| Literature DB >> 29210981 |
Adele Houghton1, Carlos Castillo-Salgado2.
Abstract
Climate change is increasingly exacerbating existing population health hazards, as well as resulting in new negative health effects. Flooding is one particularly deadly example of its amplifying and expanding effect on public health. This systematic review considered evidence linking green building strategies in the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design® (LEED) Rating System with the potential to reduce negative health outcomes following exposure to urban flooding events. Queries evaluated links between LEED credit requirements and risk of exposure to urban flooding, environmental determinants of health, co-benefits to public health outcomes, and co-benefits to built environment outcomes. Public health co-benefits to leveraging green building design to enhance flooding resilience included: improving the interface between humans and wildlife and reducing the risk of waterborne disease, flood-related morbidity and mortality, and psychological harm. We conclude that collaborations among the public health, climate change, civil society, and green building sectors to enhance community resilience to urban flooding could benefit population health.Entities:
Keywords: climate change adaptation; climate change mitigation; sustainable communities; sustainable design; urban flood-related hazards
Mesh:
Year: 2017 PMID: 29210981 PMCID: PMC5750937 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph14121519
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Health-related prerequisites and credits in LEED version 2009 commercial rating systems by section.
| Sustainable Sites | Water Efficiency | Energy & Atmosphere | Materials & Resources | Indoor Environmental Quality | Innovation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HC-Avoid Mercury | Environmental Tobacco Smoke Control | ||||
| HC-Acoustics | |||||
| Brownfield Mitigation | Wastewater Reduction | HC-Emissions Limits | HC-Avoid PBTs | Ventilation | |
| HC-Places of Respite | Thermal Comfort | ||||
| HC-Exterior Access | Low-Emitting Materials | ||||
| Construction Indoor Air Quality | |||||
| Chemical & Pollutant Source Control | |||||
| Daylighting, Views | |||||
| Schools-Mold Prevention | |||||
| HC/Schools-Acoustics |
Abbreviations: HC: LEED for Healthcare; Schools: LEED for Schools.
Figure 1Conceptual framework: establishing an evidence base for associations between LEED credit requirements and climate change resilience outcomes.
Figure 2Flow chart of LEED credit inclusion criteria. a One or more primary or secondary impact may be designated under each adaptation strategy. b LEED prerequisites and credits may be listed under more than one adaptation strategy. Additionally, LEED for New Construction credits that are relevant to a strategy but not listed in the report were included in the assessment. PRISMA Flow Diagram adapted from Moher et al. (2009) [42].
Figure A2PRISMA Checklist.
Figure A1Flow Chart of Urban Flooding Literature Review Credit Inclusion Criteria. Note: PRISMA Flow Diagram adapted from Moher et al. (2009) [42].
LEED credits included in flooding resilience literature review.
| LEED Credit Title |
|---|
| * Sustainable Sites Credit 1: Site Selection |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 4.1: Alternative Transportation—Public Transportation Access |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 4.4: Alternative Transportation—Parking Capacity |
| * Sustainable Sites Credit 5.1: Site Development—Protect or Restore Habitat |
| * Sustainable Sites Credit 5.2: Site Development—Maximize Open Space |
| * Sustainable Sites Credit 6.1: Stormwater Design—Quantity Control |
| * Sustainable Sites Credit 6.2: Stormwater Design—Quality Control |
| * Sustainable Sites Credit 7.1: Heat Island Effect—Non-roof |
| * Sustainable Sites Credit 7.2: Heat Island Effect—Roof |
| Water Efficiency Credit 1: Water Efficient Landscaping |
| Water Efficiency Credit 2: Innovative Wastewater Technologies |
| Water Efficiency Credit 3: Water Use Reduction |
Note: * Evidence of contribution to both heat resilience and flooding resilience. Source: LEED Reference Guide for Green Building Design and Construction [26].
Association between LEED credits and community resilience to urban flooding events: A review of the evidence.
| LEED Credit | Requirements | MeSH Query Terms | Relevant Citations (Total Queried in PubMed and Farr Associates (2008) [ | How Strategy Impacts Risk of Exposure | Environmental Determinants of Health | Co-Benefits to Public Health Outcomes | Co-Benefits to Built Environment Outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sustainable Sites Credit 1: Site Selection | Avoid development in or adjacent to the following areas | ||||||
| Prime farmland [ | Agriculture | 5 (17) | Habitat fragmentation | Access to opportunities to exercise. | Reduced risk of flooding-related injury; under- and mal-nutrition; infectious disease; interface between wildlife and humans. | Reduced development in areas without services. | |
| Floodplain [ | Floods | 5 (7) | Flooding depth/damage ratio | Urban flooding. | Reduced risk of respiratory disease. | Severity of flooding mitigated. | |
| Endangered Species Habitat [ | Biodiversity | 4 (7) | Urban flooding | Exposure to biodiversity in urban environments. | Improved mental health and wellbeing. | Severity of flooding mitigated. | |
| Wetlands [ | Wetlands | 6 (52) | Drought/flooding cycle | Wetland restoration and maintenance. | Reduced risk of waterborne disease, respiratory disease, malaria, and population displacement. | Increased wildlife habitat, protection from flooding, carbon storage. | |
| Water Body [ | Cities | 9 (11) | Biodiversity | Water quality. | Reduced risk of flooding-related injury and mortality; waterborne disease; water scarcity; disruption to public services; population displacement. | Increased water efficiency; onsite stormwater capture, treatment, and storage; onsite wastewater treatment; aquifer recharge. | |
| Parkland [ | Biodiversity | 3 (4) | Land use changes | Habitat fragmentation. | Reduced risk of interface between wildlife and humans; waterborne disease. | Cluster development. | |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 4.1: Alternative Transportation—Public Transportation Access | Locate building on a site near public transit stops [ | Disasters | 14 (161) | Ability to evacuate | Physical and financial access to multiple modes of transportation during an evacuation (particularly to vulnerable populations). | Reduced risk factors for obesity (precondition of vulnerability to flooding). | High mix of land uses. |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 4.4: Alternative Transportation—Parking Capacity | Provide preferred parking or dedicated drop-off areas for carpools. No evidence for reducing total parking capacity [ | Disasters | 11 (149) | Ability to evacuate | Physical and financial access to multiple modes of transportation during an evacuation (particularly to vulnerable populations). | Reduced risk factors for obesity (precondition of vulnerability to flooding). | High mix of land uses. |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 5.1: Site Development—Protect or Restore Habitat | Limit habitat disturbance during construction or restore habitat [ | Floods | 11 (55) | Drought/flooding cycle | Percentage pervious cover in neighborhoods with vulnerable populations. | Reduced risk of flooding-related injury or mortality; waterborne disease; disruption to public services; population displacement; exposure to repeated flooding; combined sewer overflows; mental health problems; chemical toxins and physical hazards. | Reduced risk of property damage due to flooding. |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 5.2: Site Development—Maximize Open Space | Increase vegetated open space [ | Floods | 17 (107) | Drought/flooding cycle | Percentage pervious cover in neighborhoods with vulnerable populations. | Reduced risk of flooding-related injury or mortality; waterborne disease; malaria; disruption to public services; population displacement; exposure to repeated flooding; combined sewer overflows; mental health problems; chemical toxins and physical hazards. | Reduced risk of property damage due to flooding. |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 6.1: Stormwater Design—Quantity Control | Design the site to reduce the post-development peak discharge quantity after heavy precipitation events [ | Floods | 18 (112) | Drought/flooding cycle | River basin retention capacity. | Reduced risk of flooding-related injury or mortality; waterborne disease; exposure to repeated flooding; combined sewer overflows; chemical toxins and physical hazards. | Reduced risk of property damage due to flooding. |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 6.2: Stormwater Design—Quality Control | Design the site to remove pollution from stormwater runoff [ | Floods | 21 (164) | Compromised water and wastewater quality | Percentage pervious cover in neighborhoods with vulnerable populations. | Reduced risk of flooding-related injury or mortality; waterborne disease; malaria; disruption to public services; population displacement; exposure to repeated flooding; combined sewer overflows; mental health problems; chemical toxins and physical hazards. | Reduced risk of property damage due to flooding. |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 7.1: Heat Island Effect—Non-roof | Shade impervious surfaces on-site, install light-colored or pervious hardscape, or install covered parking [ | Floods | 11 (112) | Compromised water and wastewater quality | Percentage pervious cover in neighborhoods with vulnerable populations. | Reduced risk of flooding-related injury or mortality; waterborne disease; malaria; disruption to public services; population displacement; exposure to repeated flooding; combined sewer overflows; mental health problems; chemical toxins and physical hazards. | Reduced risk of property damage due to flooding. |
| Sustainable Sites Credit 7.2: Heat Island Effect—Roof | Install light colored roof or vegetated roof. [ | Climate Change | 3 (57) | Burden on wastewater system from stormwater runoff | Percentage pervious cover in neighborhoods with vulnerable populations. | Reduced risk of flooding-related injury or mortality; waterborne disease. | Reduced risk of property damage due to flooding. |
| Water Efficiency Credit 1: Water Efficient Landscaping | Reduce potable water consumption for irrigation [ | Biodiversity | 11 (15) | Biodiversity | Exposure to biodiversity in urban environments. | Reduced risk of waterborne disease; interface between wildlife and humans. | Increased onsite wastewater and stormwater treatment and storage. |
| Water Efficiency Credit 2: Innovative Wastewater Technologies | Reduce potable water use for building sewage conveyance [ | Cities | 6 (6) | Burden on wastewater system and waterways from stormwater runoff | Water quality. | Reduced risk of flooding-related illness, waterborne disease, water scarcity; Improved mental health and wellbeing. | Increased water efficiency; onsite water capture and treatment; recharge aquifer. |
| Water Efficiency Credit 3: Water Use Reduction | Reduce potable water consumption inside the building [ | Cities | 4 (4) | Biodiversity | Water Quality. | Reduced risk of flooding-related illness, waterborne disease, water scarcity; Improved mental health and wellbeing. | Increased water efficiency, onsite water capture and treatment, recharge aquifer. |