L Maini1, A Sharma1, S Jha4, A Sharma1, A Tiwari1. 1. Maulana Azad Medical College, Delhi, India. 2. Maulana Azad Medical College, Delhi, India. dramite31@gmail.com. 3. , E-31, Radha Kunj, Brij Vihar, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh, 201011, India. dramite31@gmail.com. 4. Indian Institute of Technology, Delhi, India.
Abstract
PURPOSE: Due to the complexity of acetabulum, achieving anatomical contouring intra-operatively is difficult for surgeon. A 3D (dimensional) real model can facilitate us both in contouring the plate pre-operatively and in better pre-operative planning. Patient-specific pre-contoured plate in acetabular fracture has been studied by few researchers but randomized case-control study was lacking. Hence, we conducted a case-control study to evaluate the accuracy of patient-specific pre-contoured plate. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Prospective randomized case control study was conducted. 21 patients were included. 10 patients were distributed in "case" group and remaining 11 in "control" group. INCLUSION CRITERIA: Displaced acetabulum fractures with displacement of ≥3 mm in adults who reported within 3 weeks of injury. Exclusion criteria were: Open fractures, associated Morel-Lavallée lesion and patients with >3 weeks old fracture. In case group, patient-specific real 3D model of fractured acetabulum was generated using rapid prototyping technology and plates were contoured pre-operatively. Control group was treated using intra-operative contoured plates. Both the groups were compared using parameters: Blood loss, Surgery time, post-operative reduction on X-ray, post-surgical residual displacement and reduction achieved as evaluated by CT scan. RESULTS: Reduced blood loss (100 ml less in case group) and surgical time (12 min less in case group) and better post-operative reduction were observed in case than control. In control group, 4 patients even had step of 2-3 mm, which was not seen in case group. All the pre-contoured plates fitted well to the pelvis intra-operatively. Reduction achieved as evaluated by CT was more in "case" group with statistically significant outcomes (p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: Patient-specific pre-contoured plate made using 3D model is a better implant than intra-operatively contoured plate. Real-time 3D pelvis model is an accurate technique for pre-operative planning in acetabular fractures.
RCT Entities:
PURPOSE: Due to the complexity of acetabulum, achieving anatomical contouring intra-operatively is difficult for surgeon. A 3D (dimensional) real model can facilitate us both in contouring the plate pre-operatively and in better pre-operative planning. Patient-specific pre-contoured plate in acetabular fracture has been studied by few researchers but randomized case-control study was lacking. Hence, we conducted a case-control study to evaluate the accuracy of patient-specific pre-contoured plate. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Prospective randomized case control study was conducted. 21 patients were included. 10 patients were distributed in "case" group and remaining 11 in "control" group. INCLUSION CRITERIA: Displaced acetabulum fractures with displacement of ≥3 mm in adults who reported within 3 weeks of injury. Exclusion criteria were: Open fractures, associated Morel-Lavallée lesion and patients with >3 weeks old fracture. In case group, patient-specific real 3D model of fractured acetabulum was generated using rapid prototyping technology and plates were contoured pre-operatively. Control group was treated using intra-operative contoured plates. Both the groups were compared using parameters: Blood loss, Surgery time, post-operative reduction on X-ray, post-surgical residual displacement and reduction achieved as evaluated by CT scan. RESULTS: Reduced blood loss (100 ml less in case group) and surgical time (12 min less in case group) and better post-operative reduction were observed in case than control. In control group, 4 patients even had step of 2-3 mm, which was not seen in case group. All the pre-contoured plates fitted well to the pelvis intra-operatively. Reduction achieved as evaluated by CT was more in "case" group with statistically significant outcomes (p < 0.05). CONCLUSION:Patient-specific pre-contoured plate made using 3D model is a better implant than intra-operatively contoured plate. Real-time 3D pelvis model is an accurate technique for pre-operative planning in acetabular fractures.
Authors: Jürgen Fornaro; Marius Keel; Matthias Harders; Borut Marincek; Gábor Székely; Thomas Frauenfelder Journal: J Orthop Surg Res Date: 2010-08-04 Impact factor: 2.359
Authors: Simon Weidert; Sebastian Andress; Eduardo Suero; Christopher Becker; Maximilian Hartel; Maren Behle; Christian Willy Journal: Unfallchirurg Date: 2019-06 Impact factor: 1.000
Authors: Maximilian J Hartel; Gerrit Althoff; Stefan Wolter; Benjamin Ondruschka; Eric Dietz; Karl-Heinz Frosch; Darius M Thiesen Journal: Arch Orthop Trauma Surg Date: 2022-01-18 Impact factor: 3.067