Johannes Koehbach1,2, Christian W Gruber1, Christian Becker3, David P Kreil4, Alexander Jilek3,4. 1. Centre for Physiology and Pharmacology, Medical University of Vienna , Schwarzspanierstraße 17, A-1090 Vienna, Austria. 2. School of Biomedical Sciences, The University of Queensland , Brisbane, QLD, 4072 Australia. 3. Institute of Biological Chemistry, Department of Chemistry, University of Vienna , Währinger Straße 38, A-1090 Vienna, Austria. 4. Chair of Bioinformatics, University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences , Muthgasse 18, A-1190 Vienna, Austria.
Abstract
Several biologically active peptides contain a d- amino acid in a well-defined position, which is position 2 in all peptide epimers isolated to date from vertebrates and also some from invertebrates. The detection of such D- residues by standard analytical techniques is challenging. In tandem mass spectrometric (MS) analysis, although fragment masses are the same for all stereoisomers, peak intensities are known to depend on chirality. Here, we observe that the effect of a d- amino acid in the second N-terminal position on the fragmentation pattern in matrix assisted laser desorption time-of-flight spectrometry (MALDI-TOF/TOF MS) strongly depends on the peptide sequence. Stereosensitive fragmentation (SF) is correlated to a neighborhood effect, but the d- residue also exerts an overall effect influencing distant bonds. In a fingerprint analysis, multiple peaks can thus serve to identify the chirality of a sample in short time and potentially high throughput. Problematic variations between individual spots could be successfully suppressed by cospotting deuterated analogues of the epimers. By identifying the [d-Leu2] isomer of the predicted peptide GH-2 (gene derived bombininH) in skin secretions of the toad Bombina orientalis, we demonstrated the analytical power of SF-MALDI-TOF/TOF measurements. In conclusion, SF-MALDI-TOF/TOF MS combines high sensitivity, versatility, and the ability to complement other methods.
Several biologically active peptides contain a d- amino acid in a well-defined position, which is position 2 in all peptide epimers isolated to date from vertebrates and also some from invertebrates. The detection of such D- residues by standard analytical techniques is challenging. In tandem mass spectrometric (MS) analysis, although fragment masses are the same for all stereoisomers, peak intensities are known to depend on chirality. Here, we observe that the effect of a d- amino acid in the second N-terminal position on the fragmentation pattern in matrix assisted laser desorption time-of-flight spectrometry (MALDI-TOF/TOF MS) strongly depends on the peptide sequence. Stereosensitive fragmentation (SF) is correlated to a neighborhood effect, but the d- residue also exerts an overall effect influencing distant bonds. In a fingerprint analysis, multiple peaks can thus serve to identify the chirality of a sample in short time and potentially high throughput. Problematic variations between individual spots could be successfully suppressed by cospotting deuterated analogues of the epimers. By identifying the [d-Leu2] isomer of the predicted peptide GH-2 (gene derived bombininH) in skin secretions of the toad Bombina orientalis, we demonstrated the analytical power of SF-MALDI-TOF/TOF measurements. In conclusion, SF-MALDI-TOF/TOF MS combines high sensitivity, versatility, and the ability to complement other methods.
Bioactive peptides
are involved in numerous biological functions
and serve important functions as hormones and neuropeptides for cellular
signaling, as secretory peptides for interspecies communication, or
as peptide toxins as well as defense peptides against microbes and
predatory animals.[1] For the understanding
of all of these processes, the knowledge and analysis of their primary
structure is essential. In consequence, an array of adequate techniques
such as amino acid analysis or tandem MS sequencing is available,
which allows for the routine determination of amino acid sequences
and the majority of chemical modifications. Some peptides, however,
carry a perfidiously unsuspicious post-translational modification
that is not readily detected by standard analytical measurements.
In these peptides and some proteins, the dogma of ubiquitous protein
homochirality is violated by a single d- amino acid substitution.
In some cases, a d- residue in peptide linkage can result
from age-dependent racemization.[2] However,
during peptide biosynthesis, which is completely unrelated to aging,
the d- amino acid is generated from the corresponding l-isomer present within the precursor polypeptide by the action
of peptidyl-aminoacyl-l/d-isomerases. Interestingly,
all l/d-isomerases studied to date from vertebrates
act exclusively on the second N-terminal amino acid residue.[3−7] The first peptide, which was found to be processed by such an enzyme,
was dermorphin isolated from the skin of a South American tree frog.[8] Further, the discovery of dermorphin as well
as the related deltorphins[9] was facilitated
by the striking effect of the d- residue on biological activity
(i.e., the all-l peptides were inactive). By contrast, more
subtle effects were observed in other vertebrate peptides, for which
a natural form with a d- amino acid exists as well, for example,
the bombinins H from frog skin,[10] and,
interestingly, a C-type natriuretic peptide and a β-defensin-like
peptide from the venom of male platypus, a primitive mammal.[11,12]The analysis of d- amino acids within polypeptides
poses
a challenge,[13] mainly due to two limitations:
first, although Edman degradation gives rise to chiral phenylthiohydantoin
amino acid derivatives, for the resolution of the enantiomers, chiral
media are required;[14] second, stereoisomerisation
does not lead to any detectable mass differences. Moreover, fragment
masses are identical for all stereoisomers in tandem MS experiments,
which nowadays is the commonly used sequencing method. However, recent
findings suggest that the stereochemistry of the backbone, modulates
fragment ion abundances, which can be expressed by the so-called chiral
recognition factor (Rchiral, henceforth
referred to as R).[15]R is calculated for a pair of fragment ion peaks i,j according
the formulas given in the Methods section. Early successful applications
of MS/MS to identify peptide epimers using collision-induced dissociation
(CID) comprise peptides with up to four residues,[15,16] and, later, segments of ω-agatoxin IVB and C, and Aβ(17–29)
with a focus on serine epimerization after metal complexation.[17] In an alternative approach, electron capture
dissociation (ECD) fragmentation was applied to dermorphin and another
small protein, the 20-residue Trp-cage.[18] In the case of the Trp-cage, the fragmentation pattern was found
to be sensitive also to the tertiary structure. Recently, radical-directed
dissociation (RDD) yielded a respectable chiral discrimination when
applied to dermorphin and to peptides containing d-Ala, d-Ser, or d-Asp.[19] A recent
identification of crustacean hyperglycemia hormones (CHHs) epimers
was achieved by using ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) analysis of
MS-generated epimeric fragment ions.[20] Most
promising results were obtained by application of matrix assisted
laser desorption time-of-flight spectrometry (MALDI-MS/MS) metastable
decay–CID to dermorphin as well as a heptapeptide derived from
the sequence of natural HIV isoforms with a d- residue in
varying positions (residue 2, 3, or 5).[21] MALDI-MS/MS yielded good results when validated with several short
molluskan peptides (3–5 residues) and could be combined with
direct measurement in Aplysia neurons.[22,23] However, given several successful examples of d- amino
acid identification using MS techniques, stereoselective fragmentation,
and the impact of residues adjacent to d- amino acids are
still poorly understood.In this study, we systematically explored
the sequence dependence
of the stereoselective fragmentation propensity in MALDI-TOF/TOF metastable
decay–CID experiments. We focused on model peptides with a
single d- amino acid residue in position 2 as peptides bearing
an inversion of backbone chirality at this position might be of highest
biological significance in vertebrates.[24] We investigated the effect of different d- residues in
position 2 as well as the modulating effect of the nearest neighbor
residues on the fragmentation pattern. Our data suggest that the stereosensitivity
is highly sequence-dependent and can be indeed of practical use for
the analysis of a varity of peptide sequences. As a major experimental
improvement, the investigation of stereoisomers with unfavorable R became feasible by using a deuterated analogue of the
suspected epimeric candidate. As a proof-of-concept, we were able
to confirm the presence of a d- residue in a predicted peptide
from frog skin secretions by means of SF-MALDI-TOF/TOF MS.
Experimental
Procedures
Peptide Synthesis
Peptides were synthesized on a continuous-flow
synthesizer using standard Fmoc solid-phase chemistry with a Rink
Amide AM resin (200–400 mesh, 0.62 meqg–1; Nova-Biochem), PyBOP (benzotriazol-1-yloxytripyrrolidinophosphonium
hexafluorophosphate) as condensation reagent, and N-methylmorpholine as a base. After cleavage, peptides were derivatized
with iodoacetamide and purified by reverse-phase high-performance
liquid chromatography (HPLC) over a C-18 column (Vydac) with a linear
gradient of acetonitrile (solvent A, 0.1% TFA; solvent B, 80% acetonitrile).
N-Fmoc-Val-d8 (N-(9-fluorenylmethoxycarbonyl)-l-valine-2,3,4,4,4,5,5,5-d8) was from Aldrich.
MALDI-TOF/TOF
Mass Spectrometry
Samples were analyzed
on a MALDI-TOF/TOF 4800 analyzer (ABSciex, Framingham, MA) operated
in reflector positive mode acquiring 3000 total shots per spectrum
with a fixed laser intensity set at 5000. Experiments were carried
out using α-cyano hydroxyl cinnamic acid (5 mg/mL in 50% (v/v)
acetonitrile) as matrix. Each sample (0.3–0.5 μL) was
mixed with 2–3 μL of matrix, and then 0.5 μL of
the mixture was spotted on the target plate. Tandem MS experiments
were carried out using a 1 kV method with and without collision-induced
dissociation using air as collision gas and metastable suppression
enabled. Spectra were acquired and processed using the 4800 Analyzer
and Data Explorer Software. In most cases, when loss of water peaks
were observed, peak areas a were combined with their
parent ion peaks. Compared to PSD, the application of CID favored
multiple fragmentations and, in such a way, complicated data analysis.R matrices were generated for each compound according
to formulas Ri,j = (ri,j)/(ri,j) and ri,j = (ai/aj). Thereby, a are the peak areas of two chosen fragment ions i and j
in a spectrum of epimer l or d, respectively. ri,j were averaged from three spectra, each of
a different spot. For practical purposes, these matrices can be inspected
for maximum values without further processing.
Isolation of Peptide GH-2
Skin secretions from Bombina orientalis were collected as described[3] and passed
through a Centricon filter retaining
proteins with a mass of >10 kDa. The filtrate was fractionated
over
a 218TP C-18 column (Vydac, Hesperia, CA) with a gradient of acetonitrile
(solvent A, 0.1% TFA; solvent B, 80% acetonitrile in solvent A). Fractions
yielding a mass peak matching the calculated mass of GH-2 peptide
were dried in the SpeedVac, subjected to endoproteinase Asp-N (Sequencing
grade, Sigma) cleavage in 100 mM NH4HCO3 buffer,
pH 8.5, and were rechromatographed under the same conditions.
Results
In our experimental approach, we applied MALDI-TOF/TOF metastable
decay/CID to a series of epimeric pairs of heptapeptides templated
on the N-terminal portion of bombinin H (H-IIGPVLGLVGSALGGLLKKI-NH2), which contained single amino acid substitutions within
the N-terminal tripeptide (Table ). Previous investigations by means of CD and proton
NMR in solution made it unlikely that those peptides adopt any extensive
secondary or tertiary structures,[25,26] which might
bias the effect of the primary structure. However, in the MALDI-TOF/TOF
experiments, more serious distortions of the results are known to
arise from the considerable, method-inherent spot-to-spot variations.
Therefore, peak area ratios rij = ai/aj instead of
peak areas ai were averaged after assigning
fragment ions to the mass. The rij values
were then found to be satisfactorily reproducible with a mean deviation
of typically no more than 10% (within one series of measurements).
For the interpretation of fragmentation spectra, all peaks with a
relative peak intensity of >5% were considered. From these data,
a
matrix consisting of all possible chiral recognition factors (i.e.,
involving all possible pairs of fragments i,j) was generated for each
pair of epimers. In the following sections (Table , Figure , and Figure S-1), i and
j were arbitrarily assigned to yield Ri,j ≥ 1 for comparison of the strength of the chiral effect.
Please note that |log10Ri,j | = |log10Rj,i | For demonstration
of the chiral effect, spectra of two epimers are shown in Figure .
Table 1
Peptide Epimers Tested by MALDI-TOF/TOF-MSa
Ċ denotes S-carbamidomethyl-cysteine. Upper values denote R for a given fragment i averaged over all fragments j.
Lower values
in brackets denote the obtained maximum R for a given
fragment i. When marked by an asterisk, the data for Y-ions are given
instead of y-ions.
Figure 1
Fragmentation scheme
of model heptapeptides templated on the N-terminal
heptapeptide of bombininH epimers H2 and H4. Fragments in MALDI-TOF/TOF
derived from cleavages in the neighborhood of the epimerized residue
are indicated (according to the nomenclature by Roepstorff and Johnson
et al.[46,47]). (A) R matrices of wild-type
bombininH, R1,2 = CH(CH3)CH2CH3 (Ile), R3 = H (Gly).
(B) III demonstrates the impact of residue 3. (C) R matrices of alanine-scanning mutated heptapeptide. (D) R matrices for selected peptides: GIG demonstrates non-neighborhood
SF. All R matrices are shown in Supplementary Figure S-1. Indices i,j are always assigned
yielding R ≥ 1.
Figure 2
MALDI-MS/MS spectra of peptide epimers IIG (corresponding to wild-type
bombininH) and III demonstrate differences in fragmentation patterns.
Resulting R matrices are shown in Figure A and B, Figure S-1-1 and Figure.S-1-18.
Ċ denotes S-carbamidomethyl-cysteine. Upper values denote R for a given fragment i averaged over all fragments j.
Lower values
in brackets denote the obtained maximum R for a given
fragment i. When marked by an asterisk, the data for Y-ions are given
instead of y-ions.Fragmentation scheme
of model heptapeptides templated on the N-terminal
heptapeptide of bombininH epimers H2 and H4. Fragments in MALDI-TOF/TOF
derived from cleavages in the neighborhood of the epimerized residue
are indicated (according to the nomenclature by Roepstorff and Johnson
et al.[46,47]). (A) R matrices of wild-type
bombininH, R1,2 = CH(CH3)CH2CH3 (Ile), R3 = H (Gly).
(B) III demonstrates the impact of residue 3. (C) R matrices of alanine-scanning mutated heptapeptide. (D) R matrices for selected peptides: GIG demonstrates non-neighborhood
SF. All R matrices are shown in Supplementary Figure S-1. Indices i,j are always assigned
yielding R ≥ 1.MALDI-MS/MS spectra of peptide epimers IIG (corresponding to wild-type
bombininH) and III demonstrate differences in fragmentation patterns.
Resulting R matrices are shown in Figure A and B, Figure S-1-1 and Figure.S-1-18.
Alanine Scan and the Impact of a Chiral Neighborhood
Initially,
we applied a partial alanine-scan on the wild-type peptide
to delineate contributions from certain residues within the N-terminal
tripeptide to the fragmentation propensities and as such to the preference
between alternative fragmentation pathways (Figure ).The replacement of the Ile or D-allo-Ile
in position 2 by an Ala or d-Ala, respectively, lead to decreased R values of no more than 1.5 when compared to wild-type
(R values of up to 2.6) in the MS/MS experiments
(Figure and Figure S-1). This observation indicates that
the side-chain composition in position 2 is indeed important for chiral
discrimination. Remarkably, when Gly-3 was replaced by an Ala, R values up to and above 6 (Rb6/y6) were observed. Conversely, the substitution of Ile-1 by an Ala
had only little to no effect on the fragmentation pattern. The contribution
of residues 4–7 was not investigated here.
General Substitutions
and the Abstraction of Fragmentation Rules
Next, we extended
these experiments to more general substitutions
within the N-terminal tripeptide (Table ). The resulting R matrices
are listed in Figure S-1. Stereoselective
fragmentation could often be attributed to contributions by single
fragment ions, which were rated by calculation of average R based on above matrices.The residue in position
2 crucially influences chiral recognition, whereby a major chiral
recognition is contributed by fragments a2, b2, or z5. The average R (Table ) values for those fragments can be ranked in the order I, F > S, E > A > K. Thereby, peptides with amino
acid residues
I, F, and S gave rise to R values above 2 (Figure S-1-1 and Figures S-1-8–12). When
a Lys was in this position, stereoselectivity was nearly fully diminished
(maximum peak Rz5/y4 = 1.20). For high R, bulky hydrocarbon chains without charged functional group
may thus be advantageous.A replacement of the achiral Gly in
position 3 by any other amino
acid drastically enhanced the chiral effect. Stereochemistry was then
best reported by the y6 fragment ion, which gave rise to R values in the order I > F, A > D, S > K ≫ G (Table and Figure S-1-13–18). For example, an Ile in position 3 yielded R values up to and above 9 (see Figure B and Figure S-1-18). The presence of functional groups in side chains seems to decrease R values.The N-terminal residue had comparably little
effect on the stereoselectivity.
Nevertheless, polar residues (S, E) enhanced stereosensitivity in particular of fragment y5, whereas
the Lys-peptide gave rise to Y6 and Y7 fragments with high R values (and only those), albeit with an extraordinary
high error of up to 40% (Table and Figure S-1-2–7).Please note that, whereas residue effects on fragmentation are
well-known, stereoselectivity is an additional, yet naturally not
entirely independent effect on fragmentation preferences. In fact,
any of the gas-phase reactions involved in fragmentation may be, but
not necessarily are, stereospecific.[27,28]
Isolation of
GH-2 Epimers from Bombina Skin Secretions
For the isolation of GH-2,[29] crude B. orientalis skin
secretions were prefractionated by ultrafiltration through a 10 kDa
centricon filter. The below-10 kDa fraction (filtrate) was fractionated
by semipreparative RP-HPLC, which yielded about 40 major peaks (Figure A). By MALDI-MS analysis,
a mass corresponding to the predicted peptide GH-2 ([MH]+observed = 2143.5) was found at retention times 25.0 and
27.2 min, respectively. These matched the retention times of synthetic
peptide epimers of GH-2. MS/MS produced fragmentation patterns, which
were consistent with the sequence of GH-2 (H-ILGPVLDLVGRALRGLLKKI-NH2) (Figure S-2). Visual inspection
did not show differences in fragment ion abundances between the epimers;
subtle variations became apparent in a detailed investigation of the
spectra, however (data not shown). The fraction containing the putative
epimer was subjected to endoproteinase Asp-N cleavage, and the resulting
peptides were purified to homogeneity (Figure B). A mass corresponding to the N-terminal
peptide GH-2(1-6) (H-ILGPVL–OH) was detected at retention time
of 17.6 min. This matched the retention time of the synthetic d-peptide epimer, whereas the all-l epimer eluted at
13.9 min.
Figure 3
Analysis scheme of natural GH-2 peptide. (A) RP-chromatogram of
prefractionized Bombina skin secretions.
The fraction containing the putative GH-2 epimer (arrow) was subjected
to endoproteinase Asp-N cleavage. (B) RP-chromatograms of the enzyme
digest (above) and synthetic peptides (below). Arrows denote the positions
of the epimers. Peak area of [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) in the sample
corresponds to 0.5 μg.
Analysis scheme of natural GH-2 peptide. (A) RP-chromatogram of
prefractionized Bombina skin secretions.
The fraction containing the putative GH-2 epimer (arrow) was subjected
to endoproteinase Asp-N cleavage. (B) RP-chromatograms of the enzyme
digest (above) and synthetic peptides (below). Arrows denote the positions
of the epimers. Peak area of [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) in the sample
corresponds to 0.5 μg.
Confirmation of the d- Form by Application of a Deuterated
Analogue
In MALDI MS/MS experiments, GH-2(1-6) epimers yielded
only three major peaks and stereoselective fragment pairs with R values no higher than 2 (Figure ). We therefore aimed to improve the quality
of the data by eliminating the experimental spot-to-spot variations.
For this purpose, we compared MS/MS results of GH-2(1-6) with cospotted
deuterated analogue GH-2(1-6)-d8. We found that the mean deviations
of Ry3/y4 and Rz4/y3, for example, were reduced by more than 80% when compared to R values obtained from these peptides spotted on different
targets. This fact indicates that the spot-to-spot variations indeed
contribute significantly to the experimental error of up to 20%.
Figure 4
CID-MALDI-TOF/TOF spectra of natural [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6)
(fraction 17.6 min in chromatogram Figure B) and cospotted deuterated synthetic GH-2(1-6)-d8
(panel A) or [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) epimers (panel B). The ratio
of sample to standards was 1:1.
When applied to natural GH-2(1-6), the sample was cospotted either
with GH-2(1-6)-d8 or with [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6)-d8 (Figure ). Peak area ratios
from fragment pairs of the sample were directly compared to those
of the corresponding peaks of the d8-standard (Figure ). For example, calculation of ratios between rz4/y3 of sample and GH-2(1-6)-d8 yielded 2.1
(taken from MS/MS spectra without CID), which is within the error
range of Rz4/y3 = 2.0 ± 0.1. By contrast, the ratios
between sample and [d-Leu-2]-GH-2(1-6)-d8 gave a value close
to one, which indicates stereochemical identity and thus confirms
the d- residue. The results for selected nonredundant fragment
pairs are depicted in Figure .
Figure 5
Quantitative evaluation of peak intensities in MALDI-TOF/TOF confirms
the natural GH-2(1-6) epimer. Experimental conditions without applying
CID (A) and with CID (mass spectra are shown in Figure B. Peak ratios for samples cospotted with
deuterated d8-[d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) (R = ri,j,sample/ri,j,d8-D, open
circles) are shown. Gray bars denote areas of high confidence for
the positive prediction of an epimeric peptide in this experiment,
as determined by cospotting [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) with deuterated
d8-[d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) (empty squares). Their proximate borders
were defined by the mean deviance (n = 3) in these
experiments (represented by whiskers). In a complementary experiment,
peak ratios for sample cospotted with deuterated d8-GH-2(1-6) (R = ri,j,d8-L/ri,j,sample, filled circles) were determined. Orange bars denote areas of high
confidence for the positive prediction of an epimeric peptide, as
determined by cospotted deuterated d8-GH-2(1-6) and [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6)
(filled squares). The latter ratios represent the R values. In these data sets, log10(R)
for sample cospotted with deuterated [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) are
close to zero, whereas ratios for sample cospotted with deuterated
GH-2(1-6) correlate with the respective R values,
confirming the presence of [d-Leu2] in the sample.
CID-MALDI-TOF/TOF spectra of natural [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6)
(fraction 17.6 min in chromatogram Figure B) and cospotted deuterated synthetic GH-2(1-6)-d8
(panel A) or [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) epimers (panel B). The ratio
of sample to standards was 1:1.Quantitative evaluation of peak intensities in MALDI-TOF/TOF confirms
the natural GH-2(1-6) epimer. Experimental conditions without applying
CID (A) and with CID (mass spectra are shown in Figure B. Peak ratios for samples cospotted with
deuterated d8-[d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) (R = ri,j,sample/ri,j,d8-D, open
circles) are shown. Gray bars denote areas of high confidence for
the positive prediction of an epimeric peptide in this experiment,
as determined by cospotting [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) with deuterated
d8-[d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) (empty squares). Their proximate borders
were defined by the mean deviance (n = 3) in these
experiments (represented by whiskers). In a complementary experiment,
peak ratios for sample cospotted with deuterated d8-GH-2(1-6) (R = ri,j,d8-L/ri,j,sample, filled circles) were determined. Orange bars denote areas of high
confidence for the positive prediction of an epimeric peptide, as
determined by cospotted deuterated d8-GH-2(1-6) and [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6)
(filled squares). The latter ratios represent the R values. In these data sets, log10(R)
for sample cospotted with deuterated [d-Leu2]-GH-2(1-6) are
close to zero, whereas ratios for sample cospotted with deuterated
GH-2(1-6) correlate with the respective R values,
confirming the presence of [d-Leu2] in the sample.
Discussion
In
a search for new peptides, extracts from organic tissues are
typically crudely fractionated according to size or charge and subsequently
subjected to RP-HPLC, which provides both high-resolution separations
as well as the removal of excess of undesirable alkali salts, which
may obscure the mass spectra of peptides by the formation of adducts.
In principle, RP-HPLC can provide separation of epimeric peptides;
their resolution, however, depends on the hydrophobicities of the d- residue and its nearest neighbors.[30] In consequence, the observation of a peptide mass appearing in several
HPLC peaks may hint toward the presence of epimeric forms albeit other
explanations may be likely as well. Moreover, a false positive epimer
identification may occur during the highly sensitive MALDI-MS analysis
because of detection of traces of the all-l peptide tailing
after its actual peak, which often elutes prior to the epimer. At
that stage of analysis, additional evidence from other stereosensitive
methods is appreciated. Recently, MALDI-MS/MS metastable decay–CID
was proposed as an analytical tool, not only for sequence determination
but also for the detection of epimeric peptides in biological samples.[21] Whereas earlier studies suggested that the position
of the d- residue within the peptide chain is a decisive
factor for the obtained chiral recognition, we were particularly interested
in the effect exerted by the sequence context in peptides with a d- residue in position two (where, however, stereosensitive
fragmentation patterns were recently gained only after N-terminal
acetylation[21]). Indeed, as of today, in
all vertebrate and several invertebrate peptides the d- amino
acid is the second residue of the mature product, whereas it has also
been found in other positions in invertebrates.[31−38]As a first step in dissecting the positional effect from the
sequence
context, we performed an Ala scan on the N-terminal heptapeptide of
bombinin H wild-type, a natural substrate of the Bombina
variegatal/d-isomerase (Figure ). Alanine, the most
simple but yet chiral amino acid, provides a plain methyl residue
for moderate interaction with its nearest neighbors at the site of
substitution. At the epimerization site, the substitution of a bulky
Ile, (leading to the sequence Ile-Ala or Ile-d-Ala, respectively)
is accompanied by a loss of potential steric interactions and results
in a considerable drop in stereosensitivity. The same substitution
in the neighboring position 1 simply generates the reversed sequence
Ala-Ile or Ala-d-allo-Ile but, surprisingly, only leads to
an indistinct change in the pattern in the R matrix.
At position 3, the other nearest neighbor, the substitution of Gly
leads to a remarkable increase in R values. Indeed,
glycine is achiral and devoid of a side chain, which could provide
any chiral interactions with adjacent residues.These findings
reveal a differential position effect, which necessarily
results from placing the racemized amino acid residue between a long
C-terminal chain and only one N-terminal amino acid. At position 3,
the achiral and highly flexible glycine apparently supports an equal
distribution of the kinetic energy independent of the stereochemistry
along the polypeptide chain. As such, the native sequence of Bombinin
H represents an exceptional setup.Peptides with amino acid
substitutions other than Ala within the
N-terminal tripeptide (Table ) gave rise to results consistent with the general trend yet
with subtle variations and revealed a complex sequence dependency.
As a rule of thumb, stereochemistry is readily reported by the y6
fragment ions. If there is a glycine in position 3, fragments a2,
b2, or y5 (in some cases Y5 or Y6) are reporters. In conclusion, gas-phase
disruption of amide bonds between the potential d- residue
and its nearest neighbors (Figure ) is under direct chiral control, and, moreover, cleavages
at those bonds are mediated by side-chain interactions.In many
cases, however, we observed that fragment ions derived
from breakage sites distant from the d- residue contributed
significantly to chiral recognition. This is most evident in the peptide
GIG, when the d- residue is embedded in an achiral environment,
because both flanking residues are glycines (Figure ). R values from neighborhood
fragmentations were as low as approximately 1.2, which is consistent
with the achiral environment in view of the above findings. Nevertheless,
an average R of 1.77 was observed for fragment a5
comprising maxima such as Ry4/a5 = 1.96
± 0.05 and Ry6/a5 = 2.14 ± 0.11
(Figure S-1-2). These findings suggest
that factors employing chiral interactions other than a neighborhood
effect influence the stability of bonds elsewhere in the chain and
thus affect the fragmentation propensities in the gas phase in dependence
on the stereochemistry in position 2. An important factor is possibly
the overall conformation, which is known to affect the fragmentation
pattern[18])In consequence of the
above findings, neighborhood fragmentations
are a good starting point for the determination of chirality when
facing an unknown sample. Single R values may already
suffice in case of peptides with a Phe in position 3 (Figure D and Figure.S-1-13), as found in several natural neuropeptide families,[39] for example. However, long-range fragmentations
may also serve as feasible reporters. Those probably arise from conformational
preferences and are as such difficult to predict by general rules
but may be recognized by a classifier program. So, from a more practical
point of view, combining R values derived from multiple
nonredundant fragment ions (i.e., a fingerprint analysis) can serve
to increase the confidence in this interpretation. Indeed, this strategy
turned out to be effective in the case of the natural epimer [d-Leu2]-GH2 described below (Figure ).Conversely, from the experimental
point of view, spot-to-spot variations
are a major source of error and well-known to complicate or even prevent
quantitative investigations.[40] We could
achieve a substantial improvement by the use of on-spot reference
peptides carrying a deuterium label for the first time in the analysis
of peptide epimers. These are fragmented under the very conditions
of the particular spot but appear in a different mass window, and
the resulting spectra of sample and standard can be compared directly.Finally, we combined these improvements in data acquisition and
interpretation when analyzing a real sample. Starting from Bombina skin secretions, we followed the analytical
strategy as outlined in Figure to isolate gene-derived bombininH-2 (GH-2).[29] The epimeric form of this peptide has been predicted, yet
to our knowledge not been confirmed at the peptide level. In the present
paper, evidence for natural [d-Leu-2]-GH-2 was provided by
(i) the retention time of full-length [d-Leu-2]-GH-2 in RP
chromatograms with the expected mass and fragmentation pattern in
MALDI-TOF/TOF, (ii) the retention time of a proteolytically generated
fragment [d-Leu-2]-GH-2(1-6) with the expected mass, and
(iii) a quantitative fragmentation pattern implicating analysis of
multiple ri,j values in MALDI-TOF/TOF
consistent with cospotted deuterated [d-Leu-2]-GH-2(1-6)
(Figure ). Beside
the advantage of additional verification steps, the incorporation
of an endoproteinase step into the processing scheme (Figure ) opens the field for the chiral
analysis of proteins.[41]
Conclusions
MALDI-TOF/TOF-mass spectrometry is a suitable tool to identify
the presence of a d- residue in natural peptides at position
2. In particular, it may effectively be used in the investigation
of all peptides, where the existence of epimeric forms has been suggested.[29] A few of these possess a favorable sequence,
which can be expected to yield high R values in MS/MS
experiments, such as some neuropeptides of the RFamide family (which
contain Phe in position 2; Figure D and Figure.S-1-13). For
the majority of peptides, however, this is probably not the case,
and their analysis will benefit from the use of a cospotted deuterated
reference. This group comprises several ranalexins, temporins 1DYa
and PTa, and brevenins 1PTa and 1PTb from diverse Rana species,[42,43] as well as the amyloidogenic
dermaseptin-like peptide aDrs from the skin of Pachymedusa
dacnicolor, a tree frog from southern Mexico,[44] where the d- residue acts as a switch
between different superstructure architectures of amyloid.[45] In higher mammals, LAP (lingual antimicrobial
peptide), β-defensins 2 and 8 from cattle, the human peptide
LL-37, as well as the insulin B chain (from frog, cattle, and man)
could be isomerase substrates at least under certain conditions. This
compilation of potential natural epimers is certainly not exclusive
due to several necessary compromises. For example, predictions relied
on the mature N-termini as they are given in the data banks. However,
due to alternative processing, the N-termini may vary and need to
be experimentally confirmed, which in many cases has not been done.
Many more epimeric peptides might exist, even such with a known precursor
sequence. We have demonstrated here that stereosensitive fragmentation
MALDI-MS/MS has the potential for a future use in high-through-put
peptide screening for new epimeric peptides, where the d-
residue crucially affects receptor interactions, folding propensities
or polypeptide turnover.
Authors: Allan M Torres; Ian Menz; Paul F Alewood; Paramjit Bansal; Jelle Lahnstein; Clifford H Gallagher; Philip W Kuchel Journal: FEBS Lett Date: 2002-07-31 Impact factor: 4.124
Authors: S D Heck; C J Siok; K J Krapcho; P R Kelbaugh; P F Thadeio; M J Welch; R D Williams; A H Ganong; M E Kelly; A J Lanzetti Journal: Science Date: 1994-11-11 Impact factor: 47.728
Authors: Itamar Livnat; Hua-Chia Tai; Erik T Jansson; Lu Bai; Elena V Romanova; Ting-Ting Chen; Ke Yu; Song-An Chen; Yan Zhang; Zheng-Yang Wang; Dan-Dan Liu; Klaudiusz R Weiss; Jian Jing; Jonathan V Sweedler Journal: Anal Chem Date: 2016-11-10 Impact factor: 6.986