Phenotypes, Risk Factors, and Mechanisms of Adult-Onset Asthma.

Asthma is a heterogeneous disease with many phenotypes, and age at disease onset is an important factor in separating the phenotypes. Genetic factors, atopy, and early respiratory tract infections are well-recognized factors predisposing to childhood-onset asthma. Adult-onset asthma is more often associated with obesity, smoking, depression, or other life-style or environmental factors, even though genetic factors and respiratory tract infections may also play a role in adult-onset disease. Adult-onset asthma is characterized by absence of atopy and is often severe requiring treatment with high dose of inhaled and/or oral steroids. Variety of risk factors and nonatopic nature of adult-onset disease suggest that variety of mechanisms is involved in the disease pathogenesis and that these mechanisms differ from the pathobiology of childhood-onset asthma with prevailing Th2 airway inflammation. Recognition of the mechanisms and mediators that drive the adult-onset disease helps to develop novel strategies for the treatment. The aim of this review was to summarize the current knowledge on the pathogenesis of adult-onset asthma and to concentrate on the mechanisms and mediators involved in establishing adult-onset asthma in response to specific risk factors. We also discuss the involvement of these mechanisms in the currently recognized phenotypes of adult-onset asthma.

1. Introduction

During the last decade, asthma has been revealed as a heterogeneous disease manifesting in many distinct phenotypes. Age at asthma onset has emerged as a critical factor in distinguishing these phenotypes. Patients with early-onset asthma are typically atopic with family history of atopy or asthma, Th2-predominant inflammation, good responsiveness to glucocorticoids, and good prognosis [1, 2]. In contrast, patients with adult- or late-onset asthma are most often nonatopic females without a family history of asthma or atopy and with less favourable prognosis and are more likely to develop persistent airflow limitation [3-8]. Even though majority of asthma is thought to be developed during childhood, this has been challenged recently by showing that, in the United States, adult-onset asthma is the dominant phenotype in women from 40 years of age [9].

Factors predisposing to adult-onset asthma include female sex, obesity, occupational exposure, rhinitis, respiratory infections, smoking, stressful life events, and low level of lung function [10-13] suggesting that adult-onset asthma may develop through a variety of mechanisms. This review aims to summarize the current knowledge on the pathogenesis of adult-onset asthma, concentrating on the known risk factors and on the mechanisms of how these factors might be involved in establishing asthma. We discuss the differences in the pathogenesis of adult-onset when compared to childhood-onset disease. We start by combining the information on cluster analyses identifying adult-onset asthma phenotypes, to enable association of the pathogenetic mechanisms with phenotypes, if possible.

2. Phenotypes of Adult-Onset Asthma

By combining information from cluster analyses concentrating on patients with adult-onset asthma [3] and of those including also patients with childhood-onset asthma [14-19], at least five different subtypes of late- or adult-onset asthma could be extracted (Figure 1 and Table 1). Even though plenty of resemblance was found regarding a phenotype obtained by different studies (e.g., obesity or eosinophil-predominant inflammation), also differences existed, reflecting most likely diversity of the study populations and techniques used, for example, differences in ethnicity, disease severity, method of recruitment, variables available, and variables included in the analysis. Whenever BMI was included as an input variable in cluster analysis, an obesity-related group was extracted, with the exception of Asian patient populations, where obesity is rare [14, 20]. Also exclusion or inclusion of smokers creates heterogenic results. Prevalence of smoking is generally high in many Asian populations and inclusion of smokers was nonrestricted in the two Asian analyses. A “smoking asthma” cluster was identified in a Korean analysis [14], whereas two clusters with higher rates of smoking were identified in a Japanese analysis (severe and moderate disease) [20]. The patients with moderate asthma were speculated to be more resistant to the effects of smoking [20]. Inclusion of smokers was limited in most US and European analyses, and thus “smoking asthma” clusters could not be identified.

Figure 1

Currently identified phenotypes of adult/late-onset asthma based on published cluster analysis studies. ICS = inhaled corticosteroid, NSAID = nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug, OCS = oral corticosteroid, and FEV1 = forced expiratory volume in 1 second.

Table 1

Background information of cluster analyses including characterization of phenotypes of adult-onset asthma.

Study	Patient n	Duration of asthma (mean/median years)	Patients with early-onset asthma included∗	Severity levels included	Major comorbidities (other than rhinitis/atopy) included as input or outcome variables	Smokers included	Other exclusion criteria	Study setting  CS = cross-sectional  L = longitudinal (time followed)	Variables related to biomarkers included in cluster analysis
Haldar et al. 2008 [16]	(a) 184  (b) 187  (c) 68	NR	Yes	(a) Mild-to-moderate, (b-c) refractory	(b) Scores for anxiety (input), depression and hyperventilation syndrome	Ex-smokers with <10 pack-years	(c) Therapy nonadherence	(a-b) CS  (c) L (1 year)	Sputum eosinophil count
Moore et al. 2010 [15]	(d) 726	22	Yes	All	Aspirin sensitivity/polyps, pneumonia/bronchitis, sinus disease, GERD, and hypertension (all input, included in composite variables)	Ex-smokers with <5 pack-years	Age below 12 years	CS	None
Siroux et al. 2011 [19]	(e) 1895  (f) 641	NR	Yes	All	Eczema (input)	Yes	(e) Age below 20 years  (f) Children	CS (population-based)	Total IgE
Amelink et al. 2013 [3]	(g) 200	10	No	All	NSAID sensitivity (input), history of nasal polyposis, and reflux symptoms/medication	Yes if ≥12% FEV1 reversibility after salbutamol inhalation and normal diffusion capacity.	Respiratory symptoms or chronic lung diseases during childhood, other pulmonary diseases, or nonrelated major comorbidities, pregnancy.	CS	Sputum eosinophils, total IgE
Kim et al. 2013 [14]	(h) 724  (i) 1843	NR	Yes	All	None	Yes	(h) Subjects with destroyed lungs, bronchiectasis or lung resection, age below 18 years  (i) age below 18 years	(h) L (1 year)  (i) CS	None
Newby et al. 2014 [17]	(j) 349	NR	Yes	Severe refractory	Scores for anxiety and depression, reflux history, nasal polyps, and eczema	Yes	NR	L (median 3 years)	Blood eosinophil count, total IgE
Schatz et al. 2014 [18]	(k) 3612	NR	Yes	Difficult-to-treat asthma (all)	Aspirin sensitivity, atopic dermatitis (input)	Yes, smoking history ≤30 pack-years	(k) Age below 12 years	L (1 year)	Total IgE
Kaneko et al. 2013 [20]	(l) 880	NR	Yes	All	None	Yes	NR	CS	Total IgE

NR = not reported, GERD = gastroesophageal reflux disease, NSAID = nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug, and FEV1 = forced expiratory volume in 1 second. (a), (b), and (c) Patients recruited from several different studies and sources (a = primary care, b = secondary care, c = data from a prospective clinical study), (d) SARP = the Severe Asthma Research Network, (e) ECRHSII = European Community Respiratory Health Survey, (f) EGEA2 = Epidemiological Study on the Genetics and Environment of Asthma, (g) patients recruited from hospitals in Amsterdam, (h) COREA = Cohort for Reality and Evolution of Adult Asthma in Korea, (i) SCH = Korean asthma cohort of Soonchunhyang University Asthma Genome Research Centre, (j) patients from British Thoracic Society Severe Refractory Asthma Registry, (k) TENOR = The Epidemiology and Natural History of Asthma: Outcomes and Treatment Regimens, and (l) patients recruited from University of Tsukuba Hospital, Hokkaido University Hospital, or their affiliated hospitals, Japan. Defined as age at onset <18 years.

Aspirin sensitivity was included as a separate cluster-defining variable in only two studies [3, 18] and the interpretation of the result is complicated by different patient selection. In patients with adult-onset asthma, only prevalence of nasal polyps but not nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) sensitivity was higher in patients with severe asthma when compared to milder disease [21]. In cluster analysis of the same population NSAID sensitivity was most prevalent in the phenotype with the mildest disease [3]. In another study including patients with difficult-to-treat asthma, aspirin-sensitive asthma was clearly extracted as its own phenotype, containing 58% patients with adult-onset asthma, and showed the highest risk for exacerbations and poor control [18]. In a further cluster analysis of the Severe Asthma Research Network (SARP) data including expanded lung data, a phenotype was separated with mostly late-onset asthma, strong history of nasal polyposis, sinusitis, blood and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) eosinophilia, increased blood neutrophil count, poor lung function, and high-dose corticosteroid use [22]. Whether nasal polyps are actually a more separating factor than aspirin sensitivity when identifying clusters remains to be determined. Also few smaller cluster analyses have been carried out, the results being complicated by lack of power [23, 24].

Biological mediators (other than IgE) have been rarely included in the cluster analyses published so far (Table 1), complicating the linking of clinical phenotypes to disease mechanisms. Mediators that could possibly be involved in adult- or late-onset asthma according to the limited evidence currently available are listed in Table 2, with association with a specific phenotype as suggested by the authors of this review. At the moment, periostin seems to be the most widely accepted biomarker. Generally, it is regarded as a biomarker of Th2-associated airway inflammation and predictor of airway eosinophilia and may predict response to anti-IL-13 and anti-IgE antibodies [25]. However, when studied in a population with severe asthma with majority having late-onset disease, it did not differentiate Th2-high and -low asthma but was raised in patients with eosinophilic airway inflammation when compared to mixed granulocytic, and in those with fixed airway limitation [26]. Thereby, in adult-onset asthma it could be used as a biomarker of eosinophilic inflammation-predominant asthma (Table 2).

Table 2

Biological mediators and biomarkers suggested to be involved in adult/late-onset asthma.

Mediator	Level of asthma severity included	Inclusion of patients with adult/late-onset asthma	Main finding concerning the role of mediators in adult/late-onset asthma.	References	Adult/late-onset phenotype with possible significance
Periostin	Severe	80% with late-onset asthma	Higher levels in patients with fixed airflow limitation and eosinophilic inflammation.	Bobolea et al. 2015 [26]	Eosinophilic inflammation-predominant
Eotaxin-2	All	Groups of early- and late-onset asthma compared	Patients with severe asthma showed higher epithelial expression of eotaxin-2. Levels of eotaxin-2 positively correlated with age of asthma onset, sputum eosinophils, and number of exacerbations and negatively correlated with FEV1 % predicted. Among patients with late-onset (but not early-onset) asthma, eotaxin-levels were higher in those with severe asthma. Sputum eosinophilia was more common among patients with late-onset asthma.	Coleman et al. 2012 [114]	Eosinophilic inflammation-predominant
L-arginine/ADMA	Severe	Groups of early- and late-onset asthma compared	Lower L-arginine/ADMA ratio and negative correlation to BMI in late- versus early-onset asthma; may partly explain the inverse relationship between FeNO and BMI. Reduced L-arginine/ADMA ratio associated with reduced IgE and lung volumes, increased respiratory symptoms, and worse quality of life in late- but not early-onset asthma.	Holguin et al. 2013 [75]	Obesity-related asthma
Leptin	All	Obese women with adult-onset asthma	Leptin in visceral fat associated with AHR but not airway inflammation. Adipokine receptor was expressed in airway epithelium suggesting direct effects of adipokines on the airways.	Sideleva et al. 2012 [53]  Leivo-Korpela et al. 2011 [58]	Obesity-related asthma
	All	Nonobese women with newly-onset adult asthma	Leptin correlated positively with asthma symptom score and negatively with lung function even though no difference was found on adipokine levels between patients with asthma and healthy subjects. High baseline resistin predicted steeper decrease in serum ECP, EPX, and MPO during glucocorticoid treatment.
YKL-40	All	Late- and early-onset groups compared	Levels of YKL-40 were higher in asthma with poor control and exacerbations and atopy. When phenotypes were compared, highest levels of YKL-40 in obesity-related asthma and early-onset atopic asthma. Lower levels in nonatopic late-onset asthma.	Specjalski et al. 2015 [52]	Obesity-related (and early-onset atopic)
IFN-γ and IL-8	All	Patients with moderate and severe asthma compared, approx. 85% with asthma onset ≥12 years in both groups	Levels of IFN-γ and IL-8 increased but IL-4 decreased in airway subepithelium of patients with severe poorly controlled asthma when compared to moderate disease. Patients with severe asthma had also increased number of eosinophils and neutrophils in sputum.	Shannon et al. 2008 [152]	Severe and obstructive asthma?
Chlamydia pneumonia (IgG, IgA, and IgE)	All	Groups of child- and adult-onset asthma compared	Patients with nonatopic adult-onset asthma and seropositivity to Chlamydia pneumoniae (IgG, IgA) had 4-fold-steeper decline in FEV1/FVC and accelerated decline in FEV1. C. pneumoniae infection might promote persistent airflow limitation in these patients.	Brinke et al. 2001 [7]	Severe and obstructive asthma
	All	Patients with adult-onset asthma	Seropositivity to C. pneumoniae (IgG/IgM, IgA) infection was found to accelerate the loss of lung function in subjects with new nonatopic asthma.	Pasternack et al. 2005 [168]
	All	52% with adult-onset asthma	C. pneumoniae IgE was detected in 21% of mild intermittent and 79% of severe persistent asthma. C. pneumoniae IgE was associated with asthma and asthma severity.	Hahn et al. 2012 [164]
Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin- (SA-) IgE	All	Healthy controls, severe and nonsevere asthmatics compared	SA-IgE found more often in patients with severe asthma when compared to healthy subjects. Age of asthma onset highest in SA-IgE-positive group. SA-IgE associated with increased risk for asthma, severe asthma, hospitalizations, use of oral steroids, and lower FEV1.	Bachert et al. 2012 [157]	Asthma in aged persons?
	All	Community-based population with adult-onset asthma	Risk factors for presence of SA-IgE were current smoking, older age, male sex, and inhalant allergen sensitization. SA-IgE was associated with current adult-onset asthma. Correlation between SA-IgE and total IgE.	Song et al. 2014 [158]
TSLP	All	Patients with newly diagnosed asthma (age range 16–98 years)	Smoking attenuated the age-related decrease in total IgE, blood eosinophils, and FeNO and maintained eosinophilic inflammation. Sputum TSLP levels were associated with sputum eosinophil % and pack-years. Current and ex-smokers had higher TSLP versus never-smokers. TSLP may be involved in elevating sputum eosinophils in smokers.	Nagasaki et al. 2013 [231]	Smoking asthma

NR = not reported. ADMA = asymmetric dimethyl arginine, AHR = airway hyperresponsiveness, ECP = eosinophilic cationic protein, EPX = eosinophil peroxidase, MPO = myeloperoxidase, IFN = interferon, IL = interleukin, SA-IgE = Staphylococcus Aureus enterotoxin-specific immunoglobulin E, FEV1 = forced expiratory volume in 1 second, and TSLP = thymic stromal lymphopoietin.

3. Risk Factors for Adult-Onset Asthma

3.1. Obesity

Obesity-related late-onset phenotype arose in four different cluster analyses (Figure 1). Obesity is a risk factor for adult-onset asthma in both women and men, increasing the risk for asthma by approximately 50% [11, 27]. The association was stronger in nonallergic than allergic individuals [28]. Since obese patients typically consume high-fat diet, possess systemic inflammation, metabolic syndrome, and comorbidities, and breathe at lower lung volumes [29], it has been a topic of interest which of these is actually the predisposing factor for asthma. Very recently, it was suggested that peripheral lung might be inherently more collapsible in nonallergic obese females who develop late-onset asthma when compared to obese females who do not develop asthma; this was concluded from the more pronounced effects that weight loss had on lung elastance in patients with asthma [30]. BMI has been found as a better predictor of adult-onset asthma than metabolic syndrome in women [31], but insulin resistance was reported as a better predictor of asthma-like symptoms than BMI regardless of sex [32]. The possible common pathogenetic mechanisms of asthma and comorbidities traditionally nonrelated to asthma remain to be described.

It seems that there exist two types of obesity-related asthma; early-onset obese asthma is often not developed following obesity but rather complicated by obesity. Late-onset obese asthma is more often developed following obesity [33]. Both types are characterized by increased severity with increased BMI and high use of healthcare services despite use of high dose of ICS, suggesting glucocorticoid insensitivity [3, 15, 16, 33]. Obese patients with late-onset asthma were less atopic and had less bronchial hyperresponsiveness, less airway obstruction, fewer exacerbations, lower FeNO, but no difference in sputum eosinophilia or systemic markers of inflammation when compared to the early-onset group [33, 34].

Heterogeneity exists regarding airway inflammation in obese asthmatics [15, 34]. Studies with late-onset asthma as well as majority of other studies suggest low eosinophilia in obese asthma [33-38], even though one study with bronchial biopsy samples from obese severe asthmatics suggested only redistribution of eosinophils into airway submucosa [39]. In a recent cluster analysis, two clusters consisted mostly of obese patients with late-onset asthma and their inflammatory profiles were largely classified as neutrophilic or mixed granulocytic [40]. Also absence of airway inflammation (based on bronchial biopsy specimen) in obese patients with mild-to-moderate asthma was reported recently and no difference was observed between adult- and childhood-onset asthma [41].

One hallmark of obesity is a systemic low-grade inflammation with increased levels of many inflammatory markers such as C-reactive protein (CRP), interleukin- (IL-) 6, tumor necrosis factor- (TNF-) α, and leptin, and this is maybe important for the pathogenesis of obesity-related asthma [34, 42–45]. Systemic inflammation is generally considered to be a consequence of hypertrophy of adipocytes and their enhanced metabolic activity and macrophage infiltration into the adipose tissue at obese state [46]. Adipose tissue macrophages are polarized towards the classically activated proinflammatory M1 type (in contrast to anti-inflammatory M2 macrophages involved in tissue repair) [47]. In obese patients with asthma, increased number but reduced function (efferocytosis) of airway macrophages was shown, as well as reduced M2 marker expression in blood monocytes. Oxidative stress was found as a possible mechanism for altering macrophages [48]. Elevated systemic IL-6 and CRP as well as systemic biomarker of macrophage activation (soluble CD163) have been associated with poorer lung function and neutrophilic inflammation [49-51]. Also levels of YKL-40 were found highest in obesity-related phenotype (even though lowest in late-onset nonatopic asthma). YKL-40 was associated with poor asthma control and exacerbations, even though its function remains unclear [52] (Table 2).

Adipokines involve mediators with both proinflammatory (e.g., leptin and resistin) and anti-inflammatory (e.g., adiponectin) functions. Serum levels of leptin increase while the levels of adiponectin decrease with increasing BMI [53-57] but leptin has not been consistently shown to be increased in childhood- or adult-onset asthma when adjusted to BMI [58-61]. Leptin levels are higher in women with equivalent BMI when compared to men [62], and the association between leptin and asthma seems to be stronger in women [63]; both issues support the role of leptin in the pathogenesis of asthma in obese females. In nonobese women with adult-onset asthma, leptin correlated positively with asthma symptom score and negatively with lung function when adjusted for BMI [58] (Table 2). Inconsistent results have been reported on correlation between plasma and BAL leptin levels in patients with adult-onset asthma and no correlation regarding adiponectin [53, 56, 64]. Both clinical and experimental evidence suggests that leptin might rather function by augmenting airway hyperresponsiveness than by affecting inflammation [53, 65, 66] (Table 2). Leptin and adiponectin may have direct effect on airway hyperresponsiveness via their receptors in the airway epithelium and smooth muscle cells [53, 67, 68]. This is supported by a report of increased expression of their receptors in epithelia of obese asthmatics when compared to obese controls [53]. Furthermore, a significant negative correlation was found between visceral fat leptin expression and airway hyperreactivity to methacholine in patients with adult-onset asthma [53]. In contrast, a proinflammatory role in promoting eosinophilia is suggested by the finding that leptin acts as eosinophil survival-promoting factor [69, 70]. Adiponectin may act in different manner in women and men; in women, low serum adiponectin was associated with higher incidence of adult-onset asthma whereas men with higher serum adiponectin were associated with worse symptoms and more active disease [71, 72]. The association between asthma and adiponectin remains, altogether, inconsistent [63, 64].

Neutrophilic airway inflammation may be promoted by high-fat meal, suggesting involvement of this mechanism in obesity-related asthma. Obese and nonobese patients with asthma showed increased percentage of sputum neutrophils, expression of Toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) mRNA, and suppressed response to bronchodilator after a meal with high content of fat or trans-fat [45]. Interestingly, this may be a more important route in males as compared to females, since the level of saturated and monounsaturated fatty acids predicted sputum neutrophil percentage in asthmatic males, but not females [73]. Indeed, free fatty acids have been shown to activate TLR4 pathway and innate immune response, constituting a mechanism for this phenomenon [74].

One attempt to the pathobiology of obesity-related adult-onset asthma was carried out recently by Holguin and coworkers. An inverse relationship between BMI and FeNO was observed in late- but not early-onset asthma. To explain the difference, they showed increased level of asymmetric dimethyl arginine (ADMA, an inhibitor of all NOS isoforms) and decreased ratio of L-arginine/ADMA in obese patients with late-onset asthma, which was less evident in early-onset asthma [75] (Table 2). The decreased ratio was also associated with worse outcome of asthma in late- but not early-onset asthma. Increased ADMA may direct iNOS to form superoxide instead of NO and on the other hand, since NO acts as bronchodilator [76, 77], reduced production of NO by iNOS could play a role in the pathogenesis of adult-onset obesity-related asthma. Reduced L-arginine and NO also suggest increased activation of arginase-polyamine pathway which may play a role in the pathobiology of asthma by promoting airway hyperreactivity or eosinophilia [78, 79].

Because many players are involved in obesity, the etiology of obesity-related late-onset asthma is not simple and straightforward. Inherent abnormal lung mechanics, systemic inflammation, and direct effects of adipokines on airway hyperresponsiveness and inflammatory cells may be involved, as well as mechanisms yet unexplored. Because majority of patients with adult-onset asthma are not only obese but also of female gender, the role of female sex hormones should be considered.

3.2. Gender and Sex Hormones

After puberty, females are clearly more often affected with asthma and have more severe disease [80-82]. Even though a smaller airway calibre may provide a partial explanation, evidence exists of the involvement of hormones in the disease pathogenesis. In prospective cohort studies, the risk of asthma in females has been reported to generally decrease after menopause, except in women using postmenopausal hormone replacement therapy [83, 84]. Current/recent use of oestrogen preparations increased risk of adult-onset asthma, while preparations containing both oestrogen and progestin showed contradictory results [83-85]. The risk was greatest amongst women who reported an allergic disease prior to asthma and in those who were never-smokers [83]. Smoking has antiestrogenic effects, which is one possibility to explain the reduced risk in smokers [85]. On the other hand, hormone replacement therapy was shown to improve the course of asthma in women with asthma [86]. Also phase of menstrual cycle has been reported to be associated with respiratory function, respiratory symptoms, and atopy in women with and without asthma, even though the results have been inconsistent [80, 87–89]. As suggested by differential risk of hormone-related adult-onset asthma between smokers and never-smokers, the effect of sex hormones on asthma risk or respiratory symptoms may differ in different subgroups of patients and explain the contradictory findings.

Th2-promoting capacity of estrogen on airway inflammation has been aroused in many mice studies [90-93], even though anti-inflammatory effects have been described as well [94]. The effects of progesterone have been less clear and are less studied [95, 96]. Similar findings have been obtained by using human cells [97, 98]. Testosterone, instead, has been shown to suppress Th2 cytokine production and increase IL-10 via androgen receptor of CD4+ T cells [99-101]. Neutrophils and whole blood cells from healthy males were also shown to produce smaller amount of 5-lipoxygenase (5-LO) products, leukotriene B4, and 5-hydroperoxyeicosatetraenoic acid (HPETE) when compared to female, because male androgens had a suppressive effect on the production [102]. These types of mechanisms may protect male from developing asthma after adolescence. Mice studies have also indicated that differences in the number of M2 macrophages in lung tissue after allergen exposure in female and male mice may lead to distinct regulation of airway inflammation [103]. Nonatopic males with adult-onset asthma were interestingly shown to exert an increased risk for persistent airflow limitation [6]. Smoking was not found to explain the finding, and most likely male hormones are not a significant player. For example, a common trigger of asthma in these subjects may be involved in the mechanism.

Nuclear receptors for sex hormones are expressed in healthy human lung tissue enabling direct effects on airway cells [104-106]. Even though the main mechanism of action of sex hormones is considered to be regulation of gene expression, they produce also nongenomic effects [107]. The nongenomic effects involve G-protein coupled estrogen receptor- (GPER-) mediated effects, modulation of ion channel function, and kinase activities [108-110]. Interestingly, a link between female sex hormones and eosinophils seems to exist, supported by the findings where eosinophils are recruited to female reproductive tissues with a mechanism related to estrogen [111-113]. Peripheral blood eosinophils were recently shown to express GPER and activation of this receptor enhanced chemotaxis in the presence of eotaxin (chemotactic agent for eosinophils) and modulated eosinophil viability [109], suggesting a direct mechanism for interaction between estrogen and eosinophils. Increased levels of eotaxin-2 have been found in bronchial epithelial brushings from patients with severe late-onset asthma, as well as its correlation with sputum eosinophilia [114] (Table 2). Whether estrogen further augments the chemotaxis of eosinophils into the airways in these patients in vivo remains to be determined. Given that free biologically active 17-β estradiol was higher in overweight when compared to normal-weight women, this type of eosinophilia-promoting mechanism may be present in overweight females, or those with otherwise high levels of estrogen [115]. Indeed, adult-onset asthma patients with severe eosinophil-predominant inflammation were mainly overweight females [3] (Figure 1). Obesity-related asthma is mainly considered as noneosinophilic, and obesity rather characterized by decreased level of estradiol [116], and thus eosinophilia-promoting capacity of estrogen is an unlikely mechanism to contribute to the phenotype.

The interplay between structurally similar sex hormones and corticosteroids and their effects on the modulation of airway inflammation is also an interesting issue that may affect development or severity of asthma [110]. Estrogen may, for example, inhibit production and function of cortisol [117] contributing in this manner to severe asthma.

3.3. Psychosocial Factors

Depressive disorders are at least twice as common in patients with asthma when compared to the general population [118, 119]. Psychosocial factors, such as perceived stress, childhood adverse events, early- and late-onset depression, and high extroversion score in women, have been reported as risk factors for adult-onset asthma [12, 120–124], even though the direction of causality between psychosocial factors and asthma still remains unclear and requires further studies. An association has also been shown, where patients with worse control of asthma showed increased risk of depression [118]. Depression may have common pathophysiological features with asthma explaining their coexistence but alternatively, stress of a chronic illness or treatment for it (long-term steroid treatment) may induce depression. Also common comorbidities and environmental factors, such as obesity and smoking, have been suggested to explain the association between depression and incident asthma but this hypothesis is not supported by the finding that the risk exists even after excluding these subgroups [12]. In a very recent cross-sectional study, depression and increased BMI were both associated with worse asthma control in adults but interestingly, depression was found to mediate the association between BMI and asthma control [125].

Several common pathophysiological pathways have been suggested to explain cooccurrence of asthma and major depressive disorder (MDD). In a recent meta-analysis, levels of IL-1, TNF-α, IL-6, and IL-4 were found higher in depressed patients when compared to nondepressed subjects [126] suggesting involvement of inflammatory pathways in the pathophysiological processes of MDD. These cytokines are elevated in at least specific phenotypes of asthma [34] and are able to generate symptoms such as fatigue and loss of appetite that overlap with symptoms of depression [127]. Cytokines may induce hyperactivation of hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, ending up in increased cortisol levels and symptoms of depression [128]. Moreover, serotonergic neuron transmission is deficient in MDD and inflammatory cytokines elevate enzyme indoleamine-2,3-dioxygenase (IDO), which degrades tryptophan, the most important precursor of serotonin. IDO also increases kynurenine metabolites that have neurotoxic effects [129]. Biomarkers of oxidative stress are elevated in patients with MDD as well as patients with asthma. Reactive oxygen species (ROS) has been suggested directly, or via inducing inflammation, to damage cells and biomolecules, cause cell death and neurotoxic effects and reduce neurogenesis leading to MDD [130]. Additionally, cholinergic activation mediates airway constriction and has been associated with experience of hopelessness/depression suggesting that dysregulation of autonomous nervous system may be one mechanism in the pathogenesis of both diseases [128].

A recent hypothesis suggests that nod-like receptor protein 3 (NLRP3) inflammasome forms a link between stress, depression, and systemic disease [131]. NLRP3 inflammasome is a sensor for variety of danger substances ranging from pathogens (fungi, toxin-producing bacteria such as S. aureus, and viruses such as H. influenza) to elevated extracellular glucose, amyloid-β peptide, oxidized low-density lipoprotein (LDL), and number of environmental irritants [132]. NLRP3 inflammasome activates caspase-1 resulting in cleavage of pro-IL-1β into IL-1β. Psychological stressors have been shown to elevate IL-1β and may therefore activate inflammasome, even though direct mechanism has not been demonstrated [131]. Interestingly, in mice IL-1β and TNF-α also upregulated serotonin transporter (SERT) gene, and SERT by uptake of serotonin to the presynaptic neuron is central in inducing despair-like behaviour [133-135].

Clinical trials have provided further proof of an association between inflammatory and depressive disorders. Evidence exists that treatment with antidepressants (tricyclic/SSRIs) normalizes the levels of inflammatory cytokines in depressed patients [136]. Additionally, anti-inflammatory drugs have shown beneficial effects in the treatment of depression [131]. For example, treatment of patients with MDD with both antidepressant and NSAID celecoxib showed greater improvement in depressive symptoms when compared to treatment with antidepressant alone [137]. Altogether, a link has been constituted between depression, asthma, and inflammation, not forgetting obesity as a player in the pathophysiological process. In the cluster analysis of Newby et al. the highest depression score was present in the obesity-related phenotype [17] (Figure 1), strengthening the interplay between obesity, asthma, and depression. The causal relationships, however, require further studies.

3.4. Rhinitis, Sinusitis, and Respiratory Tract Infections

Rhinitis and sinusitis are frequently associated with asthma, regardless of age of onset. Rhinitis (allergic or nonallergic) is an independent risk factor for adult-onset asthma and the risk was further enhanced by belonging to the highest IgE tertile or by having a concomitant sinusitis [10, 138–140]. Chronic sinusitis alone, without clear nasal allergies, is very common in adult-onset asthma but markedly less prevalent in childhood-onset asthma [141]. Atopy seems to explain only minor portion of adult-onset asthma [10, 142]. One source of rhinitis and sinusitis is a respiratory tract infection, and consistently, recurrent infections of upper airways as well as infection of the lower airways were risk factors for adult-onset asthma. The risk was enhanced by current or past allergic rhinitis or atopic dermatitis or by an atopic parent [13]. The results are very similar to childhood asthma, where respiratory infections early in life have been shown to increase risk of asthma in childhood and to act synergistically with allergic sensitization [143].

Coexistence of upper and lower respiratory diseases and many shared morphological and functional properties of the upper and the lower respiratory tract suggest common underlying pathophysiological processes and have led to the theory of united airways diseases [144]. The close relationship between upper and lower airway diseases has also been shown in patients with adult-onset asthma. For example, sinus abnormalities are present in majority of patients with severe asthma, even in the absence of nasal symptoms, and were particularly associated with adult-onset asthma [145]. The degree of sinus disease positively correlated with eosinophilic airway and systemic inflammation and airway trapping and negatively with diffusion capacity in patients with adult-onset disease [145]. It was concluded that, in adult-onset severe disease, airway parenchyma and peripheral airways might participate in the disease progress, and inflammation might reach the alveolar wall. Nonallergic rhinitis is a general condition in patients with adult-onset asthma but it was shown that nonallergic and allergic patients with asthma possess strikingly similar nasal inflammation and nasal symptoms [146]. These “nonallergic” patients may therefore have a local allergic rhinitis, and local production of allergen-specific IgE, without never developing into systemic allergic rhinitis [147]. Thus, the close connection between upper and lower respiratory disease is most likely present in patients with adult-onset asthma, with similarities in the pathogenetic mechanisms.

Sometimes sinus disease/rhinitis and asthma are accompanied by aspirin sensitivity with or without nasal polyps, the clinical entity being named aspirin-exacerbated respiratory disease (AERD). Typically, AERD is an adult-onset disease, starting around 30 years of age with rhinitis, followed by asthma, aspirin sensitivity, and often nasal polyps. It is often more severe and more prevalent in females [148]. AERD is characterized by eosinophilic inflammation, overproduction, and responsiveness to cysteinyl leukotrienes and underproduction and responsiveness to prostaglandins in the airway inflammatory cells. These phenomena are augmented by aspirin and other NSAIDs, and, for example, alcohol, all inhibitors of cyclooxygenase- (COX-) 1 enzyme, which further moves the balance between synthesis of prostanoids and cysteinyl leukotrienes towards the latter [149, 150]. Recently, it was demonstrated that AERD patients show high levels of both IL-4 and IFN-γ in sinus tissue, suggesting a mixed Th1/Th2 milieu instead of solely Th2. Eosinophils were the main source of IFN-γ, and this cytokine was able to promote maturation and cysteinyl leukotriene production of eosinophils [151]. Also patients with severe poorly controlled late-onset asthma showed enhanced IFN-γ and IL-8 when compared to moderate disease, showing further proof that certain phenotypes of adult-onset disease may have a significant Th1 component (Table 2) [152]. Also variants of genes related to arachidonate pathway, inflammation, and immune responses [153, 154] as well as staphylococcal superantigens [155] may play a role in the pathogenesis of AERD. Patients with AERD (majority of them with adult-onset disease) were associated with fewer comorbidities in general (e.g., components of metabolic syndrome) but more coronary heart disease or congestive heart failure when compared to asthma without AERD [156]. Whether a common pathogenetic component exists remains to be studied.

Staphylococcus aureus is a bacterium responsible for many infections (e.g., sinusitis) but may also be commensal. Serum IgE specific to S. aureus enterotoxin (SA-IgE) has been linked to adult-onset asthma and worse outcome of asthma [157-159]. IgE may be formed against bacterial/viral components or products in both atopic and nonatopic patients and presence of pathogen-specific IgE may reflect current or past contact with the pathogen. S. aureus enterotoxin may act as antigen promoting a specific IgE response (SA-IgE) or as superantigen stimulating massive activation of lymphocytes, formation of polyclonal IgE (reflected as high total IgE), and Th2 response [157, 160]. In a recent study, approximately 60% of adults with severe asthma were positive for SA-IgE, majority being nonatopic [157]. SA-IgE positivity in nonatopic patients was associated with increased use of oral steroids and hospitalizations, lower FEV1, and disease onset at higher age [157]. Among patients with adult-onset asthma the presence of SA-IgE was associated with male gender, current smoking, age ≥61 years, and inhalant allergen sensitization and marginally with diabetes mellitus [158] (Table 2). Functional SA-IgE was also detected in polyp tissue from subjects with nasal polyps; presence of IL-5 and SA-IgE was associated with comorbid asthma [161, 162]. In addition to markers of eosinophilic inflammation, these patients showed high systemic total IgE (>450 kU/L) [161]. Staphylococcus aureus enterotoxin-driven massive IgE production and Th2 inflammation may be one mechanism explaining the overlap between severe asthma, rhinitis, and/or nasal polyps [157, 159, 161].

History of sinusitis and pneumonia is more common among patients with severe late-onset asthma when compared to severe early-onset asthma. Pneumonia was also a strong predictor of severe asthma, suggesting that pathogens causative for pneumonia may be involved in the pathogenesis of the disease [163]. Chlamydophila pneumoniae and Mycoplasma pneumoniae are bacteria causing pneumonia and many other infections of upper and lower respiratory tract and have been linked to both adult- and childhood-onset asthma [164-167]. In a Finnish longitudinal study, seropositivity for C. pneumoniae was not a risk factor for adult-onset asthma [168], even though it has been associated with asthma or asthma severity in several studies including patients with adult-onset asthma [164, 166, 167]. Seropositive patients with nonatopic adult-onset asthma had significantly steeper decline in lung function when compared to seronegative patient groups or seropositive patients with early-onset asthma [7, 168] (Table 2). Additionally, C. pneumoniae-specific IgE was associated with disease severity in population of asthmatic patients, where half had disease onset in adulthood [164] (Table 2). Age of onset did not affect the likelihood of being seropositive among patients with severe asthma. Seropositive patients with nonatopic adult-onset asthma used high doses of inhaled and/or oral steroids suggesting that they were relatively insensitive to steroids and may require alternative treatment options [7]. C. pneumoniae could function by activating C. pneumoniae-specific IgE/FcεR1 complex on mast cells or basophils, enhancing Th2 inflammatory response [164]. It may also contribute to airway remodelling by enhancing production of several growth factors and cytokines by the airway structural cells [169-171]. Furthermore, C. pneumoniae may alter cellular responsiveness to glucocorticoids [172] explaining the need for high steroid doses of seropositive patients. The possible role of C. pneumoniae in the etiology or progression of coronary heart disease in addition to asthma [173] raises interesting possibilities for common pathogenetic or disease-modifying factors in these diseases.

It has been postulated that chronic diseases of the respiratory tract including asthma, rhinitis, and sinusitis are all manifestations of defective mucosal function, suggesting that the primary causal phenomenon would be the defective epithelial/mucosal function leading to higher susceptibility to respiratory tract infections and asthma. Thereby, the direction of causality remains unclear. Patients with asthma have disrupted epithelial cell tight junctions in the airways enhancing passage of antigens and they are more susceptible to the proteolytic or prooxidative effects of allergens, respiratory viruses, air pollutants, and tobacco smoke [174-176]. Whether these defects are present before the disease onset remains unclear. Asthma susceptibility genes that encode proteins related to epithelial integrity or function have been associated with childhood-onset asthma [177, 178] and may be found in phenotypes of adult-onset asthma (severe adult-onset asthma, asthma-COPD overlap) [179, 180]. Even though the susceptible individual may be spared from the disease during childhood, changes in life-style or environmental factors could trigger asthma in adulthood. Also allergy or smoking may produce defects in the defence system against respiratory tract infections [181-183]. Allergic reaction and IgE crosslinking with its receptor (FcεR1) in plasmacytoid dendritic cells prior to infection may lead to insufficient production of IFN in response to viral infection [181, 184, 185]. This may promote a prolonged, more severe infection leading more likely to a chronic airway disease [186]. Mechanism for the development of chronic airway inflammation in response to viral respiratory tract infection has been suggested based on an experimental study. Interestingly, the mechanism was based on an innate immune response. The acute response to viral respiratory tract infection was followed by a delayed response with IL-13 production and manifestation of airway hyperresponsiveness and mucous cell metaplasia. The cellular source of IL-13 was shown to be macrophages exhibiting markers of alternative activation (M2) and the production was driven by direct interaction of macrophages with natural killer T (NKT) cells. At the time of the delayed response, very low, almost undetectable level of the virus was present in the lungs. The mechanism had also a genetic aspect since another mouse strain did not develop a similar chronic airway inflammation [187]. Apart from immunological defects, also pathogen-recognition receptors such as Toll-like receptors (TLRs) and innate immune response may have importance in the development of asthma [174]. Interestingly, some allergens such as house dust mite (HDM) allergen, Der p, have been shown to mimic proteins required for Toll-like receptor 4 activation [188]. Stimulation by HDM led to TLR4 activation in structural airway cells and induced production of “proallergic” TSLP, GM-CSF, IL-25, and IL-33 and DC activation [189]. Thus, HDM by triggering an innate immune response initiated an allergic response. Bacterial and viral components may also directly activate and increase longevity of granulocytes via TLRs [190-192].

Alterations in the immune functions are manifested with increasing age and these changes most likely increase susceptibility of elderly to respiratory infections. Alterations seen in subjects above 60–65 years include reduced mucociliary clearance, reduced phagocytic capacity and increased apoptosis in neutrophils, decreased degranulation of eosinophils, and defects in antigen phagocytosis and presentation and lymphocyte function resulting in reduced levels of antibody production [193]. These changes may predispose older individuals to more severe infections and development of late-onset asthma.

3.5. Alcohol

In a large Danish twin-study, overall alcohol intake was associated with the risk of adult-onset asthma in a U-shaped manner. Subjects with moderate weekly intake (1–6 units/week) showed the lowest risk of incident asthma, while the highest risk was observed in the group of rare/never drinkers [194]. When the biomarkers of alcohol consumption were studied, mathematical combination of carbohydrate-deficient transferrin (CDT) and γ-glutamyltransferase (GGT) was positively associated with self-reported asthma in women but not men [195].

Alcohol has complex associations with asthma. Pure ethanol is a moderate and transient bronchodilator but nonalcoholic components of alcoholic beverages (e.g., sulphites of red wine) and acetaldehyde (product of ethanol metabolism) may act as triggers of asthma attacks [196]. Those who suffer from wine-induced symptoms are often women with early-onset asthma [197].

Alcohol consumption increases the level of serum total IgE, even when consumed at lower quantities (10–70 g/week) [198-200]. This effect was seen in both atopics and nonatopics [198, 200–202] but its clinical significance for IgE-mediated diseases remains unclear. Additionally, despite the elevated IgE levels, it is also unclear whether chronic alcohol abuse leads to Th2 predominance. Impaired Th1 cell-mediated immunity and polarization towards Th2 response [203, 204] but also Th1 predominance has been reported in alcoholics [198]. Duration and amount of alcohol consumption may play a pivotal role in determining its effect on inflammation. It was shown that moderate, acute alcohol use in vitro and in vivo resulted in anti-inflammatory effects on human monocytes whereas chronic use led to upregulation of NF-κB and proinflammatory effects. Also activation status of the cells was important; higher activation state (the presence of costimulators) turned the effects of acute use into proinflammatory [203]. These interesting observations may reveal the basis for increased risk of asthma among heavy drinkers and the beneficial effects of moderate alcohol use.

3.6. Smoking and Oxidative Stress

The current evidence suggests, even though it is not conclusive, that active or passive smoking is a risk factor for adult-onset asthma [10, 205–208], the risk being greatest in individuals with allergic rhinitis [209]. Healthy smoking effect most likely contributes to the partially conflicting results; those with sensitive airways or any respiratory problems may not start smoking or quit more easily [210-213]. Smoking increases asthma severity [210, 214], and current evidence suggests that this effect of smoking also occurs in patients with adult-onset disease. A two-year follow-up of patients with new-onset adult asthma showed that history of smoking at baseline predicted increased asthma severity in a dose-dependent manner [215]. Smoking accelerated the normal annual decline in lung function in nonatopic patients with early- or late-onset asthma (onset ≥ 10 years) [216]. Current smoking also increased risk of airway obstruction but only in patients with late-onset asthma. The greatest risk was among those with asthma onset during adolescence, which is the time of maximal lung growth [216]. Another study showed that especially current smokers with asthma (early- or late-onset) and atopy are susceptible to fixed obstruction, with stronger association among patients with early-onset asthma [217]. In patients with mild newly diagnosed adult-onset asthma, the effectiveness of low dose ICS therapy in reducing FEV1 decline was not affected by smoking [218] even though the result might be different in patients with severe asthma.

Smoking increases oxidative stress and has proinflammatory effects on the lungs of nonasthmatics; these are changes predisposing for development of asthma. Smoking increases number of airway inflammatory cells (neutrophils, macrophages), as well as inflammatory cytokine production in nonasthmatics [219, 220]. Airway epithelia is in direct contact with cigarette smoke and produces IL-1β and IL-8 being responsible for the neutrophil recruitment [221]. Epithelium also undergoes many changes, such as disruption of tight junctions leading to increased permeability and reduced barrier function [182, 183], altered structure and function of mitochondria [222], changes in gene expression patterns [223, 224], and ageing [225] in response to cigarette smoke. In smokers without asthma, epithelial integrity was reduced and negatively correlated to number of eosinophils and macrophages, and thickness of the tenascin and laminin layers was increased [220]. Smoking patients with asthma exhibited similar changes in epithelia, as well as increased proliferation rate of epithelial cells, most likely to cope with the smoke-induced damage. Ex-smokers (at least one year without smoking) did not exhibit these changes in epithelium, suggesting that smoke-induced changes can be reversed by smoking cessation. Ex-smokers, however, still showed increased neutrophilic inflammation [226, 227].

One puff of cigarette smoke contains approximately 1014 oxygen radicals and 3000 ppm NO leading to increased oxidative stress in smokers. Airway epithelium is damaged and shed by oxidants. Oxidants impair cell membrane lipids, inactivate enzymes/receptors, oxidate/nitrosylate transcription factors and kinases leading to modified expression of inflammatory genes, and contribute to formation of other bioactive molecules such as 8-isoprostane (bronchoconstrictor) [228]. In addition to pathogenesis of smoking-related asthma, increased oxidative stress and reduced antioxidant levels may contribute to development of adult-onset asthma in general [228-230]. Thymic stromal lymphopoietin (TSLP) is one possible mediator of smoking-induced adult-onset asthma; it was elevated in the sputum of smokers with adult-onset asthma, positively correlated with pack-years and negatively correlated with FEV1/FVC [231] (Table 2). It is produced mainly by epithelial cells. Studies in mice also suggest involvement of TSLP in smoking-induced asthma [232].

3.7. Air Pollution

Increasing body of literature suggests, though it is not conclusive, that traffic-related air pollution (NO2 and particulate matter less than 2.5 μm in diameter [PM2.5]) increases the risk for adult-onset asthma [233-235]. Most studies on air pollution and asthma have concentrated on children, but whether different mechanisms are involved in patients with adult-onset asthma who often are less atopic remains unclear. In elderly women, long-term exposure to traffic- and industrial-related air pollution was associated with increased inflammatory markers (leukotriene B4 and TNF-α) in exhaled breath condensate and induced sputum [236]. Oxidative stress has been hypothesized as the mechanism of how air pollution might cause asthma. NO2 is a free radical and specific components of PM2.5 also induce oxidative stress [235, 237]. Additionally, polymorphism of genes involved in the pathways of oxidative stress may affect susceptibility to asthma in response to air pollution [238]. However, the mechanisms as well as association between air pollution and adult-onset asthma are still uncertain and require further studies.

3.8. Occupational Exposures

Work-related asthma (occupational or work-exacerbated) is estimated to account for 10–25% of adult-onset asthma cases [239, 240]. Occupational asthma may be developed via several different mechanisms and should thus not be regarded as one single phenotype [241]. Additionally, methodological and legal aspects hamper specific definition of occupational asthma.

Occupational asthma is divided into sensitizer- and irritant-induced asthma. The causative agents of occupational asthma, high-molecular weight (HMW) proteins (e.g., from animals, plants, microorganisms) and low-molecular weight (LMW) chemical agents (e.g., toluene diisocyanate), seem mainly to use different mechanisms to develop asthma, IgE- and non-IgE-mediated mechanism, respectively. HMW factor-induced IgE-mediated asthma accounts for majority of occupational asthma [242, 243]. Specific IgE is rarely detected in asthma induced by LMW chemicals, and FeNO levels have been reported to be lower when compared to HMW factor-induced asthma; occupational asthma induced by LMW chemicals seems to constitute its own phenotype [241] with several speculated mechanisms [242]. Irritant-induced asthma develops after acute high exposure to vapor, gas, fume, or smoke. It is thought to develop following inhalation injury by a nonimmunological route but the pathogenetic process is mostly unknown [244]. More detailed discussion of mechanisms of asthma phenotypes related to occupational exposures, their prognosis, and treatment can be found elsewhere [240–242, 244–247].

4. Conclusions and Future Perspectives

Even though childhood- and adult-onset asthma may share some pathogenetic mechanisms, for example, those related to united airway diseases, obesity, and psychological distress, also significant differences exist. Factors such as hormones and those associated with life-style or work (alcohol, active smoking, and occupational exposure) of course mainly affect adolescence/adulthood and thereby only trigger or modify adult/adolescent-onset disease. However, also factors that are involved in both early- and late-onset diseases, such as seropositivity to Chlamydophila pneumonia, show striking differences to the disease progress depending on the disease onset and atopy status, suggesting that adult-onset disease has unique features.

So far, cluster analyses defining the phenotypes of asthma have been based mainly on clinical variables and less on biological markers. To what degree a common mechanism explains a specific phenotype identified based on clinical variables remains unknown. If endotypes and clinical phenotypes do not overlap with high extent, success of one therapy to treat all subjects inside a clinical phenotype is questionable. However, it is promising that identification of the clinical phenotypes of asthma has aided in revealing the genetic heterogeneity of the disease [248], suggesting that common genetic variants and thereby common mechanisms are involved in specific phenotypes. Use of biological markers in the cluster analyses would give us more detailed information on endotypes and disease pathogenesis and open possibilities for novel treatments. In addition, inclusion of major comorbidities traditionally nonrelated to asthma (e.g., psychiatric disorders, type II diabetes, and coronary heart disease) to cluster analyses may significantly affect the end result raising novel phenotypes. The coexistence of adult-onset asthma with many disorders suggests involvement of common pathogenetic mechanisms and is an interesting area for further studies. Whether the current clinical phenotypes are only preliminary or close to the final remains an open question. Because the current phenotypes (such as obesity-related ones) aroused in different studies have more similarities than differences, they are a good starting point for further analyses.