Recent Advances in Substrate-Controlled Asymmetric Induction Derived from Chiral Pool α-Amino Acids for Natural Product Synthesis.

Chiral pool α-amino acids have been used as powerful tools for the total synthesis of structurally diverse natural products. Some common naturally occurring α-amino acids are readily available in both enantiomerically pure forms. The applications of the chiral pool in asymmetric synthesis can be categorized prudently as chiral sources, devices, and inducers. This review specifically examines recent advances in substrate-controlled asymmetric reactions induced by the chirality of α-amino acid templates in natural product synthesis research and related areas.

1. Introduction

The chiral pool approach is highly attractive in the asymmetric total synthesis of bioactive natural products with diverse and complex architectures [1,2]. This strategy is one of the best methods available to synthetic organic chemists for establishing pivotal stereocenters in optically active compounds [3,4,5,6,7]. The chiral pool is a versatile tool, comprising naturally occurring chiral molecules such as carbohydrates, amino acids, terpenes, alkaloids, and hydroxyacids [2,6]. They include enantiomerically enriched species that can be synthetically transformed into the desired target molecules. Chiral pool materials are also inexpensive and commercially available, making them adequate for use in accessing natural products and bioactive compounds [2]. The usage of the chiral pool in asymmetric synthesis can be classified in three general categories, as shown in Figure 1: (a) chiral sources, used as building blocks containing built-in stereocenters for target molecules; (b) chiral devices, employed as useful tools for enantioselective catalysts and auxiliaries; and (c) chiral inducers, applied to the generation of new stereocenters in a substrate-controlled manner [1,2,3,4,5,6,7]. The chiral inducer strategy is a highly efficient method to exploit advantages of both the chiral source and device approach at the same time.

Figure 1

Three categories of chiral pool use in asymmetric synthesis.

The specific aim of this review is to present useful applications of enantiomerically enriched α-amino acids as substrate-controlled asymmetric inducers in natural product synthesis from 2011 to May 2016. Chirally pure α-amino acids are very useful materials due to diversity of functional group and ease of commercial use [7]. The α-amino acids described in this review are illustrated in Figure 2. The use of amino acids as chiral sources and devices for asymmetric synthesis is not covered. Also, synthesis of acyclic or cyclic peptide natural products is not included.

Figure 2

Representative α-amino acids.

2. Chiral Pool: Proline

Recently, a wide range of natural and non-natural product syntheses using proline as the chiral pool material in a substrate-controlled manner have been reported. Suh et al. synthesized polyhydroxylated indolizidine alkaloids, 1-deoxy-6,8a-di-epi-castanospermine (4) and 1-deoxy-6-epi-castanospermine (7), that can act as selective α-glycosidase inhibitors [8,9]. l-Proline was utilized as a platform to construct the indolizidine skeleton, as shown in Scheme 1. (E)-Silyl enol ether 2, obtained from l-proline via a known protocol [10,11], underwent an aza-Claisen rearrangement to produce the corresponding 9-membered lactam 3 in 66% yield. This transformation was impressive not only because it created a new stereogenic center through a 6-membered transition state, but also because it afforded a cis-azoninone framework simultaneously. The final product 4 was afforded after subsequent transformations. Similarly, (Z)-silyl enol ether 5 was converted into trans-azoninone 6 under microwave-assisted conditions. It is noteworthy that the syn-diol moiety of the azoninone skeleton was created via chiral communication of the l-proline stereocenter during aza-Claisen rearrangement-induced ring expansion. The transition states in both these conversions made it possible for the sole chiral center of amino acid 1 to induce additional chirality in cis or trans azoninones 3 and 6.

Scheme 1

Total syntheses of castanospermines 4 and 7.

Another substrate-controlled chiral induction application of l-proline is summarized in Scheme 2. Srihari et al. accomplished the stereoselective total synthesis of alkaloid (−)-allonorsecurinine (10) [12]. To create the stereocenter in the lactone moiety of 10, precursor 8 was readily prepared from l-proline in three steps. The Grignard reaction of isopropenyl magnesium bromide with α-amidoketone 8 afforded tertiary alcohol 9 in high yield and with excellent facial selectivity, with the pivotal tertiary alcohol moiety in 9 constructed via Si-face addition to the carbonyl group. With key intermediate 9 in hand, subsequent classical reactions, such as Aldol and Horner–Wittig reactions, provided final product 10, a Euphorbiaceae alkaloid.

Scheme 2

Total synthesis of (−)-allonorsecurinine (10).

Cycloaddition reactions have also been adapted for the proline-derived total synthesis of natural products. Sarpong et al. completed the impressive syntheses of ent-citrinalin B (15) and cyclopiamine B (16) as shown in Scheme 3 [13,14,15]. The authors utilized the chirality of d-proline for the stereoselective construction of a cis-fused ring system within final products 15 and 16. Unsaturated cyanoamide 12 was prepared from d-proline in 55% yield over seven steps for use as a dienophile in the key face-selective Diels-Alder reaction. When diene 13 underwent cycloaddition with 12 in the presence of Lewis acid [16], desired product 14 was obtained in 73% yield after a basic work-up. As dienophile 12 provided a convex face environment in the bicyclic ring system, diene 13 approached the β-face of the unsaturated lactam ring selectively, establishing the two adjacent stereocenters in tricyclic ketone 14 simultaneously. Subsequent steps transformed 14 into ent-citrinalin B (15) and cyclopiamine B (16).

Scheme 3

Total syntheses of ent-citrinalin B (15) and cyclopiamine B (16).

Memory of chirality is a very special case. Recently, Kim et al. reported the first total synthesis of (−)-penibruguieramine A (22), employing a biomimetic approach (Scheme 4) [17,18]. Acid 17 was coupled with l-proline t-butyl ester (18) in the presence of DCC, providing amide 19, an intramolecular aldol reaction precursor, in 79% yield. Exposure of 19 to sodium ethoxide enabled the pyrrolizidine backbone and two additional stereogenic centers of 21 to be established through memory of chirality and concomitant dynamic kinetic resolution. When amide 19 was treated with a base, its central chirality should have been deleted by deprotonation. However, enolate 20 contained a chiral axis, resulting in memory of chirality and hampering racemization. Impressively, the dynamic kinetic resolution of racemic methine occurred, creating an α-chiral center in the amide moiety. From this transformation, bicyclic amide 21 was obtained in 77% yield, with 10% of the corresponding elimination product. Following an uneventful reduction procedure, (−)-penibruguieramine A was produced from amide 21 in 86% yield (two steps).

Scheme 4

Total synthesis of penibruguieramine A (22).

3. Chiral Pool: Tryptophan

Tryptophan, an aromatic amino acid, has been used as a precursor in the total synthesis of natural products with indole-derived heterocyclic framework. The indole moiety of tryptophan serves as a good template for a copper-catalyzed asymmetric arylation, as depicted in Scheme 5 [19]. Reisman et al. investigated and optimized these reaction conditions. After an extensive survey of bidentate ligands and electrophiles under (CuOTf)2 PhMe catalyst, cyclic dipeptide 23 in the presence of L1 and [Ph2I]OTf afforded pyrroloindololine 24 in high yield and excellent diastereoselectivity, minimizing the undesired C-2 arylated product. Two newly created stereogenic centers were induced by the chirality of tryptophan in a substrate-controlled manner.

Scheme 5

Cu-catalyzed arylation of cyclo-(Trp-Phe) 23.

This conversion strategy was applied directly to the total synthesis of (+)-naseseazine A (28) and (+)-naseseazine B (30) (Scheme 6) [20]. To construct the tetracyclic framework of 28, cyclic alanine-tryptophan dimer 25 was selected as a chiral precursor. The pivotal arylation of diketopiperazine 25 with advanced electrophile 26 in the presence of (CuOTf)2 PhMe and L2 provided desired pyrroloindoline 27 in moderate yield. Final compound 28 was conveniently constructed from tetracyclic intermediate 27 using a Larock indolization strategy [21,22]. Additionally, another natural product, (+)-naseseazine B, was obtained stereoselectively from cyclic proline-tryptophan precursor 29, employing a similar synthetic sequence.

Scheme 6

Total synthesis of (+)-naseseazines A and B.

Interestingly, applying this methodology to simple carboxamide 31 afforded pyrroloindololine compound 32, possessing the opposite stereochemistry in the C-2 and C-3 positions. This discrepancy shows that amino acids provide a tremendous opportunity for the diastereoselective synthesis of the pyrroloindololine framework as shown in Scheme 7.

Scheme 7

Diastereoselective cyclization for pyrroloindoline skeleton.

Tryptophan was also utilized as a chiral pool reagent in the total synthesis of prenylated indole alkaloids (−)-brevicompanine B (38) and (+)-aszonalenin (40) (Scheme 8) [23]. Carreira et al. reported a highly diastereoselective and regioselective iridium-catalyzed reverse prenylation reaction. The reaction of readily available l-tryptophan methyl ester 33 with tertiary carbonate 34 in the presence of [{Ir(cod)Cl}2] and phosphoramidite ligand 35 [24] furnished hexahydropyrrolo[2,3-b]indole (−)-exo-36 in 58% yield. Initially, the exo/endo ratio of the prenylation was quite low (1.3:1). However, it was improved to >20:1 by extensive optimization of base, ligand, and reaction temperature. Importantly, the installation of two vicinal stereogenic centers was controlled by the chirality of tryptophan. After this successful result, (−)-brevicompanine B (38) [25], a plant growth regulator, was finally obtained from iterative amidations in good yield. The total synthesis of another alkaloid, (+)-aszonalenin (40) [26], a substance P inhibitor for the human neurokinin-1 receptor, was efficiently completed from d-tryptophan methyl ester 39 via a similar synthetic procedure.

Scheme 8

Total syntheses of (−)-brevicompanine B (38) and (+)-aszonalenin (40).

A more recent example of tryptophan-templated chiral pool synthesis is illustrated in Scheme 9. Baran et al. accomplished the total syntheses of verruculogen (45) and fumitremorgin A (46), which both contain a unique eight-membered endoperoxide [27,28,29]. Diastereoselective Pictet-Spengler cyclization of 42, prepared from N-Boc-l-tryptophan methyl ester (41), with TBDPS-protected peroxy-aldehyde 43 gave tricycle 44. Although the facial selectivity was relatively low (2:1), major diastereomer 44 was effectively exploited to finish the total syntheses. The chirality of tryptophan from the chiral pool was critical for creating the new stereocenter in the indole system. The pivotal methoxy group in precursor 42 was introduced by Ir-catalyzed borylation and Chan-Lam coupling [30].

Scheme 9

Total syntheses of verruculogen (45) and fumitremorgin A (46).

4. Chiral Pool: Tyrosine

Various natural product syntheses have started from chiral pool reagent tyrosine, which can be transformed into enantiomerically pure intermediates. Tokuyama et al. reported the total synthesis of dimeric alkaloid (−)-acetylaranotin 49 in 2012 (Scheme 10) [31,32]. Alkaloid 49 features a dihydrooxepine backbone synthesized from α,β-unsaturated ketone 48 by olefin isomerization, Wharton rearrangement, Baeyer-Villiger oxidation, and further steps. The total synthesis commenced with the preparation of enone 48 via oxidative dearomatization of N-Cbz-l-tyrosine (47) and subsequent conjugate addition of the transition state amino moiety. This remarkable reaction was previously developed and described by Wipf et al. [33]. After oxidative dearomatization of the phenol moiety in 47, two transition states, T and T, for concomitant conjugate addition are possible. T was more stable, due to having less A1,3-strain (H and carbonyl oxygen), resulting in 48 being obtained exclusively as the major diastereomer. This high facial selectivity further demonstrates the superiority of amino acids as chiral inducers.

Scheme 10

Total synthesis of (−)-acetylaranotin (49).

Alkene asymmetric dihydroxylation is another example of tyrosine utilized as a chiral template. The stereoselective synthesis of pyrrolidinone alkaloid rigidiusculamide A was completed by Krishna et al. (Scheme 11) [34,35]. To incorporate the syn-diol moiety in 53, they dihydroxylated 51 using the Upjohn method (OsO4/NMO) [36]. This transformation afforded desired diol 52 as a single diastereomer in 69% yield. The chirality of γ-lactam 52 was thought to be responsible for the enantiomerically pure tyrosine-induced α-facial selectivity. Finally, the O-benzyl group in 52 was deprotected to afford the originally proposed structure of rigidiusculamide A. Unfortunately, the experimental data was not identical to that of the authentic natural product [35].

Scheme 11

Total synthesis of rigidiusculamide A (53).

5. Chiral Pool: Serine

Serine, containing a hydroxymethyl group, has also been used as the powerful chiral pool reagent in the synthesis of complex target molecules. A particularly impressive example, the enantioselective synthesis of (−)-α-kainic acid (60), in which Zhou and Li et al. present a unique SmI2-catalyzed [3 + 2] intramolecular cycloaddition reaction with excellent diastereoselectivity, is summarized in Scheme 12 [37,38]. The key precursor, cyclopropane 56, was synthesized from d-serine methyl ester HCl (55) using conventional protocols. When cyclopropane 56 was treated with samarium diiodide, ketyl radical 57 was initially formed. Rapid cleavage of the cyclopropyl ring and subsequent cycloaddition was observed, which afforded desired bicyclic ketone 59 in good yield. It was hypothesized that ketyl radical 57 spontaneously transformed into enolate radical 58. This newly created chiral center favored 2,3-trans stereoselectivity over 2,3-cis via facial control from the sole chiral center from the chiral amino acid. With key intermediate 59 in hand, the asymmetric synthesis of kainoid 60 was accomplished via a high-yielding sequence.

Scheme 12

Total synthesis of (−)-α-kainic acid (60).

The synthesis of iso-haouamine B is another example (Scheme 13) [39,40]. Structurally, this alkaloid, 64, consists of an indeno-tetrahydropyridine core fused to a highly distinctive 11-membered p-cyclophane ring. Trauner et al. investigated a substrate-controlled oxidative phenol coupling to establish the indeno-tetrahydropyridine ring. Coupling precursor enone 62 was readily prepared from N-Boc protected l-serine (61). With desired intermediate 62 prepared, carbonyl activation by triflic anhydride and concomitant 1,4-addition of the electron-rich aromatic ring produced enol ether 63 in moderate yield. During the crucial addition process, the syn-substituted cyclopentane skeleton was constructed without racemization. The new quaternary stereogenic center in 63 was ultimately derived from the chiral pool stereocenter in 62.

Scheme 13

Total synthesis of iso-haouamine B (64).

More recently, Ciufolini et al. described the total synthesis of (+)-erysotramidine (70) using an l-serine derivative (Scheme 14) [41,42]. Advanced oxazoline 67, prepared from l-serine methyl ester (66) via DCC coupling and Burgess reagent-induced cyclization [43], was converted into enone 68 as a precursor for stereoselective Michael cyclization. Exposure of electronically deficient enone 68 in CH2Cl2 to TsOH resulted in the desired tetracyclic core of 69 as a single diastereomer in excellent yield. Although the serine hydroxyl group could approach the two reactive Michael acceptors, the formation of desired product 69 was favored. The high diastereoselectivity was assumed to result from the minimization of unwanted nonbonding interactions between the methyl ester group and acylamido group [44,45]. The pseudoaxial conformation of the methyl ester group resulted from the chirality of serine. After this chiral communication, (+)-erysotramidine (70) was synthesized from key synthetic intermediate 69 using further manipulations.

Scheme 14

Total synthesis of (+)-erysotramidine (70).

6. Chiral Pool: Alanine

The stereocenter in alanine, a simple chiral pool reagent, has also provided good opportunities for chiral induction. Gouault et al. accomplished the asymmetric total synthesis of dendrobate alkaloid (+)-241D (74) and isosolenopsin (76) (Scheme 15) [46,47,48]. Structurally, these alkaloids consist of cis-2,6-dialkylpiperidine. Vinylogous lactams 72 and 73, which were used as chiral precursors, were readily prepared from N-Boc protected d-alanine 71 [49]. The catalytic hydrogenation of Boc-deprotected amine 73 finally gave the target molecule, (+)-241D (74), via stereoselective reduction of both the alkene and ketone. In addition, key intermediate 75, which was transformed into enantiopure alkaloid isosolenopsin (76), was obtained by hydrogenation under similar conditions. The newly generated stereogenic centers in 74 and 75 were affected by the chirality of d-alanine. The total synthesis of isosolenopsin (76) was completed using deoxygenation and Boc-deprotection steps.

Scheme 15

Total syntheses of (+)-241D (74) and isosolenopsin (76).

7. Chiral Pool: Threonine

α-Amino acid threonine is a special chiral pool reagent, containing an extra stereocenter. Recently, Seeberger et al. published the total synthesis of protected legionaminic acid 80 from d-threonine as a starting material (Scheme 16) [50,51]. Conventional protection of chiral pool reagent 77, followed by DIBAL-H reduction, provided chiral aldehyde 78 in high yield [52]. With threoninal 78 in hand, treatment with 2-lithiofuran resulted in desired alcohol 79. Although the organometallic addition reaction could produce a diastereomeric mixture, the desired syn-configured alcohol, 79, was obtained with a 5:1 ratio and in 80% isolated yield. This stereoselectivity was caused by the chirality of threonine amino acid via Cram-chelation control of the nucleophilic addition [53]. The newly generated stereogenic center served as a key stereocenter in C-6 within legionamic acid (81).

Scheme 16

De novo synthesis of orthogonally protected legionaminic acid 80.

8. Conclusions

Naturally occurring chiral pool α-amino acids provide synthetic chemists with a powerful tool for the incorporation of pivotal stereocenters in optically active natural products. Until now, α-amino acids have been exploited for use not only as chiral sources and devices, but also as chiral inducers in strategies for the synthesis of complex target molecules. In this review, many applications of α-amino acids as chiral inducers in a substrate-controlled manner were specifically discussed. To establish challenging stereocenters in natural product architectures, the chirality of α-amino acids was applied to a remarkable variety of reactions, such as rearrangement, cyclization, cycloaddition, nucleophilic addition to carbonyls, and hydrogenation. To conclude, attempts at utilizing α-amino acids as chiral inducers for the creation of new stereogenic centers will continue.