| Literature DB >> 26484010 |
Joyce Maalouf1, Mary E Cogswell2, Keming Yuan2, Carrie Martin3, Cathleen Gillespie2, Jaspreet Kc Ahuja3, Pamela Pehrsson3, Robert Merritt2.
Abstract
The sodium concentration (mg/100g) for 23 of 125 Sentinel Foods (e.g. white bread) were identified in the 2009 CDC Packaged Food Database (PFD) and compared with data in the USDA's 2013 National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference(SR 26). Sentinel Foods are foods identified by USDA to be monitored as primary indicators to assess the changes in the sodium content of commercially processed foods from stores and restaurants. Overall, 937 products were evaluated in the CDC PFD, and between 3 (one brand of ready-to-eat cereal) and 126 products (white bread) were evaluated per selected food. The mean sodium concentrations of 17 of the 23 (74%) selected foods in the CDC PFD were 90%-110% of the mean sodium concentrations in SR 26 and differences in sodium concentration were statistically significant for 6 Sentinel Foods. The sodium concentration of most of the Sentinel Foods, as selected in the PFD, appeared to represent the sodium concentrations of the corresponding food category. The results of our study help improve the understanding of how nutrition information compares between national analytic values and the label and whether the selected Sentinel Foods represent their corresponding food category as indicators for assessment of change of the sodium content in the food supply.Entities:
Keywords: Sentinel Foods; database; laboratory analysis; sodium
Year: 2015 PMID: 26484010 PMCID: PMC4607673 DOI: 10.1016/j.profoo.2015.06.016
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Procedia Food Sci ISSN: 2211-601X
Sentinel Foods description, basis for the SR data and the corresponding WWEIA food category
| Sentinel Food | NDB # | Description | Basis for SR 26 data | WWEIA Food Category |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| White bread | 18069 | Bread, white, commercially prepared (includes soft bread crumbs) | Analytical data, 2011; NFP review in 2012 – no change | Yeast breads and rolls |
| Hamburger roll | 18350 | Rolls, hamburger or hotdog, plain | Analytical data, 2011; NFP review in 2012 – no change | Yeast breads and rolls |
| Ham, packaged and deli | 07028 | Ham, sliced, prepackaged (96% fat free, water added) | Analytical data, 2013 | Cold cuts and cured meats |
| Cheese pizza, thin crust, frozen | 21505 | Pizza, cheese topping, thin crust, frozen, cooked | Analytical data, 2012 | Pizza |
| Chicken nuggets, frozen | 22974 | Chicken nuggets, frozen, cooked | Analytical data, 2013 | Poultry |
| Chicken noodle soup, RTE | 06018 | Soup, chunky chicken noodle, canned, ready-to-serve | Analytical data, 2011 | Soups |
| Chicken Noodle Soup, condensed | 06019 | Soup, chicken noodle, canned, condensed | Manufacturer's analytical; partial documentation, 2013 | Soups |
| Corn dog, frozen | 22973 | Corn dogs, frozen, prepared | Analytical data, 2011 | Sandwiches |
| American cheese | 01252 | Cheese product, pasteurized process, American, vitamin D fortified | Analytical data, 2011 | Cheese |
| Cheddar cheese | 01009 | Cheese, cheddar | Analytical data, 1976; last analyzed in 2011-no change | Cheese |
| Spaghetti with meatballs, canned | 22912 | Spaghetti, with meatballs in tomato sauce, canned | Analytical data, 2012 | Pasta mixed dishes, excludes macaroni and cheese |
| Lasagna with meat, frozen | 22916 | Lasagna with meat and sauce, frozen entrée | Analytical data, 2012 | Pasta mixed dishes, excludes macaroni and cheese |
| Chili with meat and beans, canned | 22904 | Chili con carne with beans, canned entree | Analytical data, 2011 | Meat mixed dishes |
| Potato chips, unflavored | 19411 | Snacks, potato chips, plain, salted | Analytical data, 2013 | Savory Snacks |
| Tortilla chips, unflavored | 19056 | Snacks, tortilla chips, plain, white corn, salted | Analytical data, 2013 | Savory Snacks |
| Marinara sauce, ready to serve | 06931 | Sauce, pasta, spaghetti/marinara | Analytical data, 2011 | Pasta Sauce, tomato based |
| Ranch dressing | 04639 | Salad dressing, ranch dressing, commercial, regular | Analytical data, 2013 | Salad dressings and vegetable oils |
| Beef hotdog | 07022 | Frankfurter or hot dog, beef | Analytical data, 2013 | Frankfurters |
| Flour tortilla | 18364 | Tortillas, ready-to-bake or -fry, flour, refrigerated | Analytical data, 2011 | Tortilla |
| Biscuits, refrigerated dough | 18014 | Biscuits, plain or buttermilk, refrigerated dough, higher fat | Calculated by manufacturer, 2012 | Biscuits, muffins, quick breads |
| Cheerios | 08013 | Cereals ready-to-eat, General Mills, Cheerios | Calculated by manufacturer, 2013 | Ready-to-eat cereal |
| Frosted flakes | 08069 | Cereals ready-to- eat, Kellogg’s, Frosted Flakes | from analytical, 2012 | Ready-to-eat cereal |
| Raisin bran | 08060 | Cereals ready-to- eat, Kellogg’s, Raisin Bran | Calculated by manufacturer, 2012 | Ready-to-eat cereal |
Abbreviations: SR 26: National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference, version 26, 2013; NDB#: The five-digit Nutrient Databank number uniquely representing the food in SR; WWEIA: What We Eat in America; NFP: Nutrition Facts Panel
What We Eat in America Food Categories. Available: http://www.ars.usda.gov/ba/bhnrc/fsrg.
Comparison of sodium concentration (mg/100 g) of Sentinel Foods between CDC packaged food database and USDA National Nutrient Database for Standard Reference (SR 26)
| CDC Packaged food database | USDA SR26 | Statistics | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sentinel Food | n | Range | Sodium | CV | n | Range | Sodium | % | P |
| White bread | 126 | 320–857 | 512±6 | 13% | 19 | 410–555 | 491±10 | 96% | 0.088 |
| Hamburger roll | 45 | 384–808 | 519±9 | 11% | 12 | 451–580 | 500±10 | 96% | 0.174 |
| Ham, packaged and deli | 52 | 811–1450 | 1157±19 | 12% | 5 | 1090–1480 | 1314±150 | 114% | 0.356 |
| Cheese pizza, thin crust, frozen | 21 | 382–689 | 479±16 | 16% | 12 | 446–503 | 471±5 | 98% | 0.644 |
| Chicken nuggets, frozen | 16 | 303–860 | 541±34 | 25% | 17 | 496–719 | 552±8 | 102% | 0.758 |
| Chicken noodle soup, ready-to-eat | 15 | 156–541 | 279±22 | 31% | 10 | 272–338 | 306±8 | 110% | 0.274 |
| Chicken noodle soup, condensed | 9 | 344–730 | 635±49 | 23% | 0† | N/A | 677 | 107% | NA |
| Corn dog, frozen | 13 | 397–742 | 680±24 | 13% | 12 | 495–790 | 628±27 | 92% | 0.161 |
| American cheese | 29 | 1223–1640 | 1329±22 | 9% | 10 | 1230–1450 | 1272±16 | 96% | 0.042 |
| Cheddar cheese | 93 | 571–705 | 629±10 | 4% | 24 | N/A | 621±21 | 99% | 0.802 |
| Spaghetti with meatballs, canned | 26 | 242–477 | 377±15 | 20% | 18 | 203–435 | 315±5 | 84% | 0.001 |
| Lasagna with meat, frozen | 20 | 212–423 | 350±11 | 14% | 12 | 326–392 | 354±3 | 101% | 0.733 |
| Chili with meat and beans, canned | 19 | 323–597 | 500±19 | 17% | 11 | 442–500 | 449±6 | 90% | 0.021 |
| Potato chips, unflavored | 31 | 194–1164 | 593±17 | 16% | 5 | 342–575 | 450±94 | 76% | 0.204 |
| Tortilla chips, unflavored | 41 | 23–821 | 427±10 | 16% | 12 | 184–515 | 325±22 | 76% | 0.001 |
| Marinara sauce, ready to serve | 85 | 179–675 | 449±10 | 21% | 36 | 336–590 | 419±11 | 93% | 0.052 |
| Ranch dressing | 53 | 476–1587 | 987±23 | 17% | 18 | 810–1040 | 901±7 | 91% | 0.001 |
| Beef hotdog | 68 | 683–1651 | 955±14 | 12% | 18 | 860–1190 | 992±10 | 104% | 0.036 |
| Flour tortilla | 63 | 463–952 | 733±21 | 23% | 13 | 590–818 | 686±18 | 94% | 0.096 |
| Biscuit, refrigerated dough | 100 | 806–1059 | 979±10 | 5% | 2 | 943–1011 | 977 | 100% | NA |
| Cheerios | 3 | 571–670 | 648±24 | 6% | 0† | N/A | 497 | 77% | NA |
| Frosted flakes | 4 | 449–472 | 463±3 | 2% | 6 | 424–490 | 468±12 | 101% | 0.714 |
| Raisin bran | 5 | 407–617 | 546±39 | 16% | 0† | N/A | 356 | 65% | NA |
| Total | 937 | 272 | |||||||
Abbreviations: SE: standard error; CV: coefficient of variation; SD: standard deviation; N/A: not available
% Ratio: (sodium value in SR/sodium value in Packaged food database)*100
P-value based on T-test of the difference in mean sodium concentration between the specified food in the CDC Packaged food database versus USDA SR 26. P≤0.05 was considered statistically significant
Sodium value not based on analytical data
Fig.1Median (mg/100g) and interquartile range of sodium concentration in white bread, cheese pizza, lasagna with meat, and unflavored potato chips compared to their corresponding food category using CDC packaged food database
*Horizontal dashed line indicates the mean sodium (mg/100g) of the Sentinel Food in SR 26
Fig.3Median (mg/100g) and interquartile range of sodium concentration in American and cheddar cheese compared to their corresponding food category using CDC packaged food database.
*Horizontal dashed line indicates the mean sodium (mg/100g) of the Sentinel Food in SR 26
Fig.2Median (mg/100g) and interquartile range of sodium concentration in Ham, chili with meat and beans, tortilla chips, and ranch dressing compared to their corresponding food category using CDC packaged food database.
*Horizontal dashed line indicates the mean sodium (mg/100g) of the Sentinel Food in SR 26