| Literature DB >> 27473183 |
Claudia D'Alessandro1, Giorgina Barbara Piccoli2,3, Patrizia Calella4, Giuliano Brunori5, Franca Pasticci6, Maria Francesca Egidi1, Irene Capizzi2, Vincenzo Bellizzi7, Adamasco Cupisti8.
Abstract
Evidence exists that nutritional therapy induces favorable metabolic changes, prevents signs and symptoms of renal insufficiency, and is able to delay the need of dialysis. Currently, the main concern of the renal diets has turned from the efficacy to the feasibility in the daily clinical practice.Herewith we describe some different dietary approaches, developed in Italy in the last decades and applied in the actual clinical practice for the nutritional management of CKD patients.A step-wise approach or simplified dietary regimens are usually prescribed while taking into account not only the residual renal function and progression rate but also socio-economic, psychological and functional aspects.The application of the principles of the Mediterranean diet that covers the recommended daily allowances for nutrients and protein (0.8 g/Kg/day) exert a favorable effect at least in the early stages of CKD. Low protein (0.6 g/kg/day) regimens that include vegan diet and very low-protein (0.3-0.4 g/Kg/day) diet supplemented with essential amino acids and ketoacids, represent more opportunities that should be tailored on the single patient's needs.Rather than a structured dietary plan, a list of basic recommendations to improve compliance with a low-sodium diet in CKD may allow patients to reach the desired salt target in the daily eating.Another approach consists of low protein diets as part of an integrated menu, in which patients can choose the "diet" that best suits their preferences and clinical needs.Lastly, in order to allow efficacy and safety, the importance of monitoring and follow up of a proper nutritional treatment in CKD patients is emphasized.Entities:
Keywords: CKD; Dietary phosphorus; Dietary sodium; Dietary treatment renal insufficiency; Low-protein diet; Nutrition; Simplified diet
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2016 PMID: 27473183 PMCID: PMC4966713 DOI: 10.1186/s12882-016-0296-5
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Nephrol ISSN: 1471-2369 Impact factor: 2.388
Main general features of the dietary therapy in patients with chronic renal insufficiency
| Energy | 30–35 Kcal/kg/day |
| Protein | 0.3–0.7 g/kg/day |
| Carbohydrates | At least 60 % of total energy intake |
| Lipids | At least 30 % of total energy intake |
| Sodium | 2.3 g/day (equivalent to 6 g NaCl salt) |
| Phosphate | <700 mg/day |
| Supplements | Essential amino acid and ketoacids, calcium carbonate, vitamins, iron |
Fig. 1The Phosphorus Pyramid (with permission, ref. no. 16)
Fig. 2Step by step visual tool to reduce salt intake
Energy to phosphate ratio (Kcal/mg) in protein-free products and in regular foods
| Food | Energy/phosphate (Kcal/mg) | |
|---|---|---|
| Regular food | Free/low-protein products | |
| Pasta | 1.88 | 8.5 |
| Bread | 3.57 | 6.6 |
| Biscuits | 2.64 | 22.4 |
| Rusks | 3.87 | 4.93 |
| Milk | 0.53 | 29.1 |
Dietary regimens in CKD. The degree of protein and phosphorus restriction is mostly dependent on severity of renal insufficiency, whereas adequacy of energy intake and limitation in salt intake are generally prescribed. As body weight (bw) we refer to the ideal body weight, or to the adjusted weight (when applicable)
| Dietary regimen | Main composition features | CKD stages |
|---|---|---|
| a) Healthy diet, according to WHO | Protein: 0.8 g/Kg bw/day according to RDA. | I, II, IIIa |
| Sodium according to WHO recommendation (2.3 g/day); Phosphorus according to RDA (700 mg/day) | ||
| b) Low Protein Diet (LPD) | Protein: 0.6 g/Kg bw/day, whose 0.4 g/Kg of animal origin; Sodium: 2.3 g/day; Phosphorus < 700 mg/day | IIIb, IV, V |
| c) Low Protein Vegan Diet | Protein : 0.7 g/Kg bw/die, from grains and legumes; | IIIb, IV |
| Sodium : 2.3 g/day; Phosphorus : < 700 mg/day | ||
| d) Supplemented Very Low Protein Diet (sVLPD) | Protein: 0.3-0.4 g/Kg bw/day supplemented with EAAs and KAs | IV, V |
| Sodium: 2.3 g/day, Phosphorus : 300–400 mg/day |
Kitchen measurements
Foods allowed and to avoid with sVLPD
| Food included in the diet | Food excluded from the diet |
|---|---|
| • Protein free products: pasta, biscuits, bread, breadsticks | • meat, fish, sausages and cold cuts |
aTo avoid in case of diabetes; bto avoid in case of overweight/obesity, cardiovascular diseases; cto avoid in case of hyperkaliemia
Fig. 3Tools for monitoring of nutritional status in CKD patients
A day with… a low protein (0,6 g/kg) diet
| Breakfast | |
| • 150 g rice drink or protein-free drink with a teaspoon of sugar | |
| Mid-morning snack | |
| • Protein-free sandwiches with tomatoes or stir-fried vegetables (see the recipe below) | |
| Lunch | |
| • 100 protein-free spaghetti with olives | |
| Mid-afternoon snack | |
| • 30 g low protein crackers | |
| Dinner | |
| • 80 g protein-free pasta with broccoli (see the recipe below) |
A day with…a Vegan diet
| Breakfast |
| • 150 g rice drink or oat drink |
| Snack |
| • “Bruschetta”: bread (preferably toasted) with rubbed garlic, olive oil and tomatoes |
| Lunch |
| • Rice (80 g) with lentils (30 g dry lentils) (see the recipe below) |
| Snack |
| • 100 g strawberry ice cream (see the recipe below) |
| Dinner |
| • Pasta (70 g) with chickpeas (20 g dry chickpeas) (see the recipes below) |
A day with…a very low protein diet
| Breakfast | |
| • 150 g rice drink or oat drink with a teaspoon of sugar | |
| Snack | |
| • 30 g low protein crackers | |
| Lunch | |
| • Protein-free pasta (100 g) with olives (see the recipe below) | |
| Snack | |
| • 100 g strawberry ice cream | |
| Dinner | |
| • rice (80 g) with lentils (see the recipe below) |
The VLPD is not adequate in terms of essential amino acids intake. A supplementation with essential amino acids is absolutely needed, as described above in the text
|
| Fig. 4 |
| Ingredients: |
|
|
| |
|
| Fig. 5 |
|
| |
|
| Fig. 6 |
|
| |
|
| Fig. 7 |
|
| |
|
| Fig. 8 |
|
| |
|
| Fig. 9 |
|
| |
|
| Fig. 10 |
|
| |
|
| Fig. 11 |
|
| |
Questions and tools for quickly assessing CKD patient’s dietary habits
| Do you | Yes | Not | ||
| 1. Usually shop and prepare your own food? | ||||
| 2. Read food nutrition labels? | ||||
| 3. Think that a dietary treatment could be a therapy | ||||
| In an average week, how often do you: | Usually/Often | Sometimes | Rarely/Never | Does not apply to me |
| 4. Skip breakfast? | ||||
| 5. Eat a meal take out restaurants? | ||||
| 6. Drink milk and yogurt? | ||||
| 7. Put the cheese on your pasta? | ||||
| 8. Eat beef, pork, chicken, turkey? | ||||
| 9. Eat fish? | ||||
| 10. Use regular processed meats? | ||||
| 11. Use sauce as ketchup and mayonnaise? | ||||
| 12. Eat high sodium processed foods like canned soup or frozen/packaged meals, chips? | ||||
| 13. Add salt to foods during the cooking or at the table? | ||||
| 14. Drinks soft drink like soda and cola? | ||||
| 15. Eat nuts, peanuts, pistachio nuts | ||||
| 16. Do less than 30 total minutes of physical activity 3 days a week or more? | ||||
| 17. Eat pulse | dried | canned | frozen | |
The diets presently employed are identified according to the target protein intake expressed as g/Kg/day (0.6 with protein free food; 0.6 vegan supplemented; 0.6-0.8 vegan non supplemented; 0.3 vegan with protein free- products, supplemented with essential amino acid and keto-acids)
| 0.6 with protein free food | 0.6 vegan supplemented | 0.6-0.8 vegan not supplemented |
|---|---|---|
| Our diet plans to replace bread and pasta-rice-flour with protein free-food; fruits and vegetables can be taken without restriction; meat, fish cheese, etc. can be used as “seasoning” for the pasta, or as part of the “main course” that has to be completed as much as possible with vegetables. | Our diet is based upon foods of plant origin only (fruit, vegetables, sugars, starches such as pasta and bread, cous-cous, polenta and legumes) supplemented by tablets of a mixture of amino acids and “ketoacids (Alfa-Kappa® or Ketosteril®). | Our diet employs only foods of plant origin (fruit, vegetables, sugars, starches such as pasta and bread, legumes); they must be combined with each other to allow intake of “complete” proteins, with the sufficient quantity of “essential” amino acids, which are those contained in food of animal origin (meat, fish, cheese and eggs) but not in those of vegetable origin (where the proteins are “incomplete” and must be integrated with each other). |
| Finally, keep a food diary for a few days between each visit, to allow us scoring quality and quantity of food. | ||
| BREAKFAST For example biscuits or bread or croissants (all protein-free), jam, tea or coffee, preferably without milk or with soy milk; small amounts of milk are allowed. A lovely cake is fine (with protein free flour). It is important to eat at least a portion of cake, or a few biscuits, or bread, butter and jam, or, for those who do not love the sweet, protein-free bread with oil and tomatoes or other vegetables … | BREAKFAST For example biscuits or bread or croissants, jam, tea or coffee, preferably without milk or with soy milk; in selected cases small amounts of milk are allowed. A lovely cake is fine (a small amount of egg is allowed; however prefer the homemade cakes and egg yolk as compared with egg white). It is important to eat at least a portion of cake, or a few biscuits, or bread, butter and jam, or, for those who do not love the sweet, bread with oil and tomatoes or other vegetables … | BREAKFAST For example biscuits or bread or croissants, jam, tea or coffee, preferably without milk or with soy milk; small amounts of milk are allowed. A lovely cake is fine; combine different types of flour if you like, It is important to eat at least a portion of cake, or a few biscuits, or bread, butter and jam, or, for those who do not love the sweet, bread (white or raw) with oil and tomatoes or other vegetables … |
| LUNCH | LUNCH | LUNCH |
| DINNER | DINNER | DINNER |
| BEVERAGES | ||
| NOTE: for a 0.3 g/Kg/day protein diet: | ||
This diet is based on a series of very simple assumptions: - the first is that the low-protein diet is not only a mean to slow down the progression of kidney failure, but also a very powerful “metabolic regulator”.
- the second is that the proteins of vegetable origin induce a lesser “workload” for the kidney, and therefore, at equal protein content, they are better suited to stabilize the renal function and the metabolism;
- the third is that diets should be followed to improve the quality of life, and hence they have to be followed with some flexibility, and with a certain degree of freedom, progressively adapting to the preferences of each patient: we need your help to identify problems and to solve them together.
- the fourth is that this is almost an “anti-diet” if diet is intended to lose weight: this is a diet rich in pasta, bread and carbohydrates, even if they are different from the usual ones… Sweets and pastry may also be included…