hear or read in this course to decide if I find them convincing | .041 | −.035 | .581 | −.107 |
| 8 | I treat the learning material as a starting point and try to develop my own ideas about it | .217 | −.093 | .514 | −.069 |
| 24 | When reading for this course, I generate questions to help focus my reading | .077 | .025 | .563 | .335 |
| 32 | I try to work with other students from this course to complete the course assignments | −.089 | −.015 | −.065 | .764 |
| 22 | When I can’t understand the material in this course, I ask another student in this course for help | .145 | .002 | −.129 | .671 |
| 27 | I try to identify students in this course whom I can ask for help if necessary | −.019 | −.037 | −.049 | .660 |
| 16 | When studying for this course, I often set aside time to discuss course material with a group | −.150 | .019 | .134 | .636 |
| 33 | When I study for this course, I set goals for myself in order to direct my activities in each study period | .309 | −.045 | .028 | .423 |
| 11 | When studying for this course, I often try to explain the material to a classmate or a friend | −.072 | −.238 | .173 | .418 |
| 12 | I ask myself questions to make sure I understand the material I have been studying in this course | .185 | .006 | .371 | .395 |
| 28 | I try to change the way I study in order to fit the course requirements | .291 | .055 | −.088 | .407 |
| 4 | During teaching sessions I often miss important points because I’m thinking of other things | .141 | −.227 | −.238 | .014 |
| 13 | I ask the teacher to clarify concepts which I don’t understand well | .089 | .007 | .206 | .289 |
| Eigenvalues | 7.415 | 3.071 | 2.323 | 1.963 | |
| % of variance | 21.810 | 9.034 | 6.832 | 5.772 | |
SR self-regulation, SO self-orientation, CT critical thinking, FS feedback seeking
Subscales and items of 32-item modified MSLQ following factor analysis of the MD and MBBS student group results (n = 554)
| Item | Factor/component | Alpha (internal consistency) coefficient | Guttman split-half reliability |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5, 9, 10, 18, 20, 21, 26, 30, 34 | Self-orientation (SO) | .874 | .847 |
| 11, 16, 22, 27, 32 | Feedback seeking (FS) | .731 | .740 |
| 3, 8, 12, 17, 24, 25, 29 | Critical thinking (CT) | .775 | .768 |
| 1, 2, 6, 7, 14, 15, 19, 23, 28, 31, 33 | Self-regulation (SR) | .666 | .622 |
Inter-correlations of Modified MSLQ scores and Four Subscales, for 554 Medical Students
| Modified MSLQ | Self Orientation | Feedback | Critical Thinking | Self-regulation | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Modified MSLQ | – | .75 | .59 | .74 | .78 |
| Self Orientation | .75 | – | .24 | .38 | .39 |
| Feedback | .59 | .24 | – | .32 | .36 |
| Critical Thinking | .74 | .38 | .32 | – | .50 |
| Self-regulation | .78 | .39 | .36 | .50 | – |
Key: All correlations, p < .01