| Literature DB >> 28648780 |
Valentin Flury1, Paula Raluca Georgescu2, Vytautas Iesmantavicius1, Yukiko Shimada1, Tahsin Kuzdere3, Sigurd Braun4, Marc Bühler5.
Abstract
Faithful propagation of functionally distinct chromatin states is crucial for maintaining cellular identity, and its breakdown can lead to diseases such as cancer. Whereas mechanisms that sustain repressed states have been intensely studied, regulatory circuits that protect active chromatin from inactivating signals are not well understood. Here we report a positive feedback loop that preserves the transcription-competent state of RNA polymerase II-transcribed genes. We found that Pdp3 recruits the histone acetyltransferase Mst2 to H3K36me3-marked chromatin. Thereby, Mst2 binds to all transcriptionally active regions genome-wide. Besides acetylating histone H3K14, Mst2 also acetylates Brl1, a component of the histone H2B ubiquitin ligase complex. Brl1 acetylation increases histone H2B ubiquitination, which positively feeds back on transcription and prevents ectopic heterochromatin assembly. Our work uncovers a molecular pathway that secures epigenome integrity and highlights the importance of opposing feedback loops for the partitioning of chromatin into transcriptionally active and inactive states.Entities:
Keywords: Brl1/BRE1; Gcn5; H2B ubiquitin; H3K36me3; Mst2; RNA interference; acetylomics; epigenetic gene silencing; heterochromatin; histone modification
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2017 PMID: 28648780 PMCID: PMC5526834 DOI: 10.1016/j.molcel.2017.05.026
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Mol Cell ISSN: 1097-2765 Impact factor: 17.970
Figure 1Mst2 Counteracts siRNA-Directed De Novo Heterochromatin Assembly
(A) Scheme: de novo silencing in trans by siRNAs from a hairpin RNA-producing locus is repressed by Paf1C and other protein complexes.
(B) Experimental setup: white (expressed) or red (silenced) colonies were selected, and their descendants were analyzed for initiation and maintenance of the silenced state, respectively.
(C) Descendants were categorized by color, and the percentage of colonies containing non-white (red) cells was calculated. The p value was calculated using the two-sided, two-sample Student’s t test (n ≥ 3 individual white colonies). Exact numbers are listed in the STAR Methods.
(D) Silencing assays were performed with indicated mutant strains to illustrate the difference between initiation and maintenance of silencing. A representative experiment is shown. Note that quantification shown in (C) was not based on this assay, because individual colonies cannot be clearly distinguished. For (C) and (D), see the STAR Methods for details.
Figure 2Large Heterochromatin Domains Form upon Removal of mst2
(A) Upper panel: ChIP analysis of H3K9me2 showing enrichments at the target gene ade6-704 and neighboring regions. Error bars indicate SD (n ≥ 3 independent biological replicates). The y axis is shown in logarithmic scale. Middle and lower panels: siRNAs (middle panel) and RNA (lower panel) reads mapping to the ade6-M210 locus and neighboring regions in wild-type (gray), paf1-Q264Stop (red), and paf1-Q264Stop mst2Δ cells (blue), respectively, are shown. Read counts were normalized to the total read number and are depicted in log2 (middle panel) or linear scale (lower panel).
(B) H3K9me2 enrichments at the right centromere boundary of chromosome 1 (IRC1R). ChIP enrichments are shown relative to the centromeric repeats dg/dh, which was set at 100%. Error bars indicate SD (n = 2 or 3 independent biological replicates; mst2Δ ago1Δ and mst2Δ dcr1Δ or wild-type (WT) and mst2Δ, respectively).
(C) siRNAs mapping to IRC1R and neighboring regions in wild-type (gray), paf1-Q264Stop (red), and paf1-Q264Stop mst2Δ cells (blue). Read counts were normalized to the total read number and are depicted in log2 scale.
See also Figure S1.
Figure 3Mst2 Is Excluded from Constitutive Heterochromatin and Specifically Associates with Transcriptionally Active Chromatin
(A) Mst2 DamID maps for all three chromosomes (bottom) compared to previously generated H3K9me2 ChIP-sequencing data (top; Keller et al., 2013). The signal of Dam-Mst2 (normalized to Dam only) was averaged over 500 probes and is shown in log2 scale. The x axis shows position on chromosomes.
(B) Enrichment of Dam-Mst2 at different genomic regions. Two independent replicates are shown (scale in log2).
(C) Zoom of DamID map from (A) on centromere of chromosome 1.
(D) Enrichment of Dam-Mst2 at different euchromatic elements. Two independent replicates are shown (scale in log2).
(E and F) ChIP enrichment of Mst2-FLAG (blue) compared to untagged Mst2 (black) over the mto1/tef3 locus (E) and the ade6-704 locus (F). ChIP data are shown relative to the mean of the untagged control with the background subtracted (n = 4 ± SEM).
Figure 4Pdp3 Anchors the Mst2 Complex to Euchromatin via H3K36me3
(A) Scheme of the Mst2 complex and protein domain organization of Pdp3.
(B and C) Correlation between enrichment of Dam-Mst2 and ChIP-on-chip data of H3K36me3 in wild-type (B) and pdp3Δ cells (C). Two independent biological replicates are shown (in log2 scale). ChIP-on-chip data are from Wilhelm et al. (2011).
(D and E) ChIP enrichment of Mst2-FLAG in WT (blue) or pdp3Δ (red) cells compared to an untagged wild-type strain (black) at the mto1/tef3 locus (D) or the ade6-704 locus (E).
(F) ChIP enrichment of FLAG-Pdp3 (blue) or FLAG-Pdp3 mutant (pdp3-F109A, red) compared to untagged wild-type strain (black) at the mto1/tef3 locus.
(G) ChIP of Mst2-FLAG in WT (blue), set2Δ (purple), and set2-SRIΔ (green) cells at the ade6-704 locus.
(H) ChIP of H3K36me3 in WT (orange), set2Δ (purple), and set2-SRIΔ (green) cells at the ade6-704 locus. ChIP data in (D)–(G) are shown relative to the mean of the untagged control with the background subtracted; ChIP data in (H) are shown relative to the mean of WT over the entire chromatin region examined. All ChIP experiments have been performed with n = 3–4 ± SEM.
(I) Initiation frequencies in paf1-Q264Stop cells additionally deleted for mst2, pdp3, or set2 as in Figure 1D. The p values were calculated using the two-sided, two-sample Student’s t test (n ≥ 4 independent white colonies). Exact numbers are listed in the STAR Methods.
Figure 5Promiscuous Mst2 Activity in the Absence of Pdp3 Attenuates Heterochromatin Silencing
(A) Mst2 DamID maps for the centromere of chromosome 1 in WT, pdp3Δ, and set2Δ cells. The signal of DamMst2 (normalized to Dam only) was averaged over 500 probes and is shown in log2 scale. The x axis shows position on chromosomes.
(B and D) RNA expression in WT, pdp3Δ, and mst2Δ cells at centromere 1 (B) and telomere 1L (D) assessed by RNA-seq. Relative read counts normalized to total read number (axis scale in log2) are shown.
(C) Relative RNA expression levels of ura4 (qRT-PCR analysis) at the innermost repeat (imr) in indicated mutants. Shown are the transcript levels relative to WT after normalization to act1. Data are represented as mean ± SEM from four independent biological experiments.
(E) Scheme of experimental setup for tethering Mst2 at heterochromatin: Four LexA-binding sites were inserted downstream of the ade6 reporter at the outermost repeat (otr) of chromosome 1 (top). The ade6-M210 allele at the euchromatic endogenous locus of ade6 (bottom) was used as a reference.
(F–H) Expression levels of heterochromatic ade6 reporter relative to euchromatic ade6-M210 allele in WT (F), pdp3Δ (G), or set2Δ (H) cells. The p values were calculated using the two-sided, two-sample Student’s t test. Error bars indicate SD (n ≥ 3 independent biological replicates).
See also Figure S2.
Figure 6Mst2-Mediated Acetylation of Brl1 Represses Initiation of Heterochromatin Assembly
(A) Scheme: acetylomics workflow. Total peptides or peptides enriched for acetylation were labeled with TMT and subjected to LC-MS/MS/MS. We identified 8,926 acetylated peptides and quantified 3,933 proteins (Table S1). See the STAR Methods for more information.
(B) Volcano plot showing fold changes in pdp3Δ mst2Δ compared to WT cells. Identified acetylated Brl1 peptides are shown in red (n = 3 independent biological replicates). The x axis is shown in log2 scale.
(C) Immunodetection of H2BK119ub in different strains. Dilution series was 1/9, 1/3, and 1/1 of the respective protein extracts. Tubulin served as a loading control. A representative experiment is shown.
(D) Quantification of H2BK119ub (left) and H2B (right) levels normalized to tubulin and relative to WT (brl1+). Multiple independent biological replicates were for H2BK119ub (WT n = 5 and brl1-KR/KQ n = 7) and H2B (WT n = 3 and brl1-KR/KQ n = 6). The p values were calculated using the two-sided, two-sample Student’s t test with equal/unequal variance according to prior evaluation with the F test.
(E) Silencing assays of siRNA-directed de novo heterochromatin assembly (as described in Figure 1) in the strains indicated (close up). All strains contained a paf1 allele. A representative experiment is shown.
(F and H) Initiation (F) and maintenance (H) frequencies in paf1-Q264Stop cells with additional mutations in mst2+ and brl1. Assessment of initiation/maintenance frequency was as in Figure 1D. The p values were calculated using two-sided, two-sample Student’s t test (n ≥ 8 individual white colonies). Exact numbers are listed in the STAR Methods.
(G) siRNA reads mapping to the ade6-M210 locus and neighboring regions in brl1-K242R (red) and mst2Δbrl1-K242R (blue) cells. Read counts were normalized to total read number and are depicted in log2 scale.
(I and J) Dilution assays showing gradual loss of ectopic silencing at the trp1::ade6 locus in brl1-K242Q mutants, but not in brl1-K242R mutants. Cells were grown exponentially for 1 day (I) or 5 days (J), and equal cell numbers were plated onto yeast extract-nourseothricin (YE-Nat). A representative experiment with independent strains is shown. Different yeast strains are depicted on the right.
See also Figures S3 and S4 and Table S1.
Figure 7Mst2 Constitutes an Activation Barrier for Heterochromatin Assembly
(A) Scheme depicting the regulatory circuit that protects active chromatin from inactivating siRNAs (solid green arrows). Transcription by RNA polymerase II promotes Set2-mediated tri-methylation of H3K36 (Me3, green), which is recognized by Pdp3. This results in high local concentrations of Mst2 on actively transcribed genes. Mst2 acetylates Brl1 at lysine 242, which causes increased H2B ubiquitination and reinforced transcription. Black circles depict opposing feedback loops that maintain the inactive chromatin state (RNAi and CLRC). Relevant residues in the N-terminal tails of H3 and H2B are highlighted in blue. See the text for details.
(B) Model highlighting that a maximal transition state energy warranties stable propagation of euchromatic and heterochromatic states. Note that Mst2 and Paf1C repress distinct steps in the transition from euchromatin (A) to heterochromatin (R). The heterochromatin assembly reaction proceeds the fastest in paf1 mst2 double-mutant cells, where the activation energy (E) is the lowest and heterochromatin eventually reaches a low-energy state (R stable). See the text for details.
(C) Mitotic propagation of siRNA-directed silencing of the ade6+ gene monitored by red pigmentation of clones that grew on YE-Nat plates.
| REAGENT or RESOURCE | SOURCE | IDENTIFIER |
|---|---|---|
| anti-H3K9me2 | ( | N/A |
| anti-FLAG | Sigma | Cat# F3165; RRID: |
| anti-H3K14ac | Abcam | Cat# ab52946; RRID: |
| anti-H3K36me3 | Abcam | Cat# ab9050; RRID: |
| anti-H3 (ChIP) | Active Motif | Cat# 61475 |
| anti-H2B | Active Motif | Cat# 39238; RRID: |
| anti-H2BK119ub | Cell Signaling | Cat# 5546 |
| anti-H3K4me3 | Abcam | Cat# ab8580; RRID: |
| anti-H3 (Western) | Abcam | Cat# ab1791; RRID: |
| anti-tubulin | ( | N/A |
| goat anti-mouse IgG (H + L)-HRP conjugate | Bio-Rad | Cat# 1706516; RRID: |
| Peroxidase AffiniPure Goat Anti-Mouse IgG (H+L) | Jackson Immunoresearch | Cat# 115-035-146; RRID: |
| Peroxidase AffiniPure Goat Anti-Rabbit IgG (H+L) | Jackson Immunoresearch | Cat# 111-035-144; RRID: |
| Acetyl-Lysine Motif Kit | Cell Signaling | Cat# 13416S |
| 5-Fluoroorotic Acid (FOA) | US biological, Thermo Fisher | Cat# 207291-8-4 |
| nourseothricin dihydrogen sulfate (NAT) | Fisher or WERNER BioAgents GmbH | Cat# 5029426 or Cat# 5.0 |
| G418 sulfate (Geneticin) | Roche or Invitrogen/Life Technologies | Cat# 04727878001-2 or Cat# 10131027 |
| Hygromycin | Sigma or Invitrogen/Life Technologies | Cat# H7772 or Cat# 10687010 |
| PrimeSTAR GXL DNA Polymerase | Clontech | Cat# R050A |
| Taq DNA Polymerase | NEB | Cat# M0267 |
| Formaldehyde | Sigma or Carl Roth | Cat# F8775 or Cat# 4979 |
| PMSF | Sigma | Cat# P7626 |
| cOmplete Protease Inhibitor Cocktail | Roche | Cat# 11836145001 |
| AEBSF (Pefabloc SC) | Roche | Cat# 11585916001 |
| Dynabeads M-280 Sheep anti-mouse IgG | Thermo Fisher | Cat# 11202D |
| Dynabeads Protein G | Thermo Fisher/ Life Technologies | Cat# 10009D |
| Leupeptin hemisulfate | Carl Roth | Cat# CN33 |
| Proteinase K | Roche | Cat# 3115879001 |
| RNase A | Roche | Cat# 10109169001 |
| SuperScript III | Thermo Fisher/ Life Technologies | Cat# 18080085 |
| Acrylamid/BIS solution (30%) 37.5:1 | Serva | Cat# 10688 |
| Titriplex III (EDTA) | Merck Millipore | Cat# 108418 |
| SsoAdvanced Universal SYBR Green Supermix | Bio-Rad | Cat# 172-5274 |
| PowerUp SYBR Green Master Mix | Life Technologies | Cat# A25742 |
| Zymolyase | Fischer | Cat# 6064819 |
| Lysing enzyme from | Sigma | Cat# L1412 |
| DpnI | NEB | Cat# R0176 |
| DpnII | NEB | Cat# R0543 |
| T4 DNA ligase | Roche | Cat# 10481220001 |
| Lys-C | Wako Chemicals | Cat# 125-05061 |
| Trypsin | Thermo Fisher | Cat# 20233 |
| SEP-PAK | Waters | Cat# WAT036790 |
| YMC Triart C18 0.5 × 250 mm column | YMC Europe GmBH | Cat# TA12S0325J0AU |
| PepMap 100 C18 2 cm trap | Thermo Fisher | Cat# 164946 |
| EASY-Spray C18 column | Thermo Fisher | Cat# ES801 |
| Bolt 4-12% Bis-Tris Plus Gels | Thermo Fisher | Cat# NW04127BOX |
| Immobilon Western Chemiluminescent HRP Substrate | Millipore | Cat# WBKLS0500 |
| Immobilon-P Membran, PVDF, 0,45 μm | Merck Millipore | Cat# IPVH00010 |
| MasterPure Yeast RNA Purification Kit | Epicenter | Cat# MPY03100 |
| Bio-Rad Protein Assay Dye Reagent Concentrate | Bio-Rad | Cat# 500-0006 |
| TruSeq Small RNA library preparation kit | Illumina | Cat# RS-200-0012 |
| TruSeq Stranded mRNA library preparation kit | Illumina | Cat# RS-122-2101 |
| DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit | QIAGEN | Cat# 69506 |
| RNeasy Midi Kit | QIAGEN | Cat# 75144 |
| GeneChip Hybridization, Wash, and Stain Kit | Affymetrix | Cat# 900720 |
| Turbo DNA free | Thermo Fisher/ Life Technologies | Cat# AM1907 |
| ChIP DNA Clean & Concentrator | Zymo Research | Cat# D5201 |
| smallRNA and poly(A) mRNA sequencing data | This study | GEO: |
| DamID data | This study | GEO: |
| Mendeley Data dataset (original unprocessed Western Blot images) | This study | |
| Mass spectrometry raw data | This study | ProteomeXchange: |
| H3K36me3 ChIP-chip data | ( | ArrayExpress: |
| ( | spb464 | |
| ( | spb1788 | |
| ( | spb2047 | |
| ( | spb2076 | |
| This study | spb2151 | |
| This study | spb2630 | |
| This study | spb2094 | |
| ( | spb1950 | |
| ( | spb1591 | |
| This study | spb1719 | |
| This study | spb1754 | |
| This study | spb1776 | |
| This study | spb1755 | |
| ( | spb492 | |
| This study | spb2104 | |
| ( | spb426 (PSB1782) | |
| This study | PSB1855 | |
| This study | PSB1870 | |
| This study | PSB1871 | |
| This study | PSB1882 | |
| ( | PSB65 | |
| This study | PSB1696 | |
| This study | PSB1698 | |
| This study | spb2212 | |
| This study | spb2647 | |
| This study | spb2646 | |
| This study | spb2220 | |
| This study | spb2239 | |
| This study | spb2319 | |
| ( | PSB582 | |
| This study | PSB689 | |
| This study | PSB1122 | |
| This study | PSB2099 | |
| This study | spb2835 | |
| This study | spb2821 | |
| This study | spb2822 | |
| This study | spb2836 | |
| This study | spb2804 | |
| This study | spb2852 | |
| This study | spb2881 | |
| This study | spb2885 | |
| This study | spb2894 | |
| This study | spb2101 | |
| This study | spb2153 | |
| This study | spb2115 | |
| This study | spb2982 | |
| This study | spb2983 | |
| This study | spb2984 | |
| This study | spb3023 | |
| This study | spb3024 | |
| This study | spb2996 | |
| This study | spb2364 | |
| This study | spb2661 | |
| This study | spb2662 | |
| This study | spb1739 | |
| This study | spb1740 | |
| This study | spb1741 | |
| This study | spb1745 | |
| This study | spb1747 | |
| This study | spb1753 | |
| This study | spb1756 | |
| This study | spb1757 | |
| This study | spb1772 | |
| This study | spb1774 | |
| This study | spb1802 | |
| This study | spb1803 | |
| This study | PSB1524 | |
| This study | spb2404 | |
| This study | spb2443 | |
| This study | spb3115 | |
| This study | spb3116 | |
| This study | spb3117 | |
| This study | spb3118 | |
| This study | spb3119 | |
| Primers | This study | |
| pFa6a 81xnmt1 - Dam - mst2 | This study | pMB1436 |
| pJR1 - 3xL - LexA - Mst2 gDNA | This study | pMB1636 |
| pJR1 - 3xL - LexA - Mst2 mut (E274Q)-gDNA | This study | pMB1639 |
| ImageJ 1.47v | ( | N/A |
| R | ( | |
| QuasR | ( | N/A |
| Proteome Discoverer 2.1 software | Thermo Fisher | Cat# IQLAAEGAB SFAKJMAUH |
| Illumina HiSeq2500 | Illumina | N/A |
| GeneChip Scanner 3000 7G System | Affymetrix | Cat# 00-0213 |
| Agilent 1100 system | Agilent | Cat# DE33201061 |
| Orbitrap Fusion Tribrid | Thermo Fisher | Cat# IQLAAEGA APFADBMBCX |
| Easy nLC 1000 system | Thermo Fisher | Cat# LC-010190 |