Timothy I Morgenthaler1, Sarah Hashmi2, Janet B Croft3, Leslie Dort4, Jonathan L Heald2, Janet Mullington5. 1. Center for Sleep Medicine, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN. 2. American Academy of Sleep Medicine, Darien, IL. 3. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA. 4. University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada. 5. Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, MA.
Abstract
STUDY OBJECTIVES: Several organizations have provided recommendations to ensure high school starts no sooner than 08:30. However, although there are plausible biological reasons to support such recommendations, published recommendations have been based largely on expert opinion and a few observational studies. We sought to perform a critical review of published evidence regarding the effect of high school start times on sleep and other relevant outcomes. METHODS: We performed a broad literature search to identify 287 candidate publications for inclusion in our review, which focused on studies offering direct comparison of sleep time, academic or physical performance, behavioral health measures, or motor vehicular accidents in high school students. Where possible, outcomes were combined for meta-analysis. RESULTS: After application of study criteria, only 18 studies were suitable for review. Eight studies were amenable to meta-analysis for some outcomes. We found that later school start times, particularly when compared with start times more than 60 min earlier, are associated with longer weekday sleep durations, lower weekday-weekend sleep duration differences, reduced vehicular accident rates, and reduced subjective daytime sleepiness. Improvement in academic performance and behavioral issues is less established. CONCLUSIONS: The literature regarding effect of school start time delays on important aspects of high school life suggests some salutary effects, but often the evidence is indirect, imprecise, or derived from cohorts of convenience, making the overall quality of evidence weak or very weak. This review highlights a need for higher-quality data upon which to base important and complex public health decisions.
STUDY OBJECTIVES: Several organizations have provided recommendations to ensure high school starts no sooner than 08:30. However, although there are plausible biological reasons to support such recommendations, published recommendations have been based largely on expert opinion and a few observational studies. We sought to perform a critical review of published evidence regarding the effect of high school start times on sleep and other relevant outcomes. METHODS: We performed a broad literature search to identify 287 candidate publications for inclusion in our review, which focused on studies offering direct comparison of sleep time, academic or physical performance, behavioral health measures, or motor vehicular accidents in high school students. Where possible, outcomes were combined for meta-analysis. RESULTS: After application of study criteria, only 18 studies were suitable for review. Eight studies were amenable to meta-analysis for some outcomes. We found that later school start times, particularly when compared with start times more than 60 min earlier, are associated with longer weekday sleep durations, lower weekday-weekend sleep duration differences, reduced vehicular accident rates, and reduced subjective daytime sleepiness. Improvement in academic performance and behavioral issues is less established. CONCLUSIONS: The literature regarding effect of school start time delays on important aspects of high school life suggests some salutary effects, but often the evidence is indirect, imprecise, or derived from cohorts of convenience, making the overall quality of evidence weak or very weak. This review highlights a need for higher-quality data upon which to base important and complex public health decisions.
Authors: Robert Daniel Vorona; Mariana Szklo-Coxe; Andrew Wu; Michael Dubik; Yueqin Zhao; J Catesby Ware Journal: J Clin Sleep Med Date: 2011-04-15 Impact factor: 4.062
Authors: Robert Daniel Vorona; Mariana Szklo-Coxe; Rajan Lamichhane; J Catesby Ware; Ann McNallen; David Leszczyszyn Journal: J Clin Sleep Med Date: 2014-11-15 Impact factor: 4.062
Authors: Nathaniel F Watson; Jennifer L Martin; Merrill S Wise; Kelly A Carden; Douglas B Kirsch; David A Kristo; Raman K Malhotra; Eric J Olson; Kannan Ramar; Ilene M Rosen; James A Rowley; Terri E Weaver; Ronald D Chervin Journal: J Clin Sleep Med Date: 2017-04-15 Impact factor: 4.062
Authors: Galit Levi Dunietz; Amilcar Matos-Moreno; Dianne C Singer; Matthew M Davis; Louise M O'Brien; Ronald D Chervin Journal: J Clin Sleep Med Date: 2017-07-15 Impact factor: 4.062
Authors: June C Lo; Su Mei Lee; Xuan Kai Lee; Karen Sasmita; Nicholas I Y N Chee; Jesisca Tandi; Wei Shan Cher; Joshua J Gooley; Michael W L Chee Journal: Sleep Date: 2018-06-01 Impact factor: 5.849
Authors: Valentina Alfonsi; Serena Scarpelli; Aurora D'Atri; Giacomo Stella; Luigi De Gennaro Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2020-04-09 Impact factor: 3.390