Liza-Marie Johnson1, Jessica M Valdez2, Emily A Quinn2, April D Sykes3, Rose B McGee2, Regina Nuccio2, Stacy J Hines-Dowell2, Justin N Baker4, Chimene Kesserwan2, Kim E Nichols2, Belinda N Mandrell5. 1. Division of Hospitalist Medicine, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, Tennessee. 2. Division of Cancer Predisposition, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, Tennessee. 3. Department of Biostatistics, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, Tennessee. 4. Division of Quality of Life and Palliative Care, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, Tennessee. 5. Division of Nursing Research, St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, Memphis, Tennessee.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The incorporation of genomic testing to identify targetable somatic alterations and predisposing germline mutations into the clinical setting is becoming increasingly more common. Despite its potential usefulness, to the authors' knowledge physician confidence with regard to understanding and applying genomic testing remains unclear, particularly within the realm of pediatric oncology. METHODS: Before initiating an institutional feasibility study regarding the integration of clinical genomic testing, the authors surveyed pediatric oncologists regarding their confidence around understanding of genomic testing, perceived usefulness of test results, preferences around the disclosure of germline test results, and possible risks and benefits of testing. RESULTS: Among survey respondents (52 of 88 contacted; response rate of 59%), only a minority were confident in interpreting, using, and discussing somatic (35%) or germline (27%) genomic test results. Providers who were confident in interpreting somatic results were significantly more likely to anticipate using the results to plan the treatment of patients with relapsed or refractory cancers (P = .009). Similarly, providers who reported confidence in interpreting germline results were significantly more likely to discuss and use these results as part of clinical care (P<.0001). The majority of physicians (93%), regardless of their level of confidence, wanted to speak to a genetic counselor before disclosing germline test results. CONCLUSIONS: Among physicians at a comprehensive pediatric cancer center, confidence in the interpretation, use, and discussion of oncology-based genomic test results appears to be low, both in terms of somatic and germline testing. To optimize the integration of genomic sequencing into cancer care, methods must be developed to improve basic competencies around cancer-based genomic testing. Given the complexities surrounding variant interpretation and genotype-phenotype relationships, interdisciplinary collaborations are warranted. Cancer 2017;123:2352-2359.
BACKGROUND: The incorporation of genomic testing to identify targetable somatic alterations and predisposing germline mutations into the clinical setting is becoming increasingly more common. Despite its potential usefulness, to the authors' knowledge physician confidence with regard to understanding and applying genomic testing remains unclear, particularly within the realm of pediatric oncology. METHODS: Before initiating an institutional feasibility study regarding the integration of clinical genomic testing, the authors surveyed pediatric oncologists regarding their confidence around understanding of genomic testing, perceived usefulness of test results, preferences around the disclosure of germline test results, and possible risks and benefits of testing. RESULTS: Among survey respondents (52 of 88 contacted; response rate of 59%), only a minority were confident in interpreting, using, and discussing somatic (35%) or germline (27%) genomic test results. Providers who were confident in interpreting somatic results were significantly more likely to anticipate using the results to plan the treatment of patients with relapsed or refractory cancers (P = .009). Similarly, providers who reported confidence in interpreting germline results were significantly more likely to discuss and use these results as part of clinical care (P<.0001). The majority of physicians (93%), regardless of their level of confidence, wanted to speak to a genetic counselor before disclosing germline test results. CONCLUSIONS: Among physicians at a comprehensive pediatric cancer center, confidence in the interpretation, use, and discussion of oncology-based genomic test results appears to be low, both in terms of somatic and germline testing. To optimize the integration of genomic sequencing into cancer care, methods must be developed to improve basic competencies around cancer-based genomic testing. Given the complexities surrounding variant interpretation and genotype-phenotype relationships, interdisciplinary collaborations are warranted. Cancer 2017;123:2352-2359.
Authors: Jason L Vassy; Kurt D Christensen; Melody J Slashinski; Denise M Lautenbach; Sridharan Raghavan; Jill Oliver Robinson; Jennifer Blumenthal-Barby; Lindsay Zausmer Feuerman; Lisa Soleymani Lehmann; Michael F Murray; Robert C Green; Amy L McGuire Journal: Per Med Date: 2015 Impact factor: 2.512
Authors: David A Wheeler; Maithreyan Srinivasan; Michael Egholm; Yufeng Shen; Lei Chen; Amy McGuire; Wen He; Yi-Ju Chen; Vinod Makhijani; G Thomas Roth; Xavier Gomes; Karrie Tartaro; Faheem Niazi; Cynthia L Turcotte; Gerard P Irzyk; James R Lupski; Craig Chinault; Xing-zhi Song; Yue Liu; Ye Yuan; Lynne Nazareth; Xiang Qin; Donna M Muzny; Marcel Margulies; George M Weinstock; Richard A Gibbs; Jonathan M Rothberg Journal: Nature Date: 2008-04-17 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Michael V Ortiz; Rachel Kobos; Michael Walsh; Emily K Slotkin; Stephen Roberts; Michael F Berger; Meera Hameed; David Solit; Marc Ladanyi; Neerav Shukla; Alex Kentsis Journal: Pediatr Blood Cancer Date: 2016-04-15 Impact factor: 3.167
Authors: Yaping Yang; Donna M Muzny; Fan Xia; Zhiyv Niu; Richard Person; Yan Ding; Patricia Ward; Alicia Braxton; Min Wang; Christian Buhay; Narayanan Veeraraghavan; Alicia Hawes; Theodore Chiang; Magalie Leduc; Joke Beuten; Jing Zhang; Weimin He; Jennifer Scull; Alecia Willis; Megan Landsverk; William J Craigen; Mir Reza Bekheirnia; Asbjorg Stray-Pedersen; Pengfei Liu; Shu Wen; Wendy Alcaraz; Hong Cui; Magdalena Walkiewicz; Jeffrey Reid; Matthew Bainbridge; Ankita Patel; Eric Boerwinkle; Arthur L Beaudet; James R Lupski; Sharon E Plon; Richard A Gibbs; Christine M Eng Journal: JAMA Date: 2014-11-12 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Robert C Green; Katrina A B Goddard; Gail P Jarvik; Laura M Amendola; Paul S Appelbaum; Jonathan S Berg; Barbara A Bernhardt; Leslie G Biesecker; Sawona Biswas; Carrie L Blout; Kevin M Bowling; Kyle B Brothers; Wylie Burke; Charlisse F Caga-Anan; Arul M Chinnaiyan; Wendy K Chung; Ellen W Clayton; Gregory M Cooper; Kelly East; James P Evans; Stephanie M Fullerton; Levi A Garraway; Jeremy R Garrett; Stacy W Gray; Gail E Henderson; Lucia A Hindorff; Ingrid A Holm; Michelle Huckaby Lewis; Carolyn M Hutter; Pasi A Janne; Steven Joffe; David Kaufman; Bartha M Knoppers; Barbara A Koenig; Ian D Krantz; Teri A Manolio; Laurence McCullough; Jean McEwen; Amy McGuire; Donna Muzny; Richard M Myers; Deborah A Nickerson; Jeffrey Ou; Donald W Parsons; Gloria M Petersen; Sharon E Plon; Heidi L Rehm; J Scott Roberts; Dan Robinson; Joseph S Salama; Sarah Scollon; Richard R Sharp; Brian Shirts; Nancy B Spinner; Holly K Tabor; Peter Tarczy-Hornoch; David L Veenstra; Nikhil Wagle; Karen Weck; Benjamin S Wilfond; Kirk Wilhelmsen; Susan M Wolf; Julia Wynn; Joon-Ho Yu Journal: Am J Hum Genet Date: 2016-05-12 Impact factor: 11.025
Authors: Sarah Bowdin; Adel Gilbert; Emma Bedoukian; Christopher Carew; Margaret P Adam; John Belmont; Barbara Bernhardt; Leslie Biesecker; Hans T Bjornsson; Miriam Blitzer; Lisa C A D'Alessandro; Matthew A Deardorff; Laurie Demmer; Alison Elliott; Gerald L Feldman; Ian A Glass; Gail Herman; Lucia Hindorff; Fuki Hisama; Louanne Hudgins; A Micheil Innes; Laird Jackson; Gail Jarvik; Raymond Kim; Bruce Korf; David H Ledbetter; Mindy Li; Eriskay Liston; Christian Marshall; Livija Medne; M Stephen Meyn; Nasim Monfared; Cynthia Morton; John J Mulvihill; Sharon E Plon; Heidi Rehm; Amy Roberts; Cheryl Shuman; Nancy B Spinner; D James Stavropoulos; Kathleen Valverde; Darrel J Waggoner; Alisha Wilkens; Ronald D Cohn; Ian D Krantz Journal: Genet Med Date: 2016-05-12 Impact factor: 8.822
Authors: Catherine A Brownstein; Alan H Beggs; Nils Homer; Barry Merriman; Timothy W Yu; Katherine C Flannery; Elizabeth T DeChene; Meghan C Towne; Sarah K Savage; Emily N Price; Ingrid A Holm; Lovelace J Luquette; Elaine Lyon; Joseph Majzoub; Peter Neupert; David McCallie; Peter Szolovits; Huntington F Willard; Nancy J Mendelsohn; Renee Temme; Richard S Finkel; Sabrina W Yum; Livija Medne; Shamil R Sunyaev; Ivan Adzhubey; Christopher A Cassa; Paul I W de Bakker; Hatice Duzkale; Piotr Dworzyński; William Fairbrother; Laurent Francioli; Birgit H Funke; Monica A Giovanni; Robert E Handsaker; Kasper Lage; Matthew S Lebo; Monkol Lek; Ignaty Leshchiner; Daniel G MacArthur; Heather M McLaughlin; Michael F Murray; Tune H Pers; Paz P Polak; Soumya Raychaudhuri; Heidi L Rehm; Rachel Soemedi; Nathan O Stitziel; Sara Vestecka; Jochen Supper; Claudia Gugenmus; Bernward Klocke; Alexander Hahn; Max Schubach; Mortiz Menzel; Saskia Biskup; Peter Freisinger; Mario Deng; Martin Braun; Sven Perner; Richard J H Smith; Janeen L Andorf; Jian Huang; Kelli Ryckman; Val C Sheffield; Edwin M Stone; Thomas Bair; E Ann Black-Ziegelbein; Terry A Braun; Benjamin Darbro; Adam P DeLuca; Diana L Kolbe; Todd E Scheetz; Aiden E Shearer; Rama Sompallae; Kai Wang; Alexander G Bassuk; Erik Edens; Katherine Mathews; Steven A Moore; Oleg A Shchelochkov; Pamela Trapane; Aaron Bossler; Colleen A Campbell; Jonathan W Heusel; Anne Kwitek; Tara Maga; Karin Panzer; Thomas Wassink; Douglas Van Daele; Hela Azaiez; Kevin Booth; Nic Meyer; Michael M Segal; Marc S Williams; Gerard Tromp; Peter White; Donald Corsmeier; Sara Fitzgerald-Butt; Gail Herman; Devon Lamb-Thrush; Kim L McBride; David Newsom; Christopher R Pierson; Alexander T Rakowsky; Aleš Maver; Luca Lovrečić; Anja Palandačić; Borut Peterlin; Ali Torkamani; Anna Wedell; Mikael Huss; Andrey Alexeyenko; Jessica M Lindvall; Måns Magnusson; Daniel Nilsson; Henrik Stranneheim; Fulya Taylan; Christian Gilissen; Alexander Hoischen; Bregje van Bon; Helger Yntema; Marcel Nelen; Weidong Zhang; Jason Sager; Lu Zhang; Kathryn Blair; Deniz Kural; Michael Cariaso; Greg G Lennon; Asif Javed; Saloni Agrawal; Pauline C Ng; Komal S Sandhu; Shuba Krishna; Vamsi Veeramachaneni; Ofer Isakov; Eran Halperin; Eitan Friedman; Noam Shomron; Gustavo Glusman; Jared C Roach; Juan Caballero; Hannah C Cox; Denise Mauldin; Seth A Ament; Lee Rowen; Daniel R Richards; F Anthony San Lucas; Manuel L Gonzalez-Garay; C Thomas Caskey; Yu Bai; Ying Huang; Fang Fang; Yan Zhang; Zhengyuan Wang; Jorge Barrera; Juan M Garcia-Lobo; Domingo González-Lamuño; Javier Llorca; Maria C Rodriguez; Ignacio Varela; Martin G Reese; Francisco M De La Vega; Edward Kiruluta; Michele Cargill; Reece K Hart; Jon M Sorenson; Gholson J Lyon; David A Stevenson; Bruce E Bray; Barry M Moore; Karen Eilbeck; Mark Yandell; Hongyu Zhao; Lin Hou; Xiaowei Chen; Xiting Yan; Mengjie Chen; Cong Li; Can Yang; Murat Gunel; Peining Li; Yong Kong; Austin C Alexander; Zayed I Albertyn; Kym M Boycott; Dennis E Bulman; Paul M K Gordon; A Micheil Innes; Bartha M Knoppers; Jacek Majewski; Christian R Marshall; Jillian S Parboosingh; Sarah L Sawyer; Mark E Samuels; Jeremy Schwartzentruber; Isaac S Kohane; David M Margulies Journal: Genome Biol Date: 2014-03-25 Impact factor: 13.583
Authors: Suzanne C O'Neill; Kathryn L Taylor; Jonathan Clapp; Jinani Jayasekera; Claudine Isaacs; Deena Mary Atieh Graham; Stuart L Goldberg; Jeanne Mandelblatt Journal: J Health Commun Date: 2018-08-21
Authors: Ryan Pysar; Courtney K Wallingford; Jackie Boyle; Scott B Campbell; Lisa Eckstein; Rebekah McWhirter; Bronwyn Terrill; Chris Jacobs; Aideen M McInerney-Leo Journal: Eur J Hum Genet Date: 2021-08-26 Impact factor: 4.246
Authors: Bryan A Sisk; Kieandra Harvey; Annie B Friedrich; Alison L Antes; Lauren H Yaeger; Jennifer W Mack; James M DuBois Journal: Pediatr Blood Cancer Date: 2021-10-18 Impact factor: 3.167
Authors: Stacy W Gray; Jeffrey Gagan; Ethan Cerami; Angel M Cronin; Hajime Uno; Nelly Oliver; Carol Lowenstein; Ruth Lederman; Anna Revette; Aaron Suarez; Charlotte Lee; Jordan Bryan; Lynette Sholl; Eliezer M Van Allen Journal: J Am Med Inform Assoc Date: 2018-05-01 Impact factor: 4.497