A Padolino1, G Porcellini1, B Guollo1, E Fabbri2, G N Kiran Kumar1, P Paladini1, G Merolla3,4. 1. Shoulder and Elbow Unit, Cervesi Hospital, Cattolica - AUSL della Romagna, Ambito Territoriale di Rimini, Cattolica, Italy. 2. Research and Innovation Department - AUSL della Romagna, Ambito Territoriale di Rimini, Rimini, Italy. 3. Shoulder and Elbow Unit, Cervesi Hospital, Cattolica - AUSL della Romagna, Ambito Territoriale di Rimini, Cattolica, Italy. giovannimerolla@hotmail.com. 4. Biomechanics Laboratory, Cervesi Hospital, Cattolica - AUSL della Romagna, Ambito Territoriale di Rimini, Cattolica, Italy. giovannimerolla@hotmail.com.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Metal plates are the fixation devices used most frequently to proximal humeral fractures (PHFs). However, in recent years carbon fiber-reinforced polyetheretherketone (CFR-PEEK) plates have become increasingly common. This study compares the clinical and radiographic outcomes of 42 Neer three- and four-part PHFs treated with CFR-PEEK or metal (titanium) plates. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Forty-two PHF patients were managed with CFR-PEEK plates (n = 21, males/females 9/12; mean age 57.4 years; mean follow-up 30.7 months; CFR-PEEK group) or metal plates (n = 21; males/females 7/14; mean age 55.8 years; mean follow-up 52.7 months; Metal group). Active shoulder mobility (anterior elevation, lateral elevation, external rotation, and internal rotation), the Constant-Murley Score, the Simple Shoulder Test Score, and the pain score were recorded. Preoperative computed tomography scans and X-rays were obtained. Postoperative fracture healing and displacement, tuberosity resorption and/or malposition, hardware position, and cortical thinning (CT) under the plate were assessed radiographically. RESULTS: Shoulder mobility, clinical, and pain scores were similar in both patient groups. CT was significantly greater in CFR-PEEK patients (mean difference, 1.14 mm; p = 0.0003). In both groups, incomplete or poor calcar reduction was associated to a significantly higher complication rate, especially stiffness and muscle weakness (p = 0.016). The rate of tuberosity resorption was significantly higher in the Metal group (p = 0.040). Two patients required revision to a hemiarthroplasty (CFR-PEEK) and reverse arthroplasty (Metal group). CONCLUSIONS: CFR-PEEK plates provide a viable alternative to conventional titanium plates in PHFs, ensuring similar clinical outcomes and a lower rate of tuberosity resorption, but they involve higher stress shielding under the plate.
BACKGROUND:Metal plates are the fixation devices used most frequently to proximal humeral fractures (PHFs). However, in recent years carbon fiber-reinforced polyetheretherketone (CFR-PEEK) plates have become increasingly common. This study compares the clinical and radiographic outcomes of 42 Neer three- and four-part PHFs treated with CFR-PEEK or metal (titanium) plates. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Forty-two PHF patients were managed with CFR-PEEK plates (n = 21, males/females 9/12; mean age 57.4 years; mean follow-up 30.7 months; CFR-PEEK group) or metal plates (n = 21; males/females 7/14; mean age 55.8 years; mean follow-up 52.7 months; Metal group). Active shoulder mobility (anterior elevation, lateral elevation, external rotation, and internal rotation), the Constant-Murley Score, the Simple Shoulder Test Score, and the pain score were recorded. Preoperative computed tomography scans and X-rays were obtained. Postoperative fracture healing and displacement, tuberosity resorption and/or malposition, hardware position, and cortical thinning (CT) under the plate were assessed radiographically. RESULTS: Shoulder mobility, clinical, and pain scores were similar in both patient groups. CT was significantly greater in CFR-PEEKpatients (mean difference, 1.14 mm; p = 0.0003). In both groups, incomplete or poor calcar reduction was associated to a significantly higher complication rate, especially stiffness and muscle weakness (p = 0.016). The rate of tuberosity resorption was significantly higher in the Metal group (p = 0.040). Two patients required revision to a hemiarthroplasty (CFR-PEEK) and reverse arthroplasty (Metal group). CONCLUSIONS: CFR-PEEK plates provide a viable alternative to conventional titanium plates in PHFs, ensuring similar clinical outcomes and a lower rate of tuberosity resorption, but they involve higher stress shielding under the plate.
Authors: Antti P Launonen; Vesa Lepola; Aino Saranko; Tapio Flinkkilä; Minna Laitinen; Ville M Mattila Journal: Arch Osteoporos Date: 2015-02-13 Impact factor: 2.617
Authors: Christian Spross; Nicola Kaestle; Emanuel Benninger; Jürgen Fornaro; Johannes Erhardt; Vilijam Zdravkovic; Bernhard Jost Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2015-04-25 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Nobuyuki Yamamoto; Michio Hongo; Lawrence J Berglund; John W Sperling; Robert H Cofield; Kai-Nan An; Scott P Steinmann Journal: J Shoulder Elbow Surg Date: 2012-06-26 Impact factor: 3.019
Authors: A Roux; L Decroocq; S El Batti; N Bonnevialle; G Moineau; C Trojani; P Boileau; F de Peretti Journal: Orthop Traumatol Surg Res Date: 2012-09-19 Impact factor: 2.256
Authors: Rony-Orijit Dey Hazra; Karol Szewczyk; Alexander Ellwein; Robert Blach; Gunnar Jensen; Andreas Kühnapfel; Helmut Lill; Mara Warnhoff Journal: Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol Date: 2022-05-27
Authors: George D Chloros; Apostolos D Prodromidis; Jo Wilson; Peter V Giannoudis Journal: Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg Date: 2021-09-06 Impact factor: 2.374